Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2026 DAILYLAW 35012 (PNJ)

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. v. ASHA DEVI AND OTHERS

FAO/2191/2005 · 2026-08-13

Parmod Goyal

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

!" ##$% ! &' (()) *+, #-!* '-!%# %(. !" ##$% ! &' (()) *+, #-!* '-!%# %(. ! /+ 0+*.1,(2.3 +4(()) 0+#4)&,+2.3 0+ +45,6+2.3 ++(. " #$ '4(+(()47).784(())9,+ 6(8 4)):: 4 .: )+. 0+ . )6 '+7,)2 ; '+< ,+2 -4+(,+= ++.. 78 >+. .. 2>4+786(%2 29>>+..4 )6,.4#45,6+6+34,)+. ..?.,+4.:):.+3:78+(..+3+ >4).+3:+,<$/;4+++++.@.: +,<A= CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document '4(()),+6(844)):..: , 4:+,.4)):.")>#:4>48 >4>>+<:>44>+4+,<46 .->6()8.48+ +7B437).78>+9)6<: 466( ? &+. ,) + (())9,+ 6(8 4 4)):.4.:)+.'+7,), 4:+,.4 ")>#:4>48>4>>+<:>44 >+4+,<46.->6()8.48+ &+. '+7,)2 4>3+2 4. (. 4 +:,6 +.74)(())9,+6(8.4.),..4 3.")>#:4.+)7)2+4+4+> 3+>+:+C62>4+784.((6> 3+>++6 .:)+.'+7,)++..3.6(,:.>+.+ +(+.,.++.8++ ! "# $ % $ & ' $ $ & '"# ' ($)&* *(*++ CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document $ $,&*+*(*-! $ ,&*+*(*-! "# . (/*0 " $ 12*3*3*0*!3-"# $ ! . * * 4 5 6 . * . . $ ! (%!!0 ! ! ! (% ! !% ! !! $ 7 % ! (% ! , % . * * ! # $ & '( ! 8 (, $ )&* *(*++ ! $ $ ,&*+*(*-! $ "# ( ! " #" '1&292 CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ? ! . !+! "# $12*0*'*!3-% $ "# 7 %!1 * . $ ,&*+*(*-! ' *8(, !:% (/%0 " % ! (/*!( ' "# (/*0 " (/* 0 " $ "# $ 2;:$ % $ "# $ : &/0 " " (/* % . $ !1 2; < ! CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document !=>& ;62 "? # @ A, " @ +% 1 B 1? $ 92 &/*$ " % : &$A@ A "$ " 6$ @ => 92 6 !=>& ;62 2 # 6 AC " & " *!8 &/0 " % &/*!(' &/!2 6% $ !" !D /+,)3.":4>444. ++.46+,++.)..6+. >,7B..).+C6'4+C6" CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 4>443.+:+.6+.,).7 6(4.78+(. 3>.).((+)+.'+7,)>44. 7.,(3.).7+)+.'+7,)2+++7,. 4.:++..78)+.'+7,), >+4: 4+(.9.+3+.:34)4.+.(4 >7C+4+.8(+2>44>7:++8. ,.4%>44,)6)8).4(+,'43. ".++7++64 '4+7B437(+++.784)67: 4>.4).+;,+=..#45,6+<:46 6(>+..3.>+...(.78)+. 0+. )6'+7,)2-4+(,+;4+++++. @%&'()*+A=2 >4+78 (()))6 >+ >+.. ) 6( % 2 29 , .4 #4 5,6+ ;4+++++.@,-.-*/-,A= &+. '+7,) 4. >+.. ) 6( %2 29>44,.+ 6.. %29(+64 ., 9+. 0,)()+ &.(.8 %2 29 ;%2?CC = &+C( %29 '+(+ C( + 7+:: .. %29 CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 7.8 ')6(>+.. %2 29 &+. ,) + 4 (())9)6 4 ,:4 466(4))>::+,. That the learned Tribunal has erred in not assessing the income of the deceased as pleaded and proved by the claimants. That the learned Tribunal has failed to apply the correct multiplier, as per age of deceased. That the deduction towards the personal and living expenses of the deceased is excessive and contrary to the settled principles of law. That no addition towards future prospects has been made while calculating the loss of dependency. Future prospects ought to have been added, as per age of deceased. That the learned Tribunal has also failed to award just and appropriate compensation under the conventional heads, namely funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of spousal, parental, and filial consortium, in accordance with the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. 44(()))644..> >+<:.+3++,<7+: -%.>+: % 29(+642+7,:%29>+.4,4).C( '4+6.7843>..>4((+." .,)8,((+.78")>#:4>4>4..+3+ +,<7+: -%>444.6>44. " %4 &) 4. ) ,((+. 4 + 7B+9)64..>.+3+.>+:% 29 CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ->3+2)+8++++.(+:64.. >(+.,.78(()))67:.+)7) 3.+:+.6..24.7<<)). >+<+7:.+3+.464)86<%2 9(+ 64(+66,6>:(87)<)).>+<+(+3)4 8+>4.4.<() ? +.:)82 &).01- ..<%2 9(+ 64#..>:.?8+46.24>,). 7)...?D>+.,,+(+(3>B,.:6 (.78-A7)#,(+6 ,+*2&0)*+)/(%*).-013*)42, 5/ %*)*4!-26&*),%/ 2;=# .<(:3>: ..7?8+26,)()+@A>,).7(()7) 6.. 78-A7)#,(+6 ,+ !12 !*%+*5-%1*7%/ 5/ -+6& %*)/30%2 0%30%*2&0) 7 )% 2 ;= # #6)+)82 ..,>+.(+)C(476.47,67+ .(.>4+3(+>.,+4).+ +.:)82..,4C9?44))7(()7) '4).(.824++247.+6.78 <: 10)26+4&).01- ..7 / "8 78(()8: 9(2(%- 3%0/3-.2/ 4 C :2 1(+2&3+&-% 09 ;<= . 78 6<: ,-,(.2&0)09826>+.(+)C( (++66(+).(.82(()) )64)))7)./"9>+.9()-%*+->3-)/-/. /"9>+.+0//09-/2*2-(()))6 4))7). CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document 6( /"9 >+. +0// 09 /30(/*+ .0)/0%2&(1 (()))6 . ? 4)) 7 ). 6( /"94>+.+0//093*%-)2*+.0)/0%2&(14>3+6. )+4-A7)#,(+6 ,+>+4+++:+.: E,,66(,.+3)4.6.*/&)**/1&) 7%/ 5/ *2&0)*+)/(%*).-0 2, 2 # )# 3,+(()))62(()))64))7+<. 6,7863:((+(+(()4+:+. +.:)82+>+<.6(,.+ 6 %2 9 (+64 %2 9 (+64 ,,+/+( ?D ;%2 F= %2 9 ., 9?4 ; = %2 9 0,)()+ ')).(.8 %2 CC % 2?29 &! % 29 ,+)!C( % 29 & (,) +,6 )6 %?29 & (+) +,6 )6 %?29C? %229 ') 6( >+..(() %2?29 ') 6( >+..784'+7,) %2 29 !4. 6, 6( %2?29;>+.. (()=G%2 29 ;>+..784'+7,)= %?229 (())9)6 4)) 7 ). 4. 6(>+..(()):>4 D++64. CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document ):)6())+)H;C(,.+43)4. )+,62,+)C(2)=$.+3) 4.+4))7(87)+6,:,>+.))+)H ((+6.)7)8(86(4))7(+>+. (()+.:)8))>./.:(();=282 9+.(.+.:)8 # $ 4+B3 "44+#(<:9%. I "44+%(+7) I9 CHIRANJEEV SINGH 2026.08.14 14:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document