Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2026 DAILYLAW 35148 (PNJ)

NIC LTD. v. KAMLESH ETC.

FAO/1527/2002 · 2026-08-21

Parmod Goyal

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

! "# $%&'(( "%&%)&* $%&'(( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( SUNIL CHANDER 2026.08.21 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document +&$ / *8=--+6$+ "))-",%6)$')6"$*$6$)", ("$"*+ 9" *#+ 3%''*")"8*$8$&$8) "(+$& B "$="*)")*"!+ !""" # $##%$ $$& ' # ( )$ * + $),-./."/# + $ $$ $ , .0 ## $ % 1 2# 1 (1, #3% )%+ #%4- + $ + # # % - % + 5 # #% #$ . $ 1 , # # ) /"6!777 $ # 81*- #$ ## # #$ #!/"69 78 $ $ ## $# $$ $ $ ) ,-./. "/ $# ## ## $$ $ 1, 4 %# $ ## $ & ( ' $ # : ('$ # # "/!77 SUNIL CHANDER 2026.08.21 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document +&$ +% 8 ( ; *8<- 8% + $$ $ 1, $ $ # ),-./."/ % + 0 )%+ $ % 1, ##% # +%$ # $$ $ $ $$ $ ),-.98.//9+ # ## , $ & +# 1 $ $ ## ### # + $ # +% # # +% # +% # % # *- *- # + ## # # -;= ) : + $# 1 8 > % + # ) # # # -;& )% ) :- 8 +% 1 # + # $$ $ #6& ),-./."/#+ $ +% 1, < ) "$8 ' =- *"$="* +"=& $ SUNIL CHANDER 2026.08.21 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document +&$ "99 #"2!32323 # 23< + ##%# $ ># $# # # +. #2!32323 #" + + # +% $+%+% * + # $ # # ># $ # + $ < +% $% $$ # # + # $ # #% $ $ # +% %# > 2 3< # # +% % + + # 23 # $ + +D+ #D # E + + 2 3< ##% %# + + #$ # # ### ## F 93 )'"%$'+6)""'$*$8*- ")","$E$-%"6""=-)$,%6)$'))"8=% )(%&$($$)*)"*$''6"("#%)*$"=$*$-6*$**("** $"'',"-%6)6*=*$"=*4$*-"&"**-6$) +6"$&)'"($"'',"-6*= '=-88$&$'$937()$'* '%97;;%" $"'',"-'""&$$*$"=$*$-/)$"%&) "*$'"$(=-$"'',"-*""$$"*&$' )6*$''6"(8"("=$'"6$**=()*)'"( SUNIL CHANDER 2026.08.21 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document +&$ .$ "*',"$ "6"=-) $="* :%22%222C+ "*',"$ "6"$""* 90%;:%222C+ )"' ',"$ 90%;:%222C+ >"6"$""*A+ :%22%222C+ >"6"=-$="*A ;%;:%222C+ 19 "* ( =- $"' ',"- " "''$8*-% $,$"""*(=-"**"+'*"$,"()"',( ',"$$"**6$"=&, 11 **"+'*"$," )"** "* = $* $ & )"'",).(<:F(,)"(($*$8('*"$, $$$**$"*$G"$)*$"=$*$-("-',"$ )"**=""6" 10 $8"*$'"$>A%$("-%$C"$( )'-( )$=*"')($*('''" 0 , .1 192;121B - 6 $6- B = 6) - + B = 6) SUNIL CHANDER 2026.08.21 16:47 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document