Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9622 (KAR)
SANGAMESHA @ SANGANABASAVA v. THE STATE AND ANR
CRL.P/200285/2024 · 2025-02-01
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9622 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9622 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#$% & '% "
$ (
()*+
( ** '
!"#$%
& '
(
)
*
!"!)%+
$
!" ,
!"!$%)
&
'
*
)- $(
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* "$
* . "$. '
( %)$%) ' %!$%) * ( * ** + ) ')( '/( )'$(
* *
)0"" *
*
*
1
'
1 (
23434,526 47 829,62 3:47 ,;63 ;5/26 2<34,5 "$ ,9 =43: > ?6>@26 3, A;>7: 3:2 253462 ?6,<22/45B7 45 ?2<4>C >72 ',66;?34,5( ,)$%) ?25/45B ,5 3:2 94C2 ,947364<3>5/2774,57;/B2>/B46>64745B,;3,964D2 ,!$%) 8@ ,E>@;E3> ,C4<2 3>34,5 >/B46 9,6 3:2 ,9925<27 ?;547:>8C2 ;5/26 2<34,57 + )')('/( 62>/ =43: 2<34,5)'$(,93:262F2534,5,9,66;?34,5<3)0""
$ 2>6/C2>652/<,;572C9,63:2?>63427
2>652/<,;572C9,63:2?23434,5267;8D4373:>3 3:2 ?23434,526 :>7 8225 2G,526>32/ ,5 D26437 45 3:2
- 3 -
/2?>63D253>C ?6,<22/45B7 :2C/ ,5 7>D2 723 ,9 9><37 >5/ 3:2 7>4/ ,6/26 :>7 >33>452/ 945>C43@ :2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 >7 =2CC >7 3:2 7:>/,= =435277 :>F2 5,3 7;??,632/3:2<>72,93:2?6,72<;34,5>5/3:2629,62453:2 /2?>63D253>C?6,<22/45B7>945/45B:>7822562<,6/2/3:>3 /2D>5/ >5/ ><<2?3>5<2 ,9 3:2 86482 >D,;53 =>7 5,3 ?6,F2/:2629,6245F42=,93:2H;/BD253,93:2,5I8C2 ;?62D2 ,;63 45 3:2 <>72 ,9
)3:24D?;B52/<64D45>C?6,<22/45B747 C4>8C23,82A;>7:2/
26<,536>C2>652/<,;572C9,63:2627?,5/253J ,E>@;E3> :>7 ,??,72/ 3:2 ?6>@26 D>/2 45 3:2 ?23434,5 2 7;8D437 3:>3 3:2 73>5/>6/ ,9 ?6,,9 45 /2?>63D253>C ?6,<22/45B7478>72/,5?62?,5/26>5<2,9?6,8>84C43@>5/ 3:2 73>5/>6/ ,9 ?6,,9 45 <64D45>C <>72 47 D;<: :4B:26 262C@ 9,6 3:2 62>7,57 3:>3 3:2 ?23434,526 :>7 8225 2G,526>32/ 45 3:2 /2?>63D253>C ?6,<22/45B7 3:2 <64D45>C
)'$%$%(0##
- 4 -
<>7262B473262/>B>4573:4D9,63:2>CC2B2/,9925<27<>55,3 82 A;>7:2/ 2 :>7 ?C><2/ 62C4>5<2 ,5 3:2 H;/BD253 ,9 3:2 ,5I8C2 ;?62D2 ,;63 45 3:2 <>72 ,9 ! "! $<<,6/45BC@:2?6>@7 3,/47D4773:2?23434,5
!
"! $<<,6/45BC@:2?6>@7 3,/47D4773:2?23434,5
! 26;7>C ,9 3:2 D>3264>C ,5 62<,6/ =,;C/ B, 3, 7:,= 3:>3 3:2 >CC2B>34,5 >B>4573 3:2 ?23434,526 47 3:>3 :2 :>/ /2D>5/2/ > 7;D ,9 7)%%% 96,D 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 9,6 3:2 ?;6?,72 ,9 <:>5B45B E:>3> 2536427 45 627?2<3,9<263>454DD,F>8C2?6,?263@82C,5B45B3,3:2/2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53
5 3:2 8>747 ,9 3:2 94673 459,6D>34,5 7;8D4332/8@3:2/2 9><3,<,D?C>45>53*=>762B473262/ >B>4573 3:2 ?23434,526 45 64D2 ,!$%$ 8@ ,E>@;E3> ,C4<2>/B469,63:2>9,627>4/,9925<27>5/7;872A;253C@ 45>36>?3:>3=>7:2C/,5$%!$%)4347>CC2B2/3:>33:2 ?23434,526=>7<>;B:362/ :>5/2/=:4C262<24F45B3:286482 >D,;53 ,9 7)%%% 96,D 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 :245F2734B>34,5,93:2<>72=>7<,D?C232/>5/3:262>9326
$$%$)
- 5 -
<:>6B2 7:223 :>78225 94C2/ >B>45733:2?23434,5269,6 3:2 >9,627>4/ ,9925<27 >5/ :2 47 8245B 5,= 3642/ 829,62 3:2 2774,57,;6345?2<4>C>72',66;?34,5(,)$%) # 5 3:2 7>D2 723 ,9 >CC2B>34,57 /2?>63D253>C 25A;46@ =>7 :2C/ >B>4573 3:2 ?23434,526 >5/ 45 3:2 7>4/ ?6,<22/45B7 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 >7 =2CC >7 3:2 7:>/,==435277=2622G>D452/>7)>5/ ,3:
3:2 =43527727 :>F2 5,3 7;??,632/ 3:2 <>72 ,9 3:2 ?6,72<;34,5 5 3:2 7>4/ <>72 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 :>7 3;652/ :,734C2 >5/ :2 :>7 73>32/ 3:>3 3:2 ?23434,526 :>/5,3/2D>5/2/>5@86482>D,;5396,D:4D5,6:>/:2 ?>4/ >5@ 86482 3, :4D :2 7:>/,= =435277 /;645B 3:2 <,;672,9:47<6,77 2G>D45>34,5:>773>32/3:>3:2=>75,3 >=>62 >8,;3 3:2 <,5F267>34,5 3:>3 :>/ 3>E25 ?C><2 823=225 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 >5/ 3:2 ?23434,526><<;72/>5/:2>C7,:>773>32/3:>3>33:234D2 ,936>?:2=>75,345>?,7434,53,:2>63:2<,5F267>34,5 823=225 3:2 /2 9><3, <,D?C>45>53 >5/ 3:2 ?23434,526><<;72/ 9326 >??62<4>345B 3:2 ,6>C >5/
- 6 -
/,<;D253>6@ 2F4/25<2 >F>4C>8C2 ,5 62<,6/ 45 3:2 /2?>63D253>C?6,<22/45B743:>78225:2C/3:>33:2<:>6B2 ,9 /2D>5/ >5/ ><<2?3>5<2 ,9 86482 >D,;53 >B>4573 3:2 ?23434,526><<;72/ =>7 5,3 ?6,F2/ 8@ 3:2 5A;46@
994<26 ,5 82:>C9 ,9 3:2 47<4?C45>6@ ;3:,643@ :2 ,5I8C2 ?C,E>@;E3>:>7><<2?32/3:262?,63,93:25A;46@
994<26 >5/ :>7 62<,DD25/2/ 3, 3:2 ,F265D253 3, ><<2?3 3:2 62?,63 ,9 3:2 5A;46@
994<26 >5/ 3, 2G,526>32 3:2 ?23434,5269,63:2<:>6B27C2F2CC2/>B>4573:4D + 5?>6>B6>?:,7!3,+,93:262<,DD25/>34,5 ,9 3:2 ,5I8C2 ?>C,E>@;E3> 43 :>7 8225 ,8726F2/ >7 9,CC,=7
!"#$%"#$&'"$%"$ %( ! ) ! #$% ' $% $& ! ) *
"#$% "#$& #$% ! - 7 -
'"$%"$%('$%$&
! + ! ! $ )! +
+! "#$, ! -) +
+
+
( $
)
! +
. +
/ / 0 /+ 1
2
2 . )2
- 8 -
" :2 ,5I8C2 ;?62D2 ,;63 45 3:2 <>72 ,9
'7;?6>( 45 ?>6>B6>?: ,7)$>5/):>7,8726F2/>79,CC,=7 %3 4
5
,6
!7 8 94 ! /55:6; <,6 . ! +
+
+ !7 8; 4
+
7 8;
4
+
= 8; 4
8; . 4
- 9 -
+
= 8; 4 + '
+ ! 3>83; 5 /,>> 55
" = 8; . 4
! 4
= 8;
! ! + +
+ ! +
<
- 10 -
%, 7 8 94 !
/55:6 ,:; <,:
) ! + 4
! 4 ! 4
4
+ +
<
0 5 3:2 8><EB6,;5/ ,9 C>= C>4/ /,=5 8@ 3:2 ,5I8C2 ;?62D2 ,;63 45 3:2 <>72 ,9
'7;?6>( 49 3:2 <>72 ,5 :>5/ 47 2G>D452/ 43 47 F26@ <C2>6 3:>3 3:2 ?23434,526 :>7 8225 2G,526>32/453:2/2?>63D253>C?6,<22/45B7,5D26437>5/ > 7?2<494< 945/45B :>7 8225 62<,6/2/ 3:>3 3:2 <:>6B2 >B>4573:4D>CC2B45B/2D>5/>5/><<2?3>5<2,986482:>7
- 11 -
5,38225?6,F2/>5/3:2628@3:262475,<,536>F2534,5,9 3:2?6,F474,57,93:2><3
)% 5 3:2 <>72 ,9 ! " '7;?6>( :>F45B 62B>6/ 3, 3:2 ?2<;C4>6 9><37 >5/ <46<;D73>5<27 ,9 3:27>4/<>723:2,5I8C2;?62D2,;63:>7:2C/3:>33:2 4B: ,;63 =>7 5,3 H;734942/ 45 A;>7:45B 3:2 <64D45>C ?6,<22/45B72F253:,;B:453:2/2?>63D253>C?6,<22/45B7 3:2 ><<;72/ =>7 2G,526>32/ :2629,62 3:2 7>4/ H;/BD253 <>55,3 82 D>/2 >??C4<>8C2 3, 3:2 9><37 >5/ <46<;D73>5<27,93:2?627253<>72
)) 5/26 3:2 <46<;D73>5<27 >D ,9 3:2 ,?454,5 3:>3 3:2 4D?;B52/ <64D45>C ?6,<22/45B7 45434>32/ >B>4573 3:2 ?23434,526><<;72/ <>55,3 82 ?26D4332/ 3, 82 <,5345;2/745<23:2<:>5<27,9<,5F4<34,5453:24D?;B52/ <64D45>C?6,<22/45B745F,CF45B3:27>D2723,99><3747F26@ 62D,32<<,6/45BC@9,CC,=45B,6/2647?>772/
:2<64D45>C?23434,547>CC,=2/
- 12 -
:2 253462 ?6,<22/45B7 45 ?2<4>C >72 ',66;?34,5( ,)$%) ?25/45B 829,62 3:2 ,;63 ,9 47364<3 >5/ 2774,57 ;/B2 >/B46 >64745B ,;3 ,9 64D2 ,!$%) 62B473262/ 8@ ,E>@;E3> ,C4<2 3>34,5 >/B46 9,6 3:2 ,9925<27 ?;547:>8C2 ;5/26 2<34,57 + )')('/( 62>/ =43: 2<34,5)'$(,93:262F2534,5,9,66;?34,5<3)0"">7 >B>45733:2?23434,526><<;72/73>5/7A;>7:2/
,+
( & '% "* %
473,)C,%