Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2026 DAILYLAW 16958 (PNJ)
MUKHTIAR SINGH v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
CWP/4021/2026 · 2026-03-23
Harkesh Manuja
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 16958 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 16958 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
CWP No.4021 of 202
!!"# $% # $% $% 91: &% & (& ) )0)"+&) #& %,= %, #-#&!)*!( 9: &! %$)< (#("#&!" 7""!?, !
1@ +(/ (*(")#% ; * )/A,((#(%")"+ $% (,)"/!%$) #&!(*(0) )*%, 2026 (O&M)
B
% B
% B
% B
% )#!%$! )#!%$! )#!%$! )#!%$!
)#5( )#&% !-+.%/)#! % #&!'!#(#(%"!
) *("+! )"+&,-+.%/)#!$ (00-+.%/)#! % !'%"+!"#% 123 #&) &*!+--
,"4)5 % !'%"+!"#% 62 CCCC - 7 )08 - 7 )08 - 7 )08 - 7 )08 &% # !'0; %" 5!&)0$ %$ !'%"+ & )-
%4!/# ( !/#% - )#(%")0 %,=& & &)"#)", ')+&;);- ! !(#)>!"%" !/% + &!'!#(#(%"! 0)"+%<"! -5;<); !")#, !%$/! #(% ) (A,)&("=#&!( 1@8 ')!+ 5; !'%"+!"# % # *)""! - <(#&%,# /%"(+! ("= #& +%$#&!)*!.(00)=!EEEE$% #&!)* )< (#("#&!")#, !%$*)"+)*, %,"#%$/%*'!")#(%")&)5!!"
@1 @1 @1 @1%$@ %$@ %$@ %$@FFFF7 28 7 28 7 28 7 28 !/((%" !/((%" !/((%" !/((%" 6 6 6 6 @@@@6666 @ @ @ @FFFF
!#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"!
!'%"+!"# !'%"+!"# !'%"+!"# !'%"+!"# !$%
"+!"# % 5; <); %$ )$$(+).(# 0 (=&<); ,#&% (#; %$ "+()- !',#; )")=! - &) 5!!" $(0!+ ;%$' !!"#'!#(#(%"-!!>(,)" !(*',="!+<) ++)#!+@D @1 @ #%#)00; (" )" (00!=)0- ) 5(# ) ; ) #&! )<) + '! #)("("= #% #&! )* )*!>("+%$0)"+)"+$, #&! ' ); *,+( !/#("=#&! !'%"+!"##%' !!")<) +!+#%#&!(+!"#(/)00;'0)/ 1 (# %$ -
!+ (" ,)"/! @ )"+ )*! );!+ %'); 0)/!+ MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
0)"+%<"! (")/ ')!+5;#&!% !$! !+)G 5
"(%"%$"+())
"(%"%$"+())
"(%"%$"+())
"(%"%$"+()) )0)"+&) .(+! + /)!3% 3% 3% 3% ("=&)"+%#&! ("=&)"+%#&! ("=&)"+%#&! ("=&)"+%#&! 96: (! !.!",!!#)#!% 5!)/A,( !+("#! !/#(%"62 !'!/#(.!0; $% (=&<);1 !'%"+!"#% 6 #&!*) >!#.)0,! 96 1: !(" 78%$#&!1I 0!) "!+ 5(# )#% 61-@3'! * 96 : &! ) 5(# )#(%")<) + ,+=!- )0)"+&) <))00%<!+%" 2026 (O&M)
)//% +)"/!<(#&)") 5(# )0<) + %**((%"! -)0)"+&) (.((%" 5(# )#% H8("////)! )! )! )!% % % % 1J1 1J1 1J1 1J1@ @ @ @ ())"+%#&! ())"+%#&! ())"+%#&! ())"+%#&! HEHEHEHE0)#! ,'&!0+5;#&! ! +!/((%" +)#!+ 16 @ @6 7" 36IF3@1 36IF3@1 36IF3@1 36IF3@1-#(#0!+ G
"(%"%$ G
"(%"%$ G
"(%"%$ G
"(%"%$ " " &! H &! H &! H &! H (!$0; #)#("=- %*! 0)"+ %<"!+ %$(00)=!&)"', -!&(0,>! #! *%$"%#($(/)#(%"+)#!+ 1 26%$#&!)#(%")0(=&<); % #&! (*' %.!*!"# )"+ <(+!"("= F @@ #% 11J @ (" #&! 6')!+)")<) +,"+! !/#(%" 0,!<))!!+)##&! )#!%$ F !("=)== (!.!+-#&!'!#(#(%"! %,= IF/#-<&! !(".(+!<) ++)#! )#% )!!+ #&! *) >!# .)0,! % ! *) 0)-5!(+!)<) +%$%#&! #) &! !)$#! - !'%"+!"# % 1 2 ) ++)#!+@ @ @1@5!$% !#&! &) - &).("= ' !$! !+ 5(# )#(%"
" 1@ @17""!?, !
68)"+
) ++)#!+6 11 @@7""!?, ! (%"/,* 5(# )#% 7&! !(")$#! #% @11 @11 @11 @11-#(#0!+GB) ;)*("=&! B) ;)*("=&! B) ;)*("=&! B) ;)*("=&! !%, #%$++(#(%")0(# (/#,+ ""!?, !
J8 ')!+ (" ) 5(# )#( "+())"+)"%#&! ! ,B) ;) "+())"+)"%#&! ! ,B) ;) "+())"+)"%#&! ! ,B) ;) "+())"+)"%#&! ! ,B) ;) !+ 5; #&! '!#(#(%"! (#,)#!+ (" # ,>! ()"-(# (/#%&() ', -/)*! 1 @@211 @J @@(,!+,"+ ;/#-1IF7$% &% #G1IF/
"("= %$ )0)"+&)
)#&)">%# )#(%" ! #)#! %$
,"4)5 " 1 1 @ %"6718%$#&!1IF/#-<&! ! FDJ3'! *) 0) %,=&#) 5(# )#(%"(".%>("=!/#(%" )#!+@ @ @1@7""!?, !
8- %$ #&! )/A,( !+ 0)"+ )# #&! )#! #)#,#% ;5!"!$(# ))(0!+ #&! .)0(+(#; %$ # %, #%$0!) "!+++(#(%")0(# (%" )! % @@@@J3@1@- <&(
"+)$#! !##("=)(+!#&!<) ++)# 2
F8 #%5! ! , ! , ! , ! , ,+=!- )#(%" ) ;)* ) ;)* ) ;)* ) ;)*
" #&! *!#% ,"+!
/#H8 )#(%")0 @@J- ! !5; %"6 #&! #! %$ $ #&! (# (/# &(/& +)#!+ MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
@ @ @1@- #&! +!/((%" 96 6: )#! 1@ @1-#&!0 *)##! )$ !&)" +%("=%-0+ 5 (") 5(# )#(%"/) #% #&! )*! .(00 (+!"#(/)0 ")#, ! (+!"#(/)00;'0)/! +)#!+ 1 @@ ', '%!E$%00%<! %$!"&)"/!+*) %$ 0)"+- ( ! )= ( B) ;)* B) ;)* B) ;)* B) ;)*("=&K ("=&K ("=&K ("=&K ,'&!0+5;#&!% +)#!+16 @ @6 )"+ //% +("= #&!(*',="!+)< $).%, %$#&!'!# CONTENTION(S) ON BEHALF OF T 9: !) +(/ (*(")#(%"+% '! #)("("=#%#&! )= (/,0#, )0-#&! 2026 (O&M)
&! *)##! <) !*(##!+ 5)/> #% )#! - )$#! )5%,# 1 ;!) %$ #&! !0!) "!+ 5(# )#% .(+!(#)<) + )"+)!!+*) >!#.)0,!)##&! 5(# )#% (="% !+#&!)<) ++)#!+ /)!#(#0!+)B) ;)*("=&.
" B) ;)*("=&.
" B) ;)*("=&.
" B) ;)*("=&.
" .(00)=!E #&! )/A,((#(%" *)+! $% ! %$ 0)"+ &! 0!) "!+ 5(# )#% /!+0)"+%<"! <&%!0)"+<))/ @@ (,!+ ,"+! !/#(%" 6 % <!+5;#&!)*!)<) ++)#!+1 ) >!#.)0,!)##&! )#!%$ 1- = (/,0#, !- .(+! )<) + +)#!+ 6 1 &K/)!7,' )8 &K/)!7,' )8 &K/)!7,' )8 &K/)!7,' )8 &!)(+)<) +$, %, #%$0!) "!+++(#(%")0(# ( @67""!?, !
J8,'%"/&)00!"= ("=0;-#&!' !!"#'!#(#(%"&)5!!" )<) ++)#!+@D @1 @)"+$% = '!#(#(%"! N(S) :- OF THE PETITIONER !) "!+/%,"!0$% #&!'!#(#(%"! +%"!<(#&#&!'!#(#(%"! 0)"+%<"! #&!)*! !.!",!!#)#!!'!/()00; &!'!#(#(%"! <))<) +!+),*
#% #&! 0!) "!+ 5(# )#% $% $ ! #&! )5%.! )(+ !*)"+ % +! +)# ) ++)#!+@D @1 @-)+4,+(/)#!+ #&! )#!%$ @-@@@3'! *) 0) !+6 11 @@7""!?, !
F8')
"(%"%$"+()
"(%"%$"+()
"(%"%$"+()
"(%"%$"+())"+%#&! )"+%#&! )"+%#&! )"+%#&! '! #)("( % #&! )*! ',50(/ ', '%!- )"+ )#% %.! 0%%>!+ #&! $)/# #&)# %* )/A,( !+,"+! #&!)*!"%#($(/)#( %$ 1IF /#E $% #&! )*! ',5 1 1 @@JE<! != )"#!+#&!5!"! --@@@3'! *) 0)$% (*(0) ")#, 6 11 @@ 7""!?, !
F8 ')!+ $, #&! )##)("!+$(")0(#;-&).("=5! # (/#,+=!-)0)"+&) .(+!4,+=*!
"=!5!!"*)+!5; !'%"+!"#% !!"("#(#,#!+!!>("=!##("=)(+! = )"#%$') (#;("/%*'!")#(%" ! ,5*(##&)##&! !<))/0!)
"! )$% #&!)*!.! ;)/A,((#(% )00;-$% #&!)*!")#, !%$0)"+( *%$ @-@@@3'! *) 0)-<&! ! 3 $ !& +)#!+ +#&! 0) " )!+ ("("=
"+ %$ %*! )#(%" ,50(/ !"!$(# )#, ! !+ (" 5!!" *!"# % 1 (+!%$ %"(" /,# (#(%"E +( ! ! !) MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
)"(+!"#(/)00;'0) '! *) 0) !#& $)( /%*'!")#(% 0)"+&%0+("=- #&! !A,( !+ #% 5! 5!"!$(#%$)<) + /%,"!0 #&, ' )$% !)(+#! * 9 1: !) ("#! $! !"/! ,"+ # (/#0;0(*(#!+ )(+!)") 5(# )0 )"+ !"&)"/! #&! 5!("=).)(0)50!- <(#&#&!+(/ (* !0()"/!,'%"#&! ( !/#% - ( !/#% - ( !/#% - ( !/#% - 6J1 6J1 6J1 6J1 !0!.)"#') @ 5; ) 4,+(/ !/# #&!' #&! "#! (" =(.! +!)0 2026 (O&M)
'0)/!+0)"+%<"! <)= )"#!+#&! #&,,5*(##&)#>!!'("=("*("+ #(%" #% #&! '!#(#(%"! 0)"+%<"! #&! )<) + +)#!+ @D @1 @ ') ! !# )(+! ) #&! '!#(#(%"! 0)"+ ) +%$*) >!#.)0,!)##&! )#!%$ ' ); #&)# #&! ' !!"# < (# '!#( !) "!+/%,"!0$% #&!'!#(#(%"!
"+! !/#(%" 6 %$ #&! 5(# )#(% + #(,5*(##!+#&)##&!%, #( )0)<) +)"++%!"%#'%!#& #&! /%*'!")#(%" )"+ ) ,/&- + 0!-#&!' !!"#'!#(#(%"<) !A,( ! (*(")#(%"*!#<(#&#&!'!#(#(%"! #&!+!/((%" !"+! !+5;#&!%"K . )>!!*H . )>!!*H . )>!!*H . )>!!*H !'% #!+ #') )= )'&#&! !%$) !!?# )/#!+& #/)"#&! !$% !5!)(+#&)##&( ; )# 0!)# 6 +!/((%" %$ #&( %, ,+(/()0 # !"+ )''!) #% $).%, )" !/#(%"6)'%<! #%*%+($;- !.(!% &!' !.(%,0)</%"#)("!+("#&!1I &! 1IIF /# <) !")/#!+ 5)!+ %
"#! ")#(%")0%**! /()0 5(# )#(%"-
" !+$! " )"+ ,"#! %" "#! ")#(%" (.!" #&! 0(*(#!+ 4,+(/()0 ("#! $! !"/! !)0("=<(#&#&!*! (#%$)")<) +-#&
&!5!"!$(#)##&! )#!%$ 1--@@ ("+#&!' ("/('0!%$= )"#("=4,#) ! )=)("# /%*',0% ; )/A,((#(%" )!+ 5; #&! 0!) "!+ 5(# )#%
"+%<"! ( !"#(#0!+ $% #&! (*( %$ 1--@@@3'! *) 0) !) " !#(#(%" "!!+ #% 5! )00%<!+ (" # $, #&! /%"#!"+#&)##&!/%'! )#(%" )"+ %"/(0()#(%" /#- 1IIF (.!#!+%"0;<(#&#&!'%<! #% #&!4, (+(/#(%"#%*%+($;#&!)* - +!'(#! )0#! ")#! #)#,#% ; !*! ,( !+#%5!!"#! #)("!+-%)#%+ ",''% #-0!) "!+/%,"!0'0)/
"K50!'!?%, #("/)!%$G
%4! G
%4! G
%4! G
%4! + )@1 ,' !*! %, @1 ,' !*! %, @1 ,' !*! %, @1 ,' !*! %, +&! !,"+! $% !$! !"/! #&(A,!#(%"&)"%<5!!"!##0!+$(") %, # .!" %#&! <(!- #% #)#! #&)# # )" ("#!
' !#)#(%" #&)# <%,0+ !)+ (" (!% .) ;#&!)<) +<%,0+5!#%(="% @/#E))0%#%(="% !#&!$)/##& + %" #&! %+!0 )< (%"-1ID<&(/&-)&)5!!"'%("#!+% )#(%")0 5(# )#(%"- *)>! (# /0!) #& !"/! %" !?# !*!0; 0(*(#!+ = %,"+ " +-#&!L0(*(#!+ !*!+; ,"+! !/#(%" 4 -@@@3 #)"+ %" %$ #% ( *(0) ) "!+
" #&! '!%$ IF ( #%!# )*! *!+; +!)0 0)/! %4!/# %4!/# %4!/# %4!/# %, # %, # %, # %, # $(")00; )# #&! + ("#% (="% ! /##&)# )< %" #!+%,# #&)#- + "%# (%"6 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
(/% % ! #&! ????
F ("! )//% #)#, #&!" ("#!" #&! ' %. 5( %.! ON BEHALF OF 9:
" #&)#)=)("##&! %54!/#(%","+! ,/&-#&!' !!" /%"#!"+#&)##& <)!"#(#0!+$% 7,' )8)"+-#&! 9F: $#! #&!')'! 5%%>3 '!#(#(%"! 9J: ## ) (! %,# %$ #&! $%00%<!+)"++! 2026 (O&M)
/%#! *(",<(#&#&!L0(*(#!+ (=&# - !*)"+#&!*)##! ,"+! #&!/( /,* &! 5(# )#(%"/#-1IIF ???? M,(#!%5.(%,0;($%"!<! !#%(
"!/#(%"6-%"!<%,0+5!/ %("=# //% +("= #% #&! 4,#(/! %$ ) /)!- % #)#,#% ;' %.((%"-),+=!*,#',#& &!" )> <&!#&!
) 0()*!"# ("#!"+!+
"#!"+!+#&)#"%'%<! %$*%+($(/)#(% &! 5(# )#(%"/#-1IIF #(%"0;$% %.((%"("#&!0(=&#%$#&!!?'! (!"/ 5(# )#(%"/#-1IIF-)"+5 ("=(#(" .! H LF OF RESPONDENT Nos. 1 & 2
"#&!%#&! &)"+-0!) "!+/%,"!0 !)<) +%$0!) "!+ 5(# )#% -#&! +! !/#(%"6 %$#&! 5(# )#(%" !"#< (#'!#(#(%"("%#*)("#)(")5 #&!'!#(#(%"! /%,0+"%#' %.!5!$ % #&!)*!/%*'!")#(%")<) ! !$% !-#&!' !!"#< (#'!#(#(%"< $#! &!) ("=0!) "!+/%,"!0$% #& >3 !/% +-$("+,5#)"/!("#&!, ##&!%,#!#-(#*);5!"%#(/!+&! #&! /%*',0% ; )/A,((#(%" %$ 0) +!)0#<(#&5;)<) +%$4,#)"+$)
&# -")*!0;-!(#&! #%!#)(+!)")<) /,*#)"/!*!"#(%"!+("!/#(%"6 #%("/0,+!#&!'%<! #%*%+($;)")<)
"=#&! )>&*)" !>&))"++%("=<& !- %,=&# #% 5! +%"! " ("#! ' !#("= ,#&(*!0$("#&!&%!%$
) 0()*!"#) +!+ #&( !,0#
) 0()*!"# .! ; /0!) )#(%"%$)")<) +!?(#("!/#(%"6 0;$%
) 0()*!"##%)*!"+#&!)$% !) (!"/!%$#&!/%, #("#&!<% >("=%$# ("0("!<(#&%#&! 0!=(0)#(%"#&!<% & 2-NHAI !0$% !'%"+!"#% 12,5* #&!'!#(#(%"! &)#&! !*!+;#%$ %" 2 %"/(0()#(%" /#- 1IIF )"+
")50!)#)00 !) "!+/%,"!0$, #& 5!$% !#&!0!) "!+ 5(# )#% #&)# )= )"#!+("B) ;)*("=&K B) ;)*("=&K B) ;)*("=&K B) ;)*("=&K/) <)0()50!#%5!+(*(!+ #&!') #(!)"+&).("==%"!#& %, ,5*((%"78*)+!%"5!&)0$%$# &! !#&)##&!0(("#&!' !!"#/) 0)"+ <&(/& !!"#()00; "!!+ #% $)( /%*'!")#(%"#%#&!0)"+%<" 5 )<) + 6%$ )<) + <&)#- #("= )
"#)"+ /0!) 0; 6%$ !)(+ %$#&! <% 0+ 5*(# %$(0!
"+ ) , #&! )#&! /)! %,=& %$#&! #/)! #% 5! <"! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
"#&!' !!"#/) <!00)#&!0)"+% ) 5(# )#(%"/)!( !#)#!%$(00)=! ,"+! !/#(%"6 11 @J @@(,! 718 %$ #&! 1IF *) >!#.)0,!<) <) 5!("= ,!+ ' %/!!+("=("(#( !0)#(%"#%#&!( 678%$#&!1I !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! )#!78 )#!78 )#!78 )#!78 %/ %/ %/ %/ 1 @@ 6 11 @J @@ 6 @ @ @1@ 5( % 0!) " )<) )#!% 1@ @1 00%< !/#( ' !$! 2 ++( )0)" #&! /)! $% $ 2026 (O&M)
/)!-(#&)"%#5!!"+(',#!+#&)# +%<"!+5;%"!B) ;)*("=&-< !( ! % 1J1%$@117,' )8 )=!&)"', -!&(0,>! ()-( 6%$#&!1IF/#%" 1 @ ,!+,"+! !/#(%"6#&! !%$ F <) ')!+ 5; !'%"+!"# % <))!!+)##&! )#!%$ FD !+ $% #&! )= (/,0#, )0 ', '%! (#()#!+)##&!("#)"/!%$#&!'!#(#(% ( !'!/#(.!/0)(*$% !"&)"/!*! 1IF/#-(!#%,#&! !,"+!
"! "! "! "! 0)"+%<"! &! !(" 0)"+%<"! &! !(" 0)"+%<"! &! !(" 0)"+%<"! &! !(" B) B) B) B) %/!!+("= %/!!+("= %/!!+("= %/!!+("= )#!78 )#!78 )#!78 )#!78 %#($(/)#(%" 1 %#($(/)#(%" 11 @J 5(# )#(%" /)! 5!) ("= % 16%$@1D+!/(+!+5;#&! ) "!+ 5(# )#% <&(0! ) +("= *) >!# .)0,! )# #&! #!%$ 61-@3'! *) 0) 6 11 00%<!+ 54!/#(%" ,"+! /#(%" 6 %$ #&! 1IF /# !$! !+5; !'%"+!"#% 1 5!$% !#&!%, #%$ ++(#(%")0 (# (/# ,+=!- 0)"+&) - <&(0! !##("= )(+! ! <) + )"+ !*)"+("= #&! !5)/>#%0!) "!+ 5(# )#% $ !&+!/((%" 16 @
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
*) 0) 7 5(# )#(%")!3% 36IF3@1 6 !(") )"#(" !",! #($(!+ +)#!+ 6 ; #&! &(/& $ #&! &-(" /#(%" = 1 + = $ $ ! /#
"# ! )0 - ! $ 0) % MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
@D @1 @ $#! !*) 5( @D @1 #&! ) #&! )*! ', ' %$0) 9J 1: %* <&%! 0)"+ <) /%*'!")#(%")# B) ;)*("=&& #&%,=&$% #&!) 0)"+%<"! )=)( $ %* #&! )*! +(/ (*(")#(%") %%#%$%"#(#,# !A,)0(#;5!$% !0) 9D: % @1I 7 (("= % @1I 7 (("= % @1I 7 (("= % @1I 7 (("= % ) !*("=&H ) !*("=&H ) !*("=&H ) !*("=&H 2026 (O&M)
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
78 % III @ = %,# %$
78 % III @ = %,# %$
78 % III @ = %,# %$
78 % III @ !.!"<!"#%"#%&%0+#&)#(*(0)
% /&)00!"=! #% #&! )$% !)(+ +!/((%" +)#!+ 16 @ @6 <) *)+! 5; !'%"+!"#% 12 @6 ?!/,#(%" ''0(/)#(%" 5!) ("= ND@1 +('%!+ %$ 5!("= )#($(!+ 5; #&! 0!) "!+ ++(#(%")0 (# (/# ,+=!- )0)"+&) - <&(0! !0!)("=#&!)*%,"# %$ /%*'!")#(%" O 1--@@@3'! *) 0) &)# #&! '!#(#(%"! 0)"+%<"! &! ! "%#($(/)#(%" &) 5!!" )<) +!+ # ) 0)-<&! !)#&!(+!"#(/)00;'0)/ ##&! )#!%$ 1--@@@3'! *) + ,/&+($$! !"#()0# !)#*!"#)*% ', ,)"##%#&!)*!"%#($(/)#(%") ) 5(# ) ; )"+ )*%,"# #% &%#
") 5(# ) ;)/#(%"# (>!)##&!.! *)"+)#!%$ #(/0!1=,) )"#!!( %, #("(.(0''!)0% (.(0''!)0% (.(0''!)0% (.(0''!)0% J@F J@F J@F J@F @1I8- @1I8- @1I8- @1I8- #(#0!+ ) G
"(%" %$ "+() G
"(%" %$ "+() G
"(%" %$ "+() G
"(%" %$ "+() (0) 0;(#,)#!+0)"+%<"! /)""%# 7 ! + ;
" 1 + )0 -
"# ! !("- + #&! 0)/!+ *) 0) *%"=
")"+ %#(0! .!
; !!("= F F F F +() . +() . +() . +() . %#5! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
+!"(!+ ') (#; (" ,"+! #)>!","+! #%).%(++(/ (* ,"+! !/#(%" )''0; #% )/A,( /%"!A,!"#0; &! #(/0!1#%#&)# G1 " ! !-#&!0)"+% ( ! -#&!1IF/ &)!*'&)(Q!+ 4,#($(/)#(%" $% 0)"+%<"! <&%
"%#($(/)#(%"-#&! 9I: . &!0+ #&)# #&! 0)" ' %/!!+("="!!+ 2026 (O&M)
(" #&! *)##! %$ /%*'!")#(%" * ! )+($$! !"##)#,#% ; !=(*! (*(")#(%"-#&!%, #&!0+#&)##&! 6718- 678 )"+ D %$ #&! ,((#(%" ,"+! #&! )#(%")0 (= &!0+ !/#(%" 6 %$ #&! )#(%")0 &)#!?#!"# !0!.)"#!?/! '#( !' 1 PP B! #&! !$% ! +!/0) ! /A,((#(%"/# !0)#("=#%%0)# 6718)"+78)"+("#! !#'); <(00)''0;#%)/A,((#(%"*)+! %"!A,!"#0;-#&!' %.((%"%$ %$ #(/0!1%$#&!%"#(#,#(%" 5!,"/%"#(#,#(%")0 //% +("=0;
(+(*(!+P H " #&! ' !!"# /)!- #&! *)##! ! %$5%#&#&!0)"+%<"! <))/A, /#-', ,)"##%#&!)*!)/A,((# !+') (#;!.!")/ %+($$! !"##) $% )<) +("= +($$! !"#()0 /%*' &%! 0)"+ <! ! )/A,( !+ ,"+ &!)*!")#, !)"+!.!"#&!)*! .!"%#&! <(!-#&!%"K50!'!?
0)"+%<"! <&%! 0)"+ ) ! )/A !!+#%5!)<) +!+(*(0) )*%,"#%
" *! !0; 5!/),! #&! )/A,((#(%" "% +! #%*)("#)("#&!') (#;) #&!5!"!$(#%$%0)#(,*)"+("#! )"+ /A,((#(%" /#- 1DI <%, (=&<); /#- 1IF ) <!00- ) )0 (=&<); /# #% 5! .(%0)#(.! !' %+,/!+&! !,"+! ! #&)# #&! ' %.((%" %$ #&! ) %0)#(,*)"+("#! !#/%"#)("!+("!/#( ');)50!("#! *%$!/#(%"D' %. )+!,"+! #&!)#(%")0(=&<); %$!/#(%"6(-#%#&(!?#!"#-.(%0)#( ,#(%"%$"+())"+-#&! !$% !-+!/0) !+ ("=0;-''!)0O
78% III3@ !# %" )" !.!" # %"=! '!+!# /A,( !+,"+! #&!.! ;)*!#)#, ((#(%"' %/! "/!#&!'!?% #)#,#!-#&! !/)"5!"%/%"/!(.)5 *'!")#(%" #% (+!"#(/)00; (#,)#
"+! #&! )*! #)#,#!- #&! )* ! !.!",!!#)#! '!?%, #("/)#!")%$4,+=*!"#& /A,( !+ ,"+! #&! )*! )/A,((#(
"#%$/%*'!")#(%" 8 %" ( ;)"+ #! !# %,0+ - )"+ .! %$ )"+ !/#(%" %.(% /# %0)#(.! ) !+#% I3@1I !#)0 )#,#!- %, # .)50! ,)#!+ )*! #&) (#(%" MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
9I 1: 0 7 (("=$ %* 7 (("=$ %* 7 (("=$ %* 7 (("=$ %* "+()H "+()H "+()H "+()H&!0+)," G B! F 9I : " 7 (("=%,#%$ 7 (("=%,#%$ 7 (("=%,#%$ 7 (("=%,#%$ #)#!%$ ##)
) #)#!%$ ##)
) #)#!%$ ##)
) #)#!%$ ##)
) )/A )/A #&! ', () #&! #&! $, #&! !#/ 2026 (O&M)
0%-#&!%"K50!,' !*!%, #
R% 1@D%$@18-
R% 1@D%$@18-
R% 1@D%$@18-
R% 1@D%$@18-#(#0!+) ,"+! B! *); "%#&).!)";A,) !0 <(#& !=) + #% #&! $)/#,)0 '%(#(%" #& /0)(*)"#&).! !/!(.!++($$! !"#) #&)# #%% (" !'!/# %$ #&! 0)"+ %
"%#($(/)#(%")"+)/A,( !+$% #&!) )00#&!!#!/&"(/)0(#(!&%,0+=(.! <&(/&/)"#(005!/, !+ B!+%" + (.!" #% ,/& #!' &).("= !=) !$! !+#%)5%.! &! !$% !-<!) !%$#&!.(!<#&)# +%("=/%*'0!#!4,#(/!-<!&%0+# #&! 5!"!$(# %$ #&! 4,+=*!"# %$ #& (.(0''!)0% 1@@%$@@ H " )"%#&! /)! 5!) ("= (.(0 (.(0 ' (.(0 (.(0 ' %$
% 6 %$
% 6 %$
% 6 %$
% 66 @1J8 6 @1J8 6 @1J8 6 @1J8
)+!&)"+ H
)+!&)"+ H
)+!&)"+ H
)+!&)"+ H-#&!%"K50!' G# ( #% 5! >!'# (" *("+ #& )/A,((#(%" %$ 0)"+ 5; #&! %.! "* )/A,( !+) !"%#<(00("=') #(! #< #&!( 0)"+ &!;<! !/%*'!00!+#%= ', '%! % #&(', '%!-#&!/%"(+ ()0%"%#%$#&!( /&%(/! "#&!/%" #&! )#!)#<&(/&/%*'!")#(%"&%,0 #&!( 0)"+ ( +!#! *("!+ 5; #&! ) $, #&! ' %.(+!#&)#&(+!#! *(")#(% #&!$% *%$ !$! !"/!#%#&!(# (/# !#/ " % +! #% !", ! #&)# #&! , #("(.(0''!)0% 6@6%$@ (.(0''!)0% 6@6%$@ (.(0''!)0% 6@6%$@ (.(0''!)0% 6@6%$@ !+)G ,5 )*)"()".
"(%" ,5 )*)"()".
"(%" ,5 )*)"()".
"(%" ,5 )*)"()".
"(%" (#&#&!0!=)0'%(#(%" %<!.! - &).(
" #&)# (" ) 0)"+ )/A,((#(%" /)! #
"#)*%,"#5;<);%$/%*'!")#(%") %$ )*! ")#, ! /%.! !+ 5; #&! )* !)*!', '%!-<!) !%$#&!.(!<#& =(.!<);("/!#&!;) !' %/!+, )0) %"%##&(">#&)##&!)''!00)"#&%,0+ !=) + #% #&! $)/#,)0 '%(#(%" <! &) &)##&!0(&%,0+5!=(.!")A,(!#, 0+#&)##&!)''!00)"#&)005!!"#(#0!+ $ #&( /%, # +)#!+ @D 11 @@ ')!+ 0 ''!)0 % 0 ''!)0 % 0 ''!)0 % 0 ''!)0 % 1@I 1@I 1@I 1@I1@6@ %$ @ 1@6@ %$ @ 1@6@ %$ @ 1@6@ %$ @ 1J8 1J8 1J8 1J8#(#0!+)G) !"+! )"+ . ) !"+! )"+ . ) !"+! )"+ . ) !"+!
)"+ . '!?%, #%5! .!+),"+! + #&)# (" #&! *)##! %$ /%*',0%
"*!"#- #&! .(00)=! <&%! 0)"+ =!# #<)"%##&!( .%0,"#) ;)/##%!00% #%=(.!#&!0)"+#%#&!#)#!$% ',50(
"(+! )#(%"<&(/&(#%5!')(+#%#&!* /%"# ) ;-)'! #&!/&!*!%$#&!/ %,0+5!')(+#%#&!'! %"+(.!#!+% )"+ /A,((#(%" %00!/#% /&!*
")#(%"(,54!/##%4,+(/()0/ ,#(";( (/#,+=!)"+)''!)0#%#&!(=&%, #&! 0)"+ %<"! ) ! =(.!" ' %'! 9 $@1J $@1J $@1J $@1J (%"%$ (%"%$ (%"%$ (%"%$ &).("= ! #&! %")"+ )*! <#&)# )0)"+ ,0+5! &).! , % #0!+#% !+ (" @1J @1J @1J @1J . . . . 0% ; =!# !00%$ ,50(/ #&!* /#- !+%$ &!*!
";(" %, # %'! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
/%* /%* #)> #&! <% '! )+% /)" 9I 6: " ,#&% (#; . ) ,#&% (#; . ) ,#&% (#; . ) ,#&% (#; . ) ,' !*!%, # ,"+! GGGG 91@: , &))")0#! ")#(. )"+ %"/(0()#(%" 2026 (O&M)
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
"!< !.(!+ )#!%$ @6'! A ; ;#&! !'%"+!"##&)##&!'!#(#(%" ,"+! !/#(%"6%$#&! 5(# )#( !!"# < (# '!#(#(%" ( #&! !$% ! " 10 )$)( <) /() ; % % %#&! %"! *!"# '*!"# '*!"# '*!"# '*!"#
"K50! 0+) !%,#) $ 4,# %"# %0 )"!%, 0%<("= ,#(/! 0%<("= (/0!1 '0)/!+ )#(%" A ;+ #(%"! )#(%" ! "%# MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
*)("#)(")50!- +% )>!!*K/)!-
") %<0;/( /,* )<) +-"%##%*% 5!!" 0(#(=)#("= $ <&(0! (*(0) 0; )/A,((#(%"-&).! 6 11 @@ " !/#(%" 6 <%, !*)"+("=#&!* ' %# )/#!+ /;/0! <%,0+%"0;/%* 4,#(/! +!0);!+ ( State Exchequer/N [10.1]. Furth and Others, (198 ordinarily it is tru exercise of jurisdi has an effective, stated that the rul of convenience an the jurisdiction of [10.2] In th Income Tax and 2026 (O&M)
+%! "%# *! (# )//!'#)"/! " . -(#(<!00!##0!+#&)##&!/%'!% ,*/ (5!+-)"+#&!%, #(!*'% *%+($;#&!)*! I#('! #("!"##%* = $% "!) 0; #<% +!/)+! (" ', , 0; (#,)#!+ 0)"+%<"! %$ #&! ).!)0 !)+;5!!"= )"#!+!"&)"/!
" ,/& ) /!") (%- !0!=)#("= #&! %,0+- )# 5!#- !,0# (" !##("= *)##! $% $ !&)+4,+(/)#(%"-#&! /0! %$ ' %/!!+("=- <&(/& &! &) %*'%,"+#&!+!0);)"++!$!)##&! + ( 4,#(/! +!"(!+. Further, it wou quer/NHAI of undue interest liability Further, in the case of Ram and Shya (1985) 3 S.C.C. 267, the Hon’ble t is true that the court has imposed a r jurisdiction under Article 226 where t ctive, adequate alternative remedy. M the rule which requires the exhaustion nce and discretion rather than rule of tion of the Court. In the same regard, reliance is also and Others v. Chhabil Dass Aga
.(!< %$ #&! 0)< 0)(+ +%<" (" !%$("#! $! !"/!,"+! !/#(%"6 '%<! !+%"0;#%!#)(+!)") 5(# #%*!"#(%"&! !#&)##&!'!#(#(%"! & ,(# %$ 4,# )"+ $)( /%*'!")#(% #&! )*! .(00)=!- ,"+! (+!"#( /!+/%*'!")#(%".(+!)<) ++)# #&! '!#(#(%"! #% #&! !*!+; ,"+
"= )(+! #&! (*',="!+ )<) + ) #&! !5;,54!/#("=&(*#%;!#)"%#& &) )0 !)+; !"+, !+ ,/& ) /%, #&!!"+%$4,#(/!-$% (#(# (#!#& it would even unnecessary burden th bility. Shyam Company v. State of Haryan on’ble Supreme Court laid down th sed a restraint in its own wisdom on i here the party invoking the jurisdictio edy. More often, it has been express austion of alternative remedies is a ru ule of law. At any rate, it does not ou is also placed upon Commissioner o Agarwal, (2014) 1 S.C.C. 603, th 11
" 6( 5(# )0 ! &) )#(%"-
"#(/)0 +)#!+ ,"+! )"+ %#&! %, ! !#&)# rden the ryana that m on its sdiction xpressly is a rule not oust ner of , the MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
Hon’ble Supreme exceptions to the G7(8 *! 7((8B %$!" 7(((8 ' (" 7(.8 !'! 7.8 ' ("
91@ 6: " "+()H "+()H "+()H "+()H !'% #!+) #% !0!=)#! #&! /%*'!")#(%" (" !"&)"/!+)"+&) (#< (#4, (+(/#( <&(/&<%,0+%"0 G1 2026 (O&M)
upreme Court spelt out at least five to the rule of exhaustion of remedies a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
st five illustrative and non-exhaustiv dies as follows:-
"+! #)#,#! ( "%# !$$!/#(.! 5,# %" ()0 !0(!$E% #)/#!+(")//% +)"/!<(#&' %.((% )/#!+ (" +!$()"/! %$ $,"+)*!" % E % #!+#%(".%>!' %.((%"<&(/&) ')!+ )" % +! (" #%#)0 .(%0)#(%" (%, #("G( ("=&.
"(%" ( ("=&.
"(%" ( ("=&.
"(%" ( ("=&.
"(%" )(*(0) $)/#,)05)/>+ %'-+!/0(" /! )>("= "%#! %$ #&! $)/# #& )#!+ 0)"+%<"! &)+ )0 !)+; 5! +!!*!+(#)'' %' ()#!-("!?! /(! # )#&! #&)"/%*'!0)$ !& !$! !" #!?/! '#( !' %+,/!+&! !(","+! !"#-<!+!!*(#)'' %' ()#!#%!#)( 0%.! "*!"#+!/0("("=#&! !$! !"/! )*%,"#%$/%*'!")#(%" ,#("/!# 0)"+ %<"! &) )##)("!+ $(")0(#;- # $ )" 5(# )#% <(00 %"0; +!0); # %$ /%*'!")#(%" )"+ /),! ,""!/!) ' !!"# < (# '!#(#(%" )"+ +( !/# # )#(%"#%#&!0)"+%<"! ("#! *%$# !+(" !'!/#%$#&!%#&! 0)"+%<"! 12 haustive # %"0; ((%" *!"#)0 (/&) ! (%" %$ (%"%$ (%"%$ (%"%$ (%"%$ 0("!+ # #&)# 5!!" (!%$ !"/! +! #)(+!
"/!#% /!#&! #;- #&! ; #&! !) ; /# #&! %$#&! ! H MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
[10.4]. In t identically placed thereby offending remedy under Sec is confined only Accordingly, in writ jurisdiction u clearly justified petitioner is grant 911: 0 ) 5(# )0 )<) + ,"+%,5#!+0;0(* ) 5(# )#(%" ' %/! 0)##! /%"#!*'0) )''%("#!+5;#&! ,"+! !/#(%"1@ ' (*) (0; $%,"+! ,/& ) 5(# )#% '! /!(.!+ ("#(#, ,0!+%,# ",/ F3J %$ #&! ,'! .(% ;/ , , #&! *% !- * %, #' !(+!+% ,(0+!
.# #+ ,(0+!
.# #+ ,(0+!
.# #+ ,(0+!
.# #+ 2026 (O&M)
In the present case, the learned A placed landowners, has acted arbitra ending the fundamental principles o er Section 34 would not afford any ef only to setting aside the award y, in the peculiar facts and circumsta ction under Article 226 of the Constit tified to remedy the manifest arbit s granted just and equitable compensat 0#&%,=&#&!/%'!%$("#! $! !"/! !"+! !+ ,"+! #&! 5(# )#(% (*(#!+-#&!)*!' ("/('0!/)""%# %/!!+("= /%"+,/#!+ ,"+! #&! '0)#! ) $% * %$ #)#,#% ; ) 5(# #&!!"# )0%.! "*!"#-,"0(>!/% 1@)"+11%$1IIF/#<&! !#&
"+!+ ,'%" #&! ') #; ),#%"%*; %$ ) ! )''%("#!+ 5; #&! !"# )0 #(#,#(%")0 5() % 0)/> %$ /%*'0!# ,/&/( /,*#)"/!-)< (#/%, #!? ! %"#(#,#(%" %$ "+() *); 5! ,#(";#%!", !4,#(/!-$)( "!- *%# !/!"#0;- ) 6 ,+=!! +%.! 5;%"K50!#&!&(!$,#(/ #+2" .
"(%"%$"+()2 #+2" .
"(%"%$"+()2 #+2" .
"(%"%$"+()2 #+2" .
"(%"%$"+()2
rned Arbitrator, by denying parity arbitrarily and in breach of Article ples of fair procedure. Moreover, th any effective or substantive relief, as ward without power of modificatio umstances of the case, the exercise o onstitution, being plenary in nature, arbitrariness and to ensure that th pensation. /!,"+! #&!< (#4, (+(/#(%")=)( #(%" )"+ %"/(0()#(%" /#- 1IIF
"%#5!)''0(!+<(#&!A,)0 (=(+(#;
)#(%")0 (=&<); /#- 1IF 5(# )#(%"- <&! !(" #&! 5(# )#% /%"!",)0) 5(# )#(%"/%"#!*'0)# #&!)''%("#*!"#%$#&!) 5(# )#% %$ #&! +(',#)"# 0%- =(.!" #& )0 ),#&% (#; (#!0$- #&! '%(5(0(#; 0!#! "!,# )0(#; /)""%# 5! )0#%=!#& !?! /(("=4, (+(/#(%","+! #(/ 5! 4,#($(!+ (" !?! /(("= ) 5 %)+ -') (#;#%#&!)== (!.!+0)"+%<" !"/& %$ #&! %"K50! ,' !* #(/!%$"+()("#&!/)!%$3 3 3 3 !'% #!+)@F (.! )<7 @F (.! )<7 @F (.! )<7 @F (.!
)<7 13 arity to ticle 14, ver, the ief, as it fication. rcise of ature, is that the )("# IF ( (#;#% &! #% ( 0)#!+ #% ( #&)# (#; %$ !#&! #(/0! %)+! <"! !*! () () () () 78 78 78 78 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
F F F F <&(0! ,= /%*'!")#(%"* G F J 2026 (O&M)
,==!#("= !)")0;( %$ #&! 0! *!/&)"(*$% 0)"+)/A,((#(%"% +.! #("=#%#&!*)("/)!-(#&) &!) ("= #&)# ,"+! #&! 1IF !?' %' ()#!+0)"+%<"! 3("#! !#!+ #&! )#!%$/%*'!")#(%"+!#! *(" (".%>!) 5(# )#(%","+! !/#(%"6 /# ,/& )" ) 5(# )#(%" '!#(#(%" ),#&% (#; 5,# 5; )" %$$(/! "%# ".) ()50;- #&! %00!/#% % (# (/#3(.((%") !"%#($(!+#% =!"! )00; ' !%//,'(!+ <(#& !'%"(5(0(#(!)"+#&!;)0%+%" 4,+(/()00; # )("!+ *("+ #% )+4 +!#! *(")#(%"%$*) >!#.)0,!%$# <&(/&#&!)$$!/#!+') #(!) !"%< #&(%, #
"(%"%$"+()2)"%#&! 6@- ) <!00 ) #&! ,5 ) 0()*!"#("#&!1IF/# %#%"0;#&(-#&!$, #&! !/%, !0 %<"! % )";%#&! ("#! !#!+') #; %$#&!1IIF/#-$%00%<!+5;)$, 1IIF /# 5!$% ! #&! (=& %, # /%'! %$ ("#! $! ("= <(#& )" ) 5( ', '% #!+!?! /(!%$(#'%<! , /#-)#&!/)!*);5!-&)5!!"< %$4,+=*!"# %"# ) (0;- #&! !?' %' ()#!+ 0)"+ 0)"+<! !!) 0(! 5!("=)/A,( !+, 7(" &% #- #&! T 0+ /#T8- <! ! ! #& %,=& ) !$! !"/! ,"+! !/#( !$! !"/! <! ! +!/(+!+ %"0; 5; !(+("= $$(/! (" #&! )"> %
0!=(0)#(.! /&!*! $% ') (#;
"%5! .!+),"+! &)# )"'( !++, ("=#&!/%, !%$# F /#- #&! !*!+; ' %.(+!+ #% #!+') #;-($,/&'! %"()== (!.!+ *("!+5;#&!/%*'!#!"#,#&% (#;-(
"678 !)+<(#&' %.((%"%$#&!1I (#(%" ( )+4,+(/)#!+ "%# 5; ) 4,+(/
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
"*!"# .!",! !
) ! # )#(.! !%$) 0(>! !$(##% (%"%$ @1I8I ; #&! +0)"+ (%"6 %$#&! (*(#!+ ,* (" 1IIF /)#!") <&%! #-1DI !*!"# ,/& ("= ) (# (/# MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
D I 1@ 11 91: #&! '!#(#(%"! 0)" &,- 4,+(/()0 2026 (O&M)
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
"%#&)*'! !+% +!0);!+ &%,=& ' (*)$)/(!-(#!!*#&)##&(%54! #&!0)"+%<"! #&)##&!;<(005!!" $% #&!)/A,( !+0)"+("#&!)*!* %<"! <&%!0)"+) !)/A,( !+, /#-!.!"<&!",/&)/A,((#(%"( !!'("=#&!!$)/#% (".(!<-<!( "+()&%,0+ !.((##&!0!=(0)#(.! %$ 5 ("=("= ') (#; (" #&! *)##! +!#! *(")#(%" %$ #&! *) >!# .)0,! #(/0!6@@%$#&!%"#(#,#(%"%$ ,/&-("#&!'!/,0() $)/#)"+ 0)"+%<"! &) 5!!" 0!$# <(#& "% 0 !.(!< /%"$! !+ ,'%" #&(
!*!+; %$ $( # )''!)0 5!$% ! #&! ( %, #&)+#&!'%<! #% !)'' !/()#!) &!"$% *)"%'("(%" ! *) >!#.)0,! ' ()#!+0)"+%<"! )"+%#&! ("#! !#
"!+ 5; #&! = )"# %$ )++(#(%")0 #)#,#% %*'!")#(%","+! #&!' %.((%"%$# )"+ )"') !"/; (" )"+ /A,((#(% #/#-@167("&% #-#&!T!</#T8
"+%<"! -<&%!0)"+()/A,( !+,"+ +%<"! <&%!0)"+) !)/A,( !+"%
"# !)#!+)!') )#!/0)!-)'') !"
"#() &(0!)+#%= ).!&!) #5, ")*% )#!=% ;- ")*!0;- #&%! <&%! 0)"+ ) $0!=(0)#(.!<(+%*+(/! "(50!$ %*# #&! 1IF /#- #% #&! !$$!/# #&)# # ,# #)>! '0)/! (" ) #(*!5%,"+ ) !+!.!0%'*!"#%$)#(%")0(=&<); ,=&,/&)0!=(0)#(.!'%0(/;(0),+)5 %54!/#/)"5!>!'#("#)/#<&(0!!", ( !!"#(#0!+#%)!*!"#%$/%*'!")#( *!*)""! )(+!#! *("!+$% #&!0) !+,"+! #&! 0+/#% ,"+! #&!
"()0%$% ("$ )# ,/#, )0+!.!0%'*! <!(*'0% !)"+,==!##&)##&!
"(%" #(.!/&!*!)"+/%"(+! #&!+!( )5(0 ##! %$ ' %.(+("= ) *!/&)"(* $% # )0,! %$ )/A,( !+ 0)"+ <(#& !$! !"/!
"%$"+() H
"+/( /,*#)"/!%$#&!' !!"#/)
"% !$$(/)/(%, !*!+; )# #&( #) %, # ,"+! #(/0! F %$ # 15 (=& #!)"+ 0,!%$ !#!+ #,#% ; %$#&! ((#(%"- #T8 ,"+! +"%< ) !"#0; )*%"= + ) ! %*#&! )# #&! + )"+ );( +)50!- , ("= )#(%" !0)"+ !!< *!"# (%"%$ )5(0(#; % #&!
"/! #% /)!- )=! $ #&! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.4021 of 202
%"#(#,#(%"%$ #&!') #(!)"+) *!#!+%,# 916: " .( ,""!/!) ;&) + %, # /%"(+! ')!+ 5; #&! 0! !"#(#0!+ #% /%*' /%"!A,!"#()0 # !"+! !+("B) ;
B) ;
B) ;
B) ; 91: B( !"+("=)''0(/)# ) /& ) /& ) /& ) /&6 6 6 6-@ -@ -@ -@FFFF #(> B&! B&! 2026 (O&M)
$"+()-"!!+#%5!(".%>!+("% + +)0%#%).%(+#&!+(/ (*(")#(%" .(!< %$ #&! )$% !)(+- )"+ (" % ) +&('#&)#<%,0+!",!$ %*) (# 4,# )"+ )'' %' ()#! #% !# ) 0!) "!+ 5(# )#% //% +("=0;- *'!")#(%" )# #&! )#! %$ ₹1- #)#,#% ; 5!"!$(#- (" ') (#; < ) ;)*( ) ;)*( ) ;)*( ) ;)*("=&K/)!7,' )8
"=&K/)!7,' )8
"=&K/)!7,' )8
"=&K/)!7,' )8 B(#&#&!)$% !)(+%5! .)#(%"-#& /)#(%"78-($)";&)00#)"++('%! &!#&! '!)>("=3 !)%"!+ !3 &!#&! !'% #)50! !3
% +! #%+%/%*'0!#!4,#(/!5!#<!
"<(#&<&(/&#&!'!#(#(%"! &)5! % +! #% %5.()#! $, #&! +!0); ) ) !*)"+$% $ !&)+4,+(/)#(%"-# # )(+! #&! )<) + +)#!+ @D @1 @ 0;- #&! '!#(#(%"! 0)"+%<"! ( &! --@@@3 '! *) 0)- )0%"= <(#& <(#& #&! )<) + +)#!+ 6 11 @ -#&!' !!"#< (#'!#(#(%"()00%< %!+%$ 7 8 7 8 7 8 7 8 !3% !3% 16 <!!" 5!!" )"+ -#&( @ &!0+ #& )00 @@ <!+ MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 15:36 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment