Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2026 DAILYLAW 35205 (PNJ)
M/S SUTINDER SINGH CHANDEL v. UNION TERRITORY, CHANDIGARH ADMINISTRATION, CHANDIGARH AND OTHERS
CWP/10968/2026 · 2026-08-18
Rohit Kapoor, To Be Nominated
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 35205 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 35205 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
`
$$
'
+$
(
"4"$ , ,,$5"#" 0$**"-! 2$"*$ #"$$! 9(
#2$/$+ $% !" ,"%"3#$ $+!40 +$!,$
>?7
"$+ ! !"#
A( $%& !" "!"$! ( ""/ " !:"#"&/$ (*"&#(" (!"!")!)!"!"*"&( +$,$$($-(
(./"#"#&/$0"+$
BBB
$ " #0 $+ #2$ ,"*& $ $%& !"
"#" "*& !" "!(!"",, ,$$$#"!3" $ $
(6&78&@-?$! #2$/+$!40%"97 !,0+00"$+!, $+!,$"&$:3
" "!;+$!$<! & !"
& !" "!&!3") "" ,"*&0"$3/$)( $,#"0#"0$!/
78@6?979@;CD $+0$'6(76(979@
E$
E
,$
/$0"+$!,$(
$#" (" $# ,$$(1(
$ / "##$ 3% ! 40 !" "!& " " , , ,$"0!! $:!!,"% 3") ""+$!#2$/ $!"!#0+" 9791?979@&!"30#"( $!"!,*$:!0! 3%!0,"# $,$"$&
" "!=D"&!+$&+$"% 403%!,$+"/ ,,$$+0!0$$&0$ $0!. *$+! $
" ,"0& %$
0!! $ % +"/$ $# $ RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [2]
!"#! $ #"%#!"&%'(#)"*()+"#" &&"%#(#)"*( #)%&(! >?86?9791&0$7(79(979@&:!&!/$0! $+! $!"")"/:!"! !" "!*"$"0,"#
$,$"$ " ! 0 #": " +$ ! $+ $& ! 3")
""40+"/$$+$!&0"$3/$)( F(
,+"0$+!0""!"!,$&3 !! ! 3& :" "##$ #2$ / +$ ! 40 %" 9791?979@( ! ,$ !"+",,$"0!!40""4"$,"*&+$* !"!!" 3 0#" ! 00+# 3 +$ G0 $(6 ! "0$?0*? ,$0 !# $ F7(7@(9791( ! ,$ $ ! ,*$ $ ! ,* 0$0 3% ! & !" "! " ! 0$0 ( ! 0$**0"$3%!,$$!40""4"$,"*" F7(7@(9791&4"0!3#$:'? !! " #!$%&%' (
)
* ! ++ ! ,,
-../0.01 ! '
2
%34' #! &%' *! "
! * !!,
"
, 5
! $5 (
*6
!! , ! !5 ,,+ *6
!!, RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [3]
* 6
!! "
6
! , -4.-0.0/ *!,,7
!,
*, ! 7
,
! 8931:..4;..<
-(
+!",+$*!0$!","$!/$$+ ! 40 " "4"$ ,"* " 0$**0"$ $ ! &
!" "!3%!40,"*&!,$0"*$,$$$+! ,*2$(!,$"*#%,"+$:$*$!$! &
!" "!& :!0! :" $ ! $+
(@&&81-? , *$! $:" " (&7&19?$:" ( 1(
!,0,#,#")$+!,$=0"!"!,*3#$ $ ! & !" "! " !" $ +$*"# " * / 0"* $ 3 40 3:!,$"! & !" "!&"0)$:# !#"3#%$+! ,$ $ ,"% 0! ( "#$ ! ,$= 0" !" # 0! "
" *:"#%$3:!,"&!"*$$+0"$3 0$/","0#"#%0"$3".+$*!3") ""$ !40,"*( @(
! 0#"* $+ ! ,$ $,,$ 3% ! 40 ,"*& :!0!#,$!#$+!,$"F7(7@(9791&"3 !3"$ :!0! ! ,* : "0"##% / $ ! ,$ $ 3% ! &
!" "!(!,$!"/"#$,#"0$0$"0$**0"$$ ! & !" "!&"4 !"+#"" *$3403:! & !" "!"40""4"$++0&+$!,,$$+"#H"$$+ +$*!#$+!#2$/(!" *:" 3%!$"# RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [4]
40""4"$ $**$?0*?
$##0$;40D& !" "!(,! ,$&!$0**":!!0,"# $**$:!$ 0$,%/!"/ 3$!40,"*(!0$0" $+! & !" "!"!40,"*!"!#% " * :" $ ! 40 ,"* $#% $ 71(7F(979@( 00$ $ ! ,$&!:""0$"0$3:!,$"!40 ,"*+$,$/ ,"0$!#2$/,"$:!0!! &
!" "!& "/ ,$$ $+ ! #$0"$ $ ! ,$ " $0 0! " * 3: ! ," :" :$) ,$ " :" / ++0 $ :! ,$ $+ 3% ! ,$ +$ :$ *$!& ! 32 "*, $+ ! ,$$2$!#"3#%$,"%!&""+!$ !$#%:!" $+"!0#"*$+$+! & !" "!("#$3*!"! ,$=0$$!"! & !" "!3# "$!*%$++#
"+$0$/%$+"!"0!"*$0"$3".+$*!3")
""+!3%!,$&$#%"0"$$+!,$= $*!,$0 "$/+""/"" ( (
$*!*""#,#"0$0$&:+!"!,$:"
"##$!#0$#2$/2$(!#00#"#%,0+! #$0"$":!0!/:"$3"3#!(!,$!"$,!+"0 !" ! !" ") 3+$ ! 40 " "4"$ ,"* $ #H ! #$0"$2$+$"3#!*$+!#2$/"!"!$$)$ ,"% ! $ " *( ! ,$ !" "#$ ") $ /"0" ! ,* $ F(7F(979@( ! +"0 !" ! ,$ $!: "* $ !"/
")!"*,*+$* & !" "!&0#"#%0"/$+!+"0!" :","$!#$+!,$"$!40""4"$ ,"*!"!,*:"#$$!,$( 6(
!0$+!0"!"0!"" *:",$,$$3 RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [5]
+"#H3:! & !" "!"!40""4"$,"*+$ :!0!!"+" *:"+$:"$ & !" "!(!"+" * 0$" ,0+0"$ $+ ! ,* $ :!0! ! #2$ / :" $ 3
"3#!( #"F$@$+!" *",$0"'? -!,! ! /4491;=+$
' !"%
>? ,?!,( @AB43C
,! ! 4.,
"
& ! !, ! 6
!! "
5
! ;
! ! , '! ,'
'
D ! ",'
'
D= 2
!!!! 1
'!!"
+!6 = !D6
6
!!, E 2 !D 6
! ,'
''!!" +! 6
! &
!D= / ! " ,
! ",
'
' ! <
8(
! & !" "!&",!,$,$#":"!#$
"!40""4"$,"*:"!#(!$! $0$ $0"!""%,",,#0"$:"*$/3%!,$3+$! & !" "! +$ "##$0"$ $+ ! 2$ $ ! ,$ $ "% ,0$"03:! & !" "!"!,$+$#H !,*2$+$ $+!#2$/&:"40(!+"0$+ !0"&:&!+$&0#"#%+!""" *!"$+","
" *:":$)$3:!,"&,"$:!0!&!,* RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [6]
2$: /$!,$( 7(
!,$!"/ ,"+$:$*$!!"$:3"0)"0)
" 2$ ! #"3#% $ ,"% "* $#% $ ! $ !" "
" *3:!40""4"$,"*" & !" "!&!" $3/"##%40( (
$0$* $0!0$0#$&:#%,$!,+"0$+ !0""!"/ 3,#"0$0$3+$! $3%!
& !" "!( #$ :!,#%& & !" "!&!",#"0$0$"0$**0"$ 3% ! 40 " "4"$ $**$?0*? $##0$ ;40D& " F7(7F(9791&:!3%! & !" "!&:"2$"##$!2$ +$ , $+ #2$ / " , ! 40 ,$#0% 9791?979@( ! # ,$0!"+'? 5
! 2
!! "= ! " F
#! D
!! 5! 87!$! >!!87!(2
! ,
0.01+0.0/ $.4.;0.01 -4.-0.0/( 4:-/ 0;.00.01 5
! 2
! 5
= =0.01=-149.-0.01
" *
! &7 5 8 E
&7 4:
7
" !!$
(2 ,
"
1.9303.-0.01 $,! , ( ? ,
" ! "= ! " F #! D
!! 5! 87! RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [7]
$! >!!87!(2
! ,
0.01+0.0/$.4.;0.01-4.-0.0/( ! , ! ! , , 0.01+0/ 6 ! 6 .4.;0.01 ! ++ !! $
(
<
9(
! "+$" 0$**0"$ +$##$: 3% " * " 79(7-(9791 3% ! & !" "!& "##$: #H"$ $+ ! ,* +$
"3#!*$+!#2$/(!"$+:""#$0"!"+$" #(!0$$+#"79(7-(9791""+$##$:'? ! E ++ !! $
(
2
!! "= ! " #! "
!! 5! 87! $ ! >!! 87! 2
(
! ,
0.01+0.0/ $.4.;0.01 -4.-0.0/( 8! ,
!%141--.-0.01$
" 4;0.0/(
"
"=
#!"
!! 5! 87!$! >!! 87! 2 (
! , 0.01+0.0/$4;0.01-4-0.0/(
,, B!, /4491;=+@A! !$ 5 0.0;
13034-=+@1C",?E
--1 ( #!6
!! ! ,0.0;+0.01 ! 6
"! , G +*** ? 5
! <
RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [8]
F( ! "+$" :$ 0$**0"$ 0$0#/#% "3#! !" ! "##$*$+,"03%! & !" "!&+$"3#!*$+#2$/&:"$ ! 2 $+ ! 40 " "4"$ ,"*( ! " $+ :" "#$ *"3%! & !" "!$!40""4"$,"*(!:$ 0$**0"$0$,#:!!+$##$:,0$,$0:$#0#"#%0" !"!:""" *"/"3:!40""4"$,"*
" & !" "!+$!,*2$$3#$+$ $+"# / +"/$ $+ #0 $+ ! 40 ,"*( ," $ ! 0$**0"$!"!,$,$#":""#$$ & !" "!(! *+"0!"!#"" *:"$ ##71(7F(979@&:$#$*" !"$0!" */0"*$40,"$:!0!! !0"*$ 30"+"/$$+!40""4"$,"*$/!#"$:!0! ! #2$ / #+ :" $ 3 "3#!( G": $!: # !" "
" *3:!,"$0"#%3: (!" *0"
"#$3++$*!4,0$0$+!,"( -(
!+"0$+!,0"&:+!"0!"" *!" 3"/","$:!0!!,$$$/!,*2$:" / $ !
,$ 3% ! & !" "!( ! ,$$ $+ ! ,* !"/ 3 / $ ! ,$ !$ ! ! /$ $+ ! 40 ,"* ," $ ! "+$" " *& :$# 0#"#% # ! 40 ,"* $ 0 ! "*$ $+ "* ,"%"3# +$ ! ,* 2$(!,$0"$3,*$0$!"!0"$#%3 0$/3%! 3%+# $+"( 1(
$+""!. *$+!/$0!$+! $ ! "#! ;,"D0$0&:+!"$40,$0"3")$!,0,# #"$:!3%! $$"0!(""$(F$+!"+$". * ,$0!'? RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [9]
-
5
!6
!, ! 6
! ! 7 ,
7 6
!, ,
*
6
! ! H7!,6
! 65 6
!!!,
!< @(
$:/&:+!"!+"0$+!0"5#>;,"D
" !"3#"*0!"$" *3:!40,"*"
& !" "!,"$:!0!!,"0+$"3#!*$+#2$/:" / $ ! ,$& !" "( +"0& :& !+$& + !" ! 0" 0#"#% !"3#( (
>"#$")$$+!+"0!"3+$!+# $+!,: ,$& !,$ !" "#$ +# " +$,*" .0$ " " &
!" "! :!0!& ! 40 " "4"$ ,"*& :" *,#" " +"$(( 6(
!0$0$+!,$&!+$&:$#0"!""$,$ *&!:""%#"0)$+":"$!,"$+!,$$+!+"0!" ! :" / ! ,* 3% ! & !" "!& ," $ " " * 3:! & !" "!"40""4"$,"*(32
"*,$*")$"++0"$#%$$3.0!0$/%$+"* +$*!,$( 8(
!"/:$+!*"&:"$+!/:!":,$0 0#99@$+! $$$+"0"$3"##$:$3/$)3% 0!0,#$#0(>"#$*")0#"!"!,$ :!0!! RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. >?78@6?979@;CD [10]
:,$*", :$#$30$" "!,$+$ 0"! !3") ""( 97(
/:$+!"+$"0$&:+$*!,: ,$( $2#%& ! "* *(
" ;0"#D 0 $ !$ "#0$$!0$#+$!,$" ",$,0,( 9(
## , *0##"$ ",,#0"$;D& + "%& !"## "#$ " ,$$+(
, 6(76(979@
".! (>!!,") "$I ' $ 9(>!!,$"3#I
' $ RAJESH KUMAR 2026.08.21 11:16 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment.