- 1 - ! "#"$ %&# # ' ( ! " ! # $% &! # ! "" $% ' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ( ! ) $%' ! " * ! " '# " + , " " " " ) ! -% &$" " " " ! " " $$ ,%% " " " " " ! " ./ 0 11 23435656783976:523;6<3=8>435656783976: 523>=?@25397<962=85=44=72?A=44=?B=96;27 ;=:3C4A7D3>=:3E2=86E9=>3$=56CF=9@=:3E5678 ?F$>6G6:678 =>=@=8E26 3 3H4693> ;26A3 68 - 3 - :39G6E378,%%26A368:39G6E323;=::?:438>3> 78523@97?8>52=5232=>875>6:EA7:3>26:93=A8=C363 96 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 3 <6A3> = :?65 <79 >3EA=9=567852=526::?:438:678;=:6AA3@=A=8>:7?@25<79 C=8>=579D 68B?8E5678 57 9368:5=53 26C F=EI 6857 :39G6E3 ?968@523438>38ED7<523:?65523:=6>2=85=44=;=: 9368:5=53> 6857 :39G6E3 =8> =EE79>68@AD 23 ;652>93; 523 :?65 78 %(%--+ =539 83 =8=I=>=: <6A3> = E7C4A=685=@=68:526C<7AA7;68@;26E2=8756E3;=::39G3> ?478 26C FD 52393:478>385 7 78 -%(%( 8 523 :=6> E7C4A=685 65 ;=: =AA3@3> 52=5 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44=?B=96;=:26:<=5239=8>23;=:3C4A7D3>;652 =5 27;>=4?9 <97C %%(-( 57 (%---- =8> >63> 78 %---- 3 =AA3@3> 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 43565678397;=:6C439:78=568@26:<=5239=8>;79I68@ ;65252393:478>385:232?:F=8>7<52343565678397 ;=: 52393<793 E=AA3> ?478 57 :?FC65 =8 3H4A=8=5678 =8> ;=: :?:438>3> <97C >?5D 23 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 :?FC6553> 934AD <7AA7;68@ ;26E2 23 =@=68 =4497=E23> 5237?95 68 7((%( =8>:7?@25 <79 - 4 - 685396C68B?8E5678236G6A7?9593B3E53>523=44A6E=5678 <6A3>FD26C<7AA7;68@;26E25232?:F=8>7<5234356567839 7 ;=: I345 ?8>39 :?:438:678 <539 523 >3=52 7< 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 :23 <?986:23> = >3=52 E3956<6E=53 =8> 93J?3:53> 57 4=D 523 539C68=A F383<65: 5 ;=:=A:7F97?@25575238756E37<52393:478>385752=5 523:=A=9D7<5232?:F=8>7<43565678397;=:E93>653> 685726:=EE7?85=55=53=8I7<D>39=F=>?439C=9I35 9=8E2 ?AF=9@= 783523A3:: 93:478>385 7 >6> 875 :355A3 523 539C68=A F383<65: ;26E2 E7C43AA3> 523 4356567839:57=4497=E2526:E7?95687%+'-%+ 234356567839: E78538>3>52=5 526:7?9568539C:7< 523 79>39 >=53> +%,% =<539 E78:6>3968@ 523 E785385678: 7< 523 93:478>385: 23A> 52=5 527?@2 93:478>385: 2=> 68656=53> 68J?69D 6857 523 =AA3@=5678: 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 5234356567839;=:6C439:78=568@2=85=44=72?A=44= ?B=96 D35 523 :=6> 68J?69D >6> 875 497E33> <?95239 F?5 ;=: >97443> C6>;=D 2393<793 526: 7?95 23A> 52=5 523930: 875268@ 57 >38D 523 EA=6C 7< 523 4356567839: <79 @9=85 7< 539C68=A F383<65: =8> E78:3J?385AD =AA7;3> 523 - 5 - ;96543565678=8>>693E53>52393:478>385:239368575=I3= >3E6:678 68 =EE79>=8E3 ;652 A=; =8> >6:47:3 7< 523 93493:385=5678 7< 523 4356567839: 23 4356567839: E78538> 52=5 3G38 =<539 <?986:268@ = E74D 7< 526: 79>39 =8> 93J?3:568@ 523 93:478>385: 57 E78:6>39 52369 EA=6C <79 539C68=A F383<65:93:478>385: 2=G3 6::?3>523 6C4?@83> 79>39 >=53> -% 93B3E568@ 523 EA=6C 7< 523 4356567839: 78 523 F=:6: 7< = 934795 7< 523 =2:6A>=9 =A=F?9@6 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: I87;8 =: 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 =8> 875 2=85=44= 72?A=44=?B=96236C4?@83>79>39;=:=A:7F=:3> 78 = 934795 7< =8 68J?69D 7<<6E39 4?9:?=85 57 523 79>39 >=53>(%'%4=::3>FD526:7?95;279347953>52=5 2=852=44= 2=> >63> 3=9A639 =8> = 439:78 8=C3> 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 2=> 6C439:78=53> 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 =8> ;=: ;79I68@ =5 523 93:478>385 7 368@ =@@963G3> FD 523 :=6> 79>39 523 4356567839: =93F3<793526:7?95 - 6 - 3=983>E7?8:3A<795234356567839:E78538>52=5 656:87F7>D0:E=:352=55232?:F=8>7<52343565678397 ;=: 875 ;79I68@ ?8>39 93:478>385 7 56AA 23 >63> 78 ,%%3:?FC65:52=5527?@2523E7C4A=685:;393 A7>@3> 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 6C439:78=568@ = 439:78 8=C3> 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 F?5 523 38J?69D ;=: >97443> C6>;=D =8> 87 <68>68@;=:93E79>3>=@=68:55232?:F=8>7<5234356567839 7>?968@26:A6<356C3352393<793E78538>:52=552393 6:876C43>6C38568A=;<79523:355A3C3857<523539C68=A F383<65: 3 =A:7 :?FC65: 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 43565678397;=:;79I68@;65252393:478>3857=8> 52393=93>7E?C385::?E2=:=5678=9>=8I=::F77I >38565D =9> 7< 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 =8> 523 :?9G6G79E3956<6E=536::?3>FD523=2:6A>=9I=A=F?9@6>=53> ,%'% ;26E2 =AA :27;3> 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 43565678397E=9963>5238=C32=85=44=72?A=44= ?B=96 2393<793 23 E78538>: 52=5 523 6C4?@83> 79>39 93<?:68@ 57 @9=85 523 539C68=A F383<65: 6: 875 78AD =9F659=9DF?5=A:76AA3@=A368G653>523=553856787<523 - 7 - 7?95 57 523 <68>68@: 93E79>3> FD = E7$79>68=53 F38E2 7< 526:7?95687%+'-%+=8>E78538>3>52=5526: 7?95 2=: E=53@796E=AAD 93E79>3> = <68>68@ 52=5 56AA >=53 52393 6: 87 <68>68@ 93E79>3> =5 =8D 38J?69D 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 875 I87;8 =: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 3 52393<793 E78538>: 52=5523<68>68@:7<526:7?95E=8875F3:2795E69E?653>79 FD4=::3> FD 7F5=6868@ = 934795 7< 523 =2:6A>=9 79 FD G6:6568@ 523 G6AA=@3 =8> E78>?E568@ = ?86A=539=A 68J?69D 57 27A>52=55232?:F=8>7<5234356567839;=:8752=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 2393<793 23 E78538>: 52=5 523 6C4?@83> 79>394=::3>FD 52393:478>3857 ;=99=85: 68539<3938E3 ' 39 E7859= A3=983> E7?8:3A <79 93:478>385 7: =8> :?FC6553> 52=5 523 93:478>385 7 2=: E=93<?AADE78:6>393>523 6::?3F3<793=996G68@ =5=<68>68@ 52=55232?:F=8>7<52343565678397;=:8752=85=44= 72?A=44=?B=96F?5;=:26G=A68@=44=72?5=A68 526: 93@=9> 23 68G653> 523 =55385678 7< 523 7?95 57 =8 - 8 - 68J?69D E78>?E53> 78 %(% =5 523 G6AA=@3 7< 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 =8> 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=9623C7523968A=;7<52343565678397=EE3453> 52=5 239 :780: 8=C3 ;=: 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 =8> 52=523EA=6C3>52=523;=:3C4A7D3>;65252393:478>385 7 6C6A=9AD 523 F975239 68 A=; 7< 523 4356567839 7 :5=53> 52=5 26: <=52390: 8=C3 ;=: 2?5=A6 =8> 52=5 26: 3A>39F9752390:8=C3;=:26G=A68@=44=;27EA=6C3>52=5 23;=:3C4A7D3>68352393<793E78538>3>52=5523 93:478>385 7 52393<793 >7?F53> 523 EA=6C 7< 523 4356567839 7 52=5 239 2?:F=8> ;=: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 2?: 23 E78538>: 52=5 523 6C4?@83> 79>39 4=::3> FD 523 96=A 7?95 93<?:68@ 57 @9=85 523 539C68=AF383<65:>73:875;=99=8568539<3938E3 ( 3=983>E7?8:3A<7993:478>3857'E78538>3> 52=5 23 6:523:78 7<2=85=44= 72?A=44= ?B=96 3 =A:7 E78538>3> 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 =8> 875 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44=?B=963:?FC65:52=552393:478>38572=: - 9 - E=93<?AAD E78:6>393> 523 :5=53C385 C=>3 FD 523 93:478>3857'78%+%=8>23;=::=56:<63>52=5 2?:F=8>7<52343565678397;=:26G=A68@=44==8>875 2=852=44=3 :?FC65: 52=53G38527?@24356567839;=: E=AA3>?478FD523E78E3983>=2:6A>=93G38?38:43E579 =8> 523 43E6=A 34?5D 7CC6::67839 =A=F?9=@6 57 497>?E3 =?523856E=53> >7E?C385: 57 3:5=FA6:2 239 EA=6C 52=5 239 2?:F=8>0: 8=C3 ;=: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 :23 >6> 875 497>?E3 =8D >7E?C385: 3 52393<793 E78538>: 52=5 56AA >=53 52393 6: 87 >7E?C385 57 3:5=FA6:2 52=55232?:F=8>7<523435656783976:2=85=44=7 2?A=44=?B=96 AA 523 93:478>385: 52393<793 :?FC65 68 783 G76E352=52?:F=8>7<523435656783976:8752=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 F?5 23 6: 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 =8> 52393<793 523 4356567839: =93 875 38565A3> 57 523 539C68=AF383<65: - 10 - + 2=G3 E78:6>393> 523 :?FC6::678: 7< 523 A3=983>E7?8:3A<795234356567839:=8>A3=983>E7?8:3A<79 93:478>385: , 23 <=E5 52=5 =8 38J?69D ;=: 68:565?53> FD 523 93:478>385: F=:3> 78 = E7C4A=685 A7>@3> FD =8=I=>=: 72=85=44=6:87568>6:4?5323:=6>38J?69D;=:875 5=I38 57 65: A7@6E=A 38> =: 8365239 =8=I=>=: 7 2=85=44=87993:478>3857'239368:27;3>?4F3<793 93:478>3857:=8>573:5=FA6:252369EA=6C52=5523D =93 523 E26A>938 7< 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 2393<79368:7<=993:478>3857:=8>=93E78E3983> 56AA>=53523936:87=<<69C=56G3<68>68@52=55232?:F=8>7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 875 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 : = C=5539 7< <=E5 = 779>68=53 38E2 7< 526: 7?95 68 7%+'-%+ 2=> =A:7 8756E3> 526: :596<3 F35;3385234356567839:=8>52393:478>3857'=8>23A> =:<7AA7;: ! - 11 - " # $ % $ # %&'() ( % &*+,-- . *,- ! *,- %/ ) # % & 0 ! 12 3 4(" 5 ) " " 3 4(" 3 4(" # 1 6 4(" 7 # ( 8 "4 8 () ( ( 9' :. ; 0 < 0 # 0 : =8 %& () ( ) ) 5>8 ? # 0 ) - 12 - () ( *@&,,+ *=*,,+ # % & +. 43 3 4(" 5 3 %-& **=,-= =*,,,, ?*,,,, " 3 3 3 %-& $ A '& 0 @ . 0 &@*&*? 8 ) '7 # % % & 8 ) 'B # % & *?&*= # # 3 % & C 26:7?9552393<793>693E53>52393:478>385:57 E78:6>39523EA=6C7<5234356567839:<79:355A3C3857<523 539C68=A F383<65: 78@ 52393=<539 523 93:478>385 7: - 13 - =8>2=G3=@=6893B3E53>523EA=6C7<5234356567839:78 523 F=:6: 7< E395=68 38J?6963: E78>?E53> FD 523C =5 523 G6AA=@3 7< 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 =8> 26G=A68@=44=72?5=A623D=A:793A63>?478=38J?69D E78>?E53> FD 523 =2:6A>=9 3G38?3 8:43E579 =8> 523 43E6=A 34?5D 7CC6::67839 =A=F?9=@6 F3<793 ;27C 523 4356567839: <=6A3> 57 497>?E3 >7E?C385: 57 3:5=FA6:2 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 4356567839 7 ;=: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 23D =A:7 93A63> ?478 = 934795 7< 523 43E6=A34?5D7CC6::67839=A=F?9=@6;27:5=53>52=5 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 2=> 6C439:78=53> 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 57 >38D 523 EA=6C 7< 523 4356567839: <79:355A3C3857<539C68=AF383<65: - 5 6: :59=8@3 52=5 6< 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 ;=: 523 783 ;27 ;=: 3C4A7D3> ;652 523 93:478>385: 27; = 439:78 8=C3> 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6;=:=AA7;3>57;79I685234A=E37<2=85=44=7 2?A=44=?B=9656AA523D3=9%2393:478>3857 =8>65:7<<6E6=A:E7?A>8752=G3=AA7;3>=:59=8@3957;79I - 14 - 68523697<<6E3<7983=9AD'%D3=9:26:=4=95656:87F7>D0: E=:3 52=5 ;273G39 ;79I3> =: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96>6>875>9=;:=A=9D<97C523D3=9-(56AA523D3=9 %=8>656:87F7>D0:E=:352=5E7993:478>68@;79I;=: 875 3H59=E53> 2393<793 3G38 6< 65 6: =::?C3> 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 875 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44=?B=96F?565@73:;6527?5:=D68@52=565;=:523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;27 ;=: ;79I68@ =5 523 93:478>385 7 56AA 23 >63> 68 523 D3=9 % 23 539C68=AF383<65: =93523F383<65:;26E2523C3CF39:7< 523 <=C6AD 7< 523 439:78 =93 38565A3> 57 8 523 493:385 E=:3 65 6: 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;27 ;=: 3C4A7D3>=8>2=>E78596F?53>5752397G6>385"?8>=8> 38565A3>57@9=5?65D=8>75239F383<65:2393<7936>3=AAD65 ;=: 523 4356567839: ;27 =93 38565A3> 57 523 539C68=A F383<65: 7< 523>3E3=:3> 2=85=44= 72?A=44= ?B=96 23 93:478>385: ;27 2=G3 =AA7;3> 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 57 ;79I <97C 523 D3=9 -( 56AA 523 D3=9 % E=8875 >38D 79 >3496G3 523 539C68=A F383<65: 57 ;26E2 523 4356567839: =93 38565A3> 57 78 523 =::395678 7< - 15 - 523 93:478>385 7 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 875 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 8>39 523 E69E?C:5=8E3:52378AD;=D5793:7AG3526::5=A3C=536:57 >693E593:478>3857:=8>:355A3=AA539C68=AF383<65: 4=D=FA3575234356567839:;6527?5385395=6868@=8D>7?F5 =: 57 ;235239 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 ;=: 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 79 875 68 G63; 7< 523 87C68=5678C=>3FD2=85=44=72?A=44=?B=9668523 :39G6E3 93E79>: :27;68@ 523 4356567839 7 =: 523 87C6833 57 EA=6C 523 539C68=A F383<65: 7;3G39 523 4356567839: =93 875 38565A3> 57 EA=6C 523 93A63< 7< =447685C38578E7C4=::678=53@97?8>:78C79352=8783 93=:78;26E2=93=:<7AA7;: 6# 23 ;=D 68 ;26E2 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 72=:@=683>3C4A7DC3856::?:43E5 66# 23435656783972=:7G39E7C3239>?93::<97C 523 D3=9 % 56AA >=53 =8> 2=: F338 =FA3 57 :?:5=68239:3A< - 16 - 666# 23 4356567839 7 6: C=9963> =8> 6: >3438>=85 78 239 2?:F=8> =8> 6: 875 = >3438>385 C3CF39 7<523<=C6AD=8>52393<793:235776:87538565A3> 57EA=6C=447685C38578E7C4=::678=53@97?8>: % 8 G63; 7< 523 =F7G3 43565678 >3:39G3: 57 F3 >6:47:3>7<<78523<7AA7;68@539C: 6 35656786: 66 23 6C4?@83> 79>39 4=::3> FD 523 93:478>3857F3=968@7 >=53> -% 6: J?=:23> =8>93:478>38576:>693E53>57:355A3523 539C68=AF383<65:7<>3E3=:3>2=85=44=7 2?A=44= ?B=96 =8> 93A3=:3 =AA F383<65: 68 <=G7?9 7< 523 4356567839 7: =8> 7 68 3J?=A 4795678: =<539 >3>?E568@ ;2=53G39 6: 4=6>=A93=>D4?9:?=8557523>693E5678:6::?3> FD526:7?95 - 17 - 666 26:3H39E6:3:2=AAF3=EE7C4A6:23>;65268' C7852: <97C 523 >=53 7< 93E3645 7< E3956<63> E74D7<526:79>39 6G 23 4356567839: =93 875 38565A3> 57 523 =447685C38578E7C4=::678=53@97?8>: G 26: 79>39 ;6AA 875 E7C3 68 523 ;=D 7< 523 93:478>3857'3:5=FA6:268@26:EA=6CF3<793 =8D 7?95 7< A=; 52=5 523 2?:F=8> 7< 523 4356567839 7 6: 875 2=85=44= 7 2?A=44= ?B=96 F?5 6: 26G=A68@=44= 7 2?5=A6 )* '#( # 1 6:57A7(