- 1 - ! "# !$ %! # $ &'&()*+&)) % ! "# $%$"! &#'#"%( ! )( * ""%$%$ ")$ $%$$ * $$( Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * + * + *! " ,-. /0-1-234 567-7-82 92:60 6/7-82 )( 0 ; <%" 8= 0 -. =-46: >? 3//9.6: 8" 3..3-4-2@ 7,6 0:60 :376: ""%$%$>?7,6/89078=::-7-8234-.70-/7A6..-82. 9:@6 343>903@- -2 8")$ $%$$ ;,606-2 7,6 3554-/37-82 =-46: >? 7,6 567-7-8260 92:60 6/7-82 $$( 8= 0.66B-2@,-.:-./,30@6;3.:-.1-..6: $ 630: 7,6 463026: /892.64 =80 7,6 567-7-8260 32: 463026: -@, 8907 8C6021627 463:60 =80 7,6 06.582:627 63026:/892.64=807,6567-7-8260.9>1-7.7,376C62 -=7,63446@37-82.=892:-27,6/,30@6.,667306506.916: 78 >6 7096 7,6 3446@6: 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 .6/7-82 % 8= :86. 287 @67 37703/76: 3@3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260 ,606 -. 28 13760-34 -2 7,6 /,30@6 .,667 ;,-/, ;894: - 3 - 508C67,377,63/7/811-776:>?7,6567-7-8260 ,3:06.9476:-27,6:6/63.6:/811-77-2@.9-/-:6,606-. 2826D9.787,6:637,8=:6/63.6:32:32?3/7/811-776: >?7,6567-7-826027,63>.62/68=.9/,313760-347,6 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82 % 8= /894: 287 ,3C6>662-2C8B6:3@3-2.77,6567-7-8260 < 6.9>1-7.7,377,-.8907,3.3448;6:7,6:-./,30@6 3554-/37-82 =-46: >? 3//9.6: 8.$ 78 < -2 048$%%%<< $%$ //80:-2@4? ,6 503?. 78 3448; 7,6567-7-82 # 60 /82703 463026: -@, 8907 8C6021627 463:60 ,3.8558.6:7,6567-7-826.9>1-7.7,377,6567-7-8260-. 7,6 ,9.>32: 8= 7,6 :6/63.6: ,606 -. 3446@37-82 3@3-2.7 ,-1 7,37 3=760 ,-. ;-=6 @3C6 >-07, 78 3 /,-4: ;,8 ;3. 1627344? 06730:6: ,6 ;3. 287 5085604? 488B-2@ 3=760 ,-. ;-=632:/,-4:32:,634.8,3:32-44-/-706437-82.,-5;-7, 3287,60 43:? ,606 -. 3 :637, 2876 78 7,6 .3-: 6==6/7 -2 7,6 506.627 /3.6 //80:-2@4? ,6 503?. 78 :-.1-.. 7,6 567-7-82 - 4 - 609.348=7,613760-343C3-43>468206/80:;894:@8 78 .,8; 7,37 6C62 -= 7,6 3C601627. =892: -2 7,6 :637, 2876 3446@6:4? 46=7 >6,-2: >? 7,6 :6/63.6:&;-=6 8= 7,6 567-7-8260 ,606-2 -. 506.916: 78 >6 7096 7,6 8==62/6 92:606/7-82%8=/32287>6-2C8B6:3.3@3-2.77,6 567-7-8260 >3.6: 82 7,6 3C601627. =892: -2 7,6 3446@6: :637, 2876 ,606 -. 28 .9/, 1627-82 -2 7,6 :637, 2876 7,37 7,6 567-7-8260 ,3: /811-776: 32? .9/, 3/7 -116:-3764? 50-80 78 7,6 :6/63.6: /811-77-2@ .9-/-:6 ;,-/, ;894: ,3C6 6-7,60 -2.7-@376: 80 3>6776: 7,6 :6/63.6:&;-=6 78 73B6 .9/, :03.7-/ .765 8= /811-77-2@ .9-/-:6 ,6 3C601627. 13:6 -2 7,6 =-0.7 -2=80137-82 3. ;644 3. 7,6 /,30@6&.,667 13760-34 ;894: 13B6 897 3 50-13&=3/-6/3.63.3@3-2.77,6567-7-8260,606-2824?=80 7,68==62/6.592-.,3>4692:606/7-82.<)'&32:#%<8= 32:287=807,68==62/6592-.,3>4692:606/7-82% 8= ,6 =-0.7 -2=80137-82 3. ;644 3. 7,6 /,30@6&.,667 :86. 287 /8273-2 26/6..30? -2@06:-627. 80 13760-34. 78 -2C8B6 7,6 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82 % 8= 3@3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260 ,6 :-./,30@6 3554-/37-82 =-46: >? - 5 - 7,6 3//9.6: 8.$ 78 < -2 7,6 506.627 /3.6 ,3. >662 3448;6:.-2/67,6/,30@6&.,667:8287/8273-226/6..30? 13760-3478.,8; 7,377,6:6/63.6:;3.>6-2@.9>E6/76: 78 /09647? 6-7,60 1627344? 80 5,?.-/344? >? 7,6 3//9.6: 8.$ 78 < 32: -7 -. 92:60 7,6 .3-: /-0/91.732/6. 7,6 :-./,30@63554-/37-82=-46:>?7,63//9.6:8.$78<;3. 3448;6: >? 7,-. 8907 -2 0-1-234 6C-.-82 67-7-82 8$%%%<< $%$ ( 2.8=303.7,6567-7-8260-./82/6026:7,606-./6073-2 13760-34 3. 3@3-2.7 ,-1 ;,-/, ;894: 50-13&=3/-6 37703/7 7,6 8==62/6. 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82 <)'& 32: #%< 8= 32: 7,606=806 -7 /32287 >6 .3-: 7,37 7,606 -. 3>.849764? 28 13760-34 3. 3@3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260 -2 7,6 /,30@6&.,667 78 >6 508.6/976: =80 7,6 3446@6: 8==62/6. 8;6C60 3. .7376: 6304-60 7,6 /,30@6&.,667 13760-34 -. 287 .9==-/-627 78 508.6/976 7,6 567-7-8260 =80 7,6 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82 % 8= 2:60 7,6 /-0/91.732/6.318=7,685-2-827,377,680:6053..6: >?::-7-8234-.70-/732:6..-82.9:@6 343>903@--2 - 6 - 8")$ $%$$ :376: ""%$%$ 73B-2@ /8@2-F32/68= 7,6/,30@6&.,6676:8==62/6592-.,3>4692:606/7-82% 8= /32287 >6 .9.73-26: //80:-2@4? 7,6 =8448;-2@ 80:60 -! ,6 0-1-234 6C-.-82 67-7-82 -. 53074? 3448;6:G --! ,63554-/37-82=-46:>?7,6567-7-8260>6=806 7,6/89078=7,6::4-.70-/732:6..-82. 9:@6 343>903@- .66B-2@ ,-. :-./,30@6 -. 3448;6:-25307G ---! ,6 80:60 :376: ""%$%$ 53..6: >? 7,6 /8907 8= 7,6 ::4 -.70-/7 32: 6..-82. 9:@6 343>903@- -2 8")$ $%$$ -2.8=30 3. -7 064376. 78 :-.1-..-2@ 7,6 3554-/37-82 8= 7,6 567-7-8260 =-46: 92:60 6/7-82$$(8=0.66B-2@:-./,30@6=80 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82 % 8= -..673.-:632:/82=-016:-2.8=303.-7 064376. 78 8==62/6. 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82. <)'& 32: #%< 8= 82.6H96274? 567-7-8260I. 3554-/37-82 92:60 6/7-82$$(8=0-.53074?3448;6:32:-. - 7 - :-./,30@6: =80 8==62/6 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82%8= -C! ,6 /,30@6&.,667 .,344 >6 7,606=806 543/6: >6=806 7,6 3550850-376 8907 78 508/66: 3@3-2.7 7,6 567-7-8260 -2 3//80:32/6 ;-7, 43; =80 7,6 8==62/6. 592-.,3>46 92:60 6/7-82.<)'&32:#%<8= ,* &$ %! ) ! -.78"48(