- 1 - ! " ! ! ##$%& % ! " ##$ % & ' " ! ( ")*#+ " ##)$ (( ! , " " ##$ % & !! (- *$)$* ' Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ( )$ &' ( . *)( ! *$ $$+ ( ( ( ! ( " " " ( ! ( /+$$ ( . ( ! 0 ! ! ! & 0 ! ! ' 12344255367 8296: 3::;92<2= 8> 712 ?@=:A267 36= 3B3;= 96 C$$+ 43//2= 8> 712 ==979C635 269C; 9<95 !@=:2 36= CAA9//9C62; C;DA36 CA426/379C6 "3538@;3:9 =372= *$ 13/ 344;C3E12= 719/ C@;7 96 344235 /22D96: 26136E2A267 CF ECA426/379C6 - 3 - $ 23;= 712 523;62= EC@6/25 34423;96: FC; 712 34425536736=712;2/4C6=267C $) 12 F3E7@35 A37;9G CF 712 E3/2 9/ 7137 712 427979C62; B1C 9/ 712 344255367 12;296 B3/ 712 =;9<2; CF 712 3<2;3 <219E52 823;96: 2:C")*#+ CB62= 8> 712 ;2/4C6=267 C / /@E1 12 B3/ 36 2A45C>22 B971 712 AC6715> /353;> CF /$$$ 42; AC671 36= 13773CF/$$42;=3>6+$$3738C@7$H+# 3A B1952 712 427979C62; B3/ =;9<96: 712 /39= 3<2;3 <219E5212;3AA2=712/3A2967C343;D2=5C;;>823;96: 2:C"))623; 9443;:3E;C//12/39= 5C;;> B3/ 43;D2= C6 ;C3= 3/ 97 13= 8;CD26 =CB6 F72; 96<2/79:379C6 712 4C59E2 13<2 F952= 712 E13;:2/1227 3:396/7 712 344255367 12;296 FC; 712 CFF26E2/ 4@69/13852 @6=2; 2E79C6/ * ) )) )) 36= )$+&' CF 12;23/712>F952=712E13;:2/12273:396/7712=;9<2;CF 7125C;;>FC;712CFF26E24@69/13852@6=2;2E79C6)CF 712 C7C; 219E52/ E7 12 427979C62; 344;C3E12= 712 CAA9//9C62; @6=2; 712 A45C>22/ CA426/379C6 E7 - 4 - /22D96: ECA426/379C6 /96E2 12 13= /@FF2;2= F;3E7@;2 CF 7121@AC;C@/36=712;28>13=35/C/@/73962=42;A36267 =9/389597> $+ 6 8296: /2;<2= B971 712 6C79E2 712 ;2/4C6=267/ C 36= B1C 3;2 712 2A45C>2; 36= 712 96/@;2; 34423;2= 82FC;2 712 CAA9//9C62; 36= F952= C8?2E79C6/ B12;296 712 ;2/4C6=267 C 2A45C>2; 3=A9772= 712 ;25379C6/194 CF 2A45C>2; 36= 2A45C>22 36= 35/C 3=A9772= 7137 12 B3/ 43>96: 3 /353;> CF /H$$$ 42;AC67136=/$$42;=3>3/ 13773 2EC6726=2= 7137712;2B3/6C62:59:26E2C671243;7CF19/2A45C>22 2EC6726=2=7137712CB62;36=96/@;2;CF7125C;;>3;2 5938527C43>712ECA426/379C6 $# 12;23/71296/@;36E2ECA436>=2692=355712 3<2;A267/ CF 712 427979C6 36= 97 35/C =2692= 712 ?@;35 ;25379C6/194 827B226 427979C62; 36= 712 ;2/4C6=267 C 79/35/CEC6726=2=7137712;2B3/62:59:26E2C671243;7 CF712427979C62;19A/25F12;2FC;2979/6C75938527C43> 712ECA426/379C67C712427979C62;672;3592371296?@;92/ /@/73962= 8> 712 427979C62; 637@;2 CF 712 =9/389597> 27E B2;235/C=2692= - 5 - $H 6 712 83/9/ CF 712 38C<2 EC672679C6/ 712 CAA9//9C62; F;3A2= 344;C4;9372 9//@2/ 12 427979C62; 2G3A962= 19A/25F 3/ 12 CE7C; B1C 3 2= =9/389597> B3/ 2G3A962= 3/ 36= G 7C G# B2;2A3;D2=967122<9=26E212;2/4C6=267C=9=6C7 3==@E2 36> 2<9=26E2 12 ;2/4C6=267 C 2G3A962= 97/ CFF9E9353/8@76C=CE@A267/B2;2A3;D2= $ F72; 123;96: 8C71 /9=2/ 712 CAA9//9C62; 3B3;=2= 3 ECA426/379C6 CF /$$ 8> EC6/9=2;96: 712 96ECA2 CF /$$$ 42; AC671 8> 3=C4796: 712 344;C4;9372F3E7C;37**# $ 296: 3::;92<2= 8> 712 /3A2 712 427979C62; 9/ 82FC;2719/C@;796344235 $* F72;123;96:712523;62=EC@6/2534423;96:FC; 712 344255367 712 FC55CB96: /@8/7367935 I@2/79C6/ CF 53B B2;2F;3A2=8>719/C@;7 - 6 - !" # " $ % & ' '( ) *$ #+,- $ . *$ - - $ 12 523;62= EC@6/25 34423;96: FC; 712 ;2/4C6=267 C 13/ 34423;2= 36= ;2EC;=/ 13<2 8226 /2E@;2= - 7 - 12523;62=EC@6/2534423;96:FC;712344255367 BC@5=/@8A977137712CAA9//9C62;2;;2=961C5=96:7137 712;29/C65>$J=9/389597>2<2671C@:113=/7372= 7137 712;2 9/ 3 =9/389597> CF J 2 /@8A97/ 7137 712 =9/389597> CF J 13/ 7C 82 377;98@72= 7CB3;=/ 712 F@6E79C635=9/389597>35/C963/A@E13/712427979C62;B3/3 =;9<2; 13/ /7372= 7137 12 E366C7 =;9<2 3 123<> 43//26:2;<219E52C;3:CC=/<219E5296F@7@;212;2FC;2 712CAA9//9C62;13/2;;2=963 96:712=9/389597>963 4;C42;B3> 2; EC67;3 712 523;62= EC@6/25 34423;96: FC; 712;2/4C6=267CBC@5=/@8A977137712CAA9//9C62; 13/ EC6/9=2;2= 712 =9/389597> 96 344;C4;9372 A3662; 7 9/ 3;:@2= 7137 712 CAA9//9C62; 35/C 6C72= 7137 712 427979C62;E36/7955BC;D3/3=;9<2;CF7123<2;3<219E52 8@7 19/ F@7@;2 4;C/42E7/ FC; =;9<96: 3 :CC=/ <219E52 B3/ 6C7 /4CD26 7C 8> 19A 96 19/ 2<9=26E2 12;2FC;2 96 712 38/26E2 CF 36> 4;C<9/9C6 @6=2; 712 /E12A2 CF 712 E7 7C EC6/9=2; 712 F@7@;2 4;C/42E7/ 712 /3A2 9/ 6C7 42;A9//9852 - 8 - ) 12523;62=EC@6/2534423;96:FC;712427979C62; 13/ F39;5> 3=A9772= 7137 712 AC6715> 96ECA2 CF 712 427979C62; EC6/9=2;2= 8> 712 CAA9//9C62; 37 /$$$ 42; AC671 96 712 59:17 CF 712 C79F9E379C6 9//@2= 8> 712 C<2;6A267CF6=93@6=2;7124;C<9/9C6/CF2E79C6+CF 712 A45C>22/ CA426/379C6 E7 1C5=/ :CC= 12;2FC;2 12 9/ ;2/7;9E796: 19/ E539A 7C 712 AC6715> B3:2/ 37 /$$$42;AC671 + 3<96: 123;= 8C71 /9=2/ 712 96ECA2 CF 712 427979C62; EC6/9=2;2= 8> 712 CAA9//9C62; 37 /$$$ 42; AC671 E366C7 82 9672;F2;2= B971 96 3/ A@E1 3/ 712 4;C<9/9C6/ CF 2E79C6 + CF 712 E7 3;2 E523; 36= FC; 712 4@;4C/2 CF 3 96: 712 AC6715> B3:2/ 97 9/ C65> 712 6C79F9E379C6 B19E1 9/ 9//@2= @6=2; 2E79C6 + CF 712 E7 BC@5=82;252<36712;2FC;229712;7124;C<9/9C6/CF712 969A@A 3:2/ E7 C; 36> C712; 19:12; 96ECA2 7137 A9:1713<28226;2E29<2=8>7122A45C>223;26C7CF36> ;252<36E2 6 @A47226 6@A82; CF ?@=:A267/ 719/ C@;7 13/ 125= 7137 9;;2/42E79<2 CF 712 96ECA2 E539A2= 8> 712 - 9 - 427979C62; C; 3=A9772= 8> 712 ;2/4C6=267 2A45C>2; FC; 712 4@;4C/2 CF E35E@53796: 712 ECA426/379C6 @6=2; 712 4;C<9/9C6/CF712 E7979/C65>7126C79F9E379C69//@2= 8>712C<2;6A267B19E1BC@5=82;252<36767137<92B CF712A3772;712/@8/7367935I@2/79C6/CF53BC36= 3;236/B2;2=9671262:379<2 # 6/CF3;3/712719;=/@8/7367935I@2/79C6CF53B 9/EC6E2;62=71213/E372:C;9E355>/7372=7137712;2 9/ 3 =9/389597> CF J 8<9C@/5> 712 /39= J =9/389597>134426/7C82712=9/389597>CF71252F7@442;59A8 =@27CF;3E7@;2CF7121@AC;C@/36=BC@5==2F969725>;2/@57 96=245272=/7;26:71CF712/39=59A8B19E1BC@5==24;9<2 712 427979C62; F;CA =;9<96: 3 123<> :CC=/ <219E52 19/ F@6E79C635=9/389597>13/7C82EC6/9=2;2=8>712C@;7 H 12 CAA9//9C62; 96 712 9A4@:62= ?@=:A267 13/C4962=7137712F@6E79C635=9/389597>BC@5=82$J7 9/42;7962677C6C727137);=CF712=9/389597>CF71259A8 7;36/53796: 3/ 3 F@6E79C635 =9/389597> BC@5= 82 3 4;C42; EC@;/2 CF 3E79C6 B126 97 E366C7 82 23/95> 7;36/5372= 967C - 10 - F@6E79C635 =9/389597> 126 712 13/ /7372= 7137 712 427979C62; 9/ =283;;2= F;CA =;9<96: 36> 123<> :CC=/ <219E52719/BC@5==2F969725>;2/@57963F@6E79C635=9/389597> FC;712;2/7CF19/59F212;2FC;296712EC6/9=2;2=C4969C6 CF 719/ C@;7 /@E1 =9/389597> BC@5= 7;36/5372 967C #J 26E2712ECA426/379C69/;2BC;DC@77C/$$$42; AC671 G H$J G **# G #J K /#)H+ A96@/ /$#H$$ 3B3;=2= 8> 712 CAA9//9C62; K /#H+ 1@/ 712;2 /1355 82 36 26136E2A267 CF /#H+963==979C67CB13713/82263B3;=2=8>712 CAA9//9C62;C6/2I@2675>712344235BC@5=/@EE22=96 43;7 26E2712FC55CB96:- 12344235355CB2=9643;7 123442553679/2679752=FC;3/@ACF/#H+96 3==979C6 7C B137 13/ 8226 3B3;=2= 8> 712 CAA9//9C62; - 11 - @E126136E2A267CFECA426/379C69/C;=2;2=7C82 ;2523/2=7C712427979C62;C6712=24C/97A3=28>712 ;2/4C6=267CB97196342;9C=CF$+B22D/ 12 C712; 72;A/ CF 712 C;=2; ;2:3;=96: 9672;2/7 ;2A3963;2@63572;2= = $ ! & ! "!! 9/7C5C# "