Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9911 (KAR)

RAHUL PATIL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/201401/2024 · 2025-01-23

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#"$ %&# # ' ( ! " # # # $% %" & # ' " # ( ( %" ### $ ### ) '"&' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - #"&* #* $! ( # &&%# # ( # +"$ ( #" "&&&$, # -. ( / / 0 12 3245456728 19: :6;<14 =68 >854 57 412 794;82 6= ?97@9?;: 46 412 82:367@274: 46 39A B6?327:94567 6= :+" ;322: #5C2 D9E1 :2C27 416;:97@ 672 1;7@82@97@=5=4A67DA!97@@9?9<2:6=:" 68 57 412 9D4287945C2 46 5::;2 93386385942 @582B4567 46 412 82:367@274: 46 B67:5@28 412 82382:27494567 @942@ "&&&$57945?2F6;7@?97728 & 123245456728B67427@:4194125:4126>7286= 9763273D64F29857<6 "%&&':54;942@G283249DD5 - 3 - ;?79F9@5:485B45@9819C57<3;8B19:2@5457428?:6= 9 :9D2 @942@ %&&" 5: 79?2 >9: 274282@ 57 412 ?;75B539D82B68@:67+'&&"2:6;<14328?5::56746 B67:48;B4 9 F;5D@57< C5@2 933D5B94567 @942@ +"&& >15B1 >9: <89742@ FA 412 82:367@274: 67 "'&& 123245456728BD95?:419412282B42@9798B1 <942>9A46 27197B2 412 92:41245B C9D;2 6= 412 B67:48;B4567 4194 >9: 46F23;4;3574123863284A949B6:46=:+"$ 2 9DD2<2@ 4194 412 152= ==5B28 6= 412 82:367@27463;836842@DA5::;2@975DD2<9D68@2857412 <98F 6= 9 7645B2 @942@ &$"&&$ BD95?57< 4194 412 98B1 <942>9A >9: 3;4 ;3;79;41685H2@DA 97@B9DD2@;367 41232454567284682?6C254>54157&$16;8: 123245456728 B67427@: 4194 76 ?274567 >9: ?9@2 9: 46 16> 412 B67:48;B45676=41298B1 <942>9AC56D942@97A386C5:5676= D9> 12 3245456728 412829=428 :;F?5442@ 9 823DA 67 &&&$ BD95?57< 4194 412 98B1 <942>9A >9: 282B42@ =684123;836:26=5@2745=5B945676=15:3863284A>1282412 B67:48;B4567>9:A2446F2<57 123245456728B67427@:4194 - 4 - 412 82:367@274 6 F257< 9 :494;468A B6836894567 >9: F6;7@46B6?3DA>541412386B2@;82:246;4;7@282B4567 "+ 6= 412 987949E9 ;75B539D5452: B4 "'%$ F2=682 386B22@57< 46 3;DD @6>7 9 B67:48;B4567 6>2C28 412 82:367@2746>5416;4B67:5@2857<412823DA:;F?5442@ FA 412 3245456728 @2?6D5:12@ 412 98B1 <942>9A 67 &$"&&$ 12 3245456728 9DD2<2@ 4194 412 82:367@274 69=428@2?6D5:157<41298B1 <942>9A19@:15=42@412 274582 ?942859D 97@ @;?32@ 54 94 412 382?5:2: 6= 412 82:367@274 6 12 3245456728 412829=428 :;F?5442@ 9 82382:27494567 B67427@57< 4194 412 @2?6D54567 >9: 5DD2<9D 97@;79;41685H2@97@>9:764579BB68@97B2>541D9>97@ 41282=682B9DD2@;36741282:367@274:4639A@9?9<2:6= :+"$ 1232454567285:41282=682F2=682415:6;84 :22E57< =68 9 @582B45674641282:367@274:46 39A:;?6= :+"$ 68 46 B67:5@28 412 82382:27494567 =5D2@ FA 15?67"&&&$ $ 12D29872@B6;7:2D=684123245456728:;F?5442@ 4194 412 3245456728 19@ 282B42@ 412 98B1 <942>9A =68 412 - 5 - 3;836:2 6=5@2745=5B94567 6= 15: 3863284A 97@ 46 ?9E2 412 274897B2464123863284A94489B45C22:;F?54:419441282 5:76386C5:56757D9>>15B138615F54:4123245456728=86? 282B457< 97 98B1 <942>9A 2 9D:6 B67427@: 4194 412 82:367@2746>5416;4=6DD6>57<412@;2386B2::6=D9> 19@ 49E27 D9> 5746 54: 197@: 97@ @2?6D5:12@ 412 98B1 <942>9A 2 B67427@2@ 4194 412 82:367@274 6 19: 76> 5::;2@ 9 BD985=5B94567B;?5745?94567 @942@ &$&&$@2?97@57<9:;?6=:& 9:2I327:2: 46>98@: 2J;53?274 97@ D9F6;8 =68 F857<57< @6>7 412 98B1 <942>9A 3;4 ;3 FA 412 3245456728 2 41282=682 B67427@: 4194 412 82:367@274 6 19: 9@?5442@ 412 @2?6D54567 6= 412 98B1 <942>9A 97@ 41282=682 412 82:367@27465:F6;7@46?9E2<66@412D6:::;==282@ FA4123245456728 28 B67489 412 D29872@ B6;7:2D =68 412 82:367@274 6 :;F?54: 4194 412 98B1 <942>9A >9: B67:48;B42@ 764 >54157 4123863284A 6= 412 3245456728 F;4 >9: B67:48;B42@ 67 412 869@ ?98<57 ;79;41685H2@DA 97@ - 6 - 5DD2<9DDA 97@ >5416;4 6F495757< 97A 328?5::567 =86? 412 82:367@274 1282=682 12 B67427@: 4194 412 82:367@274 6 >9: >2DD >54157 54: 36>28 46 F857< @6>7 412 ;79;41685H2@ 98B1 <942>9A 282B42@ FA 412 3245456728 2 :;F?54:41944123245456728>9:B9DD2@;3674682?6C2412 98B1 <942>9A ;4 :57B2 12 @5@764@6 54 412 82:367@274 6 >9: 328=68B2@ 46 3;DD @6>7 415: :48;B4;82 2 B67427@:419476>128257412>854324545674123245456728 19: B67427@2@ 4194 412 98B1 <942>9A >9: 3;4 ;3 57 412 3863284A >15B1 F2D67<2@ 46 412 3245456728 1;: 12 B67427@:419441232454567285:76427454D2@4697A82?2@A 15:9398412B67427@:4194412324545672819::6;<14=68 9 >854 57 412 794;82 6= ?97@9?;: 46 @582B4 412 82:367@274:4639A9:;?6=:+" 97@415:6;84 B97764572I28B5:26=54:36>28;7@28845BD2&&%B6?32D 41282:367@274646B6?3DA>541412@2?97@?9@2FA 41232454567289:412825:76B6882:367@57<:494;468A@;4A B9:4;36741282:367@27464639AB6?327:9456746412 32454567282:;F?54:419441282:367@27465:F6;7@ FA412386C5:567:6=412987949E9;75B539D5452:B4"'%$ - 7 - 97@ 5: 27454D2@ 46 F857< 97A ;79;41685H2@ 97@ 5DD2<9D B67:48;B456757D572>541412386C5:567:6=412B497@9D:6 4638642B4412574282:46=412<27289D3;FD5B % 19C2 B67:5@282@ 412 :;F?5::567 6= D29872@ B6;7:2D =68 412 3245456728 97@ 412 D298757< B6;7:2D =68 82:367@2746 + 12 =9B4 4194 412 3245456728 19@ 3;4 ;3 97 98B1 <942>9A 5: 764 57 @5:3;42 4 5: 9D:6 764 57 @5:3;42 4194 412 82:367@274 6 19: @2?6D5:12@ 412 98B1 <942>9A :6 3;4 ;3 FA 412 3245456728 12 J;2:4567 >124128 412 98B1 <942>9A >9: 3;4 ;3 57 412 3863284A 6= 4123245456728686;4:5@24123863284A6=4123245456728579 869@?98<579829B97764F2@2B5@2@57415:32454567 1282 5: 764157< 46 :16> 4194 412 3245456728 19@ 6F49572@ 97A 328?5::567 =86? 82:367@274 6 =68 3;4457< ;3 412 98B1 <942>9A 7 412 9F:27B2 6= 97A 6= 412:2 82D2C974 57=68?94567 412 3245456728 B97764 B67427@ 4194 412 98B1 <942>9A282B42@FA15?>9:D9>=;D2:5@2:415:12 19:764?2745672@97A>128257412>854324545674194412 - 8 - 98B1 <942>9A 282B42@ FA 15? D9A >54157 15: 3863284A 1282=682415:6;84B97764<65746@5:3;42@J;2:4567:6= =9B4 46 9885C2 94 9 B67BD;:567 4194 412 @2?6D54567 6= 412 98B1 <942>9A FA 412 82:367@274 6 >9: 5DD2<9D 68 ;79;41685H2@ 15:6;849D:6B97764B67:5@28412BD95?6= 4123245456728=68@9?9<2:=41232454567285:27454D2@46 BD95?97A@9?9<2:=86?41282:367@274612?;:4@6 :6 F2=682 412 93386385942 5C5D 6;84 FA 2:49FD5:157< 412 2I327:2:57B;882@=6841298B1 <942>9A97@412=9B44194 41298B1 <942>9A>9:3;4;35793863284A>15B1F2D67<2@ 4615?97@4194412B67:48;B45676=41298B1 <942>9A>9: 579BB68@97B2>541328?5::567<89742@FA41282:367@274 6 7 4194 C52> 6= 412 ?94428 415: >854 32454567 :497@::;FK2B4464129F6C26F:28C94567: )* '#( # 5:46/"D6/% /