- 1 - ! "# ! $ %! #&& '(') &*+('** % ! "## $ # % # # #! & " $ ##% # # &'( $% ## #) ! ! # & * # # Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # # & * # ## ) ! !( # # )# +#)) !# $ +#))% ,-. /001/2 34516 178-94 &'($% 9: 6 -. :-215 ;-8, 8,1 06/<16 89 .18 /.-51 8,1 =35>?148 9: 794@-78-94 5/815! !/45965169:.14814715/815!* ! 0/..15A<8,193689:8,16-47-0/2-.86-78/451..-94. )35>1 /5>-6- -4 9! !( ;,161-4 8,1 /00122/48 /773.15 ,/. A114 794@-7815 :96 8,1 9::1471 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94 & * 9: /45 .14814715 89 34516>9.-?021-?06-.94?148:96/016-959:<1/6./45 890/<:-419:. $3011.-@1#/B,.942<%/45 -451:/3288934516>9.-?021-?06-.94?148:96/016-959: <1/6. 1/658,121/64157934.12:968,10/68-1. - 3 - & -476-?19C !&;/.61>-.81615/>/-4.8 8,1 /00122/48 /773.15 ,161-4 A< ,/,/036 92-71 8/8-94 /5>-6- :96 8,1 9::1471 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94 & * 9: 948,1A/.-.9:8,1:-6.8-4:96?/8-945/815 ! ( !& 6171-@15 :69? ! ?8,;18/ 9 5171/.15 2@1., 4@1.8->/8-94-48,17/.1;/.79?021815/457,/6>1.,118 ;/. :-215 />/-4.8 /00122/48 -4 8,1 ./-5 7/.1 /45 ,1 ;/. 86-15 :96 8,1 7,/6>1.,11815 9::1471 A1:961 8,1 )36-.5-78-94/2 1..-94. 9368 -4 9! !( 36-4> 8,17936.19:86-/28,1069.1738-94-49651689.3A.8/48-/81 -8.7,/6>1./>/-4.88,1/773.15,/51D/?-415!C7,/6>1 .,11815;-841..1./.!89!C/45>98?/6B15! 5973?148./.D!89D! 4A1,/2:9:8,151:1471 49 1@-51471 ;/. 215 496 /4< ?/816-/2 9A=178. ;161 >98 ?/6B15 ( ,1 86-/2 9368 /:816 ,1/6-4> 8,1 /6>3?148. /5561..15A<A98,.-51.@-518,1-?03>415)35>?148/45 96516,/.794@-7815/45.148147158,1/00122/48 /773.15 :96 8,1 9::1471 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94 & * 9: /45 - 4 - A1-4> />>6-1@15 A< 8,1 ./?1 8,1 /00122/48 /773.15 -. A1:9618,-.9368 #1/6415 934.12 :96 8,1 /00122/48 /773.15 .3A?-8. 8,/8 8,1 86-/2 9368 ,/. :/-215 89 /00617-/81 8,/8 8,1069.1738-94,/.:/-21589069@18,/88,15171/.15,/5 79??-8815.3-7-51A<794.3?-4>09-.941.3A?-8.8,/8 8,1 86-/2 9368 ,/. :/-215 89 0690162< /00617-/81 8,1 1@-51471 9: !' -4 8,1 A/7B>69345 9: D' DC D! /45D!!1.3A?-8.8,/88,1069.1738-94,/. 498 02/715 /4< ?/816-/2 94 617965 89 .,9; 8,/8 8,1 /773.15,/5:-215/4</002-7/8-94.11B-4>7,/4>19: ,/8/ 96 .11B-4> ?38/8-94 96516. ;,-7, ;161 0145-4> 794.-516/8-94-48,134-7-0/2-8<,161:9618,1/221>/8-94 ?/51/./>/-4.88,1/773.15-.A/.121..77965-4>2<,1 06/<.89/229;8,1/001/2 * 16 79486/ 21/6415 ->, 9368 9@164?148 21/516,/./6>315-4.3009689:8,1-?03>415)35>?148 /45 96516 /45 .3A?-8. 8,/8 8,1 86-/2 9368 ,/@-4> /00617-/8158,196/2/455973?148/6<1@-5147102/71594 - 5 - 617965,/.6->,82<794@-78158,1/00122/48:968,1/221>15 9::1471/45/77965-4>2<06/<.895-.?-..8,1/001/2 ' ,1 /00122/48 ,/. A114 7,/6>1.,11815 -4 8,1 061.148 7/.1 ;-8, /4 /221>/8-94 8,/8 A17/3.1 9: 8,1 8968361/458,61/8>-@14A<,-?898,15171/.15;,9;/. ;96B-4> /. / -22 92217896 -4 8,1 297/2 34-7-0/2-8< 8,1 5171/.15,/579??-8815.3-7-51A<794.3?-4>09-.94/45 8,161:961/221>/8-94-.?/51/>/-4.88,1/773.158,/8,1 ,/5 /A18815 8,1 5171/.15 89 79??-8 .3-7-51 /45 /77965-4>2< ,1 ,/. A114 7,/6>1.,11815 :96 8,1 9::1471 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94 & * 9: 8,1 ,1 :-6.8 -4:96?/48!-.8,1;-:19:8,15171/.15,1?/816-/2 94 617965 ;9325 >9 89 .,9; 8,/8 8,1 5171/.15 ;/. /221>152< /5?-8815 89 8,1 9.0-8/2 94 !( & & /45 ,1 ,/5.3A.1E31482<5-15-48,19.0-8/294 ! ( !&:816 8,1 51/8, 9: 8,1 5171/.15 ! ,/5 /0069/7,15 8,1 092-71 94 ! ( & /45 -4 ,16 :-6.8 -4:96?/8-94 /221>/8-94. ;161 ?/51 8,/8 A17/3.1 9: 8,1 8968361 /45 8,61/8>-@14A<8,1/773.158,15171/.15,/579??-8815 - 6 - .3-7-518-./221>158,/88,1/773.15;/.8,61/814-4>9: :-2-4> :/2.1 /8697-8< 7/.1 />/-4.8 8,1 5171/.15 -: ,1 591. 498 794.-516 8,1 /002-7/8-94 :-215 A< 8,1 ;-:1 9: 8,1 /773.15 :96 7,/4>1 9: 61@1431 1486-1. -4 61.0178 9: / 7168/-402989:2/45 ,1 069.1738-94 -4 .300968 9: -8. 7/.1 ,/. 1D/?-415!C;-841..1./.!89!C,1?/816-/2 94 617965 ;9325 >9 89 .,9; 8,/8 8,1 5171/.15 ;/. -4-8-/22< .,-:815 94 !( & !& -4 /4 ?A32/471 89 ,/,/036 9@164?148 9.0-8/2 /45 8,16/:816 ,1 ;/. .,-:815 89 9.0-8/2 /8 /2/A36/>- /45 .3A.1E31482< 89 15-7/61 9.0-8/2 /8 /2/A36/>- ;,161-4 ,1 5-15 94 ! ( !& ,1 069.1738-94 ,/. 498 1D/?-415 8,1 97896. 9: /4< 941 9: 8,1 /:961./-5 9.0-8/2. ;,161 8,1 5171/.15;/./5?-8815:96861/8?148,1?15-7/2617965. 9:8,15171/.15:69?8,1/:961./-59.0-8/2./61/2.9498 06953715A1:9618,19368 C !'6 ?06/B/.,/8-2 9356/00//8-2 -.8,197896;,9,/.79453781509.8?9681?9:8,151/5 - 7 - A95<9:8,15171/.152@1.,!',/..8/8158,/88,1 @-.716/9:8,15171/.15;/.792217815/45.148:96?15-7/2 1D/?-4/8-94/458,1?15-7/21D/?-4/8-94610968-..315A< 8,1 9614.-7 7-1471 #/A96/896< -. ?/6B15 /. D' 4 D' -8 -. 90-415 8,/8 8,1 61.-531. 9: @92/8-21 09-.94. 01.8-7-51.563>./2B/29-5./4589D-7?18/2-94.;161498 51817815 -4 8,1 /68-721. ;,-7, ;161 :96;/6515 :96 8,1 03609.19:?15-7/21D/?-4/8-94.!',/..8/8158,/8 A/.15948,1610968/8D',1,/5>-@14/:-4/2610968 61>/65-4>7/3.19:51/8,9:8,15171/.15?148-94-4>8,/8 8,1 51/8, ;/. /. / 61.328 9: /65-961.0-6/896< /661.8 .17945/6<89?328-96>/4:/-2361,1./-5610968-.?/6B15 /. DC. -4/2 90-4-94 >-@14 A< !' -. ?/6B15 /. D! ->4/8361 9: !' -4 8,1 /:961./-5 8;9 5973?148. -. ?/6B15 /. DC$/% /45 D! $/% 61.0178-@12< ! !' ,/. .017-:-7/22< .8/815 8,/8 092-71 ,/@1 /.B15:96/:368,16610968/45/77965-4>2<,1,/.>-@14/ .17945:-4/290-4-94610968.8/8-4>8,/851/8,-././61.328 - 8 - 9: 7/65-961.0-6/896< /661.8 .17945/6< 89 ?328- 96>/4 :/-2361 531 89 34B49;4 09-.94 ,1 .17945 :-4/2 90-4-94 610968 9: 8,1 597896 -. ?/6B15 /. D!! /45 ,-. .->4/8361 -. ?/6B15 /. D!!$/% 69? 8,1 1@-51471 9: !' -8 -. /00/6148 8,/8 ,1 ,/5 -..315 8,1 :-6.8 :-4/2 90-4-94 ;-8, 61>/65 89 8,1 7/3.1 9: 51/8, A/.15 94 8,1 7,1?-7/2 1D/?-4/8-94 610968 6171-@15 :69? :9614.-7 .7-14712/A96/896</.016D',1.17945:-4/290-4-94 610968;-8,61>/65898,17/3.19:51/8,-.-..315A<8,1 97896942</88,161E31.89:8,1092-71/45498A/.1594 /4< 610968 :69? 8,1 9614.-7 7-1471 #/A96/896< /45 8,161:961 -8 -. @16< 721/6 8,/8 8,1 .17945 :-4/2 90-4-94 610968;-8,61>/65898,17/3.19:51/8,9:8,15171/.15 -..315 A< !' -. 498 A/.15 94 /4< 610968 9: 8,1 79?018148 /38,96-8< ;,-7, .8/81. 8,/8 09-.9493. 96 89D-7 ?/816-/2;16151817815-48,1@-.716/9:8,15171/.15 !! 6- 6/@114 /4>/4/2?/8, 7-148-:-7 ::-716 $!&%-.8,1/38,969:D',-.;-841..,/.721/62< .8/815 8,/8 49 09-.9493. .3A.8/471 ;/. :9345 -4 8,1 - 9 - /68-721. ;,-7, ;161 :96;/6515 89 8,1 9614.-7 7-1471 #/A96/896< :96 8,1 03609.1 9: 7,1?-7/2 1D/?-4/8-94 ,161:9618,1069.1738-94,/.388162<:/-21589069@18,/8 8,1 51/8, ;/. /. / 61.328 9: 794.3?-4> 09-.94 A< 8,1 5171/.15 ,1 86-/2 9368 ,/. 898/22< :/-215 89 /00617-/81 8,-. /.0178 9: 8,1 ?/8816 /45 A/.15 94 8,1 1@-51471 9: !/45*89!!;,9,/@15109.158,/8 8,1 /773.15 ;/. 8,61/814-4> 8,1 5171/.15 9: :-2-4> :/2.1 /8697-8<7/.1/>/-4.8,-?-:,1591.498:/@96/A2<794.-516 8,1 /002-7/8-94 9: ,-. ;-:1 :96 86/4.:16 9: 8,1 61@1431 617965.-461.01789:7168/-402989:2/45,/.06971151589 794@-78 8,1 /773.15 :96 8,1 9::14.1 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94& *9:948,1>693458,/88,161-.?/816-/289 .,9;8,/8 8,1 /773.15 ;/. 8,61/814-4> /45896836-4> 8,1 5171/.15 /45 /. / 61.328 9: ;,-7, ,1 ,/5 79??-8815 .3-7-51 ,1 86-/2 9368 ,/. 34:96834/812< :/-215 89 /00617-/81 8,/8 8,1 069.1738-94 ,/. :/-215 89 1.8/A2-., A1:9618,19368A<069537-4>4171../6<?/816-/289.,9; 8,/88,151/8,9:5171/.15;/././61.3289:794.3?-4> 09-.94 - 10 - ! 4516 8,1 7-673?.8/471. /? 9: 8,1 90-4-94 8,/8 8,1 )35>?148 /45 6516 9: 794@-78-94 /45 .1481471 0/..15A<8,186-/29368794@-78-4>8,1/773.15 /00122/48 :96 9::14.1 034-.,/A21 34516 178-94 & * 9: /45 .148147-4> ,-? 89 34516>9 .-?021 -?06-.94?148 :96 / 016-959::-@1<1/6./450/<:-419:. /45-4 51:/328 89 34516>9 .-?021 -?06-.94?148 :96 / :368,16 016-95 9: 8;9 <1/6. 7/4498 A1 .3.8/-415 77965-4>2< 0/..8,1:9229;-4> $-% ,16-?-4/2001/2-.F $--% ,1 )35>?148 9: 794@-78-94 5/815 ! !/458,1965169:.14814715/815 !* ! 0/..15 -4 9! ( A< 8,1 1..-94.)35>1 9368 /8 /5>-6- -. .18 /.-51F - 11 - $---% ,1 /773.15 /00122/48 -. /7E3-8815 9: 8,1 7,/6>1.,118159::14.1/45,-.A/-2A945.-: /4<.8/45.7/4712215 $-@% ,1 :-41 /?9348 -: /4< 5109.-815 A< 8,1 /00122/48 /773.15.,/22A161:3451589,-? ,+ ' $ %! * ! #-.89!29(