- 1 - !" !# $" " % & ! " # $%! &'( " &# ! ! $ %! " # " )% " $# (" % (" $ %$ * %( ! "$ $$( " $ $$(" # & "&%! $ ! +%+" '$ (" # " !$ %$" $ ($ %$' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $# " ! $" &$!$" $" %! #'' * $ %( % "$" $ $+ $ $ $ !$ " (# $( !$# $ $ $ $ $ %( !$# $ $$ % (" "%( # '% & # ! " # $%! &''( " & ! ! " % (" # " )% " $# (" % (" $ %$ * %( ! "$ $$( " $ $$(" - 3 - # & " &%! $ ! +%+ '$ (" # " !$ %$" $ ($ %$' $# " ! $" &$!$" $" %! #'' * $ %( % "$" , $ $+ $ $ $ !$ " (# $( !$# $ $ $ $ $ %( !$# $ $$ % (" %( # "# $" $(" !$# $ $ !$ & & -% ! " &-% ! ./012./03.145637.2/88./093:;50<=./88.22/3<7 /31 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 <=. 31 0.78531.3< 93 >5<= <=./88./27 - 4 - =./88.22/3<793<=.7./88./27/0.0.78.4<9?.2@<=. 8.<9<953.07 93 57 /31 >.;50. <=. 2./03.1.39509?9261:./31 "%/7/?/A/2@/3";507=50< B 09>63/2C =.;/4<6/2D/<09E5;<=.4/7.97<=/<53+ <=. 8.<9<953.07" 3/D.2@ =9?/0/F /31 /:/3/<= G.0. <0/?.293: 53<=.903.G2@8604=/7.1.05531/D5<504@42./31/:/3/<= G/709193:<=.7/D.,<=.@D.<G9<=/3/4491.3<G=.3/G9;< /0 >./093: 5+%+ 4/D. ;05D <=. 588579<. 190.4<953 93 3.:29:.3< D/33.0 /31 452291.1 /:/937< <=. D5<504@42. 5; <=. 8.<9<953.07 7 / 0.762<" <=. /88.22/3< =9?/0/F93576;;.0.1;0/4<60.5; ";.D60" 09:=<2/<.0/24531@2."7.:D.3</2;0/4<60.5;09:=<<9>9/"09:=<;55< 4067= 93F60@" 46< ;50.;55< /D86</<953 /31 7=9;<.1 <5 #5?.03D.3<5789</2/<%/7/?/A/2@/3/<.0=.<55A<0./<D.3< /< /3/1.5789</2/<D.0://31=.G/7938/<9.3<;50/>56< 1/@7 =. 091.0 /:/3/<=" G=5 97 /88.22/3< 93 5"76;;.0.18/0<9/2/D86</<9535;09:=<D91;55<" 46< ;0/4<60. 5; /22 D.</</07/27" ;0/4<60. 5; 09:=< ! 45DD639<.1 ;0/4<60. 5; 09:=< ;.D60 7.:D.3</2" ;0/4<60. 5; 4531@2.7 . G/7 /275 /1D9<<.1 <5 <=. =5789</2 /31 <55A - 5 - <0./<D.3< ;50 3./02@ ;560 D53<=7 =.@ ;92.1 42/9D 8.<9<953 >.;50.<=. 09>63/27..A93:<=./1.H6/<.45D8.37/<953 %.;50. <=. 09>63/2" 53 9776/34. 5; <=. 35<94." 0.78531.3<7/88./0.1<=056:=<=.900.78.4<9?.45637.27 ' .78531.3< 5 5G3.0 5; <=. ?.=942. 453<.31.1 <=/< <=. 45D8.37/<953 42/9D.1 97 =9:=2@ .E50>9</3< /31 63 9D/:93/0@ /31 <=.0. G/7 35 764= 3.:29:.34. 53 =97 8/0<" >6< <=.3.:29:.34.G/753<=.8/0<5;<=.091.05;<=.D5<504@42. ;/3@45D8.37/<95397<5>.8/91"<=.7/D.>.;/7<.3.16853 0.78531.3< 53760/34. 5D8/3@ /7 <=.0. G/7 / ?/291 93760/34. .78531.3< 5 I 3760/34. 5D8/3@ <55A 68 79D92/0 453<.3<9537 /31 453<.31.1 /31 <=.0. G/7 35 764= 93760/34. >@ 9< /31 <=. 45319<9537 5; <=. 85294@ G.0. /275 ?952/<.1 =. 09>63/253<=.>/7975;<=.453<.3<95375;<=. 8/0<9.7;0/D.1/8805809/<.9776.7">5<=<=.8.<9<953.07.3<.0.1 <=. G9<3.77 >5E /311.857.1 /77 /31 /31 <=. $54<50 G=5/77.77.1<=.90197/>929<@G/7.E/D93.1/7 E7<5 - 6 - G.0. D/0A.1 53 <=.90 >.=/2; 5 .?91.34. G/7 2.1 53 >.=/2; 5; <=. 0.78531.3<7 ;<.0 =./093: >5<= <=. 791.7" <=. 09>63/2=/7/G/01.145D8.37/<953631.0<=.;5225G93:=./17& ()%I0.:/0193:=9?/0/F 2 5 ./1 G/01D563< /93/3176;;.093: 7" 5775;/D.39<9.7 7" <<.31/34.4=/0:.7 7" .194/2 E8.37.7 7"+" ' 577 5; 9345D. 16093: <0./<D.3< 7" 5775;;6<60../0393: 7+" 5</2 7"" 5631.15; 7"" ()%I0.:/0193:/:/3/<= 2 5 ./1 G/01D563< 6<60.63=/8893.77 7"" /93/3176;;.093: 7" .194/2 E8.37.7 7"" 5775;8/@ 7"" 5</2 7'"" 5631.15; 7'"+" ./03.145637.2/88./093:;50<=./88.22/3<93 5 ;92.1 >@ <=. 091.0 /:/3/<= 76>D9<7 <=/< <=56:= /:/3/<= G/7 / #5?.03D.3< D825@.." =. 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50/1.H6/<.45D8.37/<953631.0<=.=./1725775;/D.39<9.793 - 7 - 29;."8/93/3176;;.093:7/3125775;8/@< 9776>D9<<.1<=/< <=. 09>63/2 =/7 .00.1 93 /77.7793: <=. 45D8.37/<953 631.0 <=.7.=./17 + " 2./03.1 45637.2 /88./093: ;50 0.78531.3<3760/34.5D8/3@76>D9<7<=/<<=.0.97353..1 ;50/3@.3=/34.D.3<5;<=.45D8.37/<953/D563< =. /88.22/3< /:/3/<= <=56:= =/?93: 76;;.0.1 <=. />5?. 7/91 93F609.7 /31 /D86</<953 5; 75D. 5; <=. D.</</07/27" <=. 09>63/2 =5217 <=/< =. 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 <=. 45D8.37/<953 5; 7" 631.0 <=. =./1 5; 8/93 /31 76;;.093: %.93: / #5?.03D.3< .0?/3< 7.0?93: 93 <=. $.8/0<D.3< 5; .09462<60."G=94= 93?52?.7 .E<.379?. <0/?.293:" <=.45D8.37/<953/88./07<5>.5325G.0791. =.3/<60.5; <=. 93F609.7 76::.7<7 <=/< G=.3 <=.0. 97 =/2; 5; <=. ;55< =/7 >..3 /D86</<.1" =97 D5?.D.3<7 /0. 8/93;62 /31 =. =/7 <5 76;;.0<=.7/D.;500.7<5;=9729;. =.0.;50."937<./15;76D5; 7" /G/01.1 >@ <=. 09>63/2" 9< G5621 >. F67< /31 /8805809/<. <5 /G/01 / 76D 5; 7"" 631.0 <=. =./1 25775;/D.39<9.7;6<60.63=/8893.77 - 8 - 78593<.156<>@<=.2./03.145637.2/88./093:;50 <=. /88.22/3<7" E 7=5G7 <=/< <=. 8.<9<953.0 I /:/3/<= G/753./03.12./?.;50/8.09515;'1/@7 JD53<=7 5G.?.0"<=. 09>63/2939<7G9715D=.21<=/<532@;9?.D53<=7 5;2./?.G5621=/?.>..376;;949.3<=.3<=.0.972./?.5;J D53<=7 =/1 >..3 :0/3<.1 >@ <=. 9:=.0 ;;94.07 5; <=. 8.<9<953.0I/:/3/<=53/44563<5;<=.D.194/245319<9537"<=. 09>63/2 45621 35< =/?. 0.164.1 <=. 7/D. G=92. /G/0193: 45D8.37/<953 =.0.;50."<=.8.<9<953.097.3<9<2.1;50/76D5; 7" E ' K 7"+" 937<./1 5; 7"" 631.0 <=. =./1 2577 5; ./0393: 16093: 2/91 68 8.0951 2577 5; 8/@ 60<=.0"9<G5621>.F67</31/8805809/<.<5/G/01/ 76D 5; 7" 631.0 <=. =./1 /<<.31/3< 4=/0:.7 16093: 2/91 68 8.0951 .34." <=. 8.<9<953.0 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 D519;9.1 45D8.37/<953/7>.25G& 2 5 ./1 G/01 >@ <=. 09>63/2 G/01>@<=97 560< 6<60.63=/8893.77 7"" 7"" /93/3176;;.093:7 7" 7"" - 9 - .194/2.E8.37.7 7"" 7"" 5775;8/@ 7"" 7"+" ' <<.31/3<4=/0:.7 7" 7'"" 5631.15; 7'"+" 7"'" 375;/0/7<=.42/9D/3<I=9?/0/F/88.22/3<93 5974534.03.1"=.=/176;;.0.1?/0956793F609.7 /73/00/<.1>@<=. 09>63/293/0/I5;9<7F61:D.3<"G=94= 0./17/7>.25G& =. .?91.34. 5; .194/2 ;;94.0" G=5 /77.77.1<=.197/>929<@"7=5G7<=/<<=.8.<9<953.0I=9?/0/F97 63/>2. <5 7H6/<" 429D> <=. 7</907" >.31 93 <=. 09:=< =98" <=9:= /31/3A2..<4"/31<=.0.;50.=./77.77.1<=.197/>929<@/<'+L <5<=.G=52.>51@<978.0<93.3<<535<.<=/</.194/2;;94.0 4/3 532@ /77.77 <=. 8=@794/2 197/>929<@" >6< 35< <=. ;634<953/2 197/>929<@4450193:<5<=.8.<9<953.0"=.97/3:09462<6097<>@ 805;.77953 /31 /:.1 />56< @./07" <=.0.;50." <=. 197/>929<@ - 10 - 45621 35< =/?. >..3 0.164.1 >@ <=. 09>63/2 =. />5?. /0:6D.3<7 5; <=. 2./03.1 45637.2 ;50 <=. /88.22/3< 4/335< >. /44.8<.1" 7934." <=. ;634<953/2 197/>929<@ /31 <=. 8=@794/2 197/>929<@ 3..1 35< >. /2G/@7 >. .H6/2 3 <=. 453791.0.1 58939535;<=97560<"<=.;634<953/2197/>929<@5;<=.8.<9<953.0 =/7<5>.</A.3/<L/317934.<=.8.<9<953.097/:.1/>56< @./07 9< G5621>.19;;9462< ;50 /:.1 8.0753 <5 /1/8<<5 <=. 197/>929<@76;;.0.1>@=9D ' =.:691.293.79776.1>@<=. /03/</A/</<..:/2 .0?94.76<=509<@;507.<<2.D.3<5;<=.19786<.7>.;50.<=.5A 1/2/< 80.7409>. <=. 35<953/2 9345D. 5; " ;50 <=. @./0 3 6D8<..3 36D>.0 5; 1.4979537" <=97 560< =/7 =.21 <=/<<=.:691.293.79776.1>@ /0.=.21<5>./44.8</>2. 53 <=. :05631 <=/< <=.@ /0. 93 :.3.0/2 453;50D9<@ G9<= <=. D939D6D G/:.7 ;9E.1 631.0 <=. 939D6D /:.7 4< =.0.;50."<=.35<953/29345D.5;<=.8.<9<953.097/44.8<.1/7 "8.0D53<= =67" <=. 8.<9<953.0 97 .3<9<2.1 ;50 / 2577 5; ;6<60.9345D./< 7"EELE+ 937<./1 5; 7+" /G/01.1 >@ <=. 09>63/2 - 11 - 537.H6.3<2@"<=.45D8.37/<953;50<=.2/91688.0951/275 .3=/34.1<5 7"/:/937< 7"/G/01.1>@ <=. 09>63/2 =. 09>63/2=/7/G/01.1/76D5; 7" <5G/017 8/93 /31 76;;.093:7" G=94= 97 53 <=. 25G.0 791." <=.7/D.97.3=/34.1<5 7" =.45D8.37/<953631.00.7<5;<=.=./1715.7 35<0.H690. /3@ 93<.0;.0.34. >@ <=97 560<"<=.0.;50." <=. 8.<9<953.097.3<9<2.1;50<=.45D8.37/<953/7>.25G& 2 5 ./1 G/01 >@ <=. 09>63/2 G/01>@<=97 560< /93/3176;;.093: 7" 7" 5775;/D.39<9.7 7" 7" <<.31/34.4=/0:.7 7" 7" .194/2 E8.37.7 7"+" 7"+" 577 5; 9345D. 16093:<0./<D.3< 7" 7" ' 577 5; ;6<60. ./0393: 7+" 7"'" 5</2 7"" 5631.15; 7"" 7"" - 12 - + 50 <=. /;50.7/91 0./7537" <=. /88./27 1.7.0?. <5>./225G.1938/0<.34."<=.;5225G93:& $ 9 %5<=<=. 99 =./88.22/3<93597.3<9<2.1<5 /119<953/2 45D8.37/<953 5; 7" /31 <=. /88.22/3< 93 5 97 .3<9<2.1 <5 /119<953/2 45D8.37/<953 7"""G9<=93<.0.7</<L8.0/336D;05D<=.1/<. 5;8.<9<953<9229<70./29M/<953 999 =. 0.7< 5; <=. <.0D7 /31 45319<9537 0.:/0193: 1.8579</31.<4"501.0.1>@<=. 09>63/20.D/9363/2<.0.1 9? .78531.3<3760/34. 5D8/3@ 97 190.4<.1 <5 1.8579<<=./119<953/245D8.37/<953/D563<G9<=93;560G..A7 ;05D<=.1/<.5;<=.0.4.98<5;<=.458@5;<=97F61:D.3< 1 *" + " % 97<5&25& &