Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9760 (KAR)

THE BRANCH MANAGER v. SRI. MOHAMMED FAYAZ AND ANR

MFA/200489/2020 · 2025-02-04

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " # # $$% & ' () $$% & ' ( ) ! "#$ " % &'()# '*+(,) # - "(+ " % LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date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