Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9975 (KAR)
BHEEM REDDY AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200061/2020 · 2025-02-03
Rajesh Rai K
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9975 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9975 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"##
"$$ %&%'$()&
%( *
!" #$% &
' (
)
) #$$%* '
#$% & ' (
)
* '(
)
%%% %%%
+,%,
)
))
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* $% %* - . )
)
)
-
/
#"
'
/(
0123445361271859:573;31<2::05=>7;?5<:+@9+<A19:1+< 73:57 %%% 3<7 +8758 +@ 25<:5<95 73:57 %%% 4322571<+,%,BC:05 81<91436 12:819:<75221+<2 >7;53190>8D0585BC:056538<575221+<2>7;59+<A19:57 :05 3445663<:2399>257 +2 3<7 @+8 :05 +@@5<952 4><1203B65><75859:1+<2*$% 3<7%*8D59:1+<.+@ 3<725<:5<957:05?:+><758;+ 81;+8+>21?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@$C53823<7:+43C3@1<5 +@ 2$%%%E 5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :+ ><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@,?+<:02@+8:05 +@@5<954><1203B65><75859:1+<%*8D59:1+<.+@ F @>8:058 :05 399>257 385 25<:5<957 :+ ><758;+ 81;+8+>2 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7 +@ C538 3<7 :+ 43C @1<5 +@ 2%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:+@43C?5<:+@@1<5:+><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7 +@ ?+<:0 @+8 :05 +@@5<95
- 3 -
4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< 8D 59:1+< . +@ F :05 399>257385@>8:05825<:5<957:+><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<: @+834581+7+@21G?+<:023<7:+43C3@1<5+@2%%%E5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :+ ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@$73C2@+8:05+@@5<954><1203B65 ><75859:1+<8D59:1+<.+@ F@>8:058399>257385 25<:5<957 :+ 43C 3 @1<5 +@ 2%%%E 5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<:+@@1<5:+><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7 +@ % 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< 8D 59:1+<.+@ F@>8:058399>25738525<:5<957:+43C3@1<5 +@ 2%%%E 5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :+ ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7 +@ % 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<954><1203B65><75859:1+<8D59:1+<.+@ F @>8:058399>25738525<:5<957:+43C3@1<5+@2%%%E5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :+ ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@$73C2@+8:05+@@5<954><1203B65 ><75859:1+<*8D59:1+<.+@ F@>8:058399>257385 25<:5<957:+><758;+81;+8+>21?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@ C538 3<7 :+ 43C 3 @1<5 +@ 2$%%%E 5390 3<7 1< 75@3>6: +@ 43C?5<:+@@1<5:+><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7 +@ $ 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< 8D 59:1+< . +@ 3<7 @>8:058 399>257 +2 3<7 385
- 4 -
25<:5<957 :+ ><758;+ 81;+8+>2 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7 +@ +<5C5383<7:+43C@1<5+@2%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:+@ 43C?5<:+@@1<5:+><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7 +@ $ 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< $% 8D 59:1+<.+@ :12@>8:05871859:57:03:366:052>B2:3<:1A5 25<:5<952203668><9+<9>885<:6C
05@39:>36?3:81G+@:0548+259>:1+<932512:03:
05 399>257 385 :05 9016785< +@ 9+?4631<3<:H2 43:58<36 ><96515+<53238577C15 -0563<75748+458:152+@ - 3<7 399>257 D585 39I>1857 BC :05 +A58<?5<: @+8 9+<2:8>9:1+< +@ >8363 73? 48+=59: 0585 D32 3 7124>:5 B5:D55< :05? 85;3871<; :05 344+8:1+<?5<: +@ :05 9+?45<23:1+< 3?+><: 85951A57 +?4631<:2 D585 6+7;57 3<7 93252 93?5 :+ B5 85;12:5857 3;31<2: 5390 +:058 05 399>257 B+85 3<1?+21:C 3;31<2: - 3<7 :0853:5<57 01? D1:0 7185 9+<25I>5<952 ;31<2: :012 B39J78+4 +< ,%.% 3: 3B+>:
%%%3?D05< -3<7012B8+:058+<5323A383=E -* D32?3<>81<;:05@15673<7@+66+D1<;:059+?465:1+<3<7D0165 85:>8<1<; :+ :0518 0>: 3: 3B+>: %% 4? :05 3445663<:2 3<7 :0855 +:0582 D585 @+><7 0+671<; 3G5 2:19J2 2:+<52 3<7 485A5<:57 -2 3<7 * BC A58B366C 3B>257 :05? )+66+D1<;
- 5 -
D0190 - D32 3223>6:57 +< 012 65@: 20+>6758 93>21<; 01?
;815A+>21<=>8C05853@:58:05C362+3223>6:57 -*D05<05 ?3755@@+8:2:+8529>5 -3:58:05399>257@657:0524+:
>B25I>5<:6C -2 3<7 * D585 37?1::57 3: +241:36 3190>83<7B3257+<:05 -:05:05<A121:57:05 +241:363<7859+8757:052:3:5?5<:+@ -32458G
< :052:85<;:0+@G 3<)93?5:+B585;12:58573;31<2::05 399>2571<81?5+%%@+8:053@+85?5<:1+<57+@@5<952 32 458 G . 05853@:58 - 9+<7>9:57 @>8:058 1<A52:1;3:1+<BC783D1<;24+:?303K383<7362+859+A5857:05 D534+<2>2571<:05981?515
2:+3<73@:58859+871<;
:05 2:3:5?5<:2 +@ :05 8565A3<: D1:<52252 3<7 +< +B:31<1<;
<5952238C 7+9>?5<:2 @8+? :05 9+<958<57 3>:0+81:152 - 6317:059038;52055:B5@+85:059+??1::36+>8:
@:58 9+??1::36 +@ :05 9325 B5@+85 :05 5221+<2 +>8::056538<575221+<2>7;5@83?57:059038;52@+8:05 3@+85?5<:1+<57+@@5<9523<7:0523?5D328537+A58A58B3:1? :+:05399>257+D5A58:05399>25775<157:059038;523<7 9631?57:+B5:8157
< +8758 :+ 48+A5 :05 9038;52 65A56657 3;31<2: :05 399>257 B5@+85 :05 5221+<2 +>8: :05 48+259>:1+< 1< :+:36
- 6 -
5G3?1<57D1:<5225232 -2:+?38J577+9>?5<:2 32G2 :+ 3<7175<:1@157%*?3:58136+B=59:232
2:+ *05399>257362+?38J577+9>?5<:232458G2 :+
$ < 322522?5<: +@+836 3<77+9>?5<:38C5A175<95 :055221+<2>7;59+<A19:57:053445663<:2399>257+2
"@+8:059038;5265A566573;31<2::05?3<725<:5<957:05? 322:3:572>483
, 03A5 05387 81 01A3<3<7 3::3<205::C :05 6538<57 9+><256 @+8 :05 3445663<:2 3<7 81 177361<; 3:16 :05 6538<57 771:1+<36 :3:5 >B619 8+259>:+8 @+8 :05 8524+<75<:E:3:5
* 05 481?38C 9+<:5<:1+< +@ :05 6538<57 9+><256 @+8 :05 3445663<:2 12 :03: :05 =>7;?5<: ><758 :012 344536 2>@@582 @8+?458A5821:C3<71665;361:C21<95:056538<575221+<2>7;5 032 @31657 :+ 34485913:5 :05 5A175<95 +< 859+87 1< 81;0:
4582459:1A552>B?1::57:03::055A175<95+@ -23<7* :051<=>8571<:01293252>@@582@8+?25A5851<@18?1:1523<7:05 5A175<95+@5C5D1:<5225215 -2$3<7,7+<+:9+88+B+83:5 D1:0:055A175<95+@ -23<7*:12@>8:0589+<:5<757:03:
:0585 12 3< 1<+871<3:5 7563C 1< 6+7;1<; :05 9+?4631<: D0190
- 7 -
2:5?2 7+>B: 1< :05 ;5<5212 +@ :05 48+259>:1+< 9325 5 9+<:5<757:03:+<458>236+@D+><7958:1@193:5EG $+@ - :0+>;075419:2;815A+>21<=>8152 :0548+259>:1+<032@31657:+ 46395 3<C E3C 854+8: :+ :03: 5@@59: )>8:058 -* 032 2>2:31<57 ?1<+8 1<=>8152 32 458 G *ED+><7 958:1@193:5 7?1::576C:0585D3237124>:5B5:D55<:05399>2574582+<2 3<7:059+?4631<3<:85;3871<;9+?45<23:1+<85951A57BC:05? @+863<739I>121:1+<:D32@>8:0583665;57:03::059+?4631<3<: 6+7;573@36259+?4631<:3;31<2::05?99+871<;6C+<:0525 ;8+><7205483C2:+366+D:05344536
:05 6538<57 771:1+<36 :3:5 >B619 8+259>:+8 2>B?1::57 :03: :05 6538<57 5221+<2 >7;5 032 ?5:19>6+>26C 5G3?1<57 :05 ?3:581362 +< 859+87 3<7 432257 3 D566 8532+<57 =>7;?5<: 3<7 <+ 5G954:1+< 93< B5 :3J5< @8+? :05 8532+<1<; +@ :05 6538<57 5221+<2 >7;5 5 2>B?1::57 :03: :05 5A175<95 +@ -2 3<7 * :05 1<=>857 D1:<52252 9+88+B+83:52 D1:0 :05 D+><7 958:1@193:52 G2 $ 3<7 * 852459:1A56C3<7362+:+:055A175<95+@ -.:05 +9:+8D0+ :853:57 :05? 5 @>8:058 2>B?1::57 :03: :05 5A175<95 +@ :05 5C5D1:<52252 -2$ 3<7 , 9+88+B+83:52 D1:0 :05 5A175<95 +@ -2 3<7 * < 2>90 9189>?2:3<952 :05 48+259>:1+< 032
- 8 -
48+A57 :05 9038;52 65A5657 3;31<2: :05 3445663<:2399>257 B5C+<78532+<3B657+>B:23<7:056538<575221+<2>7;5032 81;0:6C9+<A19:57:053445663<:2399>25722>90052>B?1::57 :03:1<:58@585<95+@:012+>8:7+52<+:9366@+81<:051?4>;<57 =>7;?5<:3<7483C2:+712?122:05344536
.
3A1<; 05387 :05 6538<57 9+><256 @+8 :05 438:152 3<7 362+ +< 458>21<; :05 5A175<95 3<7 7+9>?5<:2 ?375 3A3163B65 B5@+85 ?5 :05 2+65 4+1<: :03: 38125 @+8 ?C 9+<217583:1+<12
! "
!#!$!%#!## #!&'! #'$ !()*+,
% :9+>67B5;3:05857@8+?:05859+872:+48+A5:05 9038;52 65A56657 3;31<2: :05 3445663<:2399>257 :05 48+259>:1+<4857+?1<3<:6C856157+<:055A175<95+@ -:05 1<=>857 9+?4631<3<: 3<7 -* 3<+:058 1<=>857 1< :012 9325 +D5A58:0548+259>:1+<362+856157+<:055A175<95+@ -2$ 3<7,:055C5D1:<52252:+:051<9175<:
<9385@>6458>236+@ :05 5A175<95 +@ :0525 D1:<52252 - BC 851:583:1<; :05 9+<:5<:2 +@ 9+?4631<:EG 032 2:3:57 :03: :05 399>257 385
- 9 -
0129+>21<23<7:0585D3237124>:53?+<;:05?1<9+<<59:1+< D1:020381<;+@9+?45<23:1+<3?+><:;83<:57:+:05?BC:05 +A58<?5<: +< 39I>181<; :0518 63<7 2 2>90 +< :05 @3:5@>6 73:5:05399>2573223>6:5701?3<7 -*D1:0
:+ 99+871<; :+ - :05 399>257 + 3223>6:57 01? D1:0 3< 3G5 +< 012 65@: 20+>6758 3<7 :05853@:58 :05 399>257 + 3223>6:57012B8+:058 -*D1:032:19J3<72:+<505+:058 399>2579+6659:1A56C3223>6:57:05?50322:3:57:03: -2$ 3<7,D1:<52257:051<9175<:3<78529>57:05?012A5821+<+@ -D32851:583:57BC -*012B8+:05899+871<;:+:0525 D1:<52252 B+:0 +@ :05? D585 :3J5< :+ +A58<?5<:
+241:363190>83:3B+>:,%%4?3<763:58BC%%%4? :05 4+6195 3881A57 3: :05 +241:36 3<7 - 6+7;57 :05 9+?4631<: 05 1<9175<: D32 93>257 3: 3B+>: %% 4? 0+D5A58:05CB+:0A121:57:05+241:363:,%%4?3<7:05 4+6195 A121:57 :05 0+241:36 3: 3B+>: %%% 4? :05853@:58 3< ) D32 85;12:5857 0+>;0 :0585 D32 7563C 1< 6+7;1<; :05 9+?4631<:399+871<;:+:012D1:<52232B+:0:051<=>857D585 ><3B65 :+ A121: :05 4+6195 2:3:1+< 3<7 B3257 +< :05 :05 4+61953881A573::050+241:36:+859+87:052:3:5?5<:+@ - 22>90:057563C1<85;12:581<;:05)1293>257
- 10 -
055A175<95+@ -23<7*9+88+B+83:52D1:0:05 :52:1?+<C+@ -2$,3<7:051<7545<75<:5C5D1:<52252:+ :05932599+871<;:+:05?:05399>257+3223>6:57 - D1:03<3G53<7399>257+3223>6:57 -*D1:032:19J3<7 2:+<5 05 +:058 399>257 D0+ D585 48525<: 9+6659:1A56C 3223>6:57 -23<7*0+>;0:0575@5<9598+22E5G3?1<57 :0525 D1:<52252 3: 65<;:0 <+:01<; D+8:0D0165 56191:57 @8+? :05?:+7129387:0518:52:1?+<C
)>8:058 -.E +9:+85G3?1<57:051<=>857 -2 3<7 * +< ,%.% 3: 3B+>: ,$ 4? 3<7 122>57 D+><7 958:1@193:5EG2 $3<7*852459:1A56C<G $1:122:3:57:03:
:051<=>8C2>2:31<57BC -D32;815A+>21<<3:>85)>8:058 -. 362+ 851:583:57 :05 9+<:5<:2 +@ G2 $ 3<7 * 1< 012 5A175<95 < 2>90 9189>?2:3<952 :0585 12 <+ 8532+< :+ 712B5615A53<771298571::055A175<95+@ -23<7*3<7:05 5A175<95+@5C5D1:<52252 -2$,3<7
05 6538<57 5221+<2 >7;5 032 9+<A19:57 :05 3445663<:2399>257 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< %* +@ 856C1<; +< :05 5A175<95 +@ -.E +9:+8 3<7 362+ G2 $ 3<7 *
< 458>236 +@ :05 5A175<95 +@ -. 05 032 2:3:57 :03: 05 :853:57 -2 3<7 * 3<7 122>57 D+><7
- 11 -
958:1@193:52 32 458 G2 $ 3<7 * 99+871<; :+ 01?
:05 E3CD32:3J5<B>::0585D32<+@839:>855A58:056522:05 48+259>:1+< @31657 :+ 48+7>95 :05 E3C 854+8: +@ :05 1<=>857 B5@+85:055221+<2+>8:
05 6538<57 9+><256@+8 :05 3445663<:2 A505?5<:6C 9+<:5<757:03::0548+259>:1+<@31657:+48+7>95:05E3C3<7 93< 854+8: +@ :05 1<=>857 :+ 2>B2:3<:13:5 :05 1<=>8152 2>2:31<57BC -23<7*385;815A+>21<<3:>8505+41<1+< ;1A5<BC:05 +9:+812B3257+<:051<=>81523<7D534+<2>257 1<:05981?5+D5A580537?1::571<0125A175<95:03::0585 D32 <+ @839:>85 )>8:058 :05 48+259>:1+< 362+ @31657 :+ 48+A5 :03: :05 399>257 037 <51:058 1<:5<:1+< <+8 J<+D657;5 :+ 7+ 3D3C:0561@5+@ -23<7*32:05CD585:0518J1<
$ :05 5<:185 1<9175<: +99>8857 +>: +@ :05 B6>5 D05< 3 8+D 58>4:57 B5:D55< :05? +D1<; :+ 93::65 ;83K1<; 7?1::576C 3 7124>:5 12 45<71<; 1< 9+<<59:1+< D1:0 20381<; +@ 9+?45<23:1+< 85951A57 @8+? :05 +A58<?5<: < 2>909189>?2:3<952:05+@@5<954><1203B65><75859:1+<%* +@ 7+52<+:3::839:3;31<2::05399>257
- 12 -
, <9385@>6458>236+@5A175<95+@ -.E +9:+8D0+ :853:57 :05 1<=>857 2+ 362+ :05 9+<:5<:2 +@ G $ 3<7 * :05 D+><7958:1@193:523281;0:6C9+<:5<757BC:056538<579+><256 @+8 :05 3445663<:2 -. 032 2:3:57 :03: <+ @839:>85 D32 2>2:31<57BC -23<7*)>8:058E3C854+8:+@ -12 <+:463957BC:0548+259>:1+<1<:055A175<95+@ -.<2>90 9189>?2:3<95 :05 1A121+< 5<90 +@ :012 +>8: 1< :05 9325 +@
!12+@:05A15D:03:3:4383;8340+23<7 :012+>8:032056732><758
"" " - # $%& '(
)*+ ',-(! ./ 012)3 *4/5 3
"0
3 6 3 "
") 12)3 7 86(
0 6 6
3 6
0 0 9:6 3 / 9 ; < 3 7 0 12)
0 3 3 3"12) = 3 3 86/ > "3
- 13 -
3 3 3 > 3 3
03 3 3 " 3 3 > 6 3 3
''%'$
#'%'$ 4
7
3
3 "
0
#')
*?!& %@'A, '5?4032122>446157BC?5(
* <758 2>90 9189>?2:3<952 1< ?C 9+<2175857 A15D :05 48+259>:1+< 032 @31657 :+ 52:3B6120 :03: :05 1<=>857 037 2>2:31<57 ;815A+>2 1<=>8152 32 75@1<57 3<7 2:14>63:57 ><758 59:1+< % +@ )>8:058 :05 +E+871<3:5 5<90 +@ :012 +>8: 1< :05 9325 +@ .//
)0 )1 " 73:57 %%% 0567 :03: D05< :05 48+259>:1+< @3162 :+ 48+A5 BC 377>91<; 9+;5<:
5A175<95 :03: :05 1<=>857 2>@@5857 ;815A+>2 1<=>8152 1: 93<<+: B50567:03::0548+259>:1+<03252:3B6120571:29325B5C+<7366 8532+<3B657+>B:25<953::059+2:+@8545:1:1+<:012+>8:
+41<52 :03: :05 48+259>:1+< 032 @31657 :+ 46395 85613B65 5A175<957+9>?5<:2 :+ 48+A5 :05 1<=>8152 2>2:31<57 BC - 32;815A+>21<<3:>85<:03:A15D+@:05?3::58:0539:+@:05
- 14 -
3445663<:2399>257@3662D1:01<:053?B1:+@59:1+<+@ 83:058 :03< 59:1+< %* +@ 1<95 :05 48+259>:1+< 032 52:3B612057 :03: :05 3445663<:2399>257 @+8?57 3< ><63D@>6 3225?B6C 9+>4657 D1:0 203857 ?+:1A5 :+ 1<@619: 1<=>8152 +< -D1:0
3<7 -*D1:0
3<7
BC9+<@1<1<; 3<7A58B366C3B>21<;:05?+@@5<952><75859:1+<2* $% 8537 D1:0 59:1+< .
+@ ;5:2 3::839:575<95:059+<A19:1+<3<725<:5<951?4+257BC:05 5221+<2 +>8: 12 613B65 :+ B5 ?+71@157 BC 25::1<; 32175 :05 9+<A19:1+< 3<7 25<:5<95 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< %* +@ 9+<@18?1<; :05 9+<A19:+< 3<7 25<:5<95 1?4+257@+8:05+:058+@@5<952
05 6538<57 9+><256 @+8 :05 3445663<:2 2>B?1::57 :03: :05 1<9175<: +99>8857 1< :05 C538 % 32 754+257 BC -2 3<7 * :05 399>257 B51<; :0518 J1< 3<7 +D1<; :+ 3 7124>:5 B5:D55< :05? 85;3871<; 20381<; +@ 9+?45<23:1+< 3?+><: :05 1<9175<: +99>8857 +>: +@ :05 B6>5 3<7 1< 20558 1?4>621A57124+21:1+<
. )>8:05832175@8+?:0129325<++:05893252D585 85;12:5857 3;31<2: :05 399>257 3<7 :0585 385 <+ B37 3<:59575<:23;31<2::05?3<732:05C385:05J1:03<7J1<+@
- 15 -
- 3<7 * 385 <+D 61A1<; 45395@>66C 5<95 :05 6538<57 9+><2562>B?1::57:03:1?4812+<1<;399>2573::0122:3;5?3C <+:258A53<C4>84+2505+<HB6545G+>8:1<:059325+@ 1/ 2/
1
"' (
3<705673:4383;83402+32><758
# ) ) 0 0
4 3 0
0 3 0
3
0 "
0 3
0 3
3
" "
) " ) "0
"
0
"
B 3,
% +D5A58 958:31< ?1:1;3:1<; @39:+82 61J5 ;83A1:C +@ +@@5<95?+:1A5@+89+??1::1<;3981?5:05?3<<581<D01901:
D32 9+??1::57 <557 :+ B5 B+8<5 1< ?1<7 3<7 :05853@:58 :05 25<:5<95 20+>67 B5 1?4+257 2 7129>2257 2>483 <+ 981?1<36 3<:59575<:2+@:053445663<:203A5B55<B8+>;0:+<859+873<7 @8+?:05859+87<+D?3753A3163B65B5@+85:012+>8:1:93<<+: B52317:03::053445663<:239:571<3485?571:3:1A57124+21:1+< 3<7+<+A583669+<217583:1+<+@:059189>?2:3<952+@:059325 3<7 9+<217581<; :05 @39: :03: :05 1<9175<: +99>8857 3B+>:
- 16 -
C5382 3;+ 3? +@ :05 9+<2175857 A15D :03: 36B51: :05 48+259>:1+< 48+A57 :03: :05 3445663<:2399>257 9+??1::57 +@@5<9524><1203B65><75859:1+<2+@ 32D56632+:058 +@@5<9523<7:0525<:5<9548+<+><957@+8:052317+@@5<95D32 C5382 +8 @1<5 +8 B+:0 3<7 :05 +:058 +@@5<952 D585 362+ 4><1203B65 D1:0 @1<5 +8 1?4812+<?5<: B>: 9+<21758 :03: 3D3871<;2>B2:3<:1A525<:5<951<:051<2:3<:9325:03:+99>8857 <5386C 3 759375 3;+ 258A52 <+ 4>84+25 <2:537 @1<7 1:
3448+4813:5 :+ 1?4+25 8532+<3B65 @1<5 :+ :05 399>257 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< +@ D+>67 ?55: :05 5<72+@=>2:195
99+871<;6C 3<2D58 :05 +1<: 831257 3B+A5 1< 438:6C3@@18?3:1A53<748+9557:+4322:05@+66+D1<;
1 05344536@1657BC:053445663<:2399>257+ 3<712%33
11 05=>7;?5<:+@9+<A19:1+<73:57%%%3<7 +8758 +@ 25<:5<95 73:57 %%% 432257 1< +%,%, BC :05 81<91436 12:819: 3<7 5221+<2 >7;5 3190>8 12 25:E32175 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< %* +@ BC >40+671<;:05=>7;?5<:+@9+<A19:1+<3<7+8758+@
- 17 -
25<:5<95 @+8 :05 +@@5<952 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+<2 * $% 8D 59:1+<.+@
111 05 25<:5<95 1?4+257 BC :05 5221+<2 +>8: @+8 :05+@@5<954><1203B65><75859:1+<+@ 12 0585BC?+71@1573<7:05399>25738525<:5<957:+ 43C3@1<5+@2%%%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:+@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :05C 20366 ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<:@+834581+7+@+<5C538
1A 05 25<:5<95 1?4+257 BC :05 5221+<2 +>8: @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< 8D 59:1+<.+@ 59:1+<8D59:1+<.+@ 3<7 59:1+< $% 8D 59:1+< .
+@ 385 ?+71@1573<7:05399>25738525<:5<957:+43C3 @1<5+@2%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:+@43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :+ ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7+@:0855?+<:02@+8:05+@@5<954><1203B65 ><75859:1+<+@ F:05399>2572036643C3 @1<5+@2$%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:+@43C?5<: +@@1<5:05C20366><758;+21?4651?4812+<?5<:@+8 3 4581+7 +@ $ 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<95 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< +@ F @>8:058 :05 399>257 2036643C3@1<5+@2%%%E53903<71<75@3>6:
+@ 43C?5<: +@ @1<5 :05C 20366 ><758;+ 21?465 1?4812+<?5<: @+8 3 4581+7 +@ $ 73C2 @+8 :05 +@@5<954><1203B65><75859:1+<$%+@
- 18 -
A 05 25<:5<95 1?4+257 BC :05 5221+<2 >7;5 @+8 :05 +@@5<952 4><1203B65 ><758 59:1+< 8D 59:1+<.+@ 59:1+<8D59:1+<.+@ 3<7 59:1+< * 8D 59:1+< . +@ 385 J54:1<E:39:
A1 6675@3>6:25<:5<952203668><9+<9>885<:6C
A11 05 399>2573445663<:2 20366 754+21: :05 @1<5 3?+><: B5@+85 :05 5221+<2 +>8: D1:01< 51;0: D55J2@8+?:0573:5+@85951A1<;3958:1@1579+4C +@:012=>7;?5<:
A111 @ :05 399>257 @316 :+ 754+21: :05 @1<5 3?+><: D1:01<51;0:D55J2:05C203662>885<758B5@+85:05 5221+<2 +>8: D1:01< +<5 D55J :05853@:58 :+ ><758;+75@3>6:25<:5<95
1G @:05399>257@316:+43C:05@1<53?+><:3<7@316 :+ 2>885<758 B5@+85 :05 5221+<2 +>8: :05 6538<57 5221+<2 >7;5 12 85I>52:57 :+ 259>85 :0518 48525<95 3<7 9+??1: :05? :+ 4812+< :+ ><758;+:0575@3>6:25<:5<95
G @ :05 399>257 754+21: :05 @1<5 3?+><: :05 6538<575221+<2>7;51285I>52:57:+<+:1@C:05 23?5 :+ -2 3<7 * 3<7 712B>825 :05 @1<5 3?+><: 15 2%%%%%E :+ - 3<7 2%%%%%E:+ -*+<48+458175<:1@193:1+<32 9+?45<23:1+<><75859:1+<$*'(+@8 05
- 19 -
B363<95 3?+><: 20366 B5 2>B?1::57 :+ :05 :3:5 8532>8C
G1 05B316B+<725G59>:57BC:05399>2573445663<:2 203662:3<793<956657
G11 5;12:8C1271859:57:+85:>8<B39J:058136+>8:
859+872 36+<; D1:0 3 9+4C +@ :012 +8758 :+ :05 6538<575221+<2>7;5@+8:0D1:0
+)
%# ( #
12:+6+