Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9861 (KAR)
RAJARAM S/O SHAMARAO PATIL v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/200554/2020 · 2025-01-29
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9861 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9861 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #
"
" $$%
& ' (
! "
#$%&&$
! "
' '
$% $" '
! ! ' (%&)(&$) ! #
$*+*(&$*
' '
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.01 15:40:15 - 0800
- 2 -
,! "
,!
" -./ 011203 ./ 4.526724 080.9/7 7-2 :;48<297 094 0=054 .9 >$*+*(&$* 10//24 ?@ 3205924 2<?25 # .:0@01;50 -252.90A725 52A25524 7> 0/ B7-25.?;903CA>5/->57"40724(%&)(&$) ( !@ 7-2 .<1;8924 :;48<297 094 0=054 7-2 5.?;903 -0/ 033>=24 7-2 630.< 127.7.>9 .9 1057 094 0=05424 0 /;< >A /$$$&# 0/ 6><129/07.>9 094 4.5267247-252/1>94297#>51>507.>97>421>/.77-2/0<2 % 7 ./ 0 60/2 >A 7-2 127.7.>925 7-07 .9 7-2 5>04 750AA.6 066.4297 40724 (+&%(&$* =-.32 -2 =0/ 750D23.98 >9 ?.6@632 7-2 7072 509/1>57 !;/ >=924 094 <090824 ?@7-252/1>9429740/-24-.<4;27>=-.6--2/;/70.924 .9:;5.2/ 094 4;27> /;6-.9:;5.2/ -2-0/ /;AA25240940/ /;6--2./297.7324A>57-26><129/07.>9 - 3 - -2 127.7.>9 =0/ 52/./724 ?@ 7-2 52/1>94297 6>97294.98 7-07 7-252 =0/ 9> /;6- 066.4297 094 7-2 6><129/07.>9630.<24./-.8-3@2E>5?.7097 + -2 5.?;903 A50<24 0115>15.072 .//;2/ 094 0A725 011526.07.98 7-2 2D.42962 =-.6- ./ .9 7-2 A>5< >A 0 421>/.7.>9>A $094E/ $7> $%152624247>850970 6><129/07.>9>A/$$$&#;94257-2A>33>=.98-204/ 24.6032E129/2/ /$$&F# 772940976-0582/ /$*&&&# 0.9094/;AA25.98 /$+&&&# >//>A0<29.7.2/ /(&&&&# >// >A 2059.98 4;5.98 75207<297 125.>4 /*&&&# >703 >;9424>AA7> /$$&F# /$$$&# * !2.98 0885.2D24 ?@ 7-2 G;097;< >A 6><129/07.>97-2127.7.>925./?2A>527-./>;57/22H.98 29-0962<297 6>97294.98 7-07 7-2 G;097;< >A 6><129/07.>9 0=05424 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 ./ >9 7-2 3>=25 /.42 - 4 - 2054 7-2 3205924 6>;9/23 011205.98 A>5 7-2 011233097 094 3205924 6>;9/23 011205.98 A>5 7-2 52/1>94297 F 205924 6>;9/23 011205.98 A>5 7-2 011233097 =>;34 /;?<.7 7-07 7-2 6><129/07.>9 0=05424 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 ;9425 7-2 -204 >A 10.9 094 /;AA25.98 077294097 6-0582/3>//>A0<29.7.2/.93.A20943>//>A2059.984;5.98 75207<297125.>4052>97-23>=25/.42 ) 25 6>9750 3205924 6>;9/23 011205.98 A>5 7-2 52/1>94297 =>;34 /;?<.7 7-07 7-2 907;52 >A 7-2 .9:;5.2/ /;AA2524?@7-2127.7.>925052/.<132.9907;520947-252./ 9> 4./0?.3.7@ =-.6- -0/ >66;5524 094 0/ /;6- 7-2 6><129/07.>9 0=05424 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 ./ 15>125 094 6>55267 $& -2526>54/=>;3452D2037-077-2127.7.>925-04 /;/70.9247-2A>33>=.98.9:;5.2/ $" ;7306250724 =>;94 5.8-7 72<1>503 % E ( 6</ 067.D2?3224.98 (" ;7306250724=>;94>96-22H+E$6</ - 5 - %" ;7306250724=>;94>99>/75.3$E$6</ " >97;/.>97259;<+E+ +" 609/H;33/;?0506-9>.4-2<>55-082 $$ 7./2D.42977-077-2127.7.>925-0/9>732409@ 2D.42962 7> /->= 7-07 7-252 =0/ 09@ 4./0?.3.7@ 7> -.< >52>D25 2E6217 .9:;5@ >+ <297.>924 0?>D2 033 >7-25 .9:;5.2/ 052 /.<132 .9 907;52 -252A>52 9> A0;37 609 ?2 A>;94=.7-7-25.?;903.99>70=054.9809@6><129/07.>9 ;94257-2-204>A3>//>AA;7;52.96><2 $( -2 6><129/07.>9 >A /$+&&&# 0=05424 ?@ 7-25.?;903;94257-2-204>A10.9094/;AA25.98011205/ 7> ?2 >9 7-2 3>=25 /.42 094 7-2 /0<2 ./ 29-09624 7> /(+&&&# $% -2 6><129/07.>9 >A /(&&&&# 0=05424 ?@ 7-25.?;903;94257-2-204>A3>//>A0<29.7.2/.93.A203/> 011205/7>?2>97-23>=25/.420947-2/0<2./29-09624 7>/&&&&# - 6 - $ 7 ./ =>57- 7> 9>72 7-07 7-2 127.7.>925 -04 /;/70.924-204.9:;5@0947-252A>52.7609/0A23@?2/0.4 7-07 -2 =0/ ;90?32 7> 52/;<2 -./ =>5H 07 320/7 A>5 0 125.>4>A7=><>97-/->;8-7-25.?;903-0/0=054240 /;<>A/*&&&#;94257-2-204>A3>//>A2059.984;5.98 75207<297125.>4.7-0/6>9/.425247-2/0<2A>50125.>4 >A$+40@/125/>9=.7-7-2-204.9:;5@./?>;947>70H2 52/7 07 320/7 A>5 0 125.>4 >A 7=> <>97-/ -252A>52 7-2 6><129/07.>9 ;9425 7-2 -204 >A 3>// >A 2059.98 4;5.98 75207<297 125.>4 ./ 29-09624 7> /$*&&&# ?@ ->34.98 7-077-29>7.>903.96><2.97-2@205(&$*=0//F&&&# $+ -2
6><129/07.>9 0=05424 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 ;9425 7-2 52<0.9.98 -204/ 4>2/ 9>7 6033 A>5 09@ .9725A252962?@7-./>;57 $* 29627-2011233097./297.7324A>57-2<>4.A.24 6><129/07.>9;94254.AA25297-204/0/?23>= - 7 - 24.6032E129/2/ /$$&F# 772940976-0582/ /$*&&&# 0.9094/;AA25.98 /(+&&&# >//>A0<29.7.2/ /&&&&# >// >A 2059.98 4;5.98 75207<297 125.>4 /$*&&&# >703 2//0=05424?@5.?;903 9-0962<297 >;9424>AA7> /($$&F# /$$$&# /%)))F# )* -;/ 7-2 011233097 ./ 297.7324 A>5 29-09624 6><129/07.>9 >A /&&&&# =.7- .97252/7 094 7-252A>52 7-2 011203 42/25D2/ 7> ?2 033>=24 .9 1057 2962 7-2 A>33>=.98 ." -2011203./033>=24.91057 .." -2 .<1;8924 :;48<297 094 0=054 10//24 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 ./ <>4.A.24 ?@ 0=054.98 0 /;<>A)#.9044.7.>97>=-07-0/ ?2290=05424?@7-25.?;9037>827-25=.7- .97252/707*I10A5><7-24072>A127.7.>9 7.33.7/5203.J07.>9 - 8 - ..." -2 52/1>94297 K >51>507.>9 ./ 4.526724 7> 421>/.7 7-2 297.52 6><129/07.>9 0<>;97 =.7-.90125.>4>A/.E=22H/A5><7-24072>A 7-./>5425 .D" 2/7 >A 7-2 >5425 10//24 ?@ 7-2 5.?;903 52<0.9/;90372524 4# % " ' " ./7>$3>