Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9788 (KAR)
S. VEERESH S/O RACHANNA v. S. SUGANNA SINCE DECEASED BY LRS ORS
RFA/6013/2012 · 2025-01-25
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9788 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9788 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#" $! % &#!!! "'
% &#!#! !$$ ($) *+ !$$ ,
($)
+
! "
#
! $
%&
! $
$ '
(
) *! &&+ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
$
&
"
"
( ! "
"
! ) !#, # (- )
# !# #,(-#
'
$
) -
)
)
$ .+ ) )
) /
"
%& ! *! "
&&&% ) )) $ ! $
)
)
- 3 -
) !$0
)"
,
+
+
! "
#
! 1
$
$ '
(
'
2
$
&
"
"
- 4 -
( ! "
"
! ) #, !# (-
'
) -
)
)
$ .+ ) )
) /
"
%& ! *! "
&&&% )
)!)
! $
$ 0 )"
)
! )
"
)
) $
3!"
3!"
" '
- 5 -
'#&
3!"
#
! 45 675859: 16651;8 175 <=;5> 2? :45 6;1=9:=<< @41;;59A=9A :45 BC>AD59: 19> >5@755 >1:5> %& 61885> =9 E&&&% 2? :45 EC7: E< 7; 59=E7 =F=; "C>A5 1=@4C7 G45752? 8C=: E< 6;1=9:=<< G18 >=8D=885> 19> @EC9:57/@;1=D 1;;EG5> >5@;17=9A >5<59>19:
9E :E 25 :45 128E;C:5 EG957 E< 67E657:=58 >58@7=25> =9 :45@45>C;5E<@EC9:57/@;1=D19>758:71=9=9A:456;1=9:=<< 19> 4=8 1A59:8 <7ED =9:57<57=9A G=:4 :45 6E88588=E9 E< @EC9:57/@;1=D67E657:?E<>5<59>19:9E
) E+&(& =8 <=;5> @41;;59A=9A :45 >=8D=881; E< 8C=: =9 E&&&% G4=;5 )
E&&&%&( =8 <=;5> 1A1=98: :45 1;;EG=9A E< :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D 19> =9 ;=A4: E< :45 8C=: 19> @EC9:57/@;1=D 25=9A >=86E85> E<< 2? 1 @EDDE9 E7>57 2E:4 :45 16651;8 175>=86E85>E<<F=>5:4=8@EDDE9BC>AD59:
- 6 -
( 45 671?578 D1>5 =9 :45 8C=: 19> @EC9:57/@;1=D 17518<E;;EG8/
! ! " 2#
# @#
"
$"% # &
'
$"%! $"%"
$"%
$"%"
( )# # !# )
- 7 -
$"% ! "
"
&&
$"%
! $"%#*
"+
45
5951;EA?E<617:=58=818<E;;EG8
45 617:=58 175 75<5775> :E 2?
:45=7 719H 25<E75 :457=1;EC7:
1D61991 1@41991 CA1991 5<59>19:/#
557584 ;1=9:=<<#
>5DD1 $=<5# 5<59>19:/ 1# 1718G1:= 1CA4:57# 5<59>19:/ 2# 17181DD1 1CA4:57# 5<59>19: @# 5F171B E9# 5<59>19:/ !181F171B E9# 5<59>19:/(
- 8 -
+ 45 6;1=9:=<< 557584 @;1=D8 :E 25 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 : =8 18857:5> :41: 1D61991 G18 :45 756E8=:C8 19> >=5> ;51F=9A 254=9> 4=8 :GE @4=;>759 1@41991 19> CA1991 >5<59>19: 9E# 45 6;1=9:=<< @;1=D8 :E 25 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 G4=;5 :45 >5<59>19: 9E819>(1758:1:5>:E25:458E98E<CA1991 %:=818857:5>:41:1<:57:45>51:4E<1D61991 :45 67E657:=58 ;5<: 254=9> 2? 4=D G575 8C@@55>5> :E 2? 1@41991 19> :45 >5<59>19: 9E =9 5IC1; 841758 : =8 <C7:457 18857:5> :41: @E985IC59: :E :45 >51:4 E< 1@41991 :45 6;1=9:=<< 418 8C@@55>5> :E :45 84175 E< 1@41991
: =8 8:1:5> :41: =9 ;=A4: E< :45 >5<59>19:8 9E: 4E9EC7=9A:45@;1=DE<:456;1=9:=<<:45675859:8C=:@1D5 :E25<=;5>855H=9A<E7>5@75575A17>=9AE9541;<8417518 1;8E419>=9AEF57E<856171:56E88588=E91<:57>=F=>=9A:45 81D52?D5:5819>2EC9>8
. 45 67E657:=58 175 DE75 <C;;? >58@7=25> =9 :45 @45>C;5 45 >5<59>19: 9E CA1991 418 <=;5> :45
- 9 -
G7=::59 8:1:5D59: >59?=9A :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 19> 18857:8 :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 419912181661
& 45 75;1:=E984=6 4EG5F57 25:G559 >5<59>19:
9E CA1991# 19> 1@41991 25=9A :45 @4=;>759 E< 1D61991 =8 1>D=::5> 19> :45 <C7:457 1F57D59: :41:
>5<59>19: 9E 19> ( 175 :45 8E98 E< >5<59>19: 9E =8 1;8E1>D=::5>
: =8 865@=<=@1;;? 18857:5> :41: >5<59>19: 9E 19> 1@41991 41> @E98:=:C:5> BE=9: <1D=;? 19> :47ECA4 BE=9:5<<E7:841>1@IC=75>F17=EC81A7=@C;:C71;;19>8
: =8 865@=<=@1;;? 18857:5> :41: 6;1=9:=<< 41> 9E:
=9@;C>5> <5G E< :45 67E657:=58 >58@7=25> =9 6171/ E< G7=::59 8:1:5D59: 18 1 8C2B5@: D1::57 E< :45 ;5A1;
67E@55>=9A8 19> 1@@E7>=9A;? :45 8C=: G18 21> >C5 :E 9E9/=9@;C8=E9E<:4581=>67E657:=58=9:45;1=9:@45>C;5
(:G181;8E 18857:5>:41::4575G181 617:=:=E9 25:G559 >5<59>19: 9E 19> 1@41991 18 75A17>8 :45
- 10 -
BE=9: <1D=;? 67E657:=58 6C78C19: :E G4=@4 DC:1:=E98 41F5 2559 5<<5@:5> =9 :45 91D58 E< >5<59>19: 9E 19> 1@41991 81@41991>=5>E9&&&&(181!1@45;E7 ;51F=9A 254=9> 4=D 9E ;5A1; 45=78 >5<59>19: 9E 1;E95 4188C@@55>5>:E1;;:45;19>5>67E657:=58E<1@4199118 675<5759:=1;;188/45=7
45>5<59>19:9E4181;8E675<5775>1@EC9:57/ @;1=D18857:=9A:41:45=8:45EG957=96E88588=E9E<:45 8@45>C;5;19>819>4181;8E>5:1=;5>:4567E657:=58=9:45 <E7D E< @45>C;5 1: 171/ E< 4=8 6;51>=9A 45 >5<59>19: 9E( 418 1>E6:5> :45 G7=::59 8:1:5D59: E< >5<59>19:9E
<:57:45>51:4E<CA1991>C7=9A:45659>59@?
E< 67E@55>=9A8 4=8 ;5A1; 75675859:1:=F58 25=9A :45 G=<5 19>>1CA4:57841F5@ED5E975@E7>18>5<59>19:9E8 1# :E @# 19> 41F5 <=;5> 1 856171:5 G7=::59 8:1:5D59: 45 >1CA4:578E<;1:5CA1991G4=;518857:=9A:41::45?G575 A=F59AE;>@18419>E:457F1;C12;567E657:=581::45:=D5 E<D177=1A5:45?41F5A=F59C6:45=7@;1=DJ=9:458C=:E7
- 11 -
9E9/8C=:67E657:=58K:=81>D=::5>:41:>5<59>19:9E8 19>(1751;E9559:=:;5>:E1;;:4567E657:=58;5<:254=9>2? :45>5@5185>6756E8=:C8
+ : =8 865@=<=@1;;? 18857:5> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< =8 1 :E:1;8:719A57:E:45<1D=;?E<:45>5<59>19:819>=8<1;85;? :7?=9A :E 1667E67=1:5 :45 67E657:=58 ;5<: 2? 1@41991 2? @;1=D=9A4=D85;<18:458E9E<1@41991
!'! %45EC7:418<71D5>:45<E;;EG=9A=88C58 % , ! # -. / , ! #
) . 0 ,
1. 2 ,!# ' ! . 3 ,
.4 . 5 ,.+
- 12 -
:=8:E259E:5>:41::45198G57875@E7>5>2? :457=1;EC7:1:6171/&E<:45=D6CA95>BC>AD59:=8=9 F17=1:=E9G=:4:457518E9=9A19>@E9@;C8=E9C@4F17=1:=E9 =89E:5>184575C9>57/ -./012345.042670323 8202 39/4:87;5/< =7<;:/53
5>67.450/>0</<4539/ 0/2.5.539/4..7/.02:/< 88C59E9:451<<=7D1:=F5
88C59E9:451<<=7D1:=F5
88C5 9E8 19> 175 198G575> =9:4595A1:=F5- 88C59E( 9E958C7F=F1;<E7 @E98=>571:=E9
88C5 9E( =8 @E9@;C>5> 18 9E: 8C7F=F=9A<E7@E98=>571:=E9-
88C59E 9E958C7F=F1;<E7 @E98=>571:=E9
88C5 9E =8 198G575> =9 :45 1<<=7D1:=F5-
88C59E 9:4595A1:=F5
88C5 9E =8 198G575> =9 :45 95A1:=F5
@@E7>=9A;? 18 657 :45 7518E9=9A8 75@E7>5> 2? :45 7=1; EC7: :45 198G578 75@E7>5> 1: 6171/& E< :45 =D6CA95>BC>AD59:ECA4::E41F5255918<E;;EG8/ =# 88C59E819>/9:4595A1:=F5- ==# 88C59E(/189E:8C7F=F=9A<E7@E98=>571:=E9 ===# 88C59E/=9:451<<=7D1:=F5 =F# 88C59E/=9:4595A1:=F5
- 13 -
. 45 6;1=9:=<< 418 ;5> =9 5F=>59@5 2? 5L1D=9=9A 4=D85;< 18 $ G4=;5 >5<59>19:8 41F5 ;5> =9 5F=>59@5 :47ECA4 $ :E $( ;1=9:=<< 418 AE: D17H5> >E@CD59:8 18 657 L :E & 19> >5<59>19:8 41F5 D17H5>:45>E@CD59:818657L:E(+
& 45 7=1; EC7: 418 E2857F5> :41: :45 E9;? >=86C:5>@E9:59:=E9=8:41::45>5<59>19:841F5>59=5>:45 75;1:=E984=6E<:456;1=9:=<<G=:4:45BE=9:<1D=;? 45 EC7: 418 :1H59 9E:5 E< :45 8CAA58:=E9 E< 6;1=9:=<< >C7=9A @7E88/5L1D=91:=E9 :41: 1<:57 :45 >51:4 E< 419912181661 17F1:41DD1 @E9:71@:5> 85@E9> D177=1A5 G=:4 1@41991 : 418 4EG5F57 E2857F5> :41:
8C@4 <1@:8 175 12859: =9 :45 6;51>=9A8 )C7:457 =: 418 9E:=@5>:41:=9L:4559:7?E<J17F1:41DD1$E 419912181661K =8 <EC9> 19> 18 75A17>8 8C@4 59:7?
9E 5L6;191:=E9G18<E7:4@ED=9A<7ED:456;1=9:=<<45EC7:
418E2857F5>:41: E..%<=;5>855H=9A>5@;171:=E9 :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 G18 >=8D=885> <E7
- 14 -
9E9/67E85@C:=E9 1H=9A 9E:5 E< :45 1;5 55>8 G4=@4 =9>=@1:5> :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 419912181661 19> 17F1:41DD1 19> E:457 D1:57=1;8 75<5775> :E 12EF5 :45 7=1; EC7: 418 @E9@;C>5> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< 418 <1=;5> :E 67EF5 :41: 45 =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 9 ;=A4: E< 8C@4 <=9>=9A :45 EC7: 418 E2857F5> :41: :45 8CAA58:=E9 :41:
8C=: 67E657:=58 175 BE=9: <1D=;? 67E657:=58 E< 6;1=9:=<< 19> >5<59>19:8 >E58 9E: 17=85 <E7 @E98=>571:=E9 19> 1@@E7>=9A;? 75@E7>5> 1 <=9>=9A 18 75A17>8 =88C5 E =9 :4595A1:=F5=88C59E(<71D5>75A17>=9A8C=:25=9A21> >C5 :E 9E9/BE=9>57 E< 1;; 67E657:=58 =8 >5@;175> 18 9E: 17=8=9A<E7@E98=>571:=E9
EG5F571875A17>8:45@EC9:57/@;1=D:45:7=1;
@EC7: 418 1;;EG5> :45 75;=5< <E7 >5@;171:=E9 @;1=D5> G4=;5 E2857F=9A:41:=9F=5GE<<=9>=9AE9=88C5E=:@1925 :1H59:41::4575;=5<E<@EC9:57/@;1=D8:19>858:12;=845>18 75A17>8:4567E657:=58>58@7=25> @@E7>=9A;?=88C5 E =845;>=9:451<<=7D1:=F59;=A4:E<8C@4758C;:675859: 16651;=8<=;5>
- 15 -
&! (51795>EC985;<E76;1=9:=<<7=1@4=9141B19 4181>F19@5>85F571;@E9:59:=E9819>4188ECA4::ED1H5 EC:1@185<E7>5@755=9A:458C=:
:=8@E9:59>5>:41::45<=9>=9AE<:457=1;EC7: E9=88C59E:41::456;1=9:=<<=89E::458E9E<1@41991 =8577E95EC8:41:1@419914=D85;<41>1>D=::5>:41::45 6;1=9:=<<=84=88E918=85F=>59:<7EDL(G4=@4=8:45 5A=8:71:=E957:=<=@1:5E<:45F54=@;584EG=9A:4591D5E< :45 6;1=9:=<< 25=9A :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 9 :57D8 E< L1@4199141>=9167E@55>=9A25<E75:45148=;>17 84EG9 :45 91D5 E< :45 6;1=9:=<< 18 4=8 8E9 C@41>D=88=E9=:=88:1:5>=82=9>=9AE9CA199119>4=8 @4=;>759 18 :45? 175 @;1=D=9A :45 67E657:? E< 1@41991 19>459@51752EC9>2?1@41991*81>D=88=E9
:=8<C7:457@E9:59>5>:41:E9@51@4199141> 1@H9EG;5>A5>4=D184=88E945GEC;>2559:=:;5>:E:45 67E657:?E<1@41991
- 16 -
+ 51795> EC985; 7=4=F1919> 1:=; GEC;> @E9:59>:41:M1>D=88=E9*E<1@41991GEC;>9E:252=9>=9A E9 :45 >5<59>19:8 G4E 175 >=86C:=9A :45 75;1:=E984=6 E< 6;1=9:=<<G=:41@41991
% : =8 8C2D=::5> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< =9 4=8 @7E88/5L1D=91:=E94181>D=::5>:41:419912181661G18 :45<=78:4C8219>E<4=8DE:45717F1:41DD119>1<:574=8 >51:4845418D177=5>1@41991<8C@4=8:458:19>E< :45 6;1=9:=<< 95@58817? 6;51>=9A8 ECA4: :E 41F5 2559 D1>519>=9:4512859@5E<8C@46;51>=9A9E1DEC9:E< 5F=>59@5@EC;>25;EEH5>=9:E
:=8865@=<=@1;;?@E9:59>5>:41::456;1=9:=<<418 9E:;51>8C<<=@=59:5F=>59@5:E>5DE98:71:5:41:45=8:45 8E9 E< 1@41991 19> 75;=19@5 =8 6;1@5> E9 F17=EC8 >E@CD59:8G4575=9:456;1=9:=<<=8>58@7=25>:E25:458E9 E< 419912181661 L&% =8 :45 1;5 55> >1:5> (&.%+ >58@7=2=9A :45 6;1=9:=<< 18 8E9 E< 419912181661 L/& :E /& G4=@4 75;1:5 :E :45 5@E7> E< =A4:8 84EG :45 91D5 E< 557584 E
- 17 -
419912181661L&G4=@4=8:451;555>2?F=7:C5 E<G4=@417F1:41DD16C7@4185867E657:?=8>58@7=25>18 17F1:41DD1 $E 419912181661 L( =8 :45 166;=@1:=E9 1>>75885> :E :45 148=;>17 75IC58:=9A :45 148=;>17:EDC:1:5:4591D5E<5F171BE557584<7ED :4591D5E<17F1:41DD1$E419912181661
' "!! .517>2E:48=>58 (&45<E;;EG=9A6E=9:817=85<E7>5:57D=91:=E9
(A) $45:457 :45 <=9>=9A E< :45 :7=1; @EC7: E9 88C59E1875A17>8:4575;1:=E984=6E<:45 6;1=9:=<< G=:4 1@41991 @1;;8 <E7 19? =9:57<5759@5N
(B) $45:457 :45 <=9>=9A E< :45 7=1; EC7: 18 75A17>8 @EC9:57 @;1=D 75IC=758 :E 25 1;;EG5>N
(C) $45:457 19? E:457 A7EC9> =8 D1>5 EC: <E7 =9:57<5759@5 G=:4 :45 <=9>=9A8 E< :45 7=1; EC7:N
- 18 -
( :DC8:259E:=@5>:41:6;1=9:=<<418865@=<=@1;;?
18857:5>:41:45=8:458E9E<1@4199119>=:=8E98C@4 218=8 :41: :45 75;=5< =9 :45 8C=: E< A719:=9A 1 >5@755 E< 617:=:=E9 19> 1;;E::=9A E95 41;< =9 :45 8C=: 8@45>C;5 67E657:=58:E:456;1=9:=<<18G5;;186188=9AE<1>5@755E< 856171:56E88588=E91<:578C@4>=F=8=E9=88ECA4:<E7
( 45 1>D=::5> <1@:8 25=9A :41: 1D61991 41> :GE8E98F=O1@4199119>CA1991456;1=9:=<<@;1=D8 :E25:458E9E<1@41991:=8:45865@=<=@@185E<:45 >5<59>19:8:41:1@41991>=5>181!1@45;E719>:41::45 6;1=9:=<<G189E:4=88E92C::458E9E<17F1:41DD119> 419912181661 @@E7>=9A;?=:=8@E9:59>5>:41:6;1=9:=<< =818:719A57:E:45<1D=;?E<1D61991
((45>5<59>19:8=9E7>57:E6C:<E7:4:45=7@185 41F5 75;=5> E9 FE;CD=9EC8 5F=>59@5 :E @E9:59> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< G18 :45 8E9 2E79 :E 17F1:41DD1 19> 419912181661
- 19 -
( 45 <E;;EG=9A 175 :45 >E@CD59:8 D17H5> =9 5F=>59@5 G4=@4 GEC;> =9>=@1:5 :41: 17F1:41DD1 19> 419912181661 G575 D177=5> :E 51@4 E:457 19> :45 6;1=9:=<< G18 1;8E >58@7=25> 18 :45=7 8E9 =9 >E@CD59:8 D17H5>185F=>59@5C@4E<:45>E@CD59:8G4=@4GEC;> 58:12;=84:4512EF575;1:=E984=6D17H5>=95F=>59@517518 <E;;EG8 =# L&% =8 :45 1;5 55> 5L5@C:5> E9 (&.%+ =9 <1FEC7 E< :45 6;1=9:=<< G4575=9 91D5E<:456;1=9:=<<=8>58@7=25>18557584 E419912181661 ==# L( =8 :45 166;=@1:=E9 A=F59 2? :45 6;1=9:=<< :E :45 148=;>17 8:1:=9A :41:
@E985IC59: :E :45 >51:4 E< 4=8 DE:457 17F1:41DD1 $E
419912181661 67E657:=58 8:19>=9A =9 457 91D5 D1? 25 @419A5>=9:E:4591D5E<4=88E95F171B9 :45 81=> >E@CD59: 6;1=9:=<< >58@7=258 4=8 DE:457 18 17F1:41DD1 $E 419912181661 19> 4=D85;< 18 557584 E 419912181661 ===# L =8 1 )1D=;? 755 G4575=9 6;1=9:=<< =8 >58@7=25>:E25:458E9E<419912181661
- 20 -
=F# L+ =8 :45 51:4 57:=<=@1:5 E< 17F1:41DD119>91D5E<4C8219>=884EG9 18419912181661 F# L%E:578=8:E<:45?517.84EG8 :45 91D5 E< 17F1:41DD1 19> 457 4C8219> 419912181661
( 4575 175 E:457 75F59C5 59:7=58 1;8E G4=@4 GEC;> =9>=@1:5 557584 18 25=9A :45 8E9 E< 419912181661 8C@4 18 L. .+ .% . .. & &&(&19>&+91;;8C@45@E7>E<=A4:8:45 91D5 E< :45 6;1=9:=<< =8 84EG9 18 557584 E 419912181661
(+ 45 12EF5 >E@CD59:8 25=9A 59:7=58 =9 6C2;=@ 75@E7>8 175 75IC=75> :E 25 A=F59 >C5 5F=>59:=17? G5=A4:1A5 18 25=9A 75@E7>8 6756175> 2? EF579D59:
<<=@=1;8 19> 6758CD6:=E9 =9 :57D8 E< 5@:=E9 E< :45 9>=19F=>59@5 @:%:41:8C@459:7=5817575<;5@:=F5 E<E<<=@=1;1@:875AC;17;?657<E7D5>
1 Illustration E to Section 114
- 21 -
(% 45 6;1=9:=<< =9 4=8 @7E88/5L1D=91:=E9 418 >56E85>18C9>57
“
! "# $ %& '() * +
" , -./0"- #1 *+ 234( 56-./0!7$-8)9 *+
:; ,49 *46 -./0 5 / < =9 $4 !7 >? ? " ? 5! >?5 74!7 >? $ > !$ $ ?
-5( *8 / < =9 74
1)9 $ @ 8 ,$1 ABC(3$7 ,49D?)4 * + ,EC *:F $ 5 / < =9
1) %G& '# H 21 *I+%G&5/ < =9 !7 , -./0 " > " $ > *8 @ -!J 9K :; ,49D?)4 * + L M
( < =: =8 :45 8:19> :41: 1@41991 D177=5> 17F1:41DD1 8C285IC59:;? 19> 1@@E7>=9A;? 6;1=9:=<< G18 @;1=D=9A18;5A1;45=7E<1@4199118G5;;8C@4@185ECA4:
- 22 -
:E41F5255985:C62?865@=<=@6;51>=9AG4=@4=812859: 9@5:45G7=::598:1:5D59:=8<=;5>>59?=9A75;1:=E984=6E< 6;1=9:=<<G=:41@41991*8<1D=;?:456;1=9:=<<ECA4::E41F5 <=;5> 1>>=:=E91; 6;51>=9A8 G=:4 657D=88=E9 E< :45 EC7:
85::=9A C6 4=8 >5<59@5 865@=<=@1;;? :41: 45 =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 =9 :57D8 E< 7>57 C;5 . E< E>5 E< =F=;
7E@5>C75 E7 1:;518: ECA4: :E 41F5 71=85> 8C@4 @185 2? <=;=9A7586E985:E:45@EC9:57@;1=D
(. :=8:4585::;5>6E8=:=E9E<;1G:41:9E1DEC9:
E< 5F=>59@5 G=:4EC: 6;51>=9A @19 25 ;EEH5> =9:E 45 7=1; EC7: 418 1;8E 7=A4:;? 9E:=@5> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< 418 9E: 6C:<E7:4 6;51>=9A8 18 :E G459 45 25@1D5 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 9;588 :45 @185 :41: 1@41991 D177=5> 17F1:41DD1 =8 85: C6 19> 5F=>59@5 =9 8C66E7: E< 8C@4 @185G18;51>25<E75:45EC7::45IC58:=E9E<1@@56:=9A :45 @E9:59:=E9 :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 >E58 9E: 17=85 4ECA4 =9 :45 ;1::57 6E8=:=E9 E< :45 81D5
2As held by the Bench of Three Judges of the Apex Court in Biraji @ Biraji & Another v. Surya Pratap and Others – (2020) 10 SCC 729 that in the absence of pleading, no amount of evidence will help the party. - 23 -
>56E8=:=E9:4575=8195<<E7::EG1:57>EG9:451>D=88=E9 :45 6;1=9:=<<*8 1>D=88=E9 :41: 419912181661 19> 17F1:41DD1G5754=8<1:45719>DE:4578:=;;75D1=98
& 45 @E9:59:=E9 1>F19@5> 1: :45 :=D5 E< 17ACD59:8 25<E75 :4=8 EC7: :41: 1@419991 41> :751:5> :456;1=9:=<<184=88E9185F=>59@5>2?67E@55>=9A825<E75 :45 148=;>17 18 657 L @E6? E< :45 5A=8:71:=E9 57:=<=@1:5 E< :45 F54=@;5 1: L( 418 :45 5<<5@: E< 2=9>=9A :45 >5<59>19: @199E: 25 1@@56:5> : =8 :45 865@=<=@@185E<:45>5<59>19::41:6;1=9:=<<=89E::458E9 E<1@4199145>5<59>19:8G4E@;1=D:47ECA4CA1991 2185:45=77=A4:818675<5759:=1;45=78E<1@4199119>=9 :4512859@5E<19?@4=;>759:E1@41991:45?=9457=::45 67E657:? E< 1@41991 =9 :57D8 E< ;1G E< 8C@@588=E9( <8C@4=8:45 7=A4:E<8C@@588=E9 6C:<E7:4 2? >5<59>19:8
3Section 11 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 is extracted as follows:- 11.
Distribution of property among heirs in class II of the Schedule.– The property of an intestate shall be divided between the heirs specified in any one entry in class II of the Schedule so that they, share equally. - 24 -
8C@4=9>5659>59:7=A4:@199E:25>5<51:5>C9;5886;1=9:=<< 67EF58:41:45=8:458E9E<1@41991
451;;5A5>1>D=88=E9E<1@41991:41:6;1=9:=<< =8 4=8 8E9 >E58 9E: @E9<57 :45 6;1=9:=<<8 G=:4 :45 ;5A1; @161@=:? E< 8E9 8E 18 :E >=86;1@5 :45 7=A4:8 @;1=D5> 2? CA1991*8 @4=;>759 18 675<5759:=1; 45=78 =9 ;1G 45 1;;5A5>1>D=88=E9E<1@41991:751:=9A:456;1=9:=<<184=8 8E9@199E:2=9>CA1991*845=784ECA4:4575175@57:1=9 >E@CD59:88C@418L%G4=@4=8:457198<5757:=<=@1:5 G4=@4 84EG8 :45 91D5 E< 557584 19> <1:457*8 91D5 18 1@4199119>DE:457*891D51817F1:41DD14EG5F57 8C@4 >E@CD59: >E58 9E: =9 19? G1? 41F5 :45 5<<5@: E< @E9@;C8=F5;? 67EF=9A :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991
9 16675@=1:=E9 E< :45 59:=75:? E< 5F=>59@5 GEC;> E9;? =9>=@1:5 :41: 6;1=9:=<< G18 :45 8E9 E< 17F1:41DD1 19> 419912181661 18 >56E85> 2? :45 6;1=9:=<<=9:45@7E88/5L1D=91:=E9
- 25 -
( :D1?25:41:17F1:41DD1D177=5>1@41991 8C285IC59:;? EG5F57 8C@4 @185 =8 9E: 6;51>5> 19> C9;5886;51>5>9E1DEC9:E<5F=>59@5@EC;>2575;=5>E9 :E 58:12;=84 8C@4 75;1:=E984=6 @@E7>=9A;? :45 <=9>=9A E< :45 :7=1; @EC7: :41: 6;1=9:=<< =8 9E: :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 75IC=7581@@56:19@5
45@EC9:57@;1=D4182559<=;5>2?:45E7=A=91;
>5<59>19: E CA1991 @E9:59>=9A :41: 1<:57 75@5=6: E< EC7:9E:=@5:456;1=9:=<<418@ED5:EH9EG75A17>=9A:45 6;1=9:=<<41F=9A59:575>4=891D51875A17>8:4567E657:? =9 :5D E8 :E E< :45 G7=::59 8:1:5D59: 8@45>C;5 67E657:=58
45 671?57 8ECA4: =9 :45 @EC9:57 @;1=D =8 :41: :45>5<59>19:=8:45128E;C:5EG957E<:45@45>C;5;19>8 19>:41:19E7>57E<=9BC9@:=E925 61885>758:71=9=9A:45 6;1=9:=<<*8 =9:57<5759@5 45 6;1=9:=<< 9E: 41F=9A <=;5> :45 G7=::598:1:5D59::E:45@EC9:57@;1=D:457=1;EC7:418 >5@755> :45 @EC9:57 @;1=D : =8 E2857F5> :41: :45 =88C5 9E 418 2559 45;> =9 :45 95A1:=F5 4E;>=9A :41: :45
- 26 -
6;1=9:=<<418<1=;5>:E67EF5:41:45=8:458E9E<1@41991 19>41867E@55>5>:E4E;>:41::456;1=9:=<<=8:45EG957E< :45G7=::598:1:5D59:@EC9:57@;1=D67E657:=58
+ 51795> @EC985; <E7 :45 6;1=9:=<< 418 @E9:59>5> :41: :45 @EC9:57 @;1=D DC8: 25 M1A1=98: :45 @;1=D E< :45 6;1=9:=<<*19>=9:45675859:@185:45@EC9:57@;1=D75;1:58 :E67E657:=58:41:1759E:1617:E<:45;1=9:8@45>C;5
% : DC8: 25 9E:=@5> :41: :45 @;1=D =9 :45 8C=: 75;1:58 :E :45 67E657:=58 8:1:5> :E 25 :45 BE=9: <1D=;? 67E657:=58 E< 1D61991 G4E G18 8C7F=F5> 2? 1@41991 19>CA1991456;1=9:=<<85:8C64=8@;1=D18:458E9E< 1@41991
45@EC9:57/@;1=D189E:=@5>12EF575;1:58:E:45 6;1=9:=<<41F=9AAE:75F59C575@E7>859:575>=9:E4=891D5 @;1=D=9A :E 8C@@55> :E 1@41991*8 84175 !E:4 :45 8C=: 19>@EC9:57@;1=D75;1:5:E:4518857:=E9E<:456;1=9:=<<18 :458E9E<1@41991
- 27 -
. @@E7>=9A;? =: @19 25 8:1:5> :41: :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D =8 M1A1=98: :45 @;1=D E< :45 6;1=9:=<<* G4=;5 :456;1=9:=<<855H8<E7617:=:=E9E<BE=9:<1D=;?67E657:=58E9 :45 675D=85 :41: 45 =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 19> 1@@E7>=9A;?41817=A4:=9:4567E657:=58;5<:EC:2?4=D :45 @EC9:57 @;1=D 855H8 <E7 1 75;=5< E< >5@;171:=E9 18 75A17>867E657:=58@;1=D5>2?:456;1=9:=<<=9:45@161@=:?
E<1@41991*88E9
& )C7:457 =: DC8: 25 9E:=@5> :41: :45 8@E65 E< @EC9:57 @;1=D 418 9EG 2559 59;17A5> 1<:57 :45 1D59>D59: :E E>5 E< =F=; 7E@5>C75 45 E2857F1:=E98 E< 65L EC7: :47EG8 ;=A4: E9 :45 G=>5 1D6;=:C>5 E< :45 @EC9:57 @;1=D =9 :45 @185 E< #2; &925 92?62 @ 539/0F/022<92!?2:4!23.25;@39/0.19> :4575;5F19:E2857F1:=E9817518<E;;EG8 3"
""" 4
)% - 5
#
4 %665)2 566#
- 28 -
1
" #
" 4
"
+
!'
"
''"
! " '
! 7
"4
# ! )#
! " 4 #
- 29 -
! ! ! 1
"
"8
! - 5
9
"4
"
'
" :! #
#
#
"$#
#
""""+
9:45675859:@185=:=81;8E:E259E:=@5>:41: 7>57C;5+E<E>5E<=F=;7E@5>C75:456;1=9:=<<=8 59:=:;5> :E 855H <E7 5L@;C8=E9 E< @EC9:57/@;1=D <7ED :45 67E@55>=9A819>D1?166;?:E:45EC7:<E719E7>57:41: :45@EC9:57/@;1=D25<=;5>181856171:58C=:C@4E6:=E9 4189E:25595L57@=85>
- 30 -
ED=9A :E :45 D57=:8 E< :45 @185 85: C6 =9 :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D1::45EC:85:75@E7>8>E9E:75F5;:41:19? 6;51>=9A =8 <=;5> 25<E75 :45 :7=1; EC7: E66E8=9A :45 @EC9:57@;1=D45@EC9:57/@;1=D855H8<E7>5@;171:=E9:41: :45>5<59>19:=8:45EG957E<:458@45>C;567E657:=5819> :41: :45 6;1=9:=<< ECA4: 9E: :E =9:57<575 G=:4 :45 81=> 67E657:=58
( 45 :7=1; EC7: 418 1;;EG5> :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D G4=;5E2857F=9A:41:E9@5=88C59E=9:458C=:=845;>=9 :4595A1:=F519>:456;1=9:=<<4189E:67EF5>:41:45=8:45 8E9E<1@4199119>18:4567E657:=5825;E9A:E1@41991 :45@EC9:57/@;1=D75IC=758:E251;;EG5>
: DC8: 25 9E:=@5> :41: :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D G18 <=;5> 2? CA1991 G459 45 G18 1;=F5 45 67=D17? 1;;5A1:=E9D1>5=8:41:6;1=9:=<<418AE:4=891D5=9857:5> =9 :45 75F59C5 75@E7>8 18 75A17>8 :45 67E657:=58 E< 1@41991
- 31 -
8 9E:=@5> 2? :45 :7=1; EC7: :45 6;1=9:=<< 418 <1=;5> :E 58:12;=84 :41: 45 =8 :45 8E9 E< 1@41991 G4=@4 @E9@;C8=F5;?67EF58:41::456;1=9:=<<@199E:@;1=D7=A4:8:E :4567E657:=58E<1@41991181;5A1;45=7E<1@41991
+4567E657:=58@;1=D5>=9:45@EC9:57/@;1=D175/ ;E C7F5?E =881 E 518C75D59:
@75
C9:1 # %
&/
# %
&/ & (# %
&/ & # + / &/ ( # &
&/
;;67E657:=588=:C1:5>1: 7E;==;;1A5
% 98E<E7 18 =:5D E8 :E ( E< :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D F=O ?E% D518C7=9A AC9:18 ?E%
D518C7=9A1@75&AC9:1819>%
D518C7=9A 1@75 AC9:18 $/ :45 6;1=9:=<< 1>D=:8 :41: :45 67E657:=58 175 :45 85;</1@IC=75> 67E657:=58 E< 1@41991 451>D=88=E975@E7>5>E9&&751>818<E;;EG8
"$"/;3< <% % %5
"$"/;3< </ )%%=
# "$"/;3 )32
! - 32 -
! - 7
"+
9 :45 12859@5 E< 19? 75A=8:575> >E@CD59: 2? 1@41991@E9F5?=9A:4567E657:?:E:456;1=9:=<<45@EC;> 9E:41F5AE::4575F59C559:7=58=94=891D5 @@E7>=9A;? 1;;EG=9AE<:45@EC9:57/@;1=D2?:45:7=1;EC7:1875A17>8 8C@467E657:=5875IC=758:E25C645;>9E:=@=9A:41::4575 G189EG7=::598:1:5D59:<=;5>:E:45@EC9:57/@;1=D
. =D=;17;? 18 75A17>8 ?E+ :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D @45>C;5 7E657:?
1: :5D E E< 7E;= F=;;1A5 G18 6C7@4185>2?CA199118657:451;555>1:L&9 ;=A4:E<1;555>=:85;<8:19>=9A=9:4591D5E<CA1991 :45IC58:=E9E<:456;1=9:=<<@;1=D=9A19?7=A4:8=9:4581=> 67E657:? >E58 9E: 17=85 19> 1@@E7>=9A;? :45 1;;EG=9A E< :45@EC9:57/@;1=D1875A17>88C@4=:5D@199E:25<1C;:5>
+& 98E<17 18 =:5D 9E E< :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D F=O ?E&M *D518C7=9A1@758AC9:18:4581D5G18 6C7@4185> 2? 1A1DD1 $E 1D61991 :45 DE:457 E< 1@41991 19> CA1991 =9 =:5D8 E< :45 1;5 55> 1:
- 33 -
L :45 *8 8:19> =9 :45 91D5 E< 1A1DD1 $E 1D6199118657L(%:E9;=A4:E<8C@475@E7>8 :4581?E<:456;1=9:=<<:41:=:25;E9A8:E4=8DE:457@199E:
25 1@@56:5> 19> :45 @;1=D 85: C6 =9 :45 @EC9:57/@;1=D 75IC=758:E25>5@755>
+4ECA4:45:7=1;EC7:4189E:>51;:=9>5:1=;18 75A17>8 :45 75@E7>8 67E>C@5> =9 8C66E7: E< :45 @EC9:57/ @;1=D 4EG5F57 :4=8 EC7: =9 ;=A4: E< :45 5F=>59@5 E9 75@E7>1<<=7D8:45@E9@;C8=E9E<:7=1;EC7:=9:57D8E<:45 >=8@C88=E9D1>512EF5
+ 9;=A4:E<:45>=8@C88=E9D1>54575=912EF5:45 6E=9:8 <E7 >5:57D=91:=E9 F=O # 19> # 175 45;> =9 95A1:=F519>6E=9: !#=845;>=91<<=7D1:=F5
@@E7>=9A;? )
E+&(& 19> ) E&&&%&(175
!$$
$
45 6;1=9:=<</1665;;19: 418 <=;5> 19 166;=@1:=E9 C9>57 7>57 C;5 % E< E>5 E< =F=; 7E@5>C75 855H=9A :E
- 34 -
67E>C@5:451>>=:=E91;>E@CD59:8C@4166;=@1:=E9=8<=;5> 1;E9AG=:4:45D5DE719>CDE<16651;
: DC8: 25 9E:=@5> :41: 7=A4: :E 67E>C@5 1>>=:=E91; 5F=>59@5=89E:19C9IC1;=<=5>7=A4:45 65LEC7:=9:45 @185E<5455<42F-0294:<<4525<539/0 418@;17=<=5>:458@E65E<8C@4166;=@1:=E98:=8E2857F5> :41: :45 67EF=8=E9 >E58 9E: 166;? G459 E9 :45 218=8 E< 5F=>59@5 E9 75@E7> :45 665;;1:5 EC7: @19 67E9EC9@5 1 81:=8<1@:E7? BC>AD59: : =8 1;8E 865@=<=5> :41: :45 81=> 67EF=8=E9@199E:25D1>5C85E<2?1617:?:E@EF57:45=7 ;16858 :6171/&=:=8E2857F5>:41::45=91>F57:59@5E< :45 617:? :E C9>578:19> :45 ;5A1; =88C58 =9FE;F5> E7 :45 G7E9A 1>F=85 E< 1 6;51>57 G45752? 617:? >=> 9E: 751;=O5 =D6E7:19@5 E< :45 >E@CD59: GEC;> 9E: @E98:=:C:5 J8C28:19:=1;@1C85KG=:4=9:45D519=9AE<:45C;5
5 (2012) 8 SCC 148
- 35 -
9 ;=A4: E< :45 12EF5 8@E65 E< 7>57 C;5 % E< :45675859:166;=@1:=E9E<:456;1=9:=<<75IC=758:E25 @E98=>575>
:=8@;517:41::455F=>59@5E975@E7>1875<5775>:E 2?:4=8EC7:=9:45BC>AD59:GEC;>D1H5=:@;517:41::45 D1:57=1;E975@E7>=88C<<=@=59::E67E9EC9@5:45BC>AD59:
:41: :4=8 EC7: =8 E< :45 F=5G :41: 9E E@@18=E9 17=858 <E7 657D=::=9A:451>>=:=E91;5F=>59@5:E@ED5E975@E7>G4=@4 GEC;>188=8::45EC7::E759>57:45BC>AD59:
457518E98188=A95>=9:451<<=>1F=:<=;5>=98C66E7: E<166;=@1:=E9=8:E:455<<5@::41:C6E9;5A1;1>F=851::45 :=D5 E< <=;=9A E< :45 16651; 1<:57 >=8@C88=E9 G=:4 :45 @EC985; 45 855H8 :E 67E>C@5 >E@CD59:8 :E 58:12;=84 4=8 @185
:=8<C7:4571F5775>:41:45G189E:1>F=85>67E657;? >C7=9A:45659>59@?E<:458C=:19>=9;=A4:E<=A9E719@5E< 67E@5>C75 19> ;1G 45 41> 9E: 67E>C@5> :45 >E@CD59:8
- 36 -
25<E75:45:7=1;EC7:19>G18C91G175E<:45=D6E7:19@5 19>75;5F19@5E<:4E85>E@CD59:8
: DC8: 25 9E:=@5> :41: 1DE9A8: :45 >E@CD59:8 8ECA4: :E 25 67E>C@5> 67E@55>=9A8 =9 :45 <E7D E< 6;51>=9A8 =9 :45 8C=:8 659>=9A 25:G559 :45 617:=58 =9 E8..%19>((..+1758ECA4::E2567E>C@5>
:=8:E259E:=@5>:41:25<E75:45:7=1;EC7:8ED5E< :45 >E@CD59:8 75;1:=9A :E E8..% 19> ((..+ 41F5 1;751>? 2559 67E>C@5> 18 L& ;1=9: =9 E((..+# 19> L ;1=9: =9 E..%# 45 1>>=:=E91; >E@CD59:8 =9 :45 ;=8: 1: ;E8 :E 75;1:5:E:4581=>8C=:819>1@@E7>=9A;?ECA4::E41F52559 67E>C@5>1::45<=78:=98:19@5=9:45:7=1;19>:45675859:
1::5D6: :E 67E>C@5 8C@4 >E@CD59:8 =9 :45 1665;;1:5 67E@55>=9A8 G=:4EC: 19?
1@@56:12;5 7518E9 DC8: 25 @E98:7C5> :E 25 19 1::5D6: :E =D67EF=85 :45=7 @185 19> @EF57 C6 :45 ;16858 G4=@4 =8 =D657D=88=2;5 19> 1@@E7>=9A;?758E7::E67E@55>=9A8C9>57 7>57C;5% E<ECA4:9E::E251;;EG5>
- 37 -
45>E@CD59:8=9:45;=8:1995L5>:E:45166;=@1:=E9 1: ;E8+ :E & 75;1:5 :E :45 67E@55>=9A8 25<E75 :45 7=D=91; EC7: 19> 9E:4=9A 675F59:5> :45 6;1=9:=<< <7ED 67E>C@=9A 8C@4 >E@CD59:8 >C7=9A :45 @EC785 E< :7=1;
ED5 E< :45 >E@CD59:8 75;1:5 :E :45 8:1:5D59:8 D1>5 G4=@4 2? :45D85;F58 G=;; 9E: 25 8C28:19:=F5 6=5@5 E< 5F=>59@5 C9;588 :45 1C:4E78 E< 8C@4 8:1:5D59: 175 5L1D=95> C@4 E< :45 G=:958858 @EC;> 41F5 2559 8CDDE95>25<E75:45:7=1;EC7:19>9E:41F=9A>E958E :45675859:5<<E7::E75@:=<?8C@4;1685=89E:657D=88=2;5
@@E7>=9A;? 9E A7EC9>8 175 D1>5 EC: :E 657D=:
1>>C@=9A E< 1>>=:=E91; 5F=>59@5 18 8ECA4: <E7 18 5F59 =< 8C@45F=>59@5G575:E25657D=::5>:E@ED5E975@E7>=:
GEC;>9E:@419A5:45EC:@ED5E7@E9@;C8=E9177=F5>1:2? :4=8EC7:
- 38 -
@@E7>=9A;? :45 166;=@1:=E9 <E7 67E>C@:=E9 E< 1>>=:=E91;>E@CD59:8=875B5@:5>
!<*
(!! "') #
!<*
(#! ) #
=8:E;E