- 1 - ! "" #! $ %&!!! "' $ %&!&! ## ( ) ! " #$ % & ' ( ( )*$$$ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! )+!$! # ((( ,)+!$! ((&' - ( * * ( . " ! ( + " #$ ( - # ( $ * ( - 3 - " " * ( ( ! (( ((( ( % & (#/ (' "( ( " ( " !$$$#!$! #$$!$! ("" ( ( " ( " 0 0 - 4 - &% & 0 ' 123415 556768429 8:134;147 5:8<271 2<<1=7> 4876<1?8331>=845147 8>78# @1=176768413>A1?8317@1912341564B91 C5B1D@8 D131 7@1 5@E2F>@2 245 7@1 =25@E2F>@2 8? 7@1 29@236 32; 24<@2E27 @2:1 <29915 64 GC1>7684 7@1 <8331<741>> 8?835138?7@1912341564B91 C5B1D@131AE7@163=1767684 <2;1 78 A1 31H1<715 "367 =1767684 D2> ?6915 AE 7@1 5@E2F>@2 245 =25@E2F>@2 <29964B 64 GC1>7684 <8331<741>> 8? 7@1 4876<1 6>>C15 AE 7@1 >>6>7247 8;;6>>68413 ?6I64B 7@1 5271 ?83 <84>651364B 7@1 J;87684 8?48<84?6514<1K ! @1 =176768413> @25 <@29914B15 7@1 >2;1 A1?831 7@1912341564B91 C5B12>>13764B7@277@131D2>48<9123 52E>K 4876<1 @1 >265 2>=1<7 D2> <84>651315 AE 7@1 9123415 64B91 C5B1 245 2 51726915 83513 @2> A114 =2>>15@1912341564B91 C5B15C364B7@1=14514<E8? =38<11564B>5631<7157@18:134;1475:8<27178>1<C31 - 5 - 7@1?6913192764B78J48<84?6514<1;87684K=38<11564B>245 C=84 =13C>29 8? 7@1 >2;1 67 D2> 4876<15 7@27 7@1 =176768413> @25 31<16:15 <8=E 8? 7@1 4876<1 AC7 @25 487 ;23F157@15271>D@6912<F48D915B64B7@131<16=78?>C<@ 4876<1CA>1GC1479E7@124<@2E271:198=;147??6<13 @25>CA;67715231=83772F64B7@1>72457@277@1>13:6<18? 4876<1 D2> <8;=91715 84 7@1 =176768413> 84 !!!$! 245 !!!$! 31>=1<76:19E (C37@13 7@1 24<@2E27 1:198=;147??6<13D2>5631<71578?691242??652:67D@6<@ D2>5841>72764B7@277@14876<18?7@1;11764B<84:1415 78 <84>6513 J;87684 8? 48 <84?6514<1K D2> >13:15 84 =176768413 8 84 !!!$! 245 84 =176768413 8! 84 !!!$! =84 72F64B 4871 8? 7@1 >2;1 7@1 9123415 64B91 C5B1@2>56>;6>>157@1=1767684@18A>13:27684> ;251 AE 7@1 9123415 64B91 C5B1 27 =232>. 245 + 231 1I732<7152>C4513 L - 6 - !"#$!#!"% & ' ( !)$!!#!* + , !*$!!#!* !"$!!#!* % &'( !*$!!#!*% %&'( !-#$!#!" + $ !*$!!#!" + ! !"$!!#!* - &'(% !*$!!#!* !"$!!#!* .% $##$!#!" $" $" .% - 7 - + ! .% / # 4 7@1 =31>147 =38<11564B> 9123415 <8C4>19 ?83 7@1=176768413>>CA;67>7@27;1319E72F64B7@15271D@14 4876<1 6> 56>=27<@15 D8C95 487 A1 >C??6<6147 ?C37@13 67 6> =8647158C77@277@124<@2E271:198=;147??6<13277@1 ?63>7 64>724<1 @25 ?C346>@15 2 31=837 52715 !*!!$! 14<98>64B 7@1 <1376?6<271 ?83 @2:64B >13:15 4876<1 8D1:13 67 6> >CA;67715 7@27 7@1 >265 31<16=7> 565 487 @2:1 5271>84 D@6<@4876<1>D13131<16:15245676>849E >CA>1GC1479E647@131=83784$!$!7@277@15271>8? 31<16=78?4876<1AE=176768413 8>245!D131=38:6515 ?832>!!!$!245!!!$! 7 6> >CA;67715 7@27 7@8CB@ 7@1 =176768413> @25 31<16:15 4876<1 2<<83564B 78 7@1 =176768413> 4876<1 D2> 31<16:15 849E 84 !*!!$! 8D1:13 9123415 84 7@187@13@245>CA;67>7@276496B@78?2;A6BC67E2??652:67 @2> A114 ?6915 AE 7@1 24<@2E27 1:198=;147 ??6<13 64 - 8 - 713;>8?7@131=8378?7@124<@2E271:198=;147??6<13 52715$!$!7@1>2;1;C>7A172F1478A17@15271 8? >13:6<1 2> 7@1 24<@2E27 1:198=;147 ??6<13 6> 24 8??6<6298?7@132;24<@2E27 ?713@2:64B@1235A87@>651>67;C>7A14876<15 7@27 7@1 =36;23E <847147684 6> 31B23564B 52E>K <9123 4876<15;677159E7@1;11764BD2>?6I1584$$!$! @1?2<731B23564B>13:6<18?4876<16>48756>=C715"@27 D2>56>=C715D2>849E7@152718?>13:6<18?4876<1@1 24<@2E27 1:198=;147 ??6<13 @2> ?6915 24 2??652:67 7@27 =176768413 8 @2> 31<16:15 4876<1 84 !!!$! 245 =176768413 8!84!!!$!@1>2652>>137684A2<F15 AE2??652:678?248??6<6298?32;24<@2E27;C>7A1B6:14 5C1 <31514<1 D@14 7@1 =176768413> 7@8CB@ 25;67764B 78 @2:1 72F14 4876<1 @2:1 ?26915 78 ;147684 7@1 5271 84 31<16=78?4876<1@12;A6BC67E64487?6I64B7@152718? 31<16=7 8? 4876<1 <24487 A1 72F14 25:2472B1 8? AE 7@1 =176768413> 7@1;>19:1> <<83564B9E 72F64B 4871 8? 7@1 8A>13:27684>8?7@1912341564B91 C5B127=232>.245+ - 9 - 1I732<7152A8:1D1?64548312>847864713?131D67@>C<@ 312>8464B @1 ?2<7C29 2>>137684> ;251 <24487 A1 14GC631564782457@18C376>64<96415782<<1=77@1>2E8? 7@124<@2E271:198=;147??6<13AE7@12??652:67 <<83564B9E7@12==1296> !*+ (!! "') & !*+ (&! ) & " 6>7 89 8.