SHARAD RAMDAS KHARTALAKAR v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA, THR. SECY., DEPT. OF SOCIAL JUSTICE AND EMPOWERMENT, MUMBAI AND ORS.
WP/8385/2022 · 2026-11-03
body2026
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 22356 (BOM) · dailylaw.ai ]
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 22356 (BOM) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY, NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR WRIT PETITION NO.3099 OF 2022 WITH WRIT PETITION NO.8385 OF 2022 WITH WRIT PETITION NO.7477 OF 2025 WRIT PETITION NO.3099 OF 2022 Rajesh s/o Ramkrishna Thakur, aged: 56 years, occupation: service, r/o Netaju Nagar, house No.260, lane No.2, Pimple Gurav, Pune. ….. Petitioner.
:: V E R S U S ::
1. State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary, Department of Social Justice and Empowerment, Mantralaya, Mumbai.
2. The Chairman, Divisional Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee No.2, Amravati Division, Amravati.
3. The Commandant, 512, Army Base Workshop, Khadki, district Pune. ….. Respondents. .....1/- 2026:BHC-NAG:14956-DB
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 2 =================================== Shri N.S.Khubalkar, Counsel and Shri C.Bailmare, Adv. for the Petitioner. Mrs.S.S.Jachak, Addl.Government Pleader for Respondent Nos.1 & 2. Mrs.Mugdha Chandurkar, Counsel for Respondent No.3. =================================== WRIT PETITION NO.8385 OF 2022 Sharad Ramdas Khartalakar, aged: 55 years, occupation: service, r/o Wadner Gangai, taluka Daryapur, district Amravati. ….. Petitioner.
:: V E R S U S ::
1. State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary, Department of Social Justice and Empowerment, Mantralaya, Mumbai.
2. The Chairman, Divisional Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Amravati Division, Amravati.
3. The Head Master Shri Chatrapati Shivaji Vidyalaya Bhor Taluka Bhor, district Pune. ….. Respondents. =================================== Shri N.S.Khubalkar, Counsel and Shri C.Bailmare, Adv. for the Petitioner. Mrs.S.S.Jachak, Addl.Government Pleader for Respondent Nos.1 & 2. =================================== WRIT PETITION NO.
7477
OF 202
5
Ms Shivani d/o Narayan Khadatalkar, aged about 20 years, .....2/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 3 occupation: student, r/o Wadner Gangai, taluka Daryapur, district Amravati. ….. Petitioner.
:: V E R S U S ::
1. The Scheduled Tribes Scrutiny Committee, Amravati, through its Secretary, having its office at Chaprashipura, Shaha Complex, Camp, Amravati – 444 602.
2. The State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary, Tribal Welfare Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32. ….. Respondents. =================================== Shri N.S.Khubalkar, Counsel and Shri C.Bailmare, Adv. for the Petitioner. Mrs.S.S.Jachak, Addl.Government Pleader for Respondents ===================================
CORAM : URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE & RAJ D.WAKODE, JJ.
CLOSED ON : 22/10/2026 PRONOUNCED ON : 03/11/2026.
JUDGMENT : (Per : URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE)
1. Heard learned counsel appearing for respective parties. Rule.
2. By these petitions, petitioners have challenged orders dated 18.2.2022; 28.11.2022, and 5.8.2025 passed by the respondent/The Scheduled Tribes Scrutiny Committee, Amravati (for short, “the .....3/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 4 Committee”) invalidating their tribe claim belonging to “Thakur Scheduled Tribe.”
3. Petitioners Rajesh and Sharad are uncles of petitioner Shivani. Petitioner Shivani, who is student, has completed “Three Years Diploma in Polytechnic” and is aspirant of pursuing studies in Engineering. Whereas, petitioner Sharad was appointed as “Assistant Teacher” and petitioner Rajesh was appointed as “Electrician.” They were granted Caste Certificates belonging to “Thakur” on 2.7.1983; 25.7.1989, and 27.7.2023.
4.
Brief facts necessary for disposal of present petitions are as under:
Petitioner Rajesh s/o Ramkrishna Thakur, in Writ Petition No.3099 of 2022, is uncle of petitioner Shivani in Writ Petition No.7477 of 2025. As per his contentions, he obtained Caste Certificate on 2.7.1983 from the Executive Magistrate, Warud, district Amravati showing he belongs to caste “Thakur Scheduled Tribe.” He is presently posted on the post of Electrician at 512, Army .....4/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 5 Base Workshop and his services are under the authority and control of respondent No.3. In the year 2012, after a period of about 24 years, the office of respondent No.3 asked the petitioner to get verification of his Caste Certificate as per requirement of Rules applicable to the Central Government Employees. Accordingly, his caste claim was forwarded to the Committee on 12.7.2013. Along with his Caste Certificate, he placed reliance on various pre- constitutional documents showing his forefathers were recorded as
“Thakur.” However, the Committee issued Show Cause Notice to the petitioner stating that the Vigilance Officers have collected some adverse documents showing adverse entries against his blood relatives. On the basis of the said entries, the Committee invalidated his caste claim and hence this petition.
Petitioner Sharad Ramdas Khartalakar in Writ Petition No.8385 of 2022, who is also uncle of petitioner Shivani, has obtained Caste Certificate on 25.7.1989. He was appointed as Assistant Teacher by appointment order dated 26.8.1997 from reserved category. He also contended that he has also placed pre- .....5/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 6 constitutional documents showing his forefathers are recorded as
“Thakur.” However, the Vigilance Officers have collected some adverse entries against blood relatives of the petitioner and, therefore, the Committee invalidated the caste claim of petitioners and hence this petition.
Petitioner Shivani is aspirant of admission to Engineering Course in Engineering College for obtaining Degree in Engineering in a seat reserved for “Scheduled Tribe Category.” She obtained Caste Certificate on 27.7.2023 issued by the Sub Divisional Officer, Daryapur showing she belongs to caste “Thakur Scheduled Tribe.” Her caste claim was forwarded for validation on 25.11.2024. As per her contentions, she has produced family tree as well as various pre- constitutional documents showing that her great-grandfather Maroti Mahadaji was recorded as “Thakur.” Her great-great-grandfather Mahadaji Yadoji was recorded as “Thakur” on 4.2.1935. There are some adverse entries against name of great-grandfather Maroti Mahadaji while recording birth entry of his son Ramkrishna. However, the oldest entries of 1931, 1935, 1940, 1947, and 1949 .....6/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 7 show that her forefathers were belonging to “Thakur Scheduled Tribe.” However, the Vigilance Officers have collected some adverse documents showing her great-grandfather Maroti Mahadaji was recorded as “Bhat” as well as her father was also recorded as
“Bramhabhat” in the school record. The Vigilance Officers collected these documents and the Committee, relying upon the said documents, invalidated the caste claim of the present petitioner and hence she approached this court.
5.
Learned counsel Shri N.S.Khubalkar for petitioners invited our attention towards family tree and submitted that one Yadoji was ancestor of petitioners, who was having son namely Mahadaji. Said Mahadaji is great-great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani and great- grandfather of petitioners Rajesh and Sharad. Said Mahadaji was having one son namely Maroti who is great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani and grandfather of petitioners Rajesh and Sharad. As per the said family tree, Maroti’s wife name was Chandrabhaga. Said Maroti was having three sons namely Ramkrishna, Ramdas, and Pralhad. Petitioner Sharad is son of Ramdas. Whereas, petitioner Rajesh is .....7/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 8 son of Ramkrishna. Petitioner Shivani’s father Narayan is son of Pralhad. The said family tree, which at page No.91 of Writ Petition No.7477 of 2025, further shows that Maroti was having daughter by name Chandrakala. He submitted that the oldest document i.e. Family Arrangement Deed executed by great-great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani namely Mahadaji in favour of Maroti’s wife Chandrabhaga is of the year 1935 dated 4.2.1935 wherein said Mahadaji was recorded as “Thakur.” The school admission extract of Pralhad Maroti, whose birth date was 6.11.1931 and was admitted in school on 2.3.1937, was also recorded as “Thakur.” While recording birth entry, Maroti’s daughter Chandrakala was recorded as “Thakur” on 12.3.1940. In School Leaving Certificate of Ramkrishna dated 26.4.1947 and other School Leaving Certificate of Pralhad dated 2.3.1949 also, forefathers of petitioners were recorded as “Thakur.” He submitted that caste claim of present petitioners were forwarded for Vigilance Report. The Vigilance Report in the case of petitioner Shivani is dated 24.4.2025; The Vigilance Report in the case of petitioner Rajesh is dated 12.7.2021, and the Vigilance Report in the case of petitioner Sharad is dated 30.6.2017. .....8/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 9
During the Vigilance Enquiry, the Vigilance Officers have collected documents of 3.7.1975 wherein father of petitioner Shivani in School Admission Extract is shown to be recorded as
“Bramhabhat;” the birth entry of son of Maroti namely Ramkrishna dated 28.8.1937 showing him as “Bhat;” another birth entry of Maroti Mahadaji dated 12.8.1942 showing said Maroti as “Bhat;” death entry of Mahadaji Yadoji dated 23.2.1943 showing said Mahadaji as “Bhat;” and another birth entry of daughter of Maroti dated 17.12.1945 showing said Maroti as “Bhat.”
The oldest entry of 1931 showing that son of Maroti namely Pralhad was born on 6.11.1931 and admitted in school on 2.3.1937 was recorded as “Thakur.” In the Property Arrangement Deed executed by great-great-grandfather Mahadaji in favour of Chandrabhaga, the wife of Maroti, also he was recorded as “Thakur.” The birth entry of Chandrakala, who is daughter of Maroti, also shows said Maroti was recorded as “Thakur” on 12.3.1940 and School Leaving Certificates of Ramkrishna and Pralhad dated 26.4.1947 and 2.3.1949 consistently show said Maroti as “Thakur.” .....9/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 10
Thus, on the basis of some adverse entries, the Committee invalidated the caste claim of petitioners. The said facts are well explained by petitioners in their explanations when Show Cause Notices were issued to them. He submitted that the oldest document, which is having the highest probative value, requires to be considered and the Committee ought to have considered the same. However, the Committee erroneously relied upon some adverse entries and ignoring the oldest entry, invalidated the caste claim of petitioners. As such, orders impugned in these petitions passed by the Committee deserve to be quashed and set aside.
6. Per contra, learned Additional Government Pleader Mrs.S.S.Jachak for the Committee vehemently submitted that there are various adverse entries showing forefathers of petitioners as
“Bhat.” These adverse entries are collected by the Vigilance. The Show Cause Notices were issued to petitioners. The petitioners have not denied any relationship with persons who were recorded as
“Bhat” and, therefore, the Committee has rightly considered that .....10/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 11 petitioners could not prove their caste claim and hence no interference is called for.
7.
Learned counsel for petitioners invited our attention towards observations of this court in Writ Petition No.5095/2021 (Dr. Parasram Kisan Nandankar vs. Vice-Chairman, Scheduled Tribe Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Adiwasi Vikas Bhavan, Giripeth, Nagpur) wherein it has been held as under:
“The other document that has been considered by the Scrutiny Committee is an extract from the property register dated 15.05.1963. The entry therein has been taken on the basis of a sale deed dated 01.04.1963. Against the name of the petitioner and his brothers, the word Koshti has been mentioned. By deleting the name of the previous owner, the names of family members of Vithoba including the petitioner were inserted in the records. The records of this document were also summoned by the Scrutiny Committee and the same were examined on 18.02.2020. Since reference of the word Koshti was found there, the Scrutiny Committee has proceeded to accept this document as indicating the petitioner' s social status. .....11/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 12 In reply to this document the petitioner stated that the word Koshti referred to the identity of persons who were locally identified on the basis of their occupation of weaving. ..........”
This Court further observed as under:
“The information supplied to the petitioner in this regard indicates that under the Indian Registration Act, 1908 as well as the Maharashtra Registration Rules, 1961, it was not mandatory to record the caste of the persons concerned while registering any document or taking entries in that regard. We further find that this document of 1963 is subsequent to the school record of the year 1959 which specifically records the social status of the petitioner as Halba. There is no reason whatsoever to ignore the document of 1959 that has been produced from the proper custody in preference to the document of 1963 which does not specifically indicate the significance of the word Koshti as to whether it indicated the social status or the profession of the persons named therein. The importance to be given to old documents has been considered by the Hon' ble Supreme Court in Priya Pramod Gajbe (supra) since such documents have greater probative value.” .....12/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 13
Learned counsel for petitioners further submitted that prior to the Amendment in 1956 in the Indian Registration Act, there was specific Clause of mentioning Caste. He invited our attention towards Section 2 of the Indian Registration (Amendment) Act,
1956.
8. Section 2 deals with Amendment of Section 2 of the Act 16 of 1908, which reads as under:
“”2. Amendment of section 2, Act 16 of 1908. - In Section 2 of the Indian Registration Act), 1908, in clause (1), the words “his caste (if any) and” shall be omitted.”
Thus, he submitted that prior to the Amendment, there was a clause to mention the Caste and accordingly the Property Arrangement Deed executed by great-great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani namely Mahadaji Yadoji of dated 4.2.1935 in favour of wife of Maroti namely Chandrabhaga wherein he was recorded as
“Thakur.” Thus, this is the oldest document which refers the great- .....13/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 14 great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani and great-grandfather of petitioners Rajesh and Sharad as “Thakur.”
9.
Learned counsel for petitioners also placed reliance on following decisions: (1) Anand vs. Committee and Verification of Tribe Claims and others, reported in 2012(1) SCC 113; (2) Writ Petition No.6222/2022 (Bharti d/o Manohar Surey vs. The State of Mah., thr.its Principal Secretary, Tribal Development Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai and ors) decided by this court on 14.8.2026; (3) Deepika Yogeshwar Nandanwar vs. State of Maharashtra and ors, reported in 2008 SCC OnLine Bom 324; (4) Writ Petition No.4780/2023 (Khrushi d/o Vishal Dehliwale vs. The District Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, thr.its Member Secretary and Deputy Director, Akola) decided by this court on 14.6.2024, and (4) Writ Petition No.3841/2005 (Pradeep s/o Himmatrao Wankhade vs. State of Mah. and ors) decided by this court on 24.2.2022.
10. After going through submissions canvassed by learned counsel for petitioners and learned Additional Government Pleader .....14/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 15 for the State, the entire controversy is regarding adverse entries collected during the Vigilance by the Vigilance Officers.
11. The family tree produced by petitioners, which at page No.91 of Writ Petition No.7477 of 2025, is reproduced as under:
.....15/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 16
The aforesaid family tree shows that Yadoji was original ancestor of petitioners having one son Mahadaji. Said Mahadaji is great-great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani and great-grandfather of petitioners Rajesh and Sharad. Said Mahadaji is having one son Maroti who is having three sons and five daughters. The record shows that said Mahadaji has executed Family Arrangement Deed on 4.2.1935, which shows that said Mahadaji executed the said Deed in favour of wife of Maroti namely Chandrabhaga. In the said Family Arrangement Deed, said Chandrabhaga Maroti was recorded as
“Thakur.” Similarly, Mahadaji Yadoji was also recorded as “Thakur.” The School Admission Extract of Pralhad Maroti whose birth date was recorded as 6.11.1931 and he was admitted in school on 2.3.1937 wherein he was recorded as “Thakur.” The said School Leaving Certificate is issued by the Headmaster, Zilla Parishad, Uttar Buniyadi School, Wadner, Gangai. Another School Leaving Certificate showing Ramkrishna was admitted in school on 26.4.1947 was also recorded as “Thakur.” The birth entry of daughter of Maroti namely Chandrakala who born on 12.3.1940 shows that Maroti was recorded as “Thakur.” .....16/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 17
12. Thus, these entries during pre-constitutional era show that sons of Maroti were recorded as “Thakur” while admitting them in school. The caste claim of petitioners was forwarded for Vigilance Enquiry. The Vigilance Report placed before us shows that during Vigilance, the Vigilance Officers have collected birth entry showing Maroti Mahadaji was recorded as “Bhat” while recording birth entry of son Ramkrishna on 10.9.1937. Similarly, said Maroti was recorded as “Bhat” while recording birth date of his another son Ramdas as 12.8.1942.
13. The Vigilance Officers have also recorded statements of relevant witnesses when caste claim of petitioners Rajesh and Sharad was forwarded.
14. Perusal of the entire material on record reveals that in support of the caste claim, petitioners have placed reliance on various documents including Property Arrangement Deed. Admittedly, the said Property Arrangement Deed is the oldest document executed on 4.2.1935 wherein the great-great-grandfather of petitioner Shivani namely Mahadaji was recorded as “Thakur.” He .....17/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 18 has executed the said Property Arrangement Deed in favour of wife of Maroti namely Chandrabhaga, who is his daughter-in-law, wherein said Chandrabhaga wife of Maroti as well as Mahadaji father of Maroti both were recorded as “Thakur.”
15.
Learned counsel for petitioners rightly placed reliance on pre-amendment Section 2, which shows that prior to the Amendment in the Registration Act, there was a provision to mention caste while executing documents. The said Section is already reproduced in earlier part of this judgment. In view of that provision, caste of Mahadaji was mentioned in the said document. Thereafter, the School Leaving Certificate of Pralhad, the son of Maroti, who was admitted in school in the year 1937 and the birth entry of daughter of Maroti namely Chandrakala who is shown in the family tree born on 12.3.1940, at the relevant time said Maroti was recorded as
“Thakur.” The School Leaving Certificate of Ramkrishna, who is another son of Maroti, who was admitted in school in the year 1947, also shows that Maroti was recorded as “Thakur.” Undisputedly, there are some adverse entries of 1937 showing Maroti Mahadaji was .....18/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 19 recorded as “Bhat” while taking birth entry of his son Ramkrishna and in the year 1942 while recording birth entry of another son Ramdas. However, admittedly, the oldest entry is the Property Arrangement Deed of the year 1935 wherein said Mahadaji, father of Maroti, was recorded as “Thakur.”
16. It is well settled that entries of pre-independence era have a higher degree of probative value. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 12 of the Maharashtra Scheduled Tribes (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of) Certificate Rules, 2003 provides that only if the Scrutiny Committee is not satisfied with documentary evidence produced by the applicant, it shall forward application to the Vigilance Cell for conducting inquiry. While interpreting the said Rule, the Hon' ble Apex Court in the case of Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat Swarakshan Samiti vs. State of Maharashtra, reported in 2023 16 SCC 415 held that as under:
"In every case, as a matter of routine, the Scrutiny Committee cannot mechanically forward the application to Vigilance Cell for conducting an enquiry. When sub rule (2) of Rule 12 contemplates that only if .....19/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 20 the Scrutiny Committee is not satisfied with the documents produced by the applicant that the case should be referred to Vigilance Cell, it follows that the Scrutiny Committee is required to pass an order recording brief reasons why it is not satisfied with the documents produced by the applicant. Before referring the case to the Vigilance Cell, application of mind to the material produced by the petitioners is required and therefore, the application of mind must be reflected in the order sheets of the Scrutiny Committee.”
17. Perusal of the record nowhere reflects that the Committee recorded its reasons as to dissatisfaction of the record and its reasons for referring the application to the Vigilance Cell. The Committee placed reliance on documents collected by the Vigilance Cell showing adverse entries in the names of great-grandfather Maroti Mahadaji and great-great-grandfather Mahadaji Yadoji. The petitioners have already explained that there are adverse entries, but the oldest entries would prevail.
18. Thus, the Committee, while considering the adverse entries, clearly ignored previous entries showing forefathers of petitioners as
“Thakur.” .....20/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 21
19. As observed earlier, pre-constitutional documents showing caste of petitioners and their ancestors as “Thakur” are of the highest probative value.
20. The Hon' ble Apex Court in the cases of Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat Swarakshan Samiti (supra), in paragraph No.20, and Anand vs. Committee and Verification of Tribe Claims and others (supra) held that, “one of the tests is as laid down in the case of Kumari Madhuri Patil and anr vs. Additional Commissioner, Tribal Development and ors, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 241. It lays down that the documents of the pre-constitution period showing the caste of the applicant and their ancestors have got the highest probative value. For example, if an applicant is able to produce authentic and genuine documents of the pre-constitution period showing that he belongs to a tribal community, there is no reason to discard his claim as prior to 1950, there were no reservations provided to the Tribes included in the ST order. In such a case, a reference to Vigilance Cell is not warranted at all.” .....21/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 22
21. In the present matter, such is not the case. On the contrary, the Committee ought to have considered the oldest documents of 1935 showing forefathers of petitioners were recorded as “Thakur.” In the present case, orders impugned nowhere reflect that any explanation is given by the Committee to ignore the said documents. Neither there is a finding recorded by the Committee nor the evidence is adduced to show that why the Committee has accepted subsequent documents of 1937 and 1942 and ignored documents of 1935 and 1940.
22. The Vigilance Cell also speaks about affinity test. Insofar as the affinity test is concerned, now, it is well settled that affinity test is not a litmus test and that document of pre-constitutional era is of the highest probative value in the eyes of law.
23. The aforesaid view is reiterated by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the recent judgment in the case of Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat Swarakshan Samiti (supra) wherein it is held that, “the vigilance cell, while conducting an affinity test, verifies the knowledge of the applicant, deities of the community, customs, .....22/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 23 rituals, mode of marriage, and death ceremonies etc. in respect of that particular scheduled tribe. By its very nature such affinity test can never be conclusive. It is further held that question of conduct of the affinity test arises only in those cases where the scrutiny committee is not satisfied with the material produced by the applicant. While concluding, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that affinity test will not be a conclusively either way. When the affinity test is conducted by the vigilance cell, the result of the test along with all other material on record having probative value will have to be taken into consideration by the scrutiny committee for deciding the tribe validity claim and in short the affinity test is not a litmus test to decide the tribe’s claim and is not an essential part in the process of determination of correctness of caste or tribe claim in every case.”
24. There is no reason for the Committee to ignore 1935 document produced from the proper custody in preference to subsequent documents. .....23/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 24
25. The importance to be given to old documents has been considered by the Hon' ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.7117/2019 (Priya Pramod Gajbe vs. State of Maharashtra) decided on 11.07.2023 and held that such documents have greater probative value.
26. In the subsequent decision, in Writ Petition No.2716 of 2022 (Ashwin Rajendra Parate vs. State of Maharashtra), decided at the Principal Seat of this Court on 24.6.2022 also held that, “merely because a document prior to 1950 is not produced, the claim of such person cannot be denied for that reason.”
It has further been held that, “on the basis of stray entry, the petitioner’s claim could not be discarded.”
27. In the light of the above, when the affinity test is not an integral part of determination of correctness of claim and when petitioners have submitted number of documents which were pre- constitutional having the highest probative value and the oldest document showing tribe claim of petitioners as “Thakur,” we are .....24/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 25 of a considered view that the tribe claim of the petitioners ought to have been considered by the Committee by giving an appropriate weightage to tribe certificates issued to petitioners.
28. In the light of the above facts and circumstances of the case, since we find that these petitions deserve to be allowed by directing the Committee to issue Tribe Validity Certificates to petitioners to be belonging to “Thakur Scheduled Tribe,” we proceed to pass following order:
ORDER (1) All the Writ Petitions are allowed. (2) The orders dated 18.2.2022; 28.11.2022, and 5.8.2025 passed by the respondent/The Scheduled Tribes Scrutiny Committee, Amravati invalidating tribe claim of petitioners belonging to “Thakur Scheduled Tribe” are hereby quashed and set aside. .....25/-
Judgment wp3099.22, 8385.22, & 7477.25.odt 26 (3) It is declared that petitioners Rajesh s/o Ramkrishna Thakur; Sharad Ramdas Khartalakar; and Ms Shivani d/o Narayan Khadatalkar belong to “Thakur Scheduled Tribe.” (4) It is directed that the respondent/The Scheduled Tribes Scrutiny Committee, Amravati shall, within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of writ of this order, issue Caste Validity Certificates to the present petitioners accordingly. Petitions stand disposed of. Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms. No costs.
(RAJ D.WAKODE, J.) (URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE, J.) !! Bhushan Wankhede !! .....26/- Signed by: Mr. B. R. Wankhede Designation: PS To Honourable Judge Date: 03/11/2026 19:37:43