- 1 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:11751 WP No. 5811 of 2026 !"# $ ! " $ ! # $ # Digitally signed by RAKESH S HARIHAR Location: High Court of Karnataka, Dharwad Bench - 2 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:11751 WP No. 5811 of 2026 % $ # & ' $() $$ $$% * + &$$ ! ' ' ! ! &#$$) , , -' - 3 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:11751 WP No. 5811 of 2026 ./0 123/3/45 /0 67 3.2 508929 :.4 /0 ;<==2> 8145 34 <50:29 < ;=</? 85>29 2;3/45 4@ 3.2 4349 !2./;=20 ;3 (( A@49 0.493 B /5 3.2 ;=</?123/3/45/5! 4&#$$)453.2@/=24@3.2 >>/3/45<= 25/49 /C/='8>D2<5>' 85089A@49 0.493 - -B .2 ;=</?<53 .<0 @/=2> <5 <11=/;<3/45 85>29 2;3/45 4@ 3.2 /?/3<3/45 ;3 )@49;45>45<3/454@3.2>2=<7/5@/=/5D3.2;=</? 123/3/45.29/685<=673.2/?18D52>49>29><32> &$$ .<0 <==4:2> 3.2 <11=/;<3/45 @/=2> 67 3.2 ;=</?<53 .2 E8203/45, :.23.29 < 62=<32> ;=</? 123/3/45 ;48=> 62 253293</52> ;45>45/5D 3.2 >2=<7 85>29 2;3/454@3.2/?/3<3/45 ;3)/0125>/5D:/3. 3.2 12F 4893 /5 40(&$(&)#$$) <5> 0/?/=<9?<33290/53.2:9/3123/3/45/5A /C/=B4 #$$& <5> ;4552;32> ?<33290 3 92?</50 85>/01832>3.<33.2 12F 489367/30/5329/?49>29 - 4 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:11751 WP No. 5811 of 2026 ><32>$$$.<046029C2>3.<33.2125>25;74@ 3.2 :9/3 123/3/450#012;/<= =2<C2 123/3/450 62@492 /3 0.<==543;4?2/53.2:<74@3.2;=</?123/3/45062/5D <>G8>/;<32>673.29/685<=0683:/3.3.203/18=<3/45 3.<3G8>D?25300.<==54362@/5<=/H2> ./0 4893 /0 4@ 3.2 ;450/>292> C/2: 3.<3 :/3. 3.2 <@49203/18=<3/45 3./0 123/3/45 ?803 62 >/01402> 4@46029C/5D3.<33.29/685<=-0/?18D52>49>29:/== 62 086G2;3 34 3.2 483;4?2 /5 3.2 125>/5D ?<33290 62@492 3.2 12F 4893 /3. 3./0 <99<5D2?253 3.2 /5E8/97 /534 3.2 ?29/30 4@ 3.2 ;=</? 123/3/45 :/== ;453/582 683 3.2 9/685<= :/== 92@9</5 @94? 1945485;/5D /30 G8>D?253 <5> <:<9> 04 3.<3 3.2 >2;/0/45453.2?29/34@3.2;=</?123/3/4543.29:/02 :/== 62 086G2;3 34 3.2 12F 4893I0 >2;/0/45 45 3.2 <@492E8203/45 - 5 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:11751 WP No. 5811 of 2026 .2123/3/4503<5>0>/01402>4@<;;49>/5D=7 ># !# ! /034,& =4,

THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO. v. K. C. MAHADEVA

Judgment text