Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2026 DAILYLAW 35910 (PNJ)
MAJOR SINGH SINCE DECEASED TH. LRS AND ORS v. PUNJAB STATE TH. COLLECTOR (INDUSTRIES DEPTT. CHD. ) AND ORS
RFA/228/2024 · 2026-08-13
Jagmohan Bansal
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 35910 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 35910 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
-1-
!"#!$%&%"'()**+
!" #$"%"
&'
"( ) !"
( ,-* . .-*
&$" !* $+ ,$!$ - ./0 )1(2! 3($ -2 !"4 !"
$+ %$5 ,%6$0 &% 78
$+ ,+,+ /9%$0 )1(2! :-!/
$+ &$" ,/- )$-0 )1(2! 3($ $"( ) ! ("+ ;
<<<
.-/* - 0) =+ / -2 !" !/$(%./ - "! ! -2!-( $ "9- . 2( )( !-( (3 )5 (3 >?; )5" - 3-- . !/ 6- + +
/ -2 !" $ "9- . 2( )( !-( (3 )5 ( !/ .$(% ) (3 29 (3 :$ "" (3 "!!%" (3 !/ 2"+ / "-6-$5 "-!%!) )(: $" 3-) " :/-2/ "! ) (:) 85 !/-" (%$!+ /5 $ !-!) !( 2(6 "!-( ! $ :-!/ "-6-$5 "-!%!) )(: $"+ @+
$ ) !! 2(% " "%86-!" !/! 2-6 (3 !" -" 2(1$) 85 7%).6 ! (3 !/-" (%$!0 /(:1$0 ( A8 %$6 (%$! /" SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-2-
$!)5 /) !/! )(: $ :(%) (! 8 !-!) !( "!!%!($5 8 3-!" ) - !$"! 3($ !/ $-() (3 )5+ + $2 ! 7%).6 ! (3 !/ %$6 (%$! - B
C0 ! ""# 1$-(%" $- 2-" .(1$ - . 2( )( !-( (3 )5 /1 8 2%) (%!+ &$.$/ D !/$(3 -" $$()%2) /$% )$*
! ! ! ! " # ! $
! $ $
" % #
&
'
&
(
" )
*
! *
+
*
, &
' #"
$
$ $
$
! ! !" -
! " SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-3-
-
. ! " /
! ! ! ! 0
;+ / %$6 (%$! - $%%
&'( ) '*+
,-''!.#.:/- !9- . "!$- . ! 1-: /" /) !/! B"%33-2- ! 2%"E 6%"! 8 "/(: 3($ !/ )5 !/$(%./(%! !/ !-$ $-()0 )6- -"!$!-1 !/$.5 ($ .-. 2 85 !! %!/($-!-" 2 (! 8 !$!) " "%33-2- ! 2%"+ 2"" (3 - ($)- ! )5 85 !! - "!$%6 !-!-"0 (%$!" 6%"! (! 2( )( )5 62/ -25+ &%8-2 - !$"! -" 8!!$ "$1) 85 3($2- . -6-!!-( "!$-2!5 !( $(6(! 22(% !8--!5 ) !-65 2!-( + 1 ! F!$2!" $ $$()%2) " 8(:* (1% ! ,
! 2
$
! ! ! ! +
*
! 3 !
%
$
,
! )
! SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-4-
! . ! ! (43 . %
. 3 , 5& /5 ! ! 62 $
7
! '4
!+
!! ! 8! 2
# 3
! ! !9
9
&
( 84'#% 7
! ! +
! !+
! %
! ! 7
7
! 0
D+ ( A8 %$6 (%$! - /0(1'
$%' 2 %03%'
%
* * ) 2'0 '' !-.. :/- )1$!- . !( !/ - ($)- ! )5 - 3-- . !/ " 83($ !/ -./ (%$! /" /) !/! )5 65 8 2( )( ) ) / 2) 2(6 "!-( 65 8 .$ !)0 SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-5-
/(:1$0 !/ 8 3-2-$542G%-$- . 8()5 2 (! 8 "))) :-!/ !/ -8--!5 (3 "!!%!($5 8 3-!" ) - !$"!+ 1 ! F!$2!" (3 !/ 7%).6 ! $) "* (:
! 7
! ;4<=+ . ! >,/ ! ;& >
! >,/ ! ;&
. 841
75
;8?4=+ . /@ A
(' 7 . ! . #. #814? )
7
7
! *
! 7
7
! ! %
=. ! * ! )
#841? ! ! 8(B
%
! ! 7
! ! #. #814? %
$
!*! 7
! . SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-6-
. $0 C:
D
?+ / %$6 (%$! 1-) 7%).6 ! )!) @++; "") - & % 4 )', - '' 5.# /" $-!$!) !/! -2!-( " "9- . 2( )( !-( (3 )5 (%./! !( 8 2( "-)$) 85 )(!- . 7%"!-2($- !) ) -8$ $(2/+ ! /" 8 (8"$1) !/! !/ )-"2$!-( 1"!) - !/ (%$!" % )$ !/ : (3 -6-!!-(
"/(%) 8 F$2-") !( )1 2 "%8"! !- 7%"!-20 ) !/!
!2/ -2 ($ ) !-2 $(2/ "/(%) (! )3! !/ )7%)-2!-( (3 )-"%!" ( !/-$ 6$-!"+ 1 ! F!$2!" (3 !/ 7%).6 ! $) "* 4)
! . *! 3
)/ * &
! & 7 %
! ! ! . ! ++ ;
- ,
7@ -
'?6 ! . )7 !#
#. ,
! 666) . ! ,
,
+,
! *
. ! ! )
SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-7-
! 86 ) :$
:! >
/ E * & / E -
&-
F. ! ! ! %
7
! ! 5 $
C&>
!% #! & #. D 88)*! *
8% /
# % &
E & GE
F
@ , F! %$ @ ,
&
! %
#
'66#'8#
)
0
+ / %$6 (%$! - 6 '1%$%' $, ''"7-:/- )(!- . -8$ $(2/ - 2( )( - . !/ )5 - " $3$$) 85 )(: $" - ) 2G%-"-!-( 6!!$"0 /" )$2!) /5$!2/ -2 $(2/+ ! /" 8 (8"$1) !/! /1- . $.$) !( !/ 8 3-2- !%$ (3 ) 2G%-"-!-( 7%$-"$%) 2 ) !/ $-./!" - 1(1) !/ 6!!$" (%./! !( 8 )7%)-2!) ( !/-$ 6$-!" $!/$ !/ 8- . $72!) ( !2/ -2 .$(% ) (3 )5+ / $6!$" -) )(: 85 !/ (%$! $ $$()%2) 8(:* SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-8-
?<)
*! H
/
&7
E 66 &(4
88% ! * /
! , *
*
$ *
)
! %
$
*
* 88')
* ! $
*
* CE&&
&%>84<( 8&8(84<(& A&D0 C:
D ++++++ ?4&
-
& ; %
F ;! -
& 8448&;161 >
:. 3
*! ! ! . ! ! ! SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-9-
F
! ! *
! . %
! ! !
* *
,
! 0 C:
D ++++++ (8%
! . ! +
+,
! . & %
! ! ! ! # '66# %
! ! *
% ! ! 0
>+ $ ) 2(% " 3($ !/ !" ( 8- . 2( 3$( !) :-!/ !/ 7%).6 !" (3 ( A8 %$6 (%$! -
0 $%%
0/0(1'
$%'2 0 & % ) 6 ' 1%$%' F$"") /-" - 8--!5 !( 2( !$(1$! !/! - 1-: (3 - ($)- ! )50 !/ !" $ (! !-!) !( "!!%!($5 8 3-!" ) - !$"!+ SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-10-
=+ 2( "2!%" (3 !/ 3($"-) 7%).6 !" (3 ( H8 %$6 (%$! $1" !/! -8$ $(2/ - 2" (3 -2!-( (3 )(: $
"9- . 2( )( !-( (3 )5 - ) 2G%-"-!-( 6!!$ "/(%) 8 )(!)+ / (%$! /" $(1) 2( )( !-( (3 )5 (3 6($ !/ 5$"+ "" (3 )(: $" 6%"! (! 8 !$!) ! $ :-!/ (!/$ 2""+ 5 -$$"2!-1 (3 %68$ (3 5$" (%./! !( 8 2( )( )+ ==+ !/ :9 (3 "!!6 ! (3 8(!/ "-)" ) 3($2-!) 7%).6 !"0 -2!-( 3($ 2( )( !-( (3 )5 "! )" (:) ) )5 - 3-- . 2(") -" /$85 2( )( )+
. =+ / !" !/$(%./ - "! ! % )$ 2!-( ; (3 ) 2G%-"-!-( 2!0 => $ "9- . "!!- . "-) (3 :$) )!) @=+?+= :/$85 )+ ))-!-( -"!$-2! %).0 $ $ )-) (! :$) 2-6) 6(% ! (3 2(6 "!-( + + $ ) 2(% " 3($ !/ !" "%86-!" !/! -""% - 1(1) /$- -" "G%$5 2(1$) 85 ($)$ )!) >++=D "") 85 !/-" (%$! - ;2#+1'+66(+ @+ 8- . "9)0 $ ) !! 2(% " 2( 2)" !/!
!"A 2-6 -" "G%$5 2(1$) 85 3($"-) "-) ($)$+ + $ ) 2(% " 3($ !/ $!-" $
!/! G%"!-( (3 ($!-( 6 ! )" !( 8 )7%)-2!) 85 -1- (%$!0 !/%"0 "-) G%"!-( 65 8 3! ( ) G%"!-( (3 / 26 ! (3 2(6 "!-( 65 8 )7%)-2!)+ SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
-11-
;+
/ -" /$85 (:) - !$6" (3 ($)$ )!) >++=D "") 85 !/-" (%$! - ;2#+1'+66(+ ! -" 6) 2$ !/! !" "/ (! 8 !-!) !( - !$"! 3($ !/ )5) $-() -++ >?; )5" ) "!!%!($5 8 3-!"+ D+ & )- . -"2+ -2!-(
"0 -3 50 "/ "! ) )-"(") (3+
.-
)**+ ,
I/!/$ "9- .4$"( ) J"4( I/!/$ $($!8 J"4( SUDEEPAK KUMAR 2026.08.17 17:17 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document