Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9888 (KAR)
SHIVAYOGISWAMY MEMORIAL EDUCATION SOCIETY v. THE DISTRICT REGISTRAR OF SOCIETIES AND ANR
WP/201487/2024 · 2025-01-07
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9888 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9888 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
& '
!"#"$
% & !! '
( (! ) !"#"$"
)
!"#" %
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
& )
(
* ( '
( ( ( (
$$ $ +
$+ $ ! +
(
$ + $ ,
! + '
(
$+$ $ - (
,
(
. )
)
/0 1023234506 74520589 2/:2 6091458052 4 ;:9 : 609380524<2/01023234506;/4=:2066093>508<64?2/0149245 $" 5 2/0 9:?0 8:@ 63 /:52:A006:9;:?@ ;:9 0=07208 :9 2/0 60938052 ;/3=0 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@ ;:9 :11435208:92/00506:=07602:6@4<2/047302@239:==0>08 2/:22/060914580524 :5842/069;06035206<0635>;32/2/0 :<<:3694<2/01023234506!47302@:582/060<460:9B3235 4+#";:9<3=08C0<4602/03A3=)B8>0&)65'08:? <46 807=:6:2345 2/:2 63 /:52:A006:9;:?@ ;:9 2/0 60938052
- 3 -
:58 63 /3A:=35>: ;:?@ ;:9 2/0 0506:= 07602:6@ 4< 2/0 1023234506 ! 47302@ :9 106 2/0 ?00235> 4< 2/0 0506:= 48@ 8:208$":582/0:==0>086094=B23458:208$-$" 1:9908 C@ 2/0 80<058:52 4 ;:9 5B== :58 A438 :58 542 C35835> 45 2/0 1=:3523<<9 /0@ :=94 94B>/2 <46 106102B:= 35DB5723452460926:352/060914580524 /06035:58:542/06 <64?35206<0635>;32/2/0:<<:3694<2/01023234506E47302@
/0 9:38 9B32 :<206 7452092 ;:9 8076008 45 +$ $$" :58 32 ;:9 807=:608 2/:2 63 /:52:A006:9;:?@ ;:9 2/0 60938052 4< 2/0 1023234506 ! 47302@ :58 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@;:92/00506:=07602:6@4<2/01023234506E 47302@:91062/00506:=48@ 00235>/0=845$" 5:110:=35
4- $$";:9160<06608C@2/06091458052 4 /06035C0<4602/03A3=)B8>0&65'08:?;/37/;:9 839?39908 35 206?9 4< 2/0 DB8>?052 :58 807600 8:208 $ $$ + /0 6091458052 4 /06035 2/05 7/:==05>08 2/0 9:38DB8>?052:588076001:9908C@2/0(3692110==:204B62 C0<4602/394B6235
4+- $;/37/;:9839?39908 :9;32/86:;545 $" $#/01023234506745205892/:22/0 =392 4< 4<<370 C0:6069 ;:9 542 60>3920608 :58 :1164A08 C@ 2/0
- 4 -
6091458052435A30;4<2/01058057@4<2/08391B20C0<460 2/03A3=4B62:992:208:C4A0/060914580524 9BC?32208 : =392 4< ?0?C069 4< 2/0 :5:>35> 4??32200 24 2/0 6091458052 4 :206 2/0 1023234506 9BC?32208 : 601609052:2345 24 7:570= 2/0 60>3926:2345 4< 2/0 =392 4< 2/0
:5:>35> 4??32200 ?0?C069 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 7746835>=@ 2/0 6091458052 4 :<206 5423735> 2/0 807600 1:9908 35 4+#" 7:570==08 2/0 =392 4< 2/0 4??32200 ?0?C069 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 35 206?94<2/074??B537:23458:208+$ $$# - /060914580524 2/057/:==05>0832C0<4602/39 4B62 35 4-$""# $$# ;/37/ ;:9 83914908 4<< 45 $ $$ 60906A35> =3C062@ 24 2/0 1023234506 2/06035 6091458052 4 /06035 24 <3=0 : 8B=@ 7459232B208 9B32 900F35> :1164163:20 60=30<9 (4==4;35> 2/39 2/0 6091458052 4 2/05 9BC?32208:60GB092C0<4602/06091458052424602B652/0 =3924< :5:>35>4??32200?0?C0694<2/01023234506!47302@ <46 2/0 @0:6 $$! 5 2/0 9:38 601609052:2345 2/0 6091458052 4 602B6508 2/0 847B?0529 24 2/0 1023234506 ! 47302@ 2/64B>/ 6091458052 4 35 206?9 4< 2/0 74??B537:2345 8:208 +$ $$ 5 2/0 ?0:5;/3=0 63
- 5 -
/:52:A006:9;:?@ 8308 45 $ $$ :58 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@;:90=07208:92/0609380524<2/01023234506 /01023234506!47302@2/05<3=08 4#++ $$C0<460 2/394B62900F35><46:836072345242/0609145805292/0603524 745938062/0601609052:23459<3=08C@32<46>6:52!35!:38<462/0 @0:69 "! :58 !
/0 9:38 ;632 10232345 ;:9 83914908 4<< 35 206?9 4< 2/0 46806 8:208 $$ $ /0 1023234506 ! 47302@ :>:35 <3=08 4#+-# $ <46 : 836072345 24 2/0 60914580529 2/06035 24 74593806 2/0 601609052:23459 8:208 $$+ $ $ $ -$ $ :58 $ $/09:38;63210232345;:9839149084<<:58: 836072345;:9399B08242/0609145805292/0603524745938062/0 601609052:23459<3=08C@2/01023234506 (4==4;35> 2/39 2/0 1023234506 9BC?32208 : 601609052:2345 8:208 $ $ 60GB09235> 2/0 6091458052 4 24 60D072 2/0 92:20?052 4< :774B529<3=08C@2/060914580524
" /05 2/35>9 92448 2/B9 : 926:5>06 1B6146208=@ 7=:3?35>24C02/00506:=07602:6@4<2/010232345069BC?32208 :601609052:23458:208 $# $242/0635731:=07602:6@4< 2/001:62?0524<4!4106:234554224052062:352/060GB0924< 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@ ;/4 ;:9 7=:3?35> 24 C0 2/0 60938052 4<
- 6 -
2/01023234506!47302@(4==4;35>2/392/0635731:=07602:6@35 206?9 4< 2/0 =02206 8:208 $+$ $ :88609908 24 2/0 6091458052 4 :58 42/069 83607208 2/0? 542 24 052062:35 601609052:234594<63/3A:=35>:9;:?@;/47=:3?0824C02/0 609380524<2/01023234506/0609380524<2/01023234506;/4 7:?024F54;4<2/09:38601609052:23459BC?32208:60GB092 8:208 $ $ 24 2/0 635731:= 07602:6@ 01:62?052 4< 057=4935> 2/060;32/ A:634B9 847B?0529 24 092:C=39/ /39 7=:3? 2/:2/0;:92/0609380524<2/01023234506E47302@(4==4;35> 2/392/0635731:=07602:6@4<2/001:62?0524<4!4106:2345 :88609908 : =02206 8:208 $ $ 24 2/0 6091458052 4 92:235> 2/:2 :9 2/060 ;:9 :==0>:2345 :58 74B5206!:==0>:2345 C02;005 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@ :58 6091458052 4 60>:6835> 2/036 ?0?C069/31 35 2/0 1023234506!47302@ /0 ;:9 :9F08 24 35A0923>:20 :58 9BC?32 : 601462 :C4B2 2/0 92:2B9 4< 2/036 ?0?C069/31352/01023234506!47302@;32/352/023?09231B=:208 2/06035
/0 1023234506 74520589 2/:2 32 ?:80 : 601609052:2345 24 2/0 6091458052 4 45 $ $ 92:235> 2/:2 6091458052 4 /:8 6093>508 :9 2/0 60938052 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ ;32/ 0<<072 <64? $" :58 /0 /:8 54
- 7 -
?:55064<63>/2232=04635206092247=:3?:92/0609380524<2/0 1023234506!47302@ 35 A30; 4< 2/0 807600 1:9908 35 4+#":58 3< /0 ;06024 <3=0 :5@ :774B529 45C0/:=< 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ 2/0 9:?0 9/4B=8 542 C0 :7701208 BC90GB052=@ 2/0 6091458052 4 9BC?32208 2/0 :774B529 >0506:= C48@ ?00235> 164700835>9 :58 2/0 =392 4< 0H07B23A0 74??32200 ?0?C069 24 2/0 6091458052 4 ;/37/ ;:9 :7701208 /0 1023234506!47302@ 7/:==05>08 2/0 :77012:570 70623<37:20399B08C@2/060914580524<462/0@0:6 $#! C0<460 2/39 4B62 35 4 $+-+ $ /0 9:38 ;632 10232345 ;:9 839?39908 60906A35> =3C062@ 24 2/0 1023234506! 47302@24:1164:7/2/0:1164163:20<46B?35:77468:570;32/ =:;246086099329>630A:5704
/01023234506<B62/06745205892/:22/06091458052 4<46;:6808:741@4<2/0=3924<2/0?0?C069<462/0106348 $ $! $ + <3=08 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 2/4B>/ /0 /:8 54 ?:55064<63>/2232=04635206092247=:3?:92/0609380524<2/0 1023234506 !
47302@ 35 A30; 4< 2/0 807600 1:9908 35 4+#" /0 1023234506 2/060<460 9BC?32208 :
601609052:2345 8:208 $ $ $ 60GB09235> 2/0 6091458052 4 24 <462/;32/ 7:570= 2/0 =392 4< :5:>35> 4??32200
- 8 -
?0?C069 <3=08 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 <46 2/0 206? $ $! + 52/0?0:5;/3=02/060914580524 1B6146208=@9BC?32208 :542/06=3924<4??32200?0?C069;/37/74?1639094</3?90=< :5842/069<462/0106348 $ $! ;/37/;:9:7F54;=08>08C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 /0 1023234506 2/060<460 9BC?32208 :
601609052:2345 8:208$+$ $ -C635>35> 24 2/0 542370 4< 2/0 6091458052 4 :C4B2 2/0 0:6=306 164700835>9 :58 2/0 350=3>3C3=32@4<2/060914580524 247=:3?:92/0609380524< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ :58 24 60D072 2/0 =392 4< 74??32200 ?0?C069 3570 2/:2 39 542 7459380608 C@ 2/0 6091458052 42/0102323450639C0<4602/394B627/:==05>35>2/0=3924< 4??32200 ?0?C069 <46 2/0 206? $ +! ;/37/ ;:9 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 :58 ;:9 :7F54;=08>08 C@ 2/06091458052445$$ $ +/09:38=39235837:2082/0 5:?04<2/060914580524 :92/0609380524<2/01023234506! 47302@/01023234506/:9:=9494B>/2<46:836072345242/0 6091458052 4 24 74593806 329 601609052:2345 8:208 $+$ $ - :58 24 :77012 2/0 =392 4< 4??32200 ?0?C069 <46 2/0@0:6 $ -! "057=4908242/0601609052:2345
# /05 2/39 10232345 ;:9 =39208 <46 468069 2/0 1023234506 60160905208 C@ 329 60938052 ;/4 :110:608 35
- 9 -
106945 9BC?32208 2/:2 2/0 6091458052 4 39 54 =45>06 2/0 609380524<2/01023234506:582/060<4602/060914580524 74B=8 542 /:A0 052062:3508 :5@ 601609052:2345 <3=08 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 46 :5@ =392 4< 4??32200 ?0?C069 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 0 9BC?3292/:22/060914580524 /:954235323:208:5@:72345 24 6092460 /39 14932345 :9 2/0 60938052 4< 2/0 1023234506 :9 83607208C@2/394B6235 4-$""# $$#&839149084<<45 $ $$'02/060<4609BC?3292/:22/060914580524 74B=8 542 /:A0 052062:3508 2/0 =392 4< 4??32200 ?0?C069 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 0 :=94 9BC?329 2/:2 2/0 60914580524;:9C4B5824745938062/0=3924<4??32200 ?0?C0699BC?32208C@2/0102323450645$+$ $ -:5893570 2/0 9:?0 39 542 8450 2/0 6091458052 4 39 =3:C=0 24 C0 83607208 24 2:F0 :1164163:20 :72345 45 2/0 9:38 601609052:2345 <3=08C@2/01023234506
<206 106B9:= 4< 2/0 847B?0529 <B6539/08 C@ 2/0 1023234506 :=45> ;32/ 2/0 ;632 10232345 450 <:72 39 0A38052 5:?0=@ 2/:2 2/0 6091458052 4 ;:9 745209235> 2/0 7:90 4< 2/01023234506!47302@2/:2/0/:86093>508<64?2/014924<2/0 60938052 0 /:8 :=94 745209208 2/0 7=:3? 4< 63
- 10 -
/3A:=35>:9;:?@2/:2/0;:92/0609380524<2/01023234506!
4< 63
- 10 -
/3A:=35>:9;:?@2/:2/0;:92/0609380524<2/01023234506! 47302@/060<46060914580524 ?B92/:A02:F059201924 6092460 /39 14932345 :9 2/0 60938052 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ 5702/03A3=4B62354+#"/:8:=60:8@807=:608 2/:2 63 /:52:A006:9;:?@ ;:9 2/0 60938052 :58 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@ ;:9 2/0 0506:= 07602:6@ 4< 2/0 1023234506 2/0 6091458052 4 /:A35> 7/:==05>08 32 B59B77099<B==@ 35 0>B=:6 110:= 4- $$" :58
0>B=:6 07458 110:= 4+- $ C0<460 2/39 4B62 74B=8 542 /:A0 358B=>08 35 ?397/30<C@<3=35>:=3924<4??32200?0?C0694<2/01023234506 ! 47302@ <46 2/0 206? $ +! C0<460 2/0 6091458052 4 09145805242/060<46074B=8542/:A0:7F54;=08>089B7/ =3924<4??32200?0?C0699BC?32208C@2/060914580524 42/:20H20522/07:904<2/01023234506?0632974593806:2345 3?3=:6=@ 93570 63 /:52:A006:9;:?@ :58 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@;0606074>53I08:92/060938052:580506:= 07602:6@60910723A0=@4<2/01023234506E47302@C@2/03A3= 4B62 35 4+#" ;/37/ 807600 ;:9 B59B77099<B==@ 7/:==05>08 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 /06035 35
0>B=:6 110:= 4- $$" :58
0>B=:6 07458 110:=4+- $ :58 35 A30;4<2/0<:722/:263/:52:A006:9;:?@/:98308:5835/39
- 11 -
1=:70 63 /3A:=35>:9;:?@ 39 0=07208 :9 2/0 60938052 4< 2/0 4??32200 4< 2/0 ?:5:>0?052 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ 2/0 =392 4< 74??32200 ?0?C069 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 1023234506 :=45> ;32/ 2/0 9:38 601609052:2345 8:208 $+$ $ - 4B>/2 24 /:A0 C005 052062:3508 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 5 46806 24 1B2 : GB302B9242/0=45>86:;5=323>:23453239:1164163:20248391490 4<<2/0;63210232345452/0<4==4;35>206?9
3 /0 632023234539 33 /00584690?052:77012:570=022068:208 $$ $ +399B08C@2/060914580524A380 550HB60 J K 24 2/0 10232345 :58 2/0 =392 4< H07B23A0 4??32200 ?0?C069 4< 2/0 1023234506!47302@ <46 2/0 206? $ +! 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 6091458052 4 C0<460 2/0 6091458052 4 A380 550HB60 .+. 24 2/0 10232345:60/060C@GB:9/08 333 4590GB052=@ 6091458052 4 39 83607208 24 74593806 2/0 601609052:2345 8:208 $+$ $ -&A380550HB60..242/010232345' :9 ;0== :9 2/0 =392 4< H07B23A0 4??32200 ?0?C0694<2/01023234506!47302@<462/0@0:6 $ -! " 9BC?32208 C@ 2/0 1023234506 A380 550HB60 .. 24 2/0 10232345 :58 1:99
- 12 -
:1164163:20 468069 60>:6835> 60>3926:2345 :58 :1164A:= 4< 2/0 9:38 =392 4< 4??32200 ?0?C069/399/:==C08450C@2/06091458052 4;32/35:1063484<2/600?452/9<64?2/0 8:204<60703124<:741@4<2/3946806
()
&"'
"
3924=4"-