Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9903 (KAR)
THE BRANCH MANAGER v. RAMESH AND ANR
MFA/200552/2020 · 2025-02-04
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9903 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9903 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
"
##$
% & '
! " #"" $ %! & '
'
"( "
" $ %! ) &&!&!& &
R LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.06 10:47:40 - 0800
- 2 -
(*
'
+!,&!, (&!+ ''
"
'
- ' '
" - ' '
./0123.4./05.167859.4:7023./;;.44/52/5123. 4./05.167859.4:7023.0.9;751.527
!& .<5=/==0<.>.1?@23.A81=B.52/51/C/01<5
7 (&!+ ?@ 23. 4./05.1 .5<70 <><4 '81=. /51 ' /51 80/1" 23. <5980/56. 67B;/5@ <9 ?.:70.23<9 7802<5/;;./4
- 3 -
!* 3. :/628/4 B/20<D 7: 23. 6/9. /0. 23/2 75 &(&! /2 *! ;B 23. 10<>.0 7: 23. 74.07 '..; ?./0<5= .=7"*$"
"&( & 107>. 23. 9/<1 >.3<64. <5 3<=39;..1/515.=4<=.52B/55.0/51479267520747>.023. 9/<1>.3<64./51B/1.<227:/44<527/1<263?@23.9<1.7: 23.07/13.;.2<2<75.0C37C/9/5<5B/2.7:'..;3/1 98::.0.1=0<.>789<5A80<.94<E.:0/6280.7::.B800/1<89/51 845/ . C/9 93<:2.1 27 7>.05B.52 79;<2/4 80/1 3.0./:2.0273<=3.0:/6<4<2<.9/2<1/023.5/=/<53.C/9 9.52 27 @1.0/?/1 :70 :8023.0 20./2B.52 /2 /D 80. 79;<2/4
3. ;74<6. 0.=<92.0.1 / 6/9. <5 60<B. 7&*%&! /51 <5>.92<=/2<75 C/9 6751862.1 3. ;.2<2<75.0 6752.51.1 23/2 3. C/9 /5 /=0<684280<92 3/><5= 4/51.1 ;07;.02<.9 /51 3/1 / B75234@ <567B. 7:
9& !!!")18.2723./66<1.52/4<5A80<.93.<985/?4.27 ;.0:70B /9 ?.:70. 3.0.:70. 23.0. <9 / :8562<75/4 1<9/?<4<2@ 27 23. ;.2<2<75.0 /51 978=32 /5 /;;07;0</2. 67B;.59/2<75:07B23.7C5.0/51<5980.07:23.>.3<64. - 4 -
!% 3. ;.2<2<75 C/9 0.9<92.1 ?@ 23. 0.9;751.52 7& F <5980/56. 67B;/5@ /475. 3. 0.9;751.52 7 0.B/<5.1 .D";/02. 3. 0.9;751.52 7& F <5980/56. 67B;/5@ 6752.51.1 23/2 23. 74.07 '..; C/9 ;.0B<22.1 :70;.0975/489.?8223.;.2<2<75.03/1?7/01.123.9/B. /9/:/0.;/@<5=;/99.5=.03.0.:70.23.0.<9><74/2<757: 2.0B9/516751<2<7597:23.;74<6@ 70.7>.023..::.62<>. /51>/4<110<><5=4<6.59.C/9/4975723.41?@23.10<>.07:
23. '..; 52.0"/4</ <2 /497 6752.51.1 23/2
23. 67B;.59/2<75 64/<B.1 <9 .D70?<2/52 <B/=<5/0@ /51 852.5/?4.<5 4/C 3./=.<567B. /517668;/2<757:23. ;.2<2<75.0C/9/4971.5<.1 ! 5 23. ?/9<9 7: 23. /?7>. 6752.52<759 23. 0<?85/4:0/B.123.:7447C<5=<998.9"
!"#!$!%&'( ()(" & (!)
) %* + , *
&)*, ,)
- 5 -
*( , %
,
,, )
* *(%% (* % +(**)*),*% **
-
* * ,&-
* % ,& * - % * *.((&%&&- *
* %
, *
, ,
(*
,%,&&, ( *- *
* %
,* /,#)01234)"5254%$ ,- -
!+ 3. ;.2<2<75.0 C/9 .D/B<5.1 /9
/51 75. C<25.99C/9.D/B<5.1/9
&/51D27D*+C.0. B/0E.175?.3/4:7:23.;.2<2<75.07.><1.56.C/94.1?@ 23.0.9;751.529
- 6 -
!( 3.0<?85/4/59C.0<5=<998.7927*<523. /::<0B/2<>. /51 <998. 79% /51 <5 23. 5.=/2<>. ;076..1.1 27 /C/01 23. 67B;.59/2<75 7: 9!!!!" 851.023.:7447C<5=3./19" 4 7 ./19 7B;.59/2<75 C/01.1
7C/019;/<5/5198::.0<5=9 9& !!!" &
.1<6/4D;.59.9 /947?/4 .1<6/4D;.59.9<5 /44 9 !!!!" * 7997:<567B.7C/019;/02</4 1<9/?4.B.527:&!G9(&!!! B842<;4<.0?@* 9,*+!!!"
72/4 9!!!!"
!$ .<5= /==0<.>.1 ?@ 23. 9/B. A81=B.52 23. <5980/56.67B;/5@<9?.:70.23<9 7802<5/;;./4 !, 3.4./05.167859.4/;;./0<5=:7023./;;.44/52 C7841 98?B<2 23/2 23. <B;8=5.1 A81=B.52 <9 <44.=/4 <56700.62 ;.0>.09. /0?<20/0@ /51 C<23782 /;;4<6/2<75 7:
A81<6<789 B<51 2 <9 98?B<22.1 23/2 23. <B;8=5.1 A81=B.52 /51 /C/01 <9 B.63/5<6/4 3.
0<?85/4 3/9 675:89.1 <29.4: /9 27 C3.23.0 23.0. 937841 ?. *01 1.1862<75 27C/019 ;.0975/4 .D;.59.9 3.0.:70. 23. - 7 -
<B;8=5.1A81=B.5217.9572B/E./;07;.0B./5<5=2 <96752.51.123/223.0<?85/42378=39/@923/2*013/9 27 ?. 1.1862.1 27C/019 ;.0975/4 .D;.59.9 <2 B842<;4<.1
23. 67B;.59/2<75 ?@ /;;4@<5= 23. B842<;4<.0 7: * 3.0.:70.<2<96752.51.123/223..52<0.6/4684/2<757:23. 67B;.59/2<75/B7852?@23.0<?85/4<9272/44@.0075.789
3. 67B;.59/2<75 851.0 23. 0.4.>/52 3./19 /0. /497 572 /99.99.1 ?@ <2 3.0.:70. 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 :70 23. /;;.44/52978=32:70/0."/99.99B.527:23.67B;.59/2<75 /B7852 ! .0 67520/ 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23.;.2<2<75.03/998;;702.123.<B;8=5.1A81=B.52/51 3/9 20<.1 27 1.:.51 23. H8/528B 7: 23. 67B;.59/2<75 /C/01.1
3. ;.089/4 7: 23. <B;8=5.1 A81=B.52 7: 23. 0<?85/4C7841937C23/257C3.0.<523..52<0.A81=B.52
23. 5/280. 7: 23. <5A80<.9 98::.0.1 ?@ 23. ;.2<2<75.0 <9 1.960<?.1 2 <9 0.4.>/52 27 572. 23/2 23. <B;8=5.1 A81=B.520.:.092723.<5A80<.9/9=0<.>789<5A80<.9?82<2
- 8 -
57C3.0. B.52<75.1 C3/2 /0. 2379. =0<.>789 <5A80<.9 C3<637:23.B3/>.67520<?82.12723.:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@ 7: 23. ;.2<2<75.0 3.0.:70. 23. ?/9<9 75 C3<63 23. 1<9/?<4<2@ C/9 /99.99.1 <9 572 />/<4/?4. <5 23. A81=B.52 8023.0<2<9C702327572.23/223.0<?85/40.<2.0/2.123. 1.;79<2<75 7:
?82 <5 /0/ 7&! <2 37419 23/2 23. 572<75/4<567B.<93.4127?.9,!!!";.0B7523C3<63 <9 9!$!!!" ;.0 /558B 3.5 <2 1.18629 *01 :07B
23. 9/B. /51 23.0.:70. @./04@ <567B. <9 6/4684/2.1 /2 9(&!!!" 2 <9 572 E57C5 C3@ 23<9 *01 3/9 ?..5 1.1862.1
3<4.6759<1.0<5=D*%"1<9/?<4<2@6.02<:<6/2. <998.1?@
&<2754@5/00/2.9C3/23/9?..592/2.1?@ &?82/?08;24@<2 67B.92723.6756489<7523/2<23/9 573.9<2/2<7527374123/223.1<9/?<4<2@2723.4<B?<9&!G .>.52378=3
&92/2.923/2<2<9*G
3<4.6759<1.0<5= 23.<998.7*0.=/01<5=6/4684/2<7523.0<?85/4/C/019/ 98B 7: 9& !!!" 27C/019 ;/<5 /51 98::.0<5= 9 !!!!"27C/019B.1<6/4.D;.59.9/516/4684/2.923. 4799 7: <567B. /9 9(&!!!" D * C3<63 67B.9 27 9!!!!" 2 <9 C7023 27 572. 23/2 23. 7;.0/2<>. - 9 -
;702<75 7: 23. 701.0 <9 /497 :70 9!!!!" 5 723.0 C7019 <2 <9 572 E57C5 37C
23. 6/4684/2<75 7:
9!!!!" <9 /00<>.1 C3.5 9(&!!!" <9 B842<;4<.1 ?@* & 389 <2 <9 .><1.52 23/2 23. 0<?85/4 3/9 572 /;;4<.1 <29 B<51 /51 :<51 6759<1.0/?4. :706. <5 23. /0=8B.527:23.4./05.167859.4:7023./;;.44/52 * ;.089/4 7: 23. 1.;79<2<75 7:
& " B.1<6/4 7::<6.0 678;4.1 C<23 23. C7851 6.02<:<6/2. ;07186.1 /2 D% /51 23. 1<963/0=. 98BB/0@ /2 D9! /51 C7841 937C 23/2 23. ;.2<2<75.0 3/1 9892/<5.1 67B;7851 0/1." 67BB85<22.1 <520/ /02<684/0 :0/6280. 7: 0/1<89 845/47C.0*01:0/6280.7523.0<=32:70./0B/513.C/9 20./2.1 C<23 6479.1 0.1862<75 <52.05/4 :<D/2<75 C<23 C<0. :<D/2<75 /51 6759.0>/2<>. B71.
20./2B.52 :70 0<=32 845/ C/9/17;2.13.;.2<2<75.0C/91<963/0=.1C<2394/? /;;4<.1 /51 3. C/9 <5 ;/2<.52 :70 / ;.0<71 :07B &$&! 27 !&&! 3. 9.6751 1<963/0=. 98BB/0@/2DC7841937C23/223.0.C/91.:70B<2@
- 10 -
<523.0<=32845//5123.0.C/9/575"85<753.0.:70.3. C/9 /=/<5 /1B<22.1 27 23. 379;<2/4 /51 7;.5 0.1862<75 <52.05/4 :<D/2<75 C/9 175. C<23 28?84/0 ;4/2. . C/9 <5;/2<.52:7075.1/@ % 2<9;.02<5.5227572.23/2C3.523.5/280.7: 23.<5A80<.998::.0.1?@23.;.2<2<75.0<96759<1.0.1<523. 4<=32 7: 23. 1.;79<2<75 7: 23. & <2 6/5 9/:.4@ ?. 9/<1 23/223.0.<9/:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@7:&!G3.;.2<2<75.0 3/1 9892/<5.1 / 575"85<75 /51 /9 9863 23. ;3@9<6/4 1<9/?<4<2@92/2.1?@
&/2*G6/5?.3.412720/594/2. <52723.:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@7:&!G
3. ;.2<2<75.0 64/<B9 23/2
3. C/9 /5 /=0<684280<92 ?82 3. 3/9 572 ;07186.1 /5@ 1768B.52/0@ .><1.56. 27 ;07>. 3<9 <567B. 3.0.:70. 23. 572<75/4 <567B.3/927?.6759<1.0.1 + 3. =8<1.4<5.9 <998.1 ?@ 23. :70 9.224.B.52 7: 1<9;82.9 ?.:70. 7E"1/4/23 ;0.960<?. / 572<75/4 <567B. 7: 9$!!!" ;.0 B7523 :70 23. @./0 &! 5 8B;2..5 58B?.0 7: A81=B.529 23<9 7802 3/9
- 11 -
3.41 23/2 23. =8<1.4<5.9 <998.1 ?@ 23. /0. <5 =.5.0/4 675:70B<2@ C<23 23. C/=.9 :<D.1 851.0 23. <5<B8B
/=.9 62 3.0.:70. 23.@ /0. /66.;2/?4. .56.23.572<75/4<567B.7:23.;.2<2<75.0<96759<1.0.1 /29$!!!" ( 3.0.:70.23.67B;.59/2<75851.023.3./17:
4799 7: :8280. ./05<5= <9 6/4684/2.1 /9 9$!!!" D & D &!GD%I9&+$$!!"?@/;;4@<5=23.B842<;4<.0% :7023./=.7:%%@./09 $ 3. ;.2<2<75.0 3/><5= 98::.0.1 23. /?7>. :0/6280.9 3. <9 .52<24.1 :70 67B;.59/2<75 7: 9& !!!" 851.023.3./17:;/<5/5198::.0<5= , 3. ;.2<2<75.0 3/9 ;07186.1 B.1<6/4 ?<449 /2 D&:709 $!!!"D*:709*$ &"D+ :70 9%%!" 272/4 :70 C7023 7: 9,+, &" 3. ?<449 /2 D;% /51(/0./1>/56.?<449/51/9986323.@/0. .D6481.1.56.23.;.2<2<75.0<9.52<24.1:709,(!!!" 851.023.3./17:B.1<6/4.D;.59.9
- 12 -
&! 523.4<=327:23.5/280.7:23.<5A80<.9<26/5 ?.9/:.4@9/<123/23.C/985/?4.270.98B.3<9C70E:70 !*B75239.56.47997:<567B.180<5=4/<18;;.0<71<9 6/4684/2.19$!!!"D*I&%!!!" & 3. ;.2<2<75.0 <9 /497 .52<24.1 :70 / 98B 7:
9& !!!"851.023.3./17:47997:/B.5<2<.9<54<:. && 3. ;.2<2<75.0 <9 /497 .52<24.1 :70 / 98B 7:
9 !!!"851.023.3./17:675>.@/56.5780<93B.52 /22.51/5263/0=.9.26 &* 3.0.:70. 23. ;.2<2<75.0 <9 .52<24.1 :70 272/4 67B;.59/2<75 7: 9% %$!!" 851.0
23. :7447C<5= 3./19" 4 7 ./19 7B;.59/2<75 C/01.1 ?@23<9 7802
7997::8280.<567B. 9&+$$!!" & /<5/5198::.0<5= 9& !!!" *
.1<6/4.D;.59.9 9,(!!!" % 7997:<567B.180<5= 23.4/<18;;.0<71 9&%!!!"
7997:/B.5<2<.9 9& !!!" + 7C/019675>.@/56. 5780<93B.52 /22.51/5263/0=.9 .26 9 !!!"
72/4
9% %$!!"
- 13 -
&% .:70. ;/02<5= C<23 23<9 A81=B.52 <2 <9 5.6.99/0@27572.23/223.5/280.7:23.<5A80<.998::.0.1 ?@23.;.2<2<75.03/9572?..5;07;.04@6759<1.0.1?@23. 0<?85/4<523.<B;8=5.1A81=B.5258B;2..558B?.09 7:A81=B.5297:23.0<?85/4923<9 78027?9.0>.923/223. 5/280. 7: 23. <5A80<.9 /51 23. B/55.0 37C <2 C7841 20/594/2. <527 :8562<75/4 1<9/?<4<2@ /0. 9.417B 1<96899.1
3. 0<?85/49 /0.
A8B;<5=2723. 6756489<75 7523.?/9<9 7: 23. 1<9/?<4<2@ 92/2.1 ?@ / B.1<6/4 7::<6.0 575 B.52<75<5= 7: 23. 5/280. 7: 23. <5A80<.9 98::.0.1) 70 1.960<?<5= 23.B 9<B;4@ /9 =0<.>789 70 9<B;4.) C7841 572 0.:4.62 23/2 23. 0<?85/49 3/1 /;;4<.1 23.<0 B<51 27 23. 5/280. 7: 23. <5A80<.9 3.0.:70. <2 <9 .D;.62.1 :07B 23. 0<?85/49 23/2 23. 5/280.7: 23. <5A80<.9 98::.0.1/51 23. B/55.037C<2C<4420/594/2.<527:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@<927 ?.92/2.1<523.:/629/516<068B92/56.9.9;.6</44@C<23 0.:.0.56. 27 23. />76/2<75 7: 23. ;.2<2<75.0 2 <9 /497 7?><78923/223.B.1<6/47::<6.09C7841=<>.23.<07;<5<75 <5 0.9;.62 7: 23. ;3@9<6/4 1<9/?<4<2@ ?82 23.@ /0. 572
- 14 -
6/;/?4.7:=<><5=23.:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@/923./>76/2<75 7: 23. <5A80.1 <9 572 ?078=32?.:70. 23.B 3.9. /9;.629 3/>.?..5.4/?70/2.4@1<96899.1?@23.75?J4.;.D67802 <523.6/9.7:
5 / 0.6.52 A81=B.52 <5 23. 6/9. 7:
! 23. ;.D 7802 7: 23. 78520@ 3/9 /=/<5 0.<2.0/2.1/511<96899.123.9.0.H8<0.B.5293.0.:70.<2 <9 5.6.99/0@ 23/2 23. 7::<6.09 C37 /0. B/55<5= 23. 0<?85/49 /0. 27 ?. 9.59<2<K.1 C<23 23. 0.H8<0.B.52 7: B.52<75<5= 23. 5/280. 7: 23. <5A80<.9 98::.0.1 ?@ 23. <5A80.1 <5 23. A81=B.529
<23782 23. 1.960<;2<75 7:
<5A80<.9/5167"0.4/2<5=<22723.1<9/?<4<2@<2<9572;799<?4. 27<5:.023/223.0<?85/493/1/;;4<.123.<0B<5127/99.99 23.:8562<75/41<9/?<4<2@ & .56. /;;./4 1.9.0>.9 27 ?. /447C.1 <5 ;/02 3.0.:70.23.:7447C<5=)
1 (2011) 1 SCC 343 2 2023 (3) SCC 439
- 15 -
3./;;./4<9/447C.1<5;/02
3. /;;.44/52 <9 .52<24.1 :70/98B7: 9% %$!!" <592./17:9!!!!":7023.272/467B;.59/2<75 /475=C<23<52.0.92/223.0/2.7:+G;/:07B1/2. 7:;.2<2<752<4423.1/2.7:1.;79<2
.92 7: 23. 701.0 ;/99.1 ?@ 23. 0<?85/4 0.=/01<5= 1.;79<2.260.B/<585/42.0.1
.=<920@ 27 9.51 / 67;@ 7: 23<9 A81=B.52 27 23. /05/2/E/ '81<6</4 6/1.B@ :70 <5:70B/2<75 <5 1.><9<5= 20/<5<5=;07=0/BB.9
1" $
" &
"
'' <92747(%