Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Jharkhand · body

2026 DAILYLAW 27455 (JHR)

RABI MAHTO v. SHEO NANDAN MAHTO

C.M.P./1186/2025 · 2026-09-24

Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

2026:JHHC:28820 --1-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND, RANCHI C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 ---- 1. Rabi Mahto S/O Late Rengtu Mahto, aged about 75 years, resident of Village- Sadma Kala, P.O. & P.S.- Petarbar, District- Bokaro. 2. Most. Saroj Devi W/O Late Harihar Prasad Mahto, aged about 68 years. 3. Taleshwar Mahto S/O Late Harihar Prasad Mahto, aged about 50 years. 4. Surendra Kumar S/O Late Harihar Prasad Mahto aged about 32 years. 5. Savitri Kumari D/O Late Harihar Prasad Mahto & W/O Gautam Kumar aged about 28 years, 6. Krishna Ballav Mahto S/O Dubraj Mahto, aged about 63 years, 7. Ashirbad Mahto S/O Dubraj Mahto, aged about 56 years, 8. Sidheshwar Mahto S/O Dubraj Mahto, aged about 53 years, 9. Panchanan Mahto S/O Dubraj Mahto, aged about 51 years, 10. Shanti Devi D/O Dubraj Mahto & W/O Budhu Mahto, aged about 70 years, Sl. No. 2 to 10 are resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S. - Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 11. Kunti Devi D/O Dubraj Mahto & W/O Shiv Kumar Mahto, aged about 68 years, Resident of Village- Kurko, P.O. Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 12. Geeta Devi D/O Dubraj Mahto & W/O Thakur Mahto, aged about 47 years, resident of Village- Banchas, Tola Churingarha, P.O. & P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 13. Niru Devi D/O Late Rengtu Mahto & W/O Chamu Mahto, aged about 72 years, resident of Village & P.O.- Ordana, P.S.- Petarbar, District- Bokaro. 14. Piyari Devi D/O Late Rengtu Mahto & W/O Bhunu Mahto, aged about 77 years, resident of Village & P.O.- Bhuchungdih, P.S.- 2026:JHHC:28820 --2-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 Rajrappa, District- Ramgarh. 15. Manohar Mahto S/O Late Fugni Devi and Ramji Mahto, aged about 26 years, resident of Village- Hanslata, Tola Gatigarha, P.O.- Dantoo, P.S. Kasmar, District - Bokaro. 16. Smt. Rekha Devi D/O Late Fugni Devi and Ramji Mahto & wife of Pradeep Kumar Mahto aged about 46 years, resident of Village Bhawani Pur, P.O.- Bagda, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 17. Aalo Devi D/O Late Fugni Devi & Ramji Mahto and wife of Shakdipad Mahto, aged about 40 years, resident of Village-Bhawani Pur, Tola- Solagiri, P.O.& P.S.-Chirachas, District- Bokaro. 18. Chinta Devi D/O Late Fugni Devi and Ramji Mahto and W/O Ajay Mahto, aged about 32 years, resident of Village Jhirke, P.O.- Ulgada, P.S.- Petarbar, District- Bokaro ...... Petitioners -- Versus -- 1. Sheo Nandan Mahto son of Late Sufal Mahto, 2. Gopal Mahto son of Late Sufal Mahto, 3. Most. Sahodari Devi wife of Late Jiwan Mahto, 4. Pradeep Mahto son of Late Jiwan Mahto, 5. Chaman Ram Mahto son of Late Jiwan Mahto, Sl. 1 to 5 are resident of Village and P.O.-Durgapur, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 6. Geeta Devi, daughter of Late Jiwan Mahto and Wife of Dasrath Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Manjura, P.S- Kasmar, District -Bokaro. 7. Sarita Devi daughter of Late Jiwan Mahto and wife of Lalchand Mahto, resident of Village-Pupanki, P.O. & P.S.- Chas, District-Bokaro. 8. Pushpa Devi wife of Kapileshwar Mahto and D/O Late Jiwan Mahto, resident of Village & P.O.- Manjura, P.S.- Kasmar, District-Bokaro. 9. Most. Shanti Devi wife of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 10. Monika Kumari daughter of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto and wife of Gobardhan Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Manjura, P.S.-Kasmar, 2026:JHHC:28820 --3-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 District- Bokaro. 11. Munni Devi daughter of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto and wife of Birendra Kumar Mahto, resident of Village Nawadih, P.O. Tangtona, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 12. Lalita Devi daughter of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto, 13. Pramila Kumari daughter of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto, 14. Kunti Kumari daughter of Late Bhuneshwar Mahto, 15. Gour Chand Mahto son of Late Bejo Mahto, Sl. No. 12 to 15 are resident of Village and P.O. Durgapur, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 16. Bikash Mahto S/O Late Parsuram Mahto 17. Most Fulia Devi W/O Late Parsuram Mahto. 18. Karuna Kumari D/O Late Parsuram Mahtor 19. Basanti Kumari D/O Late Parsuram Mahto. 20. Shankar Mahto S/O Late Ramlal Mahto. Sl. No. 16 to 20 are resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 21. Purni Devi D/O Late Ramlal Mahto and W/O Dasrath Mahto, Resident of Village- Tondra, P.O. Bhaski, P.S. Jaridih, District-Bokaro. 22. Most. Jagni Devi W/O Late Murli Mahto. 23. Most. Chinta Devi W/O Late Mukesh Mahto 24. Rohit Kumar Mahto S/O Late Mukesh Mahto 25. Sukhdeo Mahto S/O Late Murli Mahto 26. Narayan Mahto S/O Late Chhutu Mahto. Sl. No. 22 to 26 are resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 27. Ledya Devi D/O Late Paru Ram Mahto &W/O Khedan Mahto, resident of Village- Murhulsudi, P.O.- Pirgul, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 28. Kunti Devi D/O Late Parsu Ram Mahto & W/O Kishun Mahto, resident of Village Padi, P.O. Pirgul, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 29. Futni Devi D/O Late Murli Mahto & W/O Kishun Mahto, resident of 2026:JHHC:28820 --4-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 Village & P.O.- Manjura, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 30. Lila Devi D/O Late Murli Mahto & W/O Meghnath Mahto, resident of Village Nawadih, P.O. Tangtona, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 31. Most. Chaiti Devi D/O Late Chhutu Mahto & W/O Late Kishun Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 32. Saheb Ram Mahto S/O Late Sohgi Devi and Late Bigan Mahto, 33. Gujar Mahto S/O Sohgi Devi and Late Bigan Mahto, 34. Dinesh Mahto S/O Sohgi Devi and Late Bigan Mahto, Sl. No. 32 to 34 are resident of Village Hanslata, Tola Charakpakhna, P.O. Dantoo, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 35. Sarubala Devi D/O Late Sohgi Devi & Late Bigan Mahto W/O Late Jageshwar Mahto, resident of Village- Durgapur Medha Tola, P.O.- Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 36. Chanwa Devi D/O Late Sohgi Devi and Late Bigan Mahto & W/O Subodhan Mahto, resident of Village Durgapur, Tola-Dundadih, P.O. Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro 37. Malti Devi D/O Sohgi Devi and Late Bigan Mahto & W/O Manoj Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Manjura, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 38. Uday Mahto S/O Late Bhuniya Devi and Lalsai Mahto, 39. Dasaya Mahto S/O Late Bhuniya Devi and Lalsai Mahto, Sl. No. 38 and 39 are resident of Village Dhamnatand, P.O. Soso, P.S- Gola, District- Ramgarh. 40. Sanichar Mahto @ Sarju Mahto S/O Late Jhuniya Devi and Late Mathur Mahto, resident of Village Durgapur, Tola- Lalmatia, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 41. Smt. Budhni Devi D/O Late Jhuniya Devi and Late Mathur Mahto and w/o Late Govind Mahto, Resident of Village & P.O.-Chainpur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 42. Sushila Devi D/O Late Jethu Mahto & W/O Choteshwar Mahto, Resident of Village Bhalu, P.O. Potamdaga, P.S. Rajrappa, District- Ramgarh. 2026:JHHC:28820 --5-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 43. Budhan Mahto S/O Late Hiralal Mahto. 44. Pokhan Mahto S/O Late Hiralal Mahto, Sl. No. 43 & 44 are resident of Village & P.O. Palamu, P.S. Nawadih, District- Bokaro. 45. Sarju Prasad Mahto S/O Late Anand Mahto. 46. Suresh Mahto S/O Late Anand Mahto 47. Ayodhya Mahto S/O Late Anand Mahto 48. Dasrath Mahto S/O Late Anand Mahto 49. Babuchand Mahto S/O Late Anand Mahto Sl. Nos. 45 to 49 are resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S.- Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 50. Sulochna Devi D/O Late Anand Mahto & W/O Bhushan Mahto, resident of Village Tangtona, Tola Teliyadih, P.O.-Tangtona, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 51. Mishir Mahto S/O Late Shanti Devi and Gajadhar Mahto, 52. Chini Prakash Mahto S/O Late Shanti Devi and Gajadhar Mahto, Sl. No. 51 and 52 are resident of Village Murhulsudi, P.O. Pirgul, P.S. Kasmar. District- Bokaro. 53. Paru Devi D/O Late Shanti Devi and Gajadhar Mahto and W/O Dukhu Mahto, resident of Village Dumarkudar, Khudibera, P.S. Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 54. Chandan Kumar Mahto S/O Late Shanti Devi & Gajadhar Mahto, resident of Village Madhukarpur, P.O. Hensatu, P.S.-Jhalda, District- Purulia (West Bengal) 55. Parola Devi D/O Late Shanti and Devi Gajadhar Mahto and W/O Girdhari Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Pirgul, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 56. Smt. Mirola Devi D/O Late Shanti Devi and Gajadhar Mahto and W/O Jyotilal Mahto, resident of Village- Chopad, P.O.-Tulin, P.S. Jhalda, District- Purulia (West Bengal). 57. Smt. Rohni Devi D/O Late Shanti Devi & Gajadhar Mahto and W/o Pintu Mahto, resident of Village Betul, P.O.- Betul Kala, P.S.- Gola, 2026:JHHC:28820 --6-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 District- Ramgarh. 58. Dasrath Mahto S/O Late Sudu Mahto 59. Parmeshwar Mahto S/O Late Sudu Mahto Sl. No. 58 and 59 are resident of Village & P.O. Durgapur, P.S. -Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 60. Paneshwari Devi D/O Late Sudu Mahto and W/O Rajan Mahto, resident of Village Banga, P.O. Utasara, P.S. Petarbar, District- Bokaro. 61. Kiran Devi D/O Late Sudu Mahto and W/O Tilak Mahto, resident of Village Lepo, P.O. Munga Sarla, P.S. Petarbar, District- Bokaro. 62. Funiya Devi D/O Late Jagarnath Mahto and w/o Pairag Mahto, resident of Village- Goraiya Kudar, P.O.- Khairachatar, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 63. Fuleshwari Devi D/O Late Sufal Mahto & W/O Shanti Mahto, Resident of Village & P.O.- Durgapur, P.S. Kasmar, District-Bokaro. 64. Urmila Devi D/O Late Sufal Mahto & W/O Jagdish Mahto, resident of Village Tilaiya, Tola Jara, P.O. Manjura, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 65. Nuni Bala Devi D/O Late Sufal Mahto & W/O Deo Charan Mahto, Resident of Village & P.O. Kumhardaga, P.S. Gola, District- Ramgarh. 66. Pushpa Devi D/O Late Sufal Mahto & W/O Ashok Mahto, resident of Village & P.O.- Betul Kala, P.S. Gola, District-Ramgarh. 67. Bisu Mahto S/O Late Bhukhal Mahto, Resident of Village-Pilpilo, Tola- Kathardih, P.O. Narayanpur, P.S.- Nawadih, District-Bokaro. 68. Jiriya Devi D/O Late Bhukhal Mahto & W/O Jugal Mahto, resident of Village & P.O. Kurpania, P.S. Gandhi Nagar, District-Bokaro. 69. Niru Devi D/O Late Bhukhal Mahto & W/O Sohrai Mahto, resident of Village Tingra, P.O. Pordag, P.S. Nimiaghat, Distrct-Giridih. 70. Sukhdeo Mahto S/O Late Nakul Mahto, 71. Anita Kumari D/O Sukhdeo Mahto 72. Chunki Kumari D/O Sukhdeo Mahto 73. Rinki Kumari D/O Sukhdeo Mahto 74. Gansu Mahto son of Sukhdeo Mahto Sl. No. 70 to 74 are resident of Village Padi, P.O. Pirgul, P.S.-Kasmar, 2026:JHHC:28820 --7-- C.M.P. No. 1186 of 2025 District- Bokaro. 75. Dulu Devi D/O Late Beju Mahto & W/O Late Aghnu Mahto, resident of Village- Budgara, P.O. Kanjkiro, P.S. Nawadih, District- Bokaro. 76. Nemia Devi D/O Late Beju Mahto & W/O Govind Mahto, resident of Village Durgapur, Tola Lalmatia, P.O. Durgapur, P.S.-Kasmar, District- Bokaro. 77. Rohani Devi D/O Late Beju Mahto & W/O Nanku Mahto, resident of Village Pilpilo, P.O. Narayanpur, P.S. Nawadih, District- Bokaro. .... Opposite Parties ---- CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI --- For the Petitioners :- Mr. Santosh Kumar, Advocate For O.P. Nos.1 to 15 :- Mr. Nehru Mahto, Advocate ---- 03/24.09.2026 The prayer is made under Article 227 of the Constitution of India for quashing of the order of rejection of closing the evidence dated 19.09.2025 relating to Title Suit No.65 of 2007. 2. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that this petition has become infructuous and in view of that he seeks permission to withdraw this petition. 3. Learned counsel appearing for the opposite party Nos.1 to 15 have got no objection 4. Accordingly, this petition stands dismissed as withdrawn. (Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.) Dated 24.09.2026 Sangam/