Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9585 (KAR)
ASHOK v. SANTOSH AND ANR
MFA/200983/2022 · 2025-02-12
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "# #
$$
%& ' (
! "
# $" %
" &
'
& &
"
! "
("
""
""
! "
# $"""
"()
"!"!("(!('
%
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.14 11:19:02 - 0800
- 2 -
* $ %
%
& (!" ("(!(
"" (! "
&
+" '
,,
,,! - % "(."/"
"
"
& 0"
# $ 0"%
/12345/6/127/389:7+/6;9245/1<</6617417345/ 6/127/3 89:7+/6 ;92 45/ 2/+<973/74 9"( = .7+:2178/ 89><17?"
- 3 -
!(" /.7@1@@2./A/3B?45/C:3@>/741731D123.7
"9" (! 314/3 (!" ("(!( <1++/3 B? 45/ 6/127/3 33.4.9716 /7.92 .A.6 :3@/ 173
14 .C1?1<:21
45/ </4.4.97/2 .+ B/;92/ 45.+ 9:24 +//E.7@ /75178/>/749;89></7+14.97"
!*" 5/ ;184:16 >142.F 9; 45/ 81+/ .+ 4514 45/ </4.4.97/2 97 *!"!*"(! D5.6/ @9.7@ 97 5.+ >94928?86/ B/12.7@/@"9"(&* **
>/4D.4517188.3/74"5/ 1:492.8E+51D B/12.7@ /@"9"(''! 81>/ ;29> 45/ B18E+.3/ 173 8966.3/3 D.45 45/ >94928?86/ 9; 45/ </4.4.97/2"5/ </4.4.97/2 ;/66 39D7 173 +:+41.7/3.7C:2./+ 173 D1+ +5.;4/3 49 .+42.84 9+<.416 14 .C1?1<:21 173 :73/2D/74 42/14>/74" 5/ </4.4.97/2 8974/73/3 4514 5/ D1+1713A9814/51A.7@.789>/9;+"*! !!!</2>9745 173 16+9 1@2.8:64:216 .789>/" / 51+ +:;;/2/3 45/ 3.+1B.6.4?"5/2/;92/
5/.+/74.46/3;9289></7+14.97;29> 45/9D7/2173.7+:2/29;45/9;;/73.7@812"
- 4 -
!'" 5/ 2/+<973/74 9"( .7+:2178/ 89><17? 2/+.+4/3 45/ </4.4.97 8974/73.7@ 4514 45/2/ D1+ 79 +:85 7/@6.@/78/9745/<1249;45/32.A/29;45/1:492.8E+51D" 5/89></7+14.97861.>/3.+5.@56?/F92B.4174
.>1@.712? 173:74/71B6/.761D"416+98974/73/3451445/32.A/29;
45/ 1:492.8E+51D D1+ 794 51A.7@1 A16.3 32.A.7@ 6.8/7+/" 5/2/;92/
45/.7+:2178/89><17?.+7946.1B6/49<1?45/ 89></7+14.97"
!" 5/ 9D7/2 9; 45/ 1:492.8E+51D 4514 .+ 2/+<973/74 9" 3.3 794 1<</12" + +:85
5/ D1+ <618/3 /F<124/"
!" 5/2.B:716;21>/31<<29<2.14/.++:/+17345/ </4.4.97/2/F1>.7/35.>+/6;1+ &" 173F" " 49D/2/ >12E/3 .7 45/ /A.3/78/" 5/ 9;;.8.16 9; 45/ 2/+<973/74 9"( D1+ /F1>.7/3 1+ &" 173 F"" 49 F""' D/2/ >12E/3.745//A.3/78/"
- 5 -
!" ;4/2 5/12.7@ 45/ 12@:>/74+ 173 97 </2:+.7@ 45//A.3/78/972/8923
45/2.B:7165/63451445/32.A/29;
45/ 1:492.8E+51D D1+ 794 51A.7@1 A16.3 32.A.7@ 6.8/7+/" 5/2/;92/ G:174.;./3 45/ @69B16 89></7+14.97 14 Rs,.*! !!! 173 ;1+4/7/3 45/ 6.1B.6.4? 97 45/ 2/+<973/74 9" 976?"
!" 5/6/127/389:7+/61<</12.7@;9245/</4.4.97/2 .7 45.+ 1<</16 8974/73/3 4514 45/ 89></7+14.97 1D123/3 B?45/2.B:716.+9745/69D/2+.3/"451+794897+.3/2/3 45/ 89></7+14.97 :73/2 45/ 5/13 9; <1.7 173 +:;;/2.7@ 69++ 9; .789>/ 173 69++ 9; 1>/7.4./+ .7 6.;/" 4 .+ 16+9 +:B>.44/3 4514 45/ 2.B:716 /2297/9:+6? ;1+4/7/3 45/ 6.1B.6.4? 97 45/ 2/+<973/74 9" 976?" 7 A./D 9; +/A/216 C:3@>/74+ 9; 45/ </F 9:24 173 45/ .@5 9:24+
45/ 2/+<973/74 9"( +59:63 51A/ B//7 3.2/84/3 49 <1? 45/ 89></7+14.97 D.45 6.B/24?
49 2/89A/2 45/ +1>/ ;29> 45/ 2/+<973/749" "745.+2/@1235/<618/+2/6.178/9745/ C:3@>/74 9; 45/ 97-B6/ :<2/>/ 9:24 .7 45/ 81+/ 9;
- 6 -
.7 45/ 81+/ 9;
!173.745/81+/9;
" # $%"
!," /2 897421
45/ 6/127/3 89:7+/6 1<</12.7@ ;92 45/ 2/+<973/74 9"( 8974/73+ 4514 45/ B/7/;.4 9; 45/ <2.78.<6/+ 9; <1? 173 2/89A/2 .+ 1A1.61B6/ 976? .; 45/ 2/+<973/749" .7+:2/31<</12B/;92/45/2.B:716173 41E/+ :< 45/ 3/;/78/ 4514 B/6./A.7@ .7 45/ D923+ 9; 45/ 32.A/2
5/513/742:+4/345/A/5.86/495.>"76/++181+/ >13/ 9:4 97 B/516; 9; 45/ 9D7/2 9; 45/ A/5.86/ 4514 5/ 184/3.7@993;1.45
B:451+794.74/74.97166?B2/185/317? 9; 45/ 4/2>+ 173 8973.4.97+ 9; 45/ <96.8?" / +:B>.44/3 4514 45/ <2.78.<6/ 9; <1? 173 2/89A/2? 817794 B/ 897+.3/2/3D5/745/2/+<973/749" 51+B//7<618/3/F
1
2
3 $(! %*(! - 7 -
<124/B/;92/45/2.B:716)797/9;45/3/8.+.97+2/6./3B? 45/6/127/389:7+/61<</12.7@;9245/</4.4.97/24514D9:63 B/ 1<<6.81B6/ 49 45/ 81+/ 97 5173" 5/2/;92/
97 45.+ @29:73 5/ 2/+.+4/3 45/ 8974/74.97 9; 45/ 6/127/3 89:7+/6 1<</12.7@ ;92 1<</66174" /89736? 5/ 16+9 3/;/73/3 45/ G:174:> 9; 45/ 89></7+14.97 1D123/3 B? 45/ 2.B:716 +59D.7@ 45/ ;184 4514 45/2/ .+ 79 >14/2.16 97 2/8923 49 1<<2/8.14/ D5/45/2 45/2/ D1+ 17? /F</7+/+ 92 17? 3.+1B.6.4?4945/</4.4.97/2"
!" 5/;.2+41+</84.+49B/897+.3/2/3D5/45/245/ <2.78.<6/ 9; <1? 173 2/89A/2? 817 B/ 897+.3/2/3" 5/ C:3@>/74 9; 45/ </F 9:24 .7 45/ 81+/ 9;
814/@92.8166? 89>/+ 49 45/ 89786:+.97 4514 45/ .7+:2178/89><17?.+7946.1B6/49<1?45/89></7+14.97 +.78/45//A.3/78/<293:8/3+59D451445/32.A/251379 32.A.7@ 6.8/7+/" ;4/2 +414.7@ 4514 45/ .7+:2178/ 89><17? 51+49B/1B+96A/3
45/</F9:24.7 1219""(
3.2/84+ 45/ .7+:2178/ 89><17? 49 <1? 45/ 89></7+14.97 1>9:74 17345/72/89A/245/+1>/;29>45/9D7/29;45/A/5.86/"
- 8 -
" 4 .+ D9245 49 794/ 4514 45/ 923/2 9; 45/ </F 9:24 .7 3.2/84.7@ 45/ .7+:2178/ 89><17? 49 <1? 45/ 89></7+14.97D1+.7/F/28.+/9;45/<9D/2+:73/224.86/ '(9;45/97+4.4:4.979;73.1"&5/745/214.951+B//7 61.339D7B?45/</F9:24
45/+1>/.+B.73.7@"745/ ;184+ 173 8.28:>+4178/+ 9; 45/ 81+/
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
/A.3/746? 45/ .7+:2178/ 89><17?
51+ 1<</12/3 173 513 6/3 /A.3/78/" 5/2/;92/ D5/745/.7+:2178/89><17?51+.7A9E/345/<29A.+.97+9; /84.97 ! 9; 45/ 9492 /5.86/+ 84
.4 817 41E/ 17? - 9 -
3/;/78/4514.+1A1.61B6/4945/9D7/216+9"74514A./D9;
45/ >144/2
45/ C:3@>/74 .7 45/ 81+/ 9;
.+ 7941<<6.81B6/ 49 45/ 81+/ 97 5173" 5/ C:3@>/74 9; 45/ </F 9:24 .7 45/ 81+/ 9; +G:12/6? 2/6./+ 97 45/ <2.78.<6/+ 61.3 39D7 .7 45/ 81+/ 9;
"
&"5/</F9:24 51+ 5/63 1B9:4 45/ <2.78.<6/+ .7 121 9" ! 173 " 5/ <2.78.<6/+ 61.3 39D7 B? 45/ </F 9:24 D1+ ;9669D/3 .7 -+81+/"5/2/;92/
45/C:3@>/749;45/</F9:24 .7 45/ 81+/ 9; 39/+ 794 61? 39D7 45/ <2.78.<6/ 9;
<1? 173 2/89A/2?" 9D/A/2
.4 2/6./+ 97 45/ C:3@>/74 9;
49 5963 4514 .7 8/241.7 8.28:>+4178/+ D5/2/45/.7+:2/351+1<</12/3B/;92/45/9:2417351+ /F<61.7/345/8.28:>+4178/+:73/2D5.855//742:+4/345/ A/5.86/491</2+9751A.7@7932.A.7@6.8/7+/
45/<2.78.<6/ 9; <1? 173 2/89A/2? >1? B/ 923/2/3" 7 45/ ;184+ 173 8.28:>+4178/+9;45/81+/.7A96A/3.7
.4;9:7345/ 1<<6.81B.6.4?9;45/<2.78.<6/+61.339D7.745.+81+/"
4
- 10 -
'" 745/81+/975173
.4.+1713>.44/3;1844514 45/32.A/29;45/1:492.8E+51DD1+79451A.7@17?32.A.7@ 6.8/7+/"++:8545/9;;/78/:73/2/84.97*9;45/9492 /5.86/+ 84 51+ 16+9 B//7 ;1+4/7/3 :<97 5.> :73/2 45/ 8512@/+5//4" 5/ 2/+<973/74 9" .7+:2/3 51+ 794 1<</12/3 B/;92/ 45/ 2.B:716" 5/ 2/+<973/74 9"( .7+:2178/ 89><17? 51+ 6/3 /A.3/78/ 49 +59D 4514 45/ 32.A/2 D1+ 794 51A.7@ 1 A16.3 32.A.7@ 6.8/7+/" 5/2/;92/ 45/G:/+4.979;<1?1732/89A/2?3979412.+/"92/9A/2 45/ 1<</66174 817794 .7+.+4 4514 45/ 89></7+14.97 51+ 49 B/<1.3B?45/2/+<973/749"(976? D5/745/89742184:16 9B6.@14.97+ /F.+4 B/4D//7 45/ 2/+<973/74+ 9" 173 (" 5/2/;92/
45/1<</66174817794.7+.+4:<9745/</2+97D59 51+49<1?45/89></7+14.97"
" 9>.7@4945/G:174:>9;45/89></7+14.97
.4 .+/A.3/74451445/</4.4.97/2513+:;;/2/3;2184:2/9;45/ 2.@54D2.+4
45/B1+/9;;.2+417345>/41812<169;45/2.@54 5173" A.3/746? 45/ </4.4.97/2 51+ 794 <293:8/3 17? >14/2.16 49 +59D 4514 5/ D1+ .7<14./74 92 59D >:85
- 11 -
/F</7+/+5/513.78:22/3;9245/42/14>/74"5/</4.4.97/2 B/.7@6/@16<2184.4.97/2D1+A/2?D/66D.45.745/E79D6/3@/ 4514 45/+/ 398:>/74+ 12/ 49 B/ <293:8/3 B/;92/ 45/ 2.B:716 49 89>/ 49 1 89786:+.97 97 45/ 89></7+14.97 1>9:74 49 B/ 1D123/3" 5/2/;92/
.4 51+ 49 B/ .7;/22/3 4514 45/ </4.4.97/2 .+ 794 51A.7@ 17? +:85 >14/2.16" 9D/A/2
.4.+2/6/A174499B+/2A/451445/2.B:7163.3794 @.A/17?89></7+14.97+/<1214/6?:73/245/5/139;<1.7 173+:;;/2.7@
1>/7.4./+17369++9;.789>/3:2.7@45/61.3 :< </2.93" / B/.7@ 1 6/@16 <2184.4.97/2 173 51A.7@ +:;;/2/3 45/ ;2184:2/ 9; 45/ ;.2+4 173 45/ 45 >/41812<16 D1+:71B6/49</2;92>5.+3:4./+"++:85
45/2/.+17//3 ;92/75178/>/749;45/89></7+14.97"
" 7 45/ 897+.3/2/3 9<.7.97 9; 45.+ 9:24 45/ </4.4.97/2 .+ /74.46/3 ;92 1 +:> 9; +"(! !!! :73/2 45/ 5/139;<1.7173+:;;/2.7@
+:>9;+"
!!!:73/245/ 5/139;69++9;.789>/3:2.7@45/61.3:<</2.93"+:>9; Rs.'!
!!!:73/245/5/139;69++9;1>/7.4./+.76.;/"
- 12 -
" 5/2/;92/
45/ </4.4.97/2 .+ /74.46/3 ;92 49416 /75178/3 89></7+14.97 9; +"'
!!! :73/2 45/ ;9669D.7@5/13+
6" 9" /13+ 9></7+14.97 D123/3 B?45.+9:24
" 1.7173+:;;/2.7@ +"(! !!! (" 9++9;.789>/3:2.7@ 61.3:<</2.93 +"
!!! *" 9++9;1>/7.4./+ +"'! !!! 9416 /++D123/3B?45/ 2.B:716 +"
!!! +"*! !!! 9416/75178/>/74
+"'
!!! " /78/
1<</16 3/+/2A/+ 49 B/ 1669D/3 .7 <124" 5/2/;92/
45/;9669D.7@)
- 13 -
" 5/1<</16.+1669D/3.7<124"
" 5/1<</66174.+/74.46/3;921+:>9;+"'
!!!.7 133.4.97 49 D514 51+ B//7 1D123/3 B? 45/ 2.B:716 1697@D.45.74/2/+41445/214/9;H<"1";29>314/ 9;</4.4.974.6645/314/9;3/<9+.4"
" /+4 9; 45/ 923/2 <1++/3 B? 45/ 2.B:716 2/@123.7@ 3/<9+.4/48"
2/>1.7:7164/2/3"
" 5/2/+<973/749" .7+:2/39D7/29;45/A/5.86/ +5166<1?45/89></7+14.974945/</4.4.97/2D.45.71 </2.939;D//E+"
" 5/ 1<</16 1+ 1@1.7+4 45/ 2/+<973/74 9"( .+ 3.+>.++/3"
3 %# ' #
.+49" 69"