- 1 - !"#" !$$ %& ' ! "#$ ! % &'&(&$' $&(&$& ! % '# &) *' ! % +'(&$' ! $&(&$&,% '#, &) *' '# &) *' ! + + -! ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "! $ ./ 010/ .12 34/5/44/6 0.72 133/18 1917:20 0./ ;<69=/:0 610/6 &'&(&$' 3122/6 7: /227>:2 12/ >$&(&$&?@0./66707>:18 72047A01:6/227>:2!<69/ 1:918>4/5>42.>40B0./04718><40C ( ./ 31407/2 ./4/7: 14/ 4/5/44/6 0> 12 3/4 0./74 41:D 1:62010<2?/5>4/0./04718><40 ./?47/551A028/167:90>0.72133/1814/0.10+ ./ /0/A07E/:23/A0>4 :07 >F4@/88 1:918>4/ .12 2<?=700/6 0./ A.149/,2.//0 1917:20 0./ 1AA<2/6 5>4 0./ >55/:A/2 3<:72.1?8/ <:6/4 /A07>:2 '# &' 4/16 F70. /A07>:'1:6182>5>40./>55/:A/2<:6/4/A07>:2'# &) 1:6*'>50./:671:/:18>6/5>42.>40 G0./H ' 072188/9/6?@0./34>2/A<07>:0.100./4/23>:6/:0, 1://51AA<2/6>( F12.141227:90./6/A/12/6!1=//810> F10A.?8</578=2F70..7=1:60>.1E/2/I<184/8107>:F70../4 0./4/?@04/10/6./4F70.A4</80@1:6><0419/6./4=>6/20@1:6 .12 182> 97E/: =/:018 788,04/10=/:0 F.7A. 5>4A/6 !1=//81 0> - 3 - A>==702<7A76/.<2 1AA<2/6>(4/23>:6/:0.12A>==700/6 0./188/9/6>55/:A/2 * 3>:./147:9>:A.149/2 0./4718><40541=/60./ A.149/2 5>4 0./ 15>4/2176 >55/:A/2 ./ 21=/ F12 4/16 >E/4 1:6/I3817:/60>1AA<2/6>(1E7:9<:6/420>>60./21=/ 1AA<2/6>(38/16/6:>09<780@1:6A817=/60>?/047/6 ) : >46/4 0> 34>E/ 0./ 9<780 >5 0./ 1AA<2/6 34>2/A<07>: /I1=7:/6 /79.0//: F70:/22/2 12 2$ 0> $# 1:6 0F/:0@,>:/6>A<=/:02F/4/=14D/612I.7?702$0>($> =10/4718>?;/A02F/4/=14D/6>:?/.185>50./34>2/A<07>:: A8>2<4/ >5 /E76/:A/ >: 0./ 34>2/A<07>: 276/ 0./ 2010/=/:0 >5 0./1AA<2/6<:6/4/A07>:$>50./47=7:184>A/6<4/>6/ 5>42.>40 G0./4HF124/A>46/6AA<2/6>(.120>0188@ 6/:7/6 0./ /E76/:A/ >5 0./ 34>2/A<07>: F70:/22/2 / 676 :>0 A.>>2/0>8/161:@6/5/:A//E76/:A/>:.72?/.185 " 1E7:9./1460./149<=/:02>:?>0.276/2 0./4718 ><401AJ<700/61AA<2/6>(5>40./>55/:A/23<:72.1?8/<:6/4 /A07>:2'# &)1:6*'>50.//7:919947/E/6?@ 0./;<69=/:0>51AJ<70018 0./010/.1234/5/44/60.72133/18 - 4 - # /146 8/14:/6 79. ><40 >E/4:=/:0 8/16/4 133/147:9 5>4 0./ 133/881:0010/ 1:6 8/14:/6 A><:2/8 5>4 0./ 4/23>:6/:0 ./ 8/14:/6 79. ><40 >E/4:=/:0 8/16/4 F><86 2<?=700.100./7=3<9:/6;<69=/:0>51AJ<700183122/6?@0./ 4718><4072A>:0414@0>81F /E76/:A/1:6=10/471821E1781?8/ >:4/A>46./4/12>:212279:/6?@0./8/14:/6/227>:2!<69/ F.78/ 31227:9 0./ 7=3<9:/6 ;<69=/:0 >5 1AJ<70018 14/ /44>:/><2 ./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2 !<69/ .12 :>0 34>3/48@ /E18<10/60.//E76/:A/>52( )1:6 F.>14/0./4/8107E/2 >5 0./ E7A07= .1E/ 6/3>2/6 1?><0 0./ 788,04/10=/:0 =/0/6 ><0 ?@0./1AA<2/60>0./E7A07=./8/14:/6/227>:2!<69/.12 5178/6 0> A>:276/4 0.10 0./ 6/10. >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 >AA<44/6 F70.7:2/E/:@/142>50./=144719/ 23/A757A188@150/45><4@/142 1:6/79.0=>:0.2 1:60./4/5>4/10041A020./34/2<=307>:>51: <::10<4186/10.<:6/4/A07>:$$>50./:671:E76/:A/A0 $#"( $& 0 72 5<40./4 A>:0/:6/6 0.10 0./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2 !<69/.125178/60>/E18<10/0.//E76/:A/>5' F.>720./ 7:6/3/:6/:0 F70:/22 0> 0./ A12/ >5 0./ 34>2/A<07>: ./ - 5 - 8/14:/6/227>:2!<69/.12182>5178/60>/E18<10/0.//E76/:A/ >5 * F.> 72 0./ ?4>0./4 >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 1:6 0./ A>=3817:1:0 1:6 ./ 23/1D2 4/91467:9 6/=1:6 >5 6>F4@ 1:6 1AA/301:A/ >5 6>F4@ ?@ 0./ 1AA<2/6 ./ 8/14:/6 /227>:2 !<69/.12182>5178/60>/E18<10/0.//E76/:A/>52" # $& $$ $ $' $) 1:6 $# ./ 1AA<2/6 .12 :>0 97E/: 34>3/4 /I381:107>:F.78/4/A>467:90./2010/=/:0<:6/4/A07>:$>5 0./4 F.7A..12:>0?//:A>:276/4/6?@0./4718><40: 1880./2/94><:62 ./341@20>188>F0./133/18 $$ 2 1917:20 0.72 8/14:/6 A><:2/8 5>4 0./ 4/23>:6/:01AA<2/6 F><86 2<?=70 0.10 0./ 4718 ><40 .12 34>3/48@ 1334/A710/6 0./ /E76/:A/ >: 4/A>46 7: 34>3/4 3/423/A07E/?2>8<0/8@0./4/14/:>94><:620>7:0/45/4/F70. 0./ 7=3<9:/6 ;<69=/:0 >5 1AJ<70018 : 188 0./2/ 94><:62 341@20>672=7220./133/18 $( 1E7:9 ./146 0./ 149<=/:02 >: ?>0. 276/2 1:6 >: 3/4<218 >5 0./ =10/47182 1E1781?8/ >: 4/A>46 0./ 5>88>F7:9 3>7:02F><861472/5>4=@A>:276/4107>:+ $ ./0./40./4718><4072;<20757/67:1AJ<7007:9 0./ 1AA<2/6 5>4 0./ 188/9/6 A>==7227>: >5 - 6 - >55/:A/2<:6/4/A07>:2'# &)1:6*'>5 0./ ( .1046/4K ()*+,-.)$-./ $ /5>4/ 1334/A7107>: >5 /E76/:A/ 1:6 4/A>46 70 72 3/407:/:00>=/:07>:0./;<69=/:02>50./>:-?8/3/I><40 7: 0./ A12/ >5 4/3>40/67: 4/3>40/67: !! 4/3>40/6 7: 1:6 4/3>40/67: $' : 0./ A12/ >5 2<341 0./ 3/I ><40 .12 2<==147L/6 0./ 347:A738/2 9>E/4:7:9 /I/4A72/ >5 33/8810/ ;<47267A07>: F.78/ 6/187:9 F70. 1: 133/18 1917:20 ;<69=/:0 >5 1AJ<70018 <:6/4 2/A07>: "# >5 >6/ >5 47=7:18 4>A/6<4/12<:6/4+ - 7 - ! " ! ! # $ $ ! ! $ # $ ! % & ! # $ ! ! ! $ ' $ $ ! ! $ $ $ $ ( $* : 0./ A12/ >5 2<341 70 72 >?2/4E/6 0.10 70 72 ?/@>:6 0./ 318/ >5 6><?0 0.10 0./ 2A>3/ >5 7:0/45/4/:A/ ?@ 1: 33/8810/ ><40 5>44/E/427:9 0./ ;<69=/:0 >5 1AJ<70018 4/A>46/6 ?@ 0./ - 8 - 4718><407:51E><4>50./1AA<2/6.120>?//I/4A72/6F70.7: 0./5><4A>4:/42>50./5>88>F7:9347:A738/2./21=/14/+ B ) ! $ * ! " $ ! $ ! $ ! !$ C $) >34>E/0./A12/>50./34>2/A<07>: 0./34>2/A<07>: .12 /I1=7:/6 /79.0//: F70:/22/2 12 2$ 0> $# 1:6 182> =14D/60F/:0@,>:/6>A<=/:02 $" $,1472.1> 0./3.>0>9413./4.126/3>2/612 0> 0./ 3.>0>2 >5 0./ 6/16 ?>6@ >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 01D/: 7: 0./ =>40<14@>5>E/4:=/:0>237018101:01F18 $# (,?6<8 .16/4 .12 6/3>2/6 0.10 ./ D:>F2 1AA<2/6 $ 1:6 ( 1:6 1AA<2/6 >$ 72 @><:9/4 ?4>0./4 >5 1AA<2/6 >( ./ 6/A/12/6 !1=//81 72 0./ F75/ >5 ?6<8 L//L ./ .<2?1:6 >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 !1=//81 72 201@7:9 7: - 9 - 5>4/79:A><:04@/.12:>06/3>2/61:@0.7:91917:201AA<2/6 >(1:6./F1204/10/612.>2078/F70:/22 $ ,?6<8 1;//6 .12 182> :>0 2<33>40/6 0./ A12/ >50./34>2/A<07>: (& ',?6<8 L//L 72 0./ ./1421@ F70:/22 / .12 6/3>2/60.10./D:>F2!1=//811:61://527:A/',*@/142/ 6/3>2/6 0.10 1?><0 ',* @/142 ?1AD !1=//81 ./4 ?4>0./4 1://51:61AA<2/6>(.16A>=/0>0./.><2/>5(1:6 0./4/ 0./ A>=3817:1:0 7/ 0./ ?4>0./4 >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 !1=//81 .16 7:5>4=/6 0.10 1AA<2/6 >( 72 04/107:9 0./ 6/A/12/6F70.A4</80@./4/5>4/ ./.162010/60.10!1=//81 A1::>0 201@ 7: 0./ =1047=>:718 .><2/ 12 1AA<2/6 >( 72 7:27207:9 0>F10A.0./578=2F.7A. A><86:>0?/2//:/ 21@2 0.10(2/:0.72A140>2/:6!1=//810>./4314/:018.><2/ /5<40./421@20.10./0>>D0./A14>5(1:6182>!1=//81 1:6 64>33/6 ./4 7: 0./ .><2/ >5 A>=3817:1:0,1://5 / 5<40./421@20.10150/4$&0>$*61@2>52<A.A>:A787107>:/55>40 7: 0./ .><2/ >5 ( ./ A1=/ 0> D:>F 0.10 !1=//81 .16 A>==700/62<7A76/ - 10 - ($ *,=141??1 72 0./ ?4>0./4 >5 6/A/12/6 1:6 0./ A>=3817:1:0/.126/3>2/60.101://572.72?4>0./4/72 87E7:91?4>16,72.72=>0./4 ,'72.722720/41:6,* 72.72<:A8/-261<9.0/4 /A/12/6!1=//8172.72@><:9/42720/4 AA<2/6 >( 34/2/:0 ?/5>4/ 0./ ><40 72 0./ ?4>0./4 >5 1AA<2/6>$4><:6$$@/14219> !1=//81=1447/61AA<2/6 >$ 10 17D1=?1 ?><0 1 =>:0. ?/5>4/ 0./ F/667:9 0./ AA<2/6>$1:6 .7251=78@.16A>=/.>=/0>2//!1=//81 ./4/150/4 0./@ 182> E7270/6 0./74 .><2/ <47:9 0./ F/667:9 :/9>07107>:2 AA<2/6 >$ 1:6 .72 ?4>0./4,7:,81F 6/=1:6/6 2(&& 81D. 1:6 $&& 31E1: 9>86 12 6>F4@ ./@ .16 97E/: 2$&&81D.A12. 1:6"*31E1:9>86AA<2/6>$1AA/30/6 0./21=/12.>52$&&81D.F1297E/:0>AA<2/6>$?@ =@@><:9/4?4>0./421://51:62=1780725<40./46/3>2/6 0.10 10 0./ 07=/ >5 F/667:9 $&& 31E1: >5 9>86 F12 97E/: 0> !1=//8150/40./F/667:9 !1=//81201@/6F70.AA<2/6>$ 5>415/F61@2 10.72381A/10/4 2./4/0<4:/60>><4.>=/ AA<2/6 >$ F12 F>4D7:9 12 1 647E/4 7: <?17 150/4 0./74 =144719/ ./: 2./ =1447/6 AA<2/6 >$ 1:6 F/:0 0> .72 .><2/ AA<2/6>( .72F75/1:6A.7864/:F/4/182>4/2767:9 >41?><0*0>)=>:0.2 !1=//811:6AA<2/6>$F/4/87E7:9 - 11 - .13378@ F70. /1A. >0./4 10/4 AA<2/6 >$ 6/=1:6/6 2*& &&&,54>=!1=//81722720/47:5>4=/61?><00./21=/ 0> .72 ?4>0./4,1://5 AA>467:98@ 1://5 .16 97E/: 2*& &&&, 0> 0./ AA<2/6 >$ ./: AA<2/6 >$ F12 F>4D7:97: <?17./F><86A>=/.>=//E/4@@/141:6201@5>4 1=>:0.50/41@/14>50./74=144719/ AA<2/6>$1:6.72 51=78@20140/667287D7:9./4AA<2/6>$1:6.72=>0./4F/4/ 5>4A7:9!1=//810>9>?1AD0>./4314/:018.><2/<40./47072 6/3>2/6 0.10 F./: !1=//81 F12 4/2767:9 F70. AA<2/6 >$ AA<2/6>(<2/60>2.>F./4>?2A/:/E76/>21:65>4A/6./4 0>9>F70../4!1=//817:5>4=/61?><00.720>1://50.4><9. 3.>:/:>46/40>672A<220./1?>E/ 1://5F/:00>AA<2/6 >$-2.><2/>F/E/4 0./2176722</F12:>02>8E/6AA<2/6 >(0.4/10/:/6.72?4>0./40.1075./4/E/1821?><00./ 0> 1:@>:/ !1=//81 F><86 :>0 9/0 ./4 A.786 ./4/150/4 1://5 ?4><9.0=@2720/4?1AD.>=/!1=//81.16161<9.0/4?@0./ :1=/ <2.410. 1:< 50/4 A>=7:9 .>=/ !1=//81 F12 F>447/65>4$&61@2:&&((&&# F127:74>6./: 4/0<4:/6.>=/54>=0./4/10'>4*3= 3/>38/.16910./4/6 :/14 0./ .><2/ @ 2720/4 !1=//81 .16 A>==700/6 2<7A76/ ?@ - 12 - ;<=37:9 7:0> 1 F/88 :/14 0./ .><2/ <:1?8/ 0> ?/14 0./ .14122=/:0>5AA<2/6$1:6( (( )147@1==1 F.>720./2720/4>50./6/A/12/6 .12 6/3>2/6 0.10 $,1://5 72 ./4 ?4>0./4 /A/12/6 !1=//81 72 ./4 2720/4 /4 =144719/ F12 2>8/=:7L/6 F70. 0./ 1AA<2/6 >$ $$ @/142 19> 10 4/=7/4/ 188 7: 17D1=?1 0 0./ 07=/ >5 =144719/ 0./ 1AA<2/6 >$ .16 12D/6 5>4 $&& 31E1:>59>86(&&0F>81D.4<3//2126>F4@./:./4?4>0./4 1:627?87:9221760.100./@A><86:>097E/0.10=<A.1:6F><86 97E/ "* 31E1: >5 9>86 >4:1=/:02 1:6 >:/ 81D. 4<3//2 AA>467:98@ $91E/>:/81D.4<3//20>0./1AA<2/67:0./ 34/2/:A/>5188>50./= <47:90./=144719/ 0./@.1697E/: "* 31E1: >5 9>86 >4:1=/:02 0> !1=//81 50/4 0./ =144719/ !1=//81201@/6100./.><2/>50./1AA<2/6./1AA<2/6$1:6 ( 0./74 =>0./4 0./ F75/ 1:6 A.7864/: >5 1AA<2/6 >( F/4/ 87E7:97:0./.><2/>50./1AA<2/600./07=/>5=144719/ 0./ 1AA<2/6>$F12F>4D7:9121647E/47: <?17>4*=>:0.2 150/4=144719/ 0./1AA<2/6>$1:6!1=//81F/4/F/88./: 0./1AA<2/6$F1234/22<47:9!1=//810>97E/=>4/=>:/@12 6>F4@ 7/0>1441:9/=>:/@5>4.7=0>9>0> <?17!1=//81 - 13 - .16A188/6=/1:67:5>4=/6=/1?><00.72:0.724/9146 $ 91E/2*& &&&,0>0./1AA<2/6>$./:0./1AA<2/6>$ F/:00> <?17./1AA<2/6$<2/60>A>=/0>0./E78819/54>= <?17>:A/1@/141:6201@7:0./E78819/5>41=>:0.!1=//81 1:61AA<2/6$.16161<9.0/4AA<2/6$ AA<2/6(1:60./ F75/ >5 AA<2/6 ( <2/6 0> 0>40<4/ !1=//81 ./ 1AA<2/6 ( !1=//81H2?4>0./4,7:,81F<2/60>5>4A/=@2720/40>F10A.?8</ 578=A122/00/2F70..7=1:6A>,>3/410/F70..7=!1=//81.16 0>86 =/ 1:6 =@ /86/4 ?4>0./4 1?><0 0.72 $ .16 9>:/ 0> <418 167 F./4/ 0./ 1AA<2/6-2 .><2/ 72 8>A10/6 1:6 .16 1 31:A.1@101?><00.724><:60./07=/!1=//813122/61F1@ 0./ 1AA<2/6 >$ .16 A>=/ 0> ./4 E78819/ 54>= <?17 E/: 150/4 ./ F/:0 0> <?17 ./4 @><:9/4 2720/4 !1=//81201@/6 10 0./1AA<2/6-2.><2/00.1007=/ 0./1AA<2/6(F125>4A7:9 !1=//810>F10A.?8</578=20./4/1:6A>,>3/410/F70..7=: 0./31:A.1@10./86>:0.10>AA127>: 70F120>860.10./4/86/4 ?4>0./42.><8601D/!1=//81F70.0./=<:0780./1AA<2/6>$ 4/0<4:/6 54>= <?17 1:6 0.10 2./ 2.><86 4/0<4: 150/4 0./ 1AA<2/6 >$ 4/0<4:/6 0> ./4 E78819/ AA>467:98@ $ .16 01D/: ./4 @><:9/4 2720/4 1:6 ./4 61<9.0/4 0> ./4 .><2/ 7/ >>6?7647!1=//811:6./4A.786201@/610><4.><2/5>40.4// - 14 - 61@2 0 0.10 07=/ !1=//81 0>86 =/ 1?><0 0./ 0>40<4/ ?/7:9 7:587A0/6 ?@ 1AA<2/6 >( >: ./4 .4// 61@2 810/4 !1=//81 F/:00>><4=>0./4-2.><2/!1=//81F12E/4@6/34/22/6F./: 2./ A1=/ 0> 0./74 .><2/ ./@ 0>86 ./4 2/E/418 07=/2 :>0 0> F>44@1?><00.72<0!1=//81D/300.107:A76/:07:=7:61:6 D/3012D7:9<2F./0./42./2.><8687E/150/42<A.1.<=787107>: >4 0.72 4/12>: =@ 2720/4 !1=//81 A>==700/6 2<7A76/ ?@ ;<=37:97:0>0./F/88100./74=>0./4-2.><2/>:46/?4<14@ (&$# ( ",>:18614>:.1.126/3>2/60.10././1460./ 2A4/1=254>=0./.><2/>50./A>=3817:1:01:6./F/:00./4/ 1:6 5><:6 0.10 !1=//81 .16 5188/: 7:0> 0./ F/88 1:6 7==/6710/8@./8750/60./?>6@54>=0./F/881:60./4/150/40./ 3>87A/A1=/0>0./23>0 (' #==1414>>J.126/3>2/612 0>0./7:J</20 31:A.1:1=1A>:6<A0/6123/4I.7?70) (* ,2=178 .12 6/3>2/6 0.10 ./ .16 100/:6/6 0./ =144719/ >5 1AA<2/6 >$ 1:6 !1=//81 10 4/=7/4/ 188 1:6 1?><0$&61@2347>40>0./=144719/ ./.169>:/0>0./.><2/ >50./1AA<2/61:60./A>=3817:1:0317612<=>52$&&81D. - 15 - 0>1AA<2/6>$/21@20.107:0./.><2/>50./1AA<2/6 .72 =>0./4 ?4>0./42 0./74 F7E/2 1:6 2720/42 87E7:9 0>9/0./4 / 21@2 0.10 1AA<2/6 >$ .16 6/=1:6/6 1: 166707>:18 2<= >5 2*& &&&,150/40./=144719/1:60./21762<=F12182>97E/: 0> .7= / 21@2 0.10 0./4/ F12 182> A>:A787107>: 12 0./4/ F12 6723<0/?/0F//:1AA<2/6>$1:60./6/A/12/61:60./4/150/4 0./ 51=78@ =/=?/42 >5 0./ 1AA<2/6 .12 122<4/6 0.10 0./@ F><86 :>0 .14122 0./ 6/A/12/6 5<40./4 / 182> 21@2 0.10 1AA<2/6>(F127:27207:90./6/A/12/60>2//?8</578=2F70. .7=1:6!1=//81.16672A8>2/621=/?/5>4/.7=1:60./4/5>4/ 0./4/F12A>:A787107>:1:66/2370/2<A.1:/55>40 1AA<2/6>( .16A>:07:</6.72.1?70 () $&,10.:1 <=14 2176 0> ?/ 0./ 31:A.1 F70:/22 .126/3>2/6120>0./31:A.1:1=1I.7?70" (" $$ 72 0./ /67A18 557A/4 F.> A>:6<A0/6 3>20, =>40/=>50./?>6@>50./6/A/12/6/.12182>6/3>2/6120> 0./722<1:A/>53>20,=>40/=4/3>40123/4I.7?70 (# $(720.//:97://4>50./ F.>.12641F:0./ 2D/0A.>50./23>0>50./7:A76/:07/ F/881:67022<44><:67:92 123/4I.7?70$& - 16 - ( $ 0./E78819/1AA><:01:0.126/3>2/6120>0./ 722<1:A/>50./123/4I.7?70$$ & $',1:;<:10. 0./ 18<D1 I/A<07E/ 19720410/ .12 6/3>2/6 0.10 >: &&((&&# ./ .12 4/A/7E/6 3.>:/ =/2219/ 12 0> 0./ 2<7A76/ 7: 1:01F18 <418 >87A/ 0107>: ;<47267A07>: 10 1?><0 #,& 3= 1:6 0./ 3>87A/ 4/J</20/6.7=0>A>:6<A07:J</2031:A.1:1=1AA>467:98@ ./ .12 4/A/7E/6 4/J<72707>: 54>= 0./ 12 3/4 I.7?70 $( ./: ./E7270/60./>E/4:=/:0>237018 1:0F1810#,&3= 1:6 /I1=7:/6 0./ 6/16,?>6@ 1:6 A>:6<A0/6 7:J</20 31:A.1:1=1 12 3/4 I.7?70 ) 0 0./ 07=/ >5 A>:6<A07:9 31:A.1:1=1 ./.124/A>46/60./2010/=/:02>5=141??11:6 1://5 : 0./ :/I0 61@ ./ .12 4/A>46/6 0./ 2010/=/:02 >5 0./ =>0./4 1:6 2720/4 >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 7/ 27@1==1 1:6 147@1==1 / .12 A>:6<A0/6 =1.1L14 12 3/4 I.7?70 " 50/4 A>:6<A07:9 =1.1L14 1:6 4/A>467:9 2010/=/:02 >5 0./ 1?>E/2176F70:/22/2 ./A1=/0>D:>F0.100./6/A/12/667/6 6</0>788,04/10=/:0>5./4.<2?1:61:651=78@=/=?/42>50./ .<2?1:6 >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 ./4/150/4 ./ 2/:0 1 8/00/4 0> 0./ - 17 - 0> A>:6<A0 2<701?8/ 7:E/2079107>: 7: 0./ =100/4 12 3/4 I.7?70$' $ $*,.14107 $), 191?.<2.1: @ $",?.72./D >/8 1:6 $#,1E7041 /; .1E/ 6/3>2/6120>0./744/23/A07E/7:E/2079107>: ( : A14/5<8 /I1=7:107>: >5 0./ /:074/ /E76/:A/ >: 4/A>46 70 72 A4@2018 A8/14 0.10 0./ =144719/ ?/0F//: 1AA<2/6 >$ 1:6 6/A/12/6 0>>D 381A/ >: (&)(&& ./ 6/A/12/6 !1=//81 A>==700/6 2<7A76/ >: &&((&&# 10 1?><0 ,& 3= ./4/150/4 1://52>10/>.6%<1@@<=.124/3>40/60./ 21=/ 0> 0./ 1:0F18 <418 >87A/ 12 3/4 I.7?70 (& 0 0./ 07=/ >5 5787:9 0.72 A>=3817:0 0./ A>=3817:1:0 1://5 .12 :>0 F.723/4/61:@0.7:91917:200./34/2/:01AA<2/6./4/150/4 10 0./ 4/J</20 >5 A>:A/4:/6 3>87A/ 0./ 18<D1 I/A<07E/ 19720410/,1:;<:10.A>:6<A0/60./7:J</2031:A.1:1=1 123/4I.7?70).78/A>:6<A07:97:J</2031:A.1:1=1 0./ 18<D1 I/A<07E/ 19720410/ .12 4/A>46/6 2010/=/:02 >5 0./ 2>=/F70:/22/2 <47:90./A><42/>57:J</2031:A.1:1=1 ./ A1=/ 0> D:>F 1?><0 0./ 788,04/10=/:0 97E/: ?@ 1AA<2/6 >( /:A/ ./ 674/A0/6 0./ A>:A/4:/6 3>87A/ 0> 01D/ :/A/2214@ - 18 - 1A07>: 1917:20 0./ 1AA<2/6 AA>467:98@ 0./ 2<?,7:23/A0>4 >5 <418>87A/0107>: 1:0F18 2<>=>0<4/9720/4/60./A12/12 3/4 I.7?70 $# : 0.10 ?1272 1:0F18 <418 >87A/ .1E/ 4/9720/4/60./A12/7:47=/>'(&&#1917:201AA<2/6$0> 5>4 0./ >55/:A/2 3<:72.1?8/ <:6/4 /A07>:2 '# &' 4/16 F70./A07>:$'>50./1:62<?=700/60./0>0./><40 >: &"&((&&# 10 ($'* .><42 >>: 150/4 0./ 6/10. >5 0./ 6/A/12/6 :>?>6@ .12 8>69/6 1 A>=3817:0 :8@ 150/4 7:J</20 31:A.1:1=1 0./ 3>87A/ .1E/ 2<> =>0< 4/9720/4/6 0./ A12/ 1917:20 1AA<2/6 $ 0> 50/4 7:E/2079107>: 0./ :E/2079107:9 557A/4.12578/6A.149/2.//0>:8@1917:201AA<2/6$1:6( : /I1=7:107>: >5 0./ /:074/ /E76/:A/ 1:6 4/A>46 0.72><4072>50./>37:7>:0.100./4718><40.121334/A710/6 0.//E76/:A/>:4/A>467:31419413.2(*0>*&>50./;<69=/:0 1:6 7: E7/F >5 0./ 4/12>:2 12279:/6 7: 1:6 31419413.2 0./ 4718><40.121AJ<700/60./1AA<2/6 ' : 4/,/I1=7:107>: 4/,A>:276/4107>: 1:6 4/, 1334/A7107>:>50.//:074//E76/:A/>:4/A>46 6>:>057:61:@ 8/918>451A0<18/44>47:0./;<69=/:0>51AJ<700183122/6?@0./ 4718 ><40 >:276/47:9 0./ 51A02 1:6 A74A<=201:A/2 >5 0./ - 19 - A12/1:6182>D//37:97:=7:60./15>4/21766/A727>:2120>0./ 2A>3/>50./33/8810/><40 1=>50./>37:7>:0.100./4718 ><4072;<20757/67:31227:90./;<69=/:0>51AJ<70018/:A/ 1:2F/43>7:0>$7:0./""#$%&'#( ()*+,-.)$-./ + * >4 0./ 15>4/2010/6 4/12>:2 1:6 672A<227>:2 34>A//60>31220./5>88>F7:9+ ./47=7:1833/1872)#*%#**() ,0 %#"& " 720>+$8>+*(