Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9777 (KAR)

BHIMABAI v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/201098/2019 · 2025-02-01

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " "!# #$ % &'"' (" ") !"# $ % & ! ' !"# '' ' ( ' !"! ) ' ( ' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - !"# !"# ! ) !"# $ % ' * ' ' !& ' # ' ' ' +++, ' +",!+++ )-' ' ' ' ./ - 3 - 0 ! 12 3245456728 19: ;19<<27=2> 412 9336574?274 6@ 82:367>274 6! 46 412 36:4 6@ 7=97A9>5 12<328 94 B>79< 197>9 57 428?: 6@ 412 68>28 C29857= 6 >942> +++, 39::2>CD82:367>2746)1219:9<:6:6B=14@689 >582;4567 46 82:367>274 6: 46 46 9336574 128 9: 7=97A9>512<32894B>79<197>9 12 3245456728 ;<95?: 4194 :12 C2<67=: 46 97E9896??B754D97>19::4B>52>B346,41:497>98>97> 5: 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79< 2:367>274 6 5::B2> 9 7645@5;94567 >942> +#++" 57F5457= 933<5;94567: @68 7=97A9>512<32894B>79<197>9+97>641283<9;2: 12 3245456728 933<52> 46 412 :95> 36:4 97> 82:367>274 6!9<:6933<52>1282:367>2746:46)82E2;42>412 933<5;94567 6@ 412 3245456728 67 412 =86B7> 4194 :12 A9: 764 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79< 197>9 CB4 A9: 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79<89?416B=154A9:?2745672>5741282:5>27459< - 4 - ;2845@5;942 4194 412 3245456728 5: 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79< 197>9 89? B>79< 12 3245456728 ;67427>: 4194 82:367>274 6! 19> :4B>52> 67<D B346 "41 :497>98> 97> 41282@682:125:C24428GB9<5@52>419782:367>2746!97> 5:41282@68227454<2>46C293365742> ) 12 A854 32454567 5: 6336:2> CD 82:367>274 6: 46 A16 ;67427>2> 4194 41822 933<5;94567: A282 82;25F2>@6841236:46@7=97A9>512<32897>82:367>274 6! A9: 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79< 197>9 97> 41282@682128 933<5;94567 A9: ;67:5>282> 4 5: ;67427>2> 4194 57 412 82:5>27459< ;2845@5;942 :BC?5442> CD 412 3245456728 54 A9: :16A7 4194 :12 A9:982:5>274 6@B>79<F5<<9=2 97> 764 B>79<197>997>41282@682128933<5;94567A9:82E2;42> 29872> ;6B7:2< @68 82:367>274 6! 9<:6 825428942>4129C6F2;674274567: ! 127 415: A854 32454567 A9: <5:42> C2@682 415: 6B84 67 +)+ 415: 6B84 >582;42> 412 91:5<>98 B>>2C519< 46 ;67>B;4 97 27GB58D 9: 46 A124128 412 3245456728 5: 9 82:5>274 6@ B>79< 197>9 68 F5<<9=2 97> - 5 - :BC?54 9 823684 7 ++ 9 823684 A9: 3<9;2> CD 412 <29872> 5=1 6B84 6F287?274 <29>28 A16 ;67427>2>419441227GB58DCD41291:5<>9882F29<2>4194 41232454567285:82:5>57=57B>79<F5<<9=297>4194B>79< F5<<9=297>197>998267297>412:9?21282@682415: 6B84 @2<4 4194 412 829:67 @68 82E2;457= 412 ;<95? 6@ 412 3245456728 A9: 764 ;6882;4 6A2F28 415: 6B84 7645;2> 4194 82:367>274 6! A9: 9<829>D A68H57= 9: 7=97A9>5 12<328 @86? 412 D298 +, 97>41282@682 ;9<<2> B367 412 29872> >>545679< 6F287?274 >F6;942 46 F285@D A12412882:367>2746! ;6B<>C2 9;;6??6>942> 57 97D 64128 7=97A9>5 7 82:367:2 46 415: <29872> >>545679< 6F287?274 >F6;942 @958<D ;67;2>2: 9@428 6C495757= 57:48B;4567: @86? 82:367>274 6 4194 41282 5: 9 F9;974 36:54567 6@ 7=97A9>5 12<328 57 9<5H642 ;54D 97> 4194 82:367>2746!;6B<>C29;;6??6>942>5741943<9;2 # 7 F52A 6@ 412 9C6F2 412 @6<<6A57= 68>28 5: 39::2> - 6 - ! %5& 12 85424545675: %55& 12 68>28 >942> +++, 39::2> CD 82:367>274 6) 933657457= 82:367>274 6! 9: 7=97A9>5 12<328 94 B>79< 197>9 5: GB9:12> %555& 2:367>274 6) 5: >582;42> 46 9336574 412 3245456728 9: 7=97A9>5 12<328 94 B>79< 197>9@6841A541 %5F& 2:367>274 6: 46 982 >582;42> 46 49H2 5??2>5942:423:46933657482:367>2746!9: 7=97A9>512<328949<5H642A128241236:46@ 7=97A9>512<3285:<5H2<D46@9<<F9;97457F52A 6@ 412 386?64567 46 412 36:4 6@ 7=97A9>5 68H28 %F& 15::19<< C2 ;6?3<52> A54157 9 32856> 6@41822 ?6741: @86? 412 >942 6@ 82;2534 6@ 9 ;2845@52> ;63D6@415:68>28 "*+ (') '! 5:46<6)!