Research › Search › Judgment

Bombay High Court · body

2026 DAILYLAW 22365 (BOM)

SHAILESH S/O HANSRAJ CHAUDHARI v. STATE OF MAH. THR. PSO PS GADGENAGAR AMRAVATI DIST.AMRAVATI

APEAL/72/2022 · 2026-11-03

Criminal Appealbody2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.72 OF 2022 APPELLANT :- Shailesh S/o Hansraj Chaudhari Aged about 34 years, Occupation : Labourer, R/o. Belpura, Amravati, Tq. and District Amravati. ..VERSUS.. RESPONDENT :- State of Maharashtra Through Police Station officer, Police Station Gadgenagar, Amravati, District Amravati. WITH CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.452 OF 2022 APPELLANT :- Ravi Ganpatrao Dhote, Aged 33 years, R/o Hamalpura, Amravati, District – Amravati, At present detained in C-6007, Central Prison, Amravati. ..VERSUS.. RESPONDENT :- State of Maharashtra Through Police Station officer, Police Station Gadgenagar, Amravati, District Amravati. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ In Criminal Appeal No.72/2022 Mr. Tushar U. Tathod, Advocate for Appellant. Mr. I.J. Damle, A.P.P. for Respondent/State. In Criminal Appeal No.452/2022 Ms Mahak M. Agrawal a/w Ms Chaitali Bhute, Advocate for Appellant (Appointed). Mr. I.J. Damle, A.P.P. for Respondent/State. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2026:BHC-NAG:15162-DB Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 2 CORAM : SHIVKUMAR DIGE & ROHIT W. JOSHI, JJ. DATE : 03 /11/2026 J U D G M E N T : (PER : Rohit W. Joshi, J.) 1. Criminal Appeal No.72 of 2022 is filed by accused No.2 and Criminal Appeal No.452 of 2022 is filed by accused No.1 in Sessions Case No.183 of 2016, in order to challenge the judgment and order dated 10.11.2021 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Amravati, thereby convicting both the appellants/original accused Nos.1 and 2 for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 397 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”) and sentencing them to suffer life imprisonment with a fine of Rs.2,000/- and on failure to pay the fine amount, to suffer further rigorous imprisonment for one month for each offence. Both the sentences are ordered to run concurrently. 2. The learned Sessions Court has acquitted the appellants of the offence punishable under Section 120-B of the IPC. One Sachhanand Ferwani lodged a report with Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 3 Gadgenagar Police Station, Amravati on 28.08.2016 at around 02:00 A.M., stating that his son Mahesh had left the house for going to his place of work i.e. Sindh Hosiery and that at around 11:00 P.M., his wife received a phone call informing that Mahesh had met with an accident. On reaching Irwin Hospital where he was admitted, he saw the dead body of Mahesh with bleeding injuries. 3. On the basis of the offence, FIR vide Crime No.665 of 2016 came to be registered against unknown persons. On 28.08.2016, accused Nos.3 and 4 were arrested and accused Nos.1 and 2, who are the appellants in the present appeals, were arrested on the following day i.e. on 29.08.2016 at 02:08 hours. 4. After completion of investigation, chargesheet was filed in the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Amravati, who committed the case for trial to the learned Sessions Court, since the offences are exclusively triable by a Court of Session. All the accused persons pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. Charge was framed against all the Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 4 accused persons vide Exhibit 9 on 09.10.2017. The prosecution has examined 14 witnesses in all, including PW-1 (father of deceased), PW-2 (panch regarding discovery of motorcycle and knife), PW-3 (panch regarding seizure of money and clothes), PW-4 (employer of the deceased), PW-5, 10, 11 and 12 (the persons who had given money to the deceased who was working as cash collection agent of PW-4), PW-6 (sister of accused No.1), PW-8 (the doctor who has conducted post-mortem) and PW-14 (investigating officer). 5. It is the case of the prosecution that the deceased was employed as collection agent of PW-4. The deceased had collected cash amount from PW-5, 10, 11 and 12, who are the customers of his employer PW-4 and that accused No.1 and accused No.2 murdered the deceased with a view to commit robbery. 6. It is the case of the prosecution that accused Nos.3 and 4 were aware that the deceased was working as collection agent for PW-4 and they had shared said information with accused Nos.1 and 2, who in turn committed the offence of dacoity and murder. During the course of hearing of the case, the learned A.P.P. conceded that there was no evidence to implicate accused Nos.3 and 4 in the offence. Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 5 7. As regards accused Nos.1 and 2, the learned Sessions Court has found that the offence against both of them was proved beyond reasonable doubt and accordingly convicted accused Nos.1 and 2 for the offence of robbery and murder punishable under Sections 397 and 302 of the IPC, respectively. The learned Sessions Court has placed reliance on recovery of cash amount from accused Nos.1 and 2, recovery of knife from accused No.1, CA report which confirms existence of stains of human blood on the clothes of the accused, discovery of bag from accused No.1 in which cash amount was kept by the deceased and existence of bloodstains on the Activa vehicle belonging to the sister of accused No.1 which was used by him. 8. The learned advocates for appellant contend that it is the positive case of the prosecution that accused Nos.1 to 4 have committed the offence acting in conspiracy with each other and the prosecution has conceded that there is absolutely no evidence against accused Nos.3 and 4. It is further contend that the learned Sessions Court has also acquitted the appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2 of the offence under Section 120-B of the IPC. The learned advocate contends that since the foundation of the case, which is criminal conspiracy, itself is held to be not proved, the judgment by Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 6 the learned Sessions Court convicting the appellants for the offence of murder and robbery cannot be sustained. It is further contended that the prosecution has failed to prove that any amount was collected by the deceased from the customers of PW-4 and yet the appellants are convicted for the offence of robbery. It is argued that the cross-examination of the witnesses who had allegedly deposited amount with the deceased will indicate that they did not obtain any receipt from the deceased in lieu of having paid amount to the deceased which renders their testimony untrustworthy. It is also contended that no documentary evidence is produced on record to prove payment of amounts by the alleged customers of PW-4 to the deceased. It is further contended that the discovery of weapon is also not reliable since the discovery is from an open place. 9. Per contra, the learned A.P.P. justifies the findings recorded, conclusions drawn and punishment imposed. He contends that although the case is based on circumstantial evidence, the chain of circumstances is completely established. It is argued that human blood is found on the clothes of both the accused persons and blood on the clothes of accused No.1 is found to be of ‘B’ group, which is the blood group of the deceased. It is contended that accused Nos.1 and 2 have not explained the existence of blood Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 7 on their clothes. It is further contended that a huge amount of cash is recovered on discovery statement made by accused Nos.1 and 2 and that no explanation is offered by them to justify the existence of such huge amount of cash. The learned Public Prosecutor contends that the evidence on record is sufficient to sustain the conviction and sentence imposed by the learned Sessions Court upon the present appellants/accused Nos.1 and 2. 10. It is the case of the prosecution that the deceased was employed by PW-4/Sanjay Harwani as agent for collecting cash. PW-4 has entered the witness box and has specifically deposed about the same. PW-4 has also produced on record pay slips of the deceased in order to show that the deceased was his employee. Perusal of cross-examination of PW-4 will indicate that there is no cross-examination on the point that deceased was not an employee of PW-4 who was employed for the purpose of collecting money from creditors. This fact would establish that the deceased was indeed an employee of PW-4 appointed for collecting dues from the customers. The said witness stated that he had given a motorcycle bearing RTO registration No.MH-27-AJ-2691 to the deceased for the purpose of his job. PW-4 also identified the black bag which was given by him to the deceased for collection of money. The said bag Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 8 is seized from accused No.1. He also mentioned the names of customers from whom amounts were collected by the deceased prior to his demise. In the cross-examination of this witness, payment of amount by the customers who are examined as PW-5, 10, 11 and 12 is not questioned. The contention that PW-5, 10, 11 and 12 have not produced any documentary evidence in the form of receipt, etc., to prove payments allegedly made by them to the deceased is therefore rightly rejected by the learned Sessions Court. 11. PW-3 is the panch witness who has proved the seizure of clothes of accused No.1. He has stated that the clothes were worn by accused No.1 when they were seized from him. He has stated that the clothes were having bloodstains. Likewise, he has also deposed about seizure of clothes of accused No.2. He has stated that the clothes seized from accused No.2 were also having bloodstains. He has admitted his signature on the panchnama and has stated that the contents of panchnama were correct. The said witness also deposed about statement made by accused No.2 regarding discovery of amount of Rs.50,000/- and recovery of the said amount which was lying under a mattress on the bed in his house. This witness has also proved the memorandum statement and discovery of amount of Rs.88,400/- along with a black bag from accused No.1. He has Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 9 stated that apart from money and black bag, he also discovered the Activa vehicle used by the accused No.1. He has stated that there were bloodstains on the black bag and Activa vehicle. 12. Thus, money and bloodstained clothes are discovered from both the accused. Apart from this, the bag and vehicle on which the appellants were riding while committing the offence are discovered at their instance. The seized articles were sent for opinion of Chemical Analyzer. During the course of chemical analysis, it was found that the blood group of the deceased is ‘B’. Blood group of accused No.1 is ‘O’ and that of accused No.2 is ‘B’. The shirt of accused No.1 was stained with blood of Group ‘B’, which is blood group of the deceased. Likewise, the bag seized from accused No.1 also had stains of blood group ‘B’, which is the blood group of deceased. Although the blood group of the bloodstains on the clothes of accused No.2 could not be determined, the blood stains are of human blood. The panch witness has proved the discovery of the clothes. There is no explanation from accused No.2 for existence of human blood on his clothes. The knife was also discovered at the instance of accused No.1. Although in the CA report the blood group of the blood on the knife could not be detected, the conclusion drawn is that the blood is human blood. Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 10 The medical officer has given opinion that the injuries on the person of the deceased were possible with the said knife. The medical officer has also identified the knife in the witness box. The medical officer is not cross-examined on the point of his opinion that the injuries caused were possible to be inflicted by the said knife. 13. It will be pertinent to state that PW-6, who is sister of accused No.1, deposed that her two-wheeler, Honda Activa bearing RTO registration No.MH-27-BC-3949 was kept at the house of her parents and accused No.1, who is her real brother, was using the same. The said statement made by her in her deposition is not challenged in the cross-examination. The said vehicle is also discovered at the instance of accused No.1. The vehicle had bloodstains on it. This circumstance is also not explained by accused No.1. 14. As regards discovery of the bag, learned advocates for the appellants draws attention to the cross-examination of PW-4 that the police had shown him the bag on 29.08.2016. It is argued that the seizure of the bag is shown on the next day i.e. on 30.08.2016. This argument was also made before the learned Sessions Court. The argument is discarded on the ground that the witness was Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 11 deposing after a period of 4 years from the date of incident and therefore such minor blemish in mentioning the date would not be sufficient to discard his testimony. We are in agreement that a small blemish in mentioning date of a particular incident after a gap of around 4 years will not be sufficient to disbelieve the witness. 15. Although a mobile phone was found at the spot where the deceased was murdered, prosecution has not conducted any investigation with respect to the said phone. There ought to have been investigation with respect to the phone that was found at the spot of incidence. However, that by itself is not sufficient to discard the evidence that has come on record against accused Nos.1 and 2. 16. As discussed above, the knife which is the weapon of assault, bag in which amount was carried by deceased and cash amount of Rs.88,400/- was discovered from accused No.1. Likewise, the clothes of accused No.1 were also stained with human blood of blood group ‘B’, which is the blood group of the deceased. The blood group of accused No.1 is ‘O’. Likewise, human blood is also found on the Activa vehicle owned by sister of accused No.1. Likewise, cash amount of Rs.50,000/- is seized from accused No.2 and his clothes were also stained with blood. There is no explanation from both the accused persons with respect to Criminal Appeal Nos.72 & 452 Judgment.odt 12 bloodstained clothes seized from them, as also huge amount of cash seized from them. 17. In view of the above, taking into consideration the evidence on record, the findings recorded by the learned Sessions Court are just and proper and do not warrant any interference. No case for interference is made out with the well reasoned decision delivered by the learned Sessions Court. Criminal appeals are therefore dismissed. 18. Fees of the learned appointed counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No.452 of 2022, be quantified and paid as per the Rules. (ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.) (SHIVKUMAR DIGE, J.) C.L. Dhakate Signed by: Mr. C.L. Dhakate Designation: PA To Honourable Judge Date: 05/11/2026 17:06:29