Research › Search › Judgment

Bombay High Court · body

2026 DAILYLAW 22504 (BOM)

THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THR. POLICE STATION OFFICER v. SUKHDEO S/O MANNU JADHAO

APEAL/453/2012 · 2026-11-02

Criminal Appealbody2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

C.A.453.12.odt 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.453 OF 2012 APPELLANT :- The State of Maharashtra through Police Station Officer, Police Station Badnera, Distt. Amravati ..VERSUS.. RESPONDENT Accused :- Sukhdeo S/o Mannu Jadhao, Aged about 40 years, R/o Kastura Mogara, Distt. Amravati ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Mr. M. J. Khan, APP for Appellant. Mr. A. J. Kadu and P. A. Kadu, Advocates for the Respondent. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CORAM : SHIVKUMAR DIGE & ROHIT W. JOSHI, JJ. DATE : 02nd NOVEMBER, 2026 J U D G M E N T : (PER: ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.) 1) The State has filed the present appeal in order to challenge judgment and order dated 10.07.2012 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Amravati in Sessions Trial No.137 of 2009, thereby acquitting the present respondent/original accused of the offence punishable under Sections 307, 504 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). C.A.453.12.odt 2 2) One Ramji Rathod had lodged a complaint with Police Station, Badnera on 21.11.2008, alleging that the accused had caused grievous injuries, which were likely to cause death in ordinary course of nature, to him by means of an axe on 21.11.2008 at around 7:30 a.m. at village Kastura Mogra. 3) Based on the complaint, offence vide FIR No.188 of 2008 came to be registered against the accused on 21.11.2008. Upon completion of investigation, charge-sheet came to be filed and the case was referred by the learned Magistrate for trial to the learned Sessions Court. The Sessions Case came to be registered as Sessions Trial No.137 of 2009. 4) Charge in the case was framed vide Exhibit 10 on 27.08.2010. Accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. 5) The prosecution has examined complainant as PW 1. He has deposed that about two and half years prior to the date of recording his deposition, at around C.A.453.12.odt 3 7.30 a.m., the accused had assaulted him by an axe near a pan shop at village Kastura Mogra. He deposed that the accused had inflicted blows on the backside of his neck and both arms. He deposed that after he fell on the ground, his nephew Vinay came to rescue him, however, the accused also chased him threatening to assault. He has further sated that one Ramrao Rathod and Ukandrao Rathod were present at the pan shop when the incident occurred. The complainant was admitted at Irwin Hospital, Amravati. During the course of his cross- examination, he stated that civil disputes were ongoing between him and the accused. The complainant stated that he was illiterate and was not aware about the contents of his complaint at Exhibit 24 and marked his thumb impressions at the instance of the police. As against his statement in examination-in-chief that blows were inflicted on his arms, in his cross-examination, he stated that the accused had assaulted him on one shoulder. He stated that his statement in examination-in- C.A.453.12.odt 4 chief as regards assault on both hands is not correct. 6) PW 2 and 3, who are panch witnesses of the spot and seizure of clothes and the weapon, respectively, have turned hostile. Mr. Vinayak Dhanraj Rathod, who, as per the complainant, had tried to intervene in the dispute and fled from the spot on being threatened by the accused, has also turned hostile. 7) Ramrao Rathod (PW 5) has stated that the accused had assaulted the complainant from behind while he was talking on phone. However, he has not stated that the accused assaulted the complainant by means of axe. He stated in his cross-examination that he had stated to the police that, at the relevant time, he was present at the spot, since he was going to a shop for purchasing bread and that he had witnessed the scuffle between the complainant and the accused and further stated that he was not aware that the said statement was was not recorded by the police in his statement. 8) Ukandrao, the owner of the pan shop, in front of C.A.453.12.odt 5 whom the incident allegedly occurred, did not support the prosecution case and was declared hostile. 9) The learned Sessions Court has acquitted the accused, observing that witness Nos.2, 3 and 7 had turned hostile and did not support the prosecution case. The learned Sessions Court has recorded that the version of the complainant in his deposition and the complaint lodged with police was not consistent, inasmuch as he had stated in the complaint that he was assaulted on three occasions, whereas he had not stated that the accused had assaulted him on the backside of his neck and had also not stated that the accused had assaulted him on his left hand. It is observed that contrary to the version in the complaint regarding assault on both hands, in his evidence, he has admitted that the assault was only on one shoulder. It is further observed that the statement in the examination-in-chief referring to assault on both shoulders was also admitted by the complainant to be incorrect. The learned Sessions Court observed that the C.A.453.12.odt 6 complainant stated that he was not aware about the contents of the complaint. Dealing with evidence of PW 5, who is the only eye-witness who has supported the prosecution case, the learned Sessions Court has observed that the statement that he had visited a grocery store is missing in the statement of this witness recorded by the police. The learned Sessions Court has observed that the claim that PW 5 had visited a grocery store was introduced in the examination-in-chief to create an impression that he was present at the time of incident. The learned Sessions Court has also disbelieved panchanamas, since the spot-panchanama was prepared prior to registration of offence and in the panchanama for recovery of clothes and axe, some blank spaces were admittedly filled in later. The learned Sessions Court has, therefore, held that the prosecution failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. 10) Learned APP contends that evidence of injured eyewitness must be given primacy. He contends that the C.A.453.12.odt 7 complainant himself is a witness to the assault on him and that, considering his evidence, the learned Sessions Court ought to have held that the charge was duly proved. 11) The learned APP contends that minor variations in the cross-examination are not sufficient to completely shatter the deposition of the complainant, which is duly corroborated by PW 5, who is also an eye-witness to the incident and also corroborated by injury report. 12) Per contra, Mr. Kadu, learned advocate for the accused, argues that the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. He contends that having regard to inconsistent versions of the complainant, who had a civil dispute with the accused, the complainant has falsely implicated the accused. The learned advocate contends that PW 5, although he claims to be an eyewitness, has not deposed that the accused assaulted the complainant with an axe. It is further argued that the discovery of clothes and weapon has also not proved and, C.A.453.12.odt 8 as such, the impugned judgment and order do not warrant interference. 13) We have heard the rival submissions as aforesaid and perused the record with the able assistance of the learned advocates. 14) At the outset, it must be stated that scope of interference is not in an appeal arising out of acquittal is very limited. If a possible view of the matter is taken by the learned Trial Court, the Appellate Court dealing with an appeal against acquittal should not readily interfere with the findings and conclusions recorded. With this legal principle, when the evidence on record is perused, it is found that the version of complainant with respect to assault by the accused is not consistent. There is variance in the statements with respect to blows inflicted in the complaint and the examination-in-chief. In his complaint, the complainant has stated that the accused had delivered two blows on his back and one blow on his C.A.453.12.odt 9 upper right arm by means of an axe. As against this, the version in the examination-in-chief is that the accused had assaulted him on the back of his neck and, thereafter, on left and right arms. In the cross-examination, he stated that the accused had assaulted him on one shoulder only and not on both shoulders. Thus, there is no consistency in the version of the complainant with respect to the alleged assault by the accused. 15) Apart from this, PW 5, who has supported the case of assault has not mentioned that the assault was by means of an axe. 16) Likewise, discovery of the weapon and bloodstained clothes of accused is also not proved. It also appears that the complainant stated in his cross- examination that he was not aware about contents of the complainant. 17) In the light of reasons recorded above, this Court sees no reasons to interfere with the judgment and order passed by the learned Sessions Court. Criminal C.A.453.12.odt 10 Appeal is, therefore, dismissed. (ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.) (SHIVKUMAR DIGE, J.) T αɳɱαყ...