- 1 - !"!# $%" ! &%' ! " # $% & ' ' ! ' & &( ( $) ' ( ! ' ! &! ' " #$ $ &*!+ $ & )% ) ( , $ ' #&% & ! - &($, Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ). . / ' 0123241450671812095012:03;<=:605><2870 ?08484<:02 1:3 24 13164@1??1 5012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 ;1@018<2 206?<:30:8<& 24 13164@1??1 5012:03 ;<=:605 156< =:30281A068<>450@1A15187<:B0715><>206?<:30:8<6 1:3 ! 06?<:30:8 < C16 :<8 20?2060:803 B0><20 870 82415<=280:;0:<84;08<206?<:30:8<46346?0:603 746?08484<:46 >4503 B9 870 ?08484<:02C7< C16 870 ?514:84>> 4: 870 <24D4:15 6=48 4: <- &( ;71550:D4:D870<230231803 !?16603B9870 , 33484<:15 489 4@45 1:30664<:6 '=3D0 18 0:D15=2= <: <& ! 128406 8< 870 ?2<;0034:D6 67155 B0 20>02203 8< 16?514:84>>1:330>0:31:86 - 3 - 70?514:84>>>45036=481D14:6887030>0:31:86><2 870><55<C4:D20540>6. ! " #$%%%!& $ &'&%' '( ) ( ! *+ , $ - )70: 870 E18802 C16 18 870 681D0 <> ;<EE0:;0E0:8<>82415870?514:84>>>45031:1??54;184<:4: <& =:302 2302 $ =50 &( <> 870 <30 <> 4@45 2<;03=20 8< 4:;<2?<2180 ;02814: 1E0:3E0:86 70 ?2<?<6031E0:3E0:88718C166<=D782013616=:302. - 4 - . /#.01# . / $ *+, - ( 746 1??54;184<: >4503 B9 870 ?514:84>> C16 6024<=659<BF0;8038<B987030>0:31:86<:870D2<=:38718 87061E046B12203B987051C<>54E48184<:706=48C16 >45034:8709012 &(1:38701??54;184<:C16>45034:870 9012 B09<:31?024<3<>64G901261:387020><20870 61E046B12203B987051C<>54E48184<: : ;<:64302184<: <> 870 1??54;184<: 1:3 <: 70124:D 870 5012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 B<87 ?128406 870 5012:03 82415 '=3D0 20F0;803 870 1??54;184<: >4503 B9 870 ?514:84>> DD240@03B9C74;7870?514:84>>46B0><208746<=28 - 8 46 870 @070E0:8 ;<:80:84<: <> 5012:03 ;<=:605><2870?514:84>>87188704E?=D:03<2302?16603B9 - 5 - 87082415<=2846?02@026012B4821294550D151:387061E0 30602@06 8< B0 608 16430 =28702 48 46 ;<:80:303 B9 870 5012:03;<=:605871887082415<=28716E46;<:682=03870 ?08484<:02H6 ?<660664<: >2<E !&- 8455 746 0F0;8E0:8 4: & 8 46 156< ;<:80:303 8718 <@02 1 ?024<3 <> 874289 90126 ?08484<:02 C16 4: ?<660664<: <> 870 6;703=503 ?2<?0289 4: ?128 ?02><2E1:;0 <> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 :3003870I=0684<:C7087028701D200E0:846?2<@03<2 :<8461I=0684<:<>>1;81:3B930?24@4:D870?08484<:028< 600A 870 <?84<: <> 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 870 5012:03 82415 '=3D0 716 @428=1559 ?2030;4303 870 E18802 8 46 156< ;<:80:303 B9 5012:03 ;<=:605 8718 870 1??54;184<: ><2 1E0:3E0:8C16>4503?24<28<;<EE0:;0E0:8<>824151:3 87020><20 87020 C16 :< 4E?034E0:8 ><2 ;12294:D <=8 870 1E0:3E0:86870?514:84>>46:<8E1A4:D<=81:0C;160 ><2 870 2016<: 8718 70 713 1520139 681803 C487 20D123 8< 8701D200E0:8<>615071@4:DB00:0G0;=803C19B1;A<: !&-B92=879=:F1914:>1@<=2<>870?514:84>> 8<60558706=486;703=50?2<?0289E016=24:D >801688< - 6 - C068 1:3 >8 :<287 8< 6<=87 ><2 1 @15=1B50 6150 ;<:64302184<: <> 6( 8 46 >=28702 ;<:80:303 B9 8705012:03;<=:605><2870?514:84>>8718870<:/B50?0G <=28 4: 870 ;160 <> !"##$%&' ())*16C05516 4:870;160<>+,-- - ! "##. "##. /)((* 716 7053 8718 :< 1??54;184<: ><2 1E0:3E0:8 ;1: B0 155<C03 1>802 82415 716 ;<EE0:;03 <C0@02 4: 870 ?2060:8 ;160 <: 71:3 48 46 ;<:80:303 8718 870 1??54;184<: C16 >4503 B9 870 ?514:84>> ?24<28<8700@430:;0B04:D;<EE0:;030:;04846C055 C4874:870?2<@46<8<2302$=50&(<> 7020><20 1E0:3E0:8 <=D78 8< 71@0 B00: 155<C03 B9 870 5012:03 82415F=3D0 & 846156<;<:80:303B98705012:03;<=:605><2 870?514:84>>87184:870?514:870716;501259:1221803870 >1;86C48720D1238<870?514:84>>71@4:D?=2;716038706=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 B9 C19 <> 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 31803 - 7 - !&- >2<E 5180 2=879=:F191 1:3 8718 870 ?514:84>> C16 ?=8 4: ?<660664<: <> 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?02894:?128?02><2E1:;0<>8701D200E0:8<>61501:3 51802=879=:F19171320;04@0316=E<>6& 8<C1236 6150 ;<:64302184<: 1:3 1;A:<C503D0E0:8 8< 8718 0>>0;846156<?2<3=;031:387020E14:4:D1E<=:8C16156< 20;04@03 B9 870 5180 2=879=:F191 )718 20E14:03 C16 <:59 870 0G0;=84<: <> 870 6150 3003 4: ?=26=1:;0 <> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 B9 D0884:D 155 870 20I=4203 3<;=E0:86B9870@0:3<251802=879=:F191846156< ;<:80:303 8718 C16 156< 0G0;=803 ;<=?503 C487 4:802068 1:3 C718 20E14:03 C16 870 20D4682184<: <> 6150 3003 15<:0 16 0:8420 6150 ;<:64302184<: C16 ?143 8< 5180 2=879=:F191 && 012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 870 ?514:84>> 156< ;<:80:36 8718 ?24<2 8< 870 >454:D <> 870 1??54;184<: 4: <& 30>0:31:8<6&1:3!713>4503<=:3020;84<: &&<> C702087030>0:31:866<=D78><2346E46615<> - 8 - 870?2060:86=48<:870D2<=:38718870?514:84>>C7<C161 80:1:8 713 6=>>0203 870 30;200 1520139 1:3 70:;0 870 6143 30;200 ;1::<8 B0 0G0;=803 746 1??54;184<: C74;7 C16 >4503 B9 870 30>0:31:86 ;1E0 8< B0 20F0;803 B9 870 82415<=281:318?121D21?7<&&C745030;434:D8706143 1??54;184<:8705012:0382415'=3D0716705316=:302. 2 2 / $ 3 4,4 $ 56)$ 1 &7 % $ 8 % . $ $ $ 3, 86%%!% 6%!% 2 3, 86%!% 6%%!% 6"56) . $ - 9 - 9 $ : ; - & 7020><20 5012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 870 ?514:84>> ;<:80:36 8718 <: 870 0125402 <;;164<: 870 5012:03 '=3D0 713 <?4:03 8718 870 ?487 1:3 6=B681:;0 <> 870 20540> ;514E03 46 ><2 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 0:;0 870 ?2060:8 1??54;184<:>4503><21E0:3E0:8B9870?514:84>>C<=53:<8 ;71:D0870:18=20<>8706=48168706=E1:36=B681:;04: 870?514:81@02E0:861:3870?50134:D630:<808718C161: 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 1:3 870 ?514:84>> C16 600A4:D 870 ?<660664<: B1;A >2<E 870 30>0:31:86 1>802 71@4:D B00: 4550D1559<=6803>2<E746?<660664<:4:?128?02><2E1:;0<> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 31803 !&- :302 870 ;42;=E681:;06 70 600A6 8< 155<C 870 ?08484<: 1:3 ;<:60I=0:8598<608164308704E?=D:03<2302?16603B9 8705012:0382415'=3D0 - 10 - & / 24 13164@1??1 5012:03 ;<=:6051??0124:D<:B0715><>870206?<:30:86 30>0:31:8 <6& 1:3 ! @070E0:859 ;<:80:36 8718 870 ?2060:8 1??54;184<:>4503B9870?514:84>>46:<8E14:814:1B501:3870 61E0 30602@06 8< B0 346E46603 <=8 24D7859 C487<=8 0@0: ?2<;0034:D >=28702 16 870 ?514:84>> B9 C19 <> 870 1E0:3E0:8 46 600A4:D 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 <> ;<:821;8 1:313420;84<:8<0G0;=80870615030034:206?0;8<>870 6=486;703=50?2<?0289846>=28702;<:80:303B95012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 870 30>0:31:86 8718 870 6=48 ><2 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 46 84E0 B12203 1:3 870 6=48 C16 >4503 4: 870 9012 &(701D200E0:8<>61501550D038<B00G0;=803 46<>8703180 !&-7<=D74846:<813E48803B=8 908 81A4:D 870 3180 4:8< ;<:64302184<: 870 ?2060:8 1??54;184<:>4503B9870?514:84>>600A4:D1E0:3E0:84684E0 B122031:34846E<20871:(90126C74;748605>3460:848506 870 ?514:84>> ><2 600A4:D 1:9 1E0:3E0:8 7020><20 70 600A6 346E46615 <> 870 ?08484<: <: 870 D2<=:3 8718 870 5012:03 82415 '=3D0 716 :<8 ;<EE48803 1:9 022<2 <2 - 11 - 4550D15489<2?02@0264894:?1664:D870<2302<>346E46615<> 870 1??54;184<: 20F0;84:D 870 ?501 <> 870 ?514:84>> ><2 ;12294:D<=81E0:3E0:8 &! 846156<;<:80:303B95012:03;<=:6058718870 >4268 ?21902 E130 B9 870 ?514:84>> 4: 746 ?514:8 46 8< 71:3 <@02@1;1:8?<660664<:<>8706=486;703=50?2<?02898<870 ?514:84>> 70 60;<:3 ?21902 E130 C16 ><2 1 3420;84<: 8< 87030>0:31:86B9C19<>E1:318<294:F=:;84<:8<20D46802 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 4: >1@<=2 <> 870 ?514:84>> 8 46 >=28702 ;<:80:303 8718 870 60;<:3 ?21902 6<=D78 ><2 46 15E<68 4: 870 D=460 <> 1 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 <> 870 ;<:821;8 87<=D7 870 3180 716 :<8 B00: 6?0;4>4;1559 E0:84<:03 7020><20 C718 870?514:84>>C1:86 B9 C19<> 1E0:3E0:84615201396<=D78><24:87060;<:3?219028< 8706=48:302870;42;=E681:;06870?2060:81??54;184<: ><2 1E0:3E0:8 :003:<8 B0;<:6430203 <2 81A0: ><2870 64E?50 2016<: 8718 1520139 6=;7 1 ?21902 46 E130 4: 870 ><2E <> 1 E1:318<29 4:F=:;84<: : 87060 D2<=:36 70 600A6346E46615<>870?08484<: - 12 - & 71@0701235012:03;<=:605><2870?08484<:02 1:35012:03;<=:605><2870206?<:30:86 & 70 ?<4:8 8718 124606 ><2 ;<:64302184<: 46 C708702 870 4E?=D:03 <2302 ?16603 B9 870 5012:03 82415 '=3D0464550D151:3C70870248;1556><24:802>020:;0 &( 8 46 :<8 4: 346?=80 8718 870 6=48 >4503 B9 870 ?514:84>> 46 ><2 71:34:D<@02 @1;1:8 ?<660664<:<>870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 8< 870 ?514:84>> 16 48 0G46803 B0><20 870 3180 <> 4550D15 346?<660664<:1:3 60;<:359 ><2 E1:318<29 4:F=:;84<: 8< 3420;8 870 30>0:31:86 8< 20D46802 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 4: >1@<=2 <> ?514:84>> 1:3 ><2 1:<8702 ?21902 6<=D78 46 8< 3420;8 870 30>0:31:86 8< ?19 5<66 <> 4:;<E0 <> 6& ?02 319 >2<E 870 3180 <> 4550D15 346?<660664<: C74;7 46 & & 1:3 8455 870 3180 <> 346?<615<>6=48 & :1;120>=5?02=615<>870?514:84846600:8718 870 ?514:84>> 716 81A0: 870 ?501 <> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 71@4:D B00: 0:80203 4:8< B9 74E C487 5180 - 13 - 2=879=:F191 <: !&- C487 20D123 8< 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 ><2 1 @15=1B50 6150 ;<:64302184<: <> 6( E016=24:D01688<C068 >8:<2878<6<=87 >8701D200E0:8<>61507161520139B00:?2<3=;03 15<:DC487870?514:870?514:84>>4:?128?02><2E1:;0<> 8701D200E0:8 <>6150 716?143 0:8420 6150 ;<:64302184<: 1E<=:8 4: 1 ?71603 E1::02 4: 155 6( 8< 5180 2=879=:F191 8 46 156< ;<:80:303 8718 4: ?128 ?02><2E1:;0 <> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 31803 !&- 870 ?514:84>> C16 ?=8 4:8< ?<660664<: <> 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 < C718 C16 50>8 C16 <:59 C487 20D123 8< 870 0G0;=84<:1:320D4682184<:<>870615030034:>1@<=2<>870 ?514:84>> 4: 802E6 <> 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 1>802 60;=24:D :0;0661293<;=E0:86846156<;<:80:3034:870?50134:D6 <> 870 ?514:8 8718 15<:D C487 870 1D200E0:8 <> 6150 ?514:84>> 713 0G0;=803 1 :<8<24J03 D0:0215 ?<C02 <> 188<2:09 ;<=?503 C487 4:802068 C74;7 156< ?2<@06 870 >1;8 8718 C718 C16 20I=4203 8< B0 3<:0 B9 870 @0:3<2 <> 870 ?514:84>> C16 <:59 8< 0G0;=80 870 20D4680203 6150 3003 4: - 14 - >1@<=2 <> 870 ?514:84>> < 3<=B8 870 ?514:84>> 716 156< ?501303 8718 3=24:D 870 ;<=260 <> 870 ?2<;0034:D6 4: 870 ;<<234:180 ?08484<:6 >4503 B9 870 30>0:31:86 4: < & 1:3 & & 870 ?514:84>> C16 0@4;803 346?<6606603 >2<E 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 <: & &=8C708702874616?0;8716B00:81A0::<80 <> B9 870 ?514:84>> <2 ?501303 4: 1:9 <8702 ?2<;0034:D6 1?128 >2<E 870 ?50134:D6 7020 46 8< B0 ;<:6430203 4: 870 6=48C7450?1664:D870E14:<2302B987082415'=3D0 &- <C 870 I=0684<: 8718 124606 46 C708702 870 1E0:3E0:88718466<=D784620I=42038<B04:;<2?<218034: 8706=48?2<;0034:D6846600:87188701??54;184<:871846 >4503B9870?514:84>>46E020598<4:;<2?<2180870?219028< ?166 1 F=3DE0:8 1:3 30;200 ><2 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 4: >1@<=2 <> 870 ?514:84>> B9 3420;84:D 870 30>0:31:86 8< 0G0;=80120D4680203615030031:3<:>145=208<3<6<8< 3420;887020D46829<>870;<=288<0G0;=80870615030034: >1@<=2<>870?514:84>>1:38<3054@02@1;1:8?<660664<:<> 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 > 870 61E0 46 F=G81?<603 8< - 15 - 870?219021520139E130B9870?514:84>>4:870?514:8870 >4268 ?21902 C16 8< 3420;8 870 30>0:31:86 8< 71:3 <@02 @1;1:8 ?<660664<: <> 870 6=48 6;703=50 ?2<?0289 8< 870 ?514:84>> 16 48 0G46803 B0><20 870 3180 <> 4550D15 346?<660664<: 70 60;<:3 ?21902 C16 8< 3420;8 870 30>0:31:86B9C19<>E1:318<294:F=:;84<:8<20D46802870 6=486;703=50?2<?02894:>1@<=2<>870?514:84>>70><=287 ?21902C168<3420;887030>0:31:868<?195<66<>4:;<E0 <> 6& ?02 319 >2<E 870 3180 <> 4550D15 346?<660664<: 40& & 8455 870 3180 <> 346?<615 <> 8706=48:1;120>=5?02=615<>8706087200?21902615<:D C487 870 <8702 48 46 600: 8718 C718 870 ?514:84>> 46 :<C 600A4:D 8< 4:;<2?<2180 B9 C19 <> 1E0:3E0:8 46 1520139 4:;<2?<218034:870?50134:D61:36<156<4:870?21902<> 870 ?514:8 7020><20 E02059 B9 :<8 68184:D 870 C<236 F=3DE0:81:330;200><26?0;4>4;?02><2E1:;048;<=53:<8 81A0 1C19 870 6=E 1:3 6=B681:;0 <2 870 ?487 1:3 6=B681:;0 <> 870 ?50134:D6 1:3 870 ?21902 E130 B9 870 ?514:84>> 8 C16 156< 2050@1:8 8< :<80 8718 870 82415 <=28 - 16 - 48605> 4: 486 <2302 ?16603 <: < >4503 B9 870 30>0:31:86<6&1:3!7164:>1;8681803871887<=D7 :<?21902><26?0;4>4;?02><2E1:;0466<=D78><2?4871:3 6=B681:;0<>87020540>;514E0346><26?0;4>4;?02><2E1:;0 746B04:D870;160C70:1551@02E0:861:3?50134:D6120 1520139 E130 4: 870 ?514:8 4:;5=34:D 870 ?21902 870 I=0684<:<>155<C4:D870?514:84>>8<;1229<=81E0:3E0:8 8< 4:;<2?<2180 870 C<236 K6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 <> 870 ;<:821;8HE19:<8B020I=42034:E97=EB50<?4:4<: 8 46 156< 2050@1:8 8< E0:84<: 8718 5012:03 ;<=:605 ><2 870 ?514:84>> 3=24:D 870 ;<=260 <> 12D=E0:86 6=BE486 8718 70 716 1520139 503 746 0@430:;0 1:3 870 E1880246:<C6083<C:><212D=E0:861:3871870C<=53 :<8 ?2066 ><2 ?2<3=;4:D 1:9 >=28702 0@430:;0 4> 870 1E0:3E0:8468<B0155<C037020><20C70:870?514:84>> 46 :<8 4:80206803 4: 50134:D 1:9 >=28702 0@430:;0 1:3 155 8718 46 6<=D78 ><2 4: 870 1E0:3E0:8 46 1520139 4:;<2?<21803 4: 870 ?514:8 1@02E0:86 1:3 870 ?21902 E02059 ><2 870 16A4:D <> 6?0;4>4; C<236 :<8 B04:D - 17 - 4:;<2?<21803 :003 :<8 B0 870 2016<: 8< 155<C 870 1??54;184<: ><2 1E0:3E0:8 8 46 <?0: 8< 870 82415 '=3D0 C7<7161520139<?4:034:8704:8024E<23028718870?487 1:3 6=B681:;0 <> 870 ?514:8 1@02E0:86 46 ><2 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0<>870;<:821;8)70:8718B04:D6<87082415 <=28671553015C4878706=4816D<<3168706=4846>4503><2 1 6?0;4>4; ?02><2E1:;0 <> 870 ;<:821;8 < 156< ><2 870 2016<: 8718 870 60;<:3 ?21902 E130 46 ><2 1 E1:318<29 4:F=:;84<:8<20D468028706=486;703=50?2<?02894:>1@<=2 <>870?514:84>> & 8462050@1:88<E0:84<:188746681D087188746 <=28 716 :<8 305@03 4:8< 870 E02486 <> 870 E18802 C487 20D1238<8701D200E0:8<>6150<287061E0B04:DB12203 B984E0<2><28718E18802870@15434891:3D0:=4:489<>870 61E04846<?0:8<8705012:0382415F=3D08<3015C487484: 1;;<231:;0 C487 51C B1603 <: 870 <215 1:3 3<;=E0:8129 E18024156 - 18 - :302870;42;=E681:;0671@4:D:<8><=:31:9 D<<3 D2<=:3 <2 ;<D0:8 2016<: 8< 155<C 870 1??54;184<: ?166870><55<C4:D. 4 : @40C <> 870 <B602@184<:6 E130 70204:1B<@0?08484<:46346?<603 44 70 6=48 67155 B0 8201803 16 <:0 ><2 6?0;4>4;?02><2E1:;0 444 012:03 2415 '=3D0 46 20I=06803 8< 346?<60 <> 870 6=48 C4874: <:0 E<:87 >2<E 870 3180 <>20;04?8 <>;<?9 <> 870 <2302 16 :<874:D >=28702 20E14:6 0G;0?8 ><2 13320664:D 12D=E0:86 () & !' " $ 468<.&-5<.& .