Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 97358 (PNJ)

JAGRAON COOPERATIVE SUGAR MILLS LTD. v. GURJANT SINGH AND OTHERS

LPA/146/2020 · 2025-01-15

Meenakshi I Mehta, Sanjeev Prakash Sharma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

" %& ' !(" )* ' !(" #" * ' !(" # **) !(" " +# !"#" !(" " " +# '!"# " " +# !"# " " +# '!"# " " +# !"#" " "$ ,-- ../0 , -1/2 /0 #",-- ../0 , -1/2 /0 " ,-- ../0 , -1/2 /0 #" ,-- ../0 , -1/2 /0 "$ ,-- ../0 , -1/2 /0 RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 34 )+# '!"#"$ ,-- ../0 !(" "" " , -1/2 /0 &*) 5!"#" ,-- ../0 !(" '""" " , -1/2 /0 % '!"#"$ ,-- ../0 !(" "'" # " , -1/2 /0 &+# !"#" ,-- ../0 !(" "'6 " " , -1/2 /0 ) +# !"#",-- ../0 !(" " " , -1/2 /0 0 17 8 81/9*$$* : /0 #:$!8; "8/<=>2?10 /2 #:$=@."=:A>2?10 71:0= -- ../0 $ # $:@/2=08'@. =: =0=>>@/BC$ RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 3)4 #:$$"$"<<@>2?10 71:: -1/2 /0 1$01)8/ 1$ 17/271:: -1/2 /0 1$01>)01>>> )>01)>))>)*/2) 8/ 1$*17/271: : -1/2 /0 1$>*01&>/2)8/ 1$)17$ #:$'$"$1-:8>2?10 /2# $:=/! =8 =0> 2?10 71:: -1/2 /0 1 $01>&01>)>> 01%> 01)>))01)>)&01>8/ 1$%&17/271: : -1/2 /0 1 $>)01&>>01%>01&/2)*8/ 1 >*>*)>/217$ DDD !"!" 1: 0= : 1/ A /081/ 2 8/ 0= --.8081/> 0= A 8 ..1E 2/22 .F17&2F 8/: 78.8/<0= -: /0-- .8 1/21/ 2$ $ = -- ../0 =? 8. 2 0= 1:2 : - 2 CF 0= . :/ 2 "8/<. /=20 2 $$&>E= : CF0= . :/ 2"8/<. /=2 82 2 0= C@/=170= E:80- 08081/ /2= .20= E:80- 08081/ : 01C /080. 271: *G170= 2 :/ ..1E/ 1/0= . 0C 8-F2:E/CF0= A8/0 :A 17 0= 2 78/8081/ 17 .:F 1/08/ 2 8/ 0= !" = A $ = . :/ 2 "8/<. /=. 1= .20=00= B@2<A /08/#$%&&$'()*+,+ -&./ ((* 0*$*(#'& '1 ''2*(#,* -3 #+ ($ &$ '()*+ 45" !"">E1@.2--.F/20= : -1/2 /0 E1@.2-F*G170= 2 :/ ..1E/ 1/ 0= . 0 2:E/ C 8 -F 01 0=1 A-.1F E=1 1-0 271:!"/2<:/00= AC / 780170= 2 78/8081/170 :A .:F$/0 : 0 H G - : //@A E$ $7$ 0= 20 17 /080. A /0 08.. 0= 0@. 20 17 28 C@: A /0E . 128: 0 2$ $ :/ 21@/ .71:0= -- ../0 =? @CA800 20=00= 1:2 : 17 228/< *G 2 :/ ..1E/ 01 0= I8 08/< .:F 01 A; 80 0= 2 :/ -FE 8 @ 2CF0= @/BC"00 2 :081/1711- :08? RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 34 "@<:#8.. ?82 1:2 :20 2$$&$= A E /10--.8C. 010= @<:A8.. E=8=E : .: 2F.F8/<.1 2/2E : @/2 :.8J@82081//280 E . 70 71: 0= <8 0::> 11- :08? "18 08 01 0; 2 8 81/ E80= : <:201 @=.1 2 @<:A8.. 01E= 0= :*G2 :/ ..1E/ E 01 C 22 2$ 0 E . 1 28: 0 2 0=0 @= C / 780 17 228/< 17 *G 17 2 :/ ..1E/ 1/ 0= C 8 .:F E1@.2 C 7:1A 0= @:: /0 F : /A .F %$ = 2 8 81/ 17 0= @/BC "00 2 :081/ 17 11- :08? "@<: #8.. E --:1? 2 CF 0= <8 0::> 11- :08? "18 08 1/)$$&>A;8/<80--.8C. E$ $7$$$&$ )$ :/ 21@/ . @CA80 0=00= . :/ 2"8/<. @2< = :: 2 8/28: 08/<0= 822 8 81/01C --.8C. 010= A-.1F 170= .1 2 @<:A8.. 0= 1:2 :17228/<*G2 :/ ..1E/ 010= C 8 .:F E 1/.F I.@ 8? 010= :@//8/< @<:A8.. /2/10010= .1 2A8.. $08 @CA800 2 0=0 71: 0= .1 2 @<: A8.. /A .F 58:> <:1/> 08.> :82;10 /2 :/ :/> ?1.@/0:F : 08: A /0 = A E 7.10 2 CF 0= 1? :/A /017@/BC1/%$$>70 :0= --:1?.7:1A0= 1@/8.17 #8/8 0 : $ - :0= 82!" = A >0= A-.1F 170= .1 2 @<: A8.. E : /080. 2010= C / 780 0: 08/<0= .:F01A /C 8-F-.@ --:1-:80 - : /0< ?:8C. 2 :/ ..1E/ > E=8= E 01 C .@.0 21/0= C 8 17. 0 .:F2:E/$ :/ 21@/ . @CA80 0=00= I<:08E 1:28/<.F01C .@.0 2/2-82$0E . 1-18/0 21@00=08/ 0= A-.1F E=1 177 : 2 !"> 21 /10 1-0 1: E80=2:E 0= 1-081/ <8? /> E1@.2 C <:/0 2 : 0: /=A /0C / 780 - :0= : . ?/0:@. $= F0= : 71: > @CA800=0 0= .:F A /081/ 28/0= !" = A 1@.2/10C C 8-F . 0 2:E/ .:F-.@ *G2 :/ ..1E/ $ RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 3*4 $ 6 28: 0 2 0= . :/ 2 1@/ . 71: 0= -- ../0 01 -. C 71: @ 0= 1:8<8/.: 1:217-FA /017 .:F/278I081/17 .:F 80 E @CA800 20=00= ?:8C. 2 :/ ..1E/ 010= I0 /017 $&&G E 22 2010= C 8 .:F2:E/00= 08A 17.1 8/<170= A8.. 8$ $. 0 2:E/ .:FCF0= 1/ :/ 2 A-.1F $ *$ 6 =? - :@ 20= 1:8<8/.: <8 0 :>E= : 8/>0= .@.081/ = C /A2 /2: 08 78 20=08/ = 17 A-.1F 0= 2 :/ ..1E/ = C /.@.0 28/71: 820 :A /222 2010= C 8-F E=8=0= A-.1F E : 2:E8/<00= 08A 17.1 @: 170= @<:A8.. $ .@.08/<8001C 0= .:F>0= I<:08A1@/0= C /.@.0 2/2 : . 2$ $ :/ 21@/ .-- :8/<71:0= A-.1F >=1E ? :> @CA80 0=0*G2 :/ ..1E/ =1@.2=? C /22 2010= .:F8/0 :A 17 0= 2 8 81/0; /CF0= @/BC"00 2 :081/1711- :08? "@<:#8.. E=8==201C --.8 201..0= A-.1F $"8/ 0= @<:A8.. =2/10 : . 2 0= A1@/0 -:81: 01 0= 82 2 8 81/> 0= A-.1F E1@.2 C /080. 2 01 : 8? 0= 82 C / 780 /2 70 : 228/< 0=0 *G 2 :/ ..1E/ 1/0= . 020 17.1 @: 170= @<:A8.. >870= .@.081/ : 21/ > A-.1F E1@.2C A1: C / 780 2$@:0= :/128 08/081//C 2:E/C 0E /0= A-.1F E=1: E1:;8/<8/0= @<:A8.. E=8=E : 7@/081/8/<1/0= 20 E= /0= 2 8 81/E 0; /8$ $8/0= F :&/2 0= A-.1F E=1E : E1:;8/<E80=0= @<:A8.. E=8=E : .1 2$"1 7: 0= .:F-:08 1/ :/ 2>0= A-.1F 170= @<:A8.. =2. 1 /10: 8? 20= A $ $ 6 =? 1/ 82 : 20= @CA8 81/ $ %$ 6 78/20=00= 2 8 81/0; /71:<:/017228/<*G2 :/ RAJESH KUMAR ..1E/ 010= C 8-F>1A 01/A1@/0;/1E/ 2 :/ -F>E 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 3 4 0; / 1/.F 1/ $$& E80= : - 0 01 :@//8/< @<: A8.. /2 0= <8 0::>11- :08? "18 08 =2 -0 20= A /2C:1@<=0808/01 71: 7:1A$$&$ 1/$$&>0= <:1//210= : @<:A8.. 71:E=8=!" = A =2C /7.10 2> 0112.: 2F.1 2$/7080= C /8/71:A 20=00= @<:A8.. 0112.1 28/0= F :*/2C:1@<=0 @/2 : .8J@82081/ 8/ 1? AC :> * /2 0=@ 0= .8A 17 0= E:80 - 08081/ : //10C 1/-:80FE80=0= A-.1F 170= :@//8/< @<:A8.. $ :/ 2 "8/<. @2< = 0=@ :: 2 8/ --.F8/< 0= 2 8 81/ 20 2 $$&010= A-.1F 170= .1 2A8.. $ &$ = 2 78/8081/17 .:F 2 78/ 2@/2 :0= !" = A >: 2 @/2 :9 = .:F>E1@.2>0= : 71: >=? 01C .@.0 2 0= C 8 -F E=8= 0= A-.1F E 2:E/8/< . 0.F E= / 0= @<: A8.. E 8/ 1- :081/> E= : 70 : 0= ?:8C. 2 :/ ..1E/ E1@.2 C 22 2 1:28/<.F$= ?:8C. 2 :/ ..1E/ E=8=1A 01 $&&G= C / 22 2 01 0= C 8 .:F /2 0= A1@/0 = C / .@.0 2 1:28/<.F$ $ 6 21 /10 78/2 /F ::1: 8/ @= .@.081/$ #1: 1> 87 0= !"1@.2/10=? C / -0 2>0= 1/ :/ 2 A-.1F E1@.2=? 1/.F C / /080. 2 01 1A- / 081/ 8/ 0 :A 17 " 081/ * 17 0= /2@ 0:8. 8 -@0 0>&>E=8=011E1@.2=? 01C .@.0 2 1/0= . 02F 17E1:;8/<8$ $8/0= F :*$ >E1@.2>0= : 71: >< 01A- / 081/. 1 1:28/<.F/20= .:FE1@.2=? 01C 1A-@0 21/0= C 8 17E=0 RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. +# 34 = E1@.2=? C /< 008/<8/*$= C / 780= >0=@ >C /<8? /010= AI8A@A$ $ /?8 E170= C1? A0= 1:2 :- 2CF0= . :/ 2"8/<. @2< E1@.2C /10=8/< . C@07@:0= :1A-.80 0= 8 @ E80=1@0<8?8/< /F 7@:0= : 228081/. 2?/0< 01 0= A-.1F -:0 7:1A C 8/< @/ @ 08/C. 8/.E$ $ 6 >0= : 71: >21/108/0 /2011/78:A0= 1:2 :- 2CF0= . :/ 2 "8/<. /= /2 1:28/<.F E 0 82 0= 1:2 : 20 2 $$&>- 2CF0= . :/ 2"8/<. C /=$= -- . : 1:28/<.F ..1E 2$ )$ ..- /28/<A8 $--.8081/ . 1 0/228 -1 217$ 67 67 *$$* :B = $6= 0= : - ;8/<(: 1/ 2K 9 ( 1 $6= 0= :: -1:0C. K 9 ( 1 RAJESH KUMAR 2025.01.23 11:51 I attest the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment.