- 1 - !"!# $%" ! & $%"" ' ( !"# $ % & ' %(( )(& ( '(( ( ' * +### ( '(( %(( )(& ( ' * +### Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' (( ", ' '* * * +### * %( & " ( !"# $ % ( *& '* * + ' ' ** ' -* ( * * ## !## . / * ** ## ' ( ' *( ( ( 0* ( * 0* ( - 3 - % 0* ( *& 12 3425267 327878961:5 ;226<8=2>;?712:33=8@:67 ;2<942 712 48;A6:= @:==86B 86 CA257896 712 @9442@76255 9< 712 94>24 9< 712 48;A6:= 86 33=8@:7896 9## D1242;?712@1:==26B27971226>9452E267:7662FA425 , :6> # 42G2@786B 712 :33=8@:7896 9< 712 :33=8@:67 <94 :339867E267 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6> 1:5 ;226 7A462> >9D6;?71248;A6:= 12;482<<:@75:4271:77123278789624:33=8@:67 85 712 596 9< 962 484:H:51 9 224:33: 12 3278789624-5<:7124>82>96##78557:72>71:7712 3278789624-5 E97124 <8=2> :6 :33=8@:7896 522H86B :339867E267 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6> 96 ##+##" :5 :552472> ;? 712 :33=8@:67 7 85 5A;E8772> 71:7 5:8> :33=8@:7896 85 <8=2> D87186 962 ?2:4 ;? 712 E97124 9< 712 :33=8@:67 - 4 - 7 85 19D2I24 5A;E8772> 71:7 71242 D242 >853A72 D87186 712 <:E8=? E2E;245 :6> 9## @:E2 79 ;2 <8=2> D18@1 2I267A:==? D:5 >2@422> 96 ,## :6> 712 5:8> 5A87 D:5 7:H26 A3 86 :332:= 86 9+#D18@1527:58>2712GA>BE2679<712748:= 9A47:6>7125:8>GA>BE2671:>:77:862><86:=87?;?I847A2 9<712GA>BE267>:72>##,#+7855A;E8772>71:786 712 8672442B6AE 423425267:78965 D242 E:>2 ;? 712 :33=8@:67 D18@1 @:E2 79 ;2 42G2@72> I8>2 26>9452E267 >:72>##:5324662FA42,96712B49A6>71:7 712 :33=8@:78965 D242 <8=2> ;? 712 :33=8@:67 ;2?96> 78E2 5783A=:72> A6>24 A=2 9< 712 :46:7:H: 8I8= 24I8@25 %339867E267969E3:55896:7249A6>5& A=25,,+%<94 51947 124286:<724 42<2442> 79 :5 J712 A=25-& 12 5:8> 26>9452E267:7662FA42,D:5428724:72>:7662FA42 # ;971 9< D18@1 D242 @1:==26B2> ;2<942 712 48;A6:= 1248;A6:=;?875>27:8=2>94>24>:72>!##1:5 42G2@72> 712 @967267896 6978@86B 71:7 712 :33=8@:7896 <8=2> ;?712:33=8@:67D:578E2;:442>86724E59< A=29<712 A=25785532@8<8@:==?9;524I2>;?71248;A6:=71:7712 - 5 - :33=8@:67<8=2>:33=8@:7896596!##+:6>### 522H86B @9E3:55896:72 :339867E267 D18@1 D:5 ;2?96> 712 32489> :5 5783A=:72> 86 A=2 9< 712 A=25 :6> :@@94>86B=? 71242 D:5 69 24494 86 712 26>9452E267 B4:672> 12 48;A6:= 1:5 :=59 398672> 9A7 71:7 712 :33=8@:789685<8=2>:<724>2=:?9<:;9A779"?2:45 " *2:462>@9A652=<947123278789624@96726>571:7 712:33=8@:67-5E971241:><8=2>:6:33=8@:7896D8718678E2 3425@48;2>86 A=29<712 A=25:6>:772678969<7129A47 85>4:D679662FA42>:72>##+##"D124286712 :33=8@:67-5E971241:>59AB17<94:339867E2679<124596 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6> @@94>86B=? 87 85 5A;E8772> 71:7:6?423425267:7896B8I26=:72486@=A>86B712962B8I26 86#+:6>#8579;2742:72> :5@96786A:78969<712 2:4=824:33=8@:7896785<A471245A;E8772>71:7712>2=:?8< :6?85:5:425A=79<@8I8=>853A72326>86BD87186712<:E8=? :6>:@@94>86B=?712=2B878E:7248B179<712:33=8@:679AB17 69779;2>2<2:72>96E242B49A6>9<>2=:? - 6 - *2:462> >>87896:= 9I246E267 >I9@:72 :332:486B<94712425396>26755A;E87571:7 A=29<712 A=25 349I8>25 71:7 8< 712 :33=8@:67 1:5 697 :77:862> E:G9487? 7126 712 :33=8@:7896 85 79 ;2 <8=2> 86 724E5 9< 349I859 79 A=2 9< 712 A=25 D18@1 3425@48;25 71:7 712 E8694 EA57 :77:86 E:G9487? D87186 7D9 ?2:45 9< >:72 9< >2:71 :6> :33=8@:7896 EA57 ;2 <8=2> D87186 7D9 ?2:45 71242:<724:6>5A@1 A=2;286B:62F@23789679712694E:= 349@2559<:339867E2678579;2@96574A2>5748@7=? + 2=8:6@2 85 3=:@2> 96 712 GA>BE267 9< 712 96-;=232F9A4786712@:529< 4239472> 86 7 85 <A47124 5A;E8772> 71:7 8442532@78I2 :7 D1952 26> >2=:?1:59@@A442>8<712@48585@9652CA26779712>2:719< 7122E3=9?221:53:552>7129A479AB17697793:55:6? 94>24 >842@786B @9658>24:7896 9< 712 :33=8@:7896 96 @9E3:55896:72B49A6>:6>5A@15A;E855896<=9D5<49E712 9;524I:78969<71296-;=232F9A4786712@:5242<2442> 79:;9I2 - 7 - 24A52>71294>249<71248;A6:= ! A=2 9< 712 :46:7:H: 8I8= 24I8@25 %339867E267 96 9E3:55896:72 49A6>5& A=25 ,,+ 42:>5:5<9==9D5 !"## $##%&' ! " #$ " % #$ % & '(()* , 7 85 @=2:4 71:7 @9E3:55896:72 :339867E267 ;286B:62F@23789679712694E:=349@2559<:339867E267 7125783A=:789686712 A=242CA842579;2<9==9D2>5748@7=? 12349I859349I8>2571:786@:529<:E869412EA571:I2 - 8 - :77:862> 712 :B2 9< ! ?2:45 D87186 7D9 ?2:45 <49E 712 >:72 9< >2:71 9< 712 9I246E267 24I:67 :6> 12 EA57 E:H2 :6 :33=8@:7896 D87186 7D9 ?2:45 71242:<724 6 712 3425267@:52:>E8772>=?712:33=8@:67D:5:B2>?2:45 #E96715:596712>:729<>2:71:6>:77:862>E:G9487? 71242:<7247EA57;26978@2>71:72I26D126712E8694 D:4>:596712>:729<>2:71D:5:E8694:6>8<12:77:865 712:B29<E:G9487?D871867D9?2:45<A4712432489>9<7D9 ?2:45 D:5 3425@48;2> D87186 D18@1 :6 :33=8@:7896 <94 @9E3:55896:72:339867E2679AB17791:I2;226<8=2> # 67123425267@:52712:33=8@:7896:7712<8457 8657:6@2:@@94>86B79712:33=8@:67D:5<8=2>;?712E97124 96 ##+##" D18@1 85 57:72> 79 1:I2 ;226 <8=2> 96 ####"6724E59<712 A=258<:5@96726>2>;?712 :33=8@:67:33=8@:7896519A=>1:I2;226<8=2>;?712E8694 :<724:77:8686B712:B29<E:G9487?86724E59<712349I859 :>E8772>=? 712 :33=8@:7896 ;? 712 :33=8@:67 124286 D:5 <8=2> 96=? 96 !##+ :6> ### A@1 :33=8@:78965 :>E8772>=? :42 ;2?96> 712 32489> :5 - 9 - 5783A=:72>A6>24349I85979 A=29<712 A=25<712>:72 9< >2:71 85 86 ## :6> :339867E267 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6> 85 578== ;286B :B87:72> 86 712 ?2:4 # @=2:4=? <86:6@8:= @48585 1:5 ;=9D6 :D:? D18@1 85 712 9;G2@78I2 <94 E:H86B:339867E26796@9E3:55896:72B49A6> 12 96-;=2 32F 9A47 86 712 @:52 9< %5A34:&1:59;524I2>71:7>2=:?D9A=> >2<2:7 5A@1 :33=8@:7896 2=2I:67 9;524I:7896 9< 712 96-;=232F9A47852F74:@72>;2=9D +,- $ . / 0 * 96-;=232F9A471:5:=5912=>71:7>2=:?:7 26>9<712:33=8@:67947122E3=9?241:5:;2:486B96712 9A47855A86B:>842@7896 A=2 9< 712 A=25 9AB17 79 ;2 5748@7=? 8672434272> D126 712 57:7A72 349I8>25 @247:86 E9>2 :6> - 10 - E:6624 9< @=:8E86B :339867E267 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6>125:8>349@2>A421:579;2:>1242>795748@7=? 12 :33=8@:7896 9< 712 E97124 >A486B 712 E869487? 9< 712 :33=8@:67 D9A=> 697 86 :6? D:? 5:I2 712 :33=8@:67 <49E :>12426@2 79 712 78E2 =8E87 <94712 :33=8@:67 79 E:H2 :6 :33=8@:789633=8@:789651:I2;226<8=2>86#+:6># :6>7125:E2:42;:442>785@=2:4<49E712349I85979 A=29<712 A=2571:7712:33=8@:6796:77:8686BE:G9487? 9AB17 79 1:I2 <8=2> :6 :33=8@:7896 :6> 5A@1 :33=8@:7896 9AB17 79 ;2 <8=2> D87186 712 32489> :5 349I8>2> 86 712 349I859 79 A=2 9< 712 A=25 12 A=2 26I85:B25 712 2I267A:=87? 9< 712 :33=8@:67 ;286B : E8694 :6> 5783A=:725 78E2 D87186 D18@1 12 85 42CA842> 79 <8=2 :33=8@:7896 A396 :77:8686BE:G9487?A@1349@2>A42@:6697;28B6942>;? 712E97124<8=86B:6:33=8@:789696;21:=<9<712E8694596 " < 712 :33=8@:7896 85 <8=2> 86 712 ?2:4 #+ :6> # 9;I89A5=? 712 :33=8@:78965 :42 78E2 ;:442> F3=:6:7896 42B:4>86B =878B:7896 ;286B 712 42:596 <94 697 <8=86B 712 :33=8@:7896 :7 :6 2:4=824 39867 9< 78E2 @:6697 - 11 - 1:I27122<<2@79<5:I86B78E2:55783A=:72>86349I85979 A=29<712 A=25 7 85 :=59 @=2:4 71:7 E942 71:6 # ?2:45 1:I2 3:552> 586@2 712 2I267 B8I86B 4852 79 712 @:A52 79 <8=2 :33=8@:7896 522H86B :339867E267 96 @9E3:55896:72 B49A6>57129A479AB1769779855A2:395878I2>842@7896 :7 7185 ;2=:72> 57:B2 D126 712 @48585 9< <86:6@8:= >2326>26@?1:5;=9D69I24@@94>86B=?712@1:==26B279 7125:8>94>2457:6>542G2@72> )* ' ! &( " )* '" ( " *8579=9