Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9580 (KAR)
SMT. SHRUTI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200432/2025 · 2025-02-27
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9580 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9580 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$%%
& '
!"! #
$
%
&
'
("""&
! !"! !"! ) $%
!"! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
( '
*
' )
+ ' *
&"
' *
&& )
&! )+
&
"
&)
&
)"
&( ' (
&*
)
&
)" &
- 3 -
!"! #
$ '&, ),
'
&"%
!!( !!*
!+"&!"! -
.' '
/01023234506703582/06093:0524;<=00=<8>5:3 6<?1<5@/<A<2 /<9 ;3=0: 2/39 B632 10232345 @/<==058358 < 5423@0 :<20: !+"&!"! 399>0: 7A 609145:052 4 @45C05358 < ?002358 4; 2/0 ?0?7069 4; <5@/<A<2 24 @4593:06<5423@04;54@45;3:05@0
- 4 -
! /0 1023234506 @45205:9 2/<2 9/0 <5: 609145:052 49 24 * <60 ?0?7069 4; <=0 0=<8>5:3 6<?1<5@/<A<2/01023234506B<90=0@20:<9<6093:052 4;9<3:6<?1<5@/<A<2<22/00=0@2345/0=:45")" !"! ;46 2/0 90@45: 206? ;46 < 10634: 4; " ?452/9 /0 @45205:92/<29/0B<9:39@/<68358/06:>2309935@060=A<5:
/45092=A 35 <@@46:<5@0 B32/ 2/0 164C393459 4; 2/0 <65<2<D< 6<? B<6<E <5: <5@/<A<2 <E @2 &++ 4B0C06 609145:052 49 24 &* /<: 9>7?3220: <5 <11=3@<23453546?4&B32/609145:05240F16099358 =<@D 4; @45;3:05@0 35 2/0 1023234506 <5: 60G>0920: 24 @45C050<?00235824@4593:06<?423454;54@45;3:05@0 023234506@45205:92/<254<==08<23459B060?<:0<8<3592 /06 35 2/0 601609052<2345 /0 @45205:9 2/<2 609145:052 4 B32/4>2 906C358 5423@0 4; 2/0 ?002358 45 /06 /<:
@45C050: < ?002358 45 & "!!"! <5: 2/060;460 2/0 164@00:358 B<9 542 35 <@@46:<5@0 B32/ >=0 $&% 4; 2/0 <65<2<D<<5@/<A<2<E$423454;445;3:05@0<8<3592 :/A<D9/<<5:1:/A<D9/<%>=09&++)/0@45205:9 2/<2 9/0 B<9 542 <2 <== 906C0: B32/ 2/0 5423@0 :<20:
- 5 -
!+"&!"! <5: /05@0 2/0 ?002358 @45C050: 45 & "!!"! B<9 C34=<23C0 4; >=09 &++) /0 =0<650: @4>590=;461023234506603206<20:2/0<74C0@4520523459<5: 9>7?3220:2/<22/060B<9545423@04;2/0?002358242/0 1023234506 <5: /05@0 2/0 164@00:3589 35323<20: 7A 609145:0524<60=3<7=02470902<25<>8/2 /052/39 10232345B<9=3920:45&*"!!"!2/394>62/<::360@20: 2/0?0023584;54@45;3:05@02470/0=:<5:<=94:360@20: 2/<22/0609>=24;2/0?0023589/<==54270<554>5@0:
0<650: ::32345<= 4C065?052 :C4@<20 9>7?3220: 2/<2 1023234506 B<9 6093:358 B32/ /06 />97<5: <5:35=<B9<2<:8363/060;4602/0)C39320:/06/4>90 <2<:83637>22/0102323450660;>90:24<@@0122/05423@0 /060;460 < @41A 4; 2/0 5423@0 B<9 <;;3F0: 45 2/0 4>206 :4464;/06/4>90<2<:836309>7?3292/<22/0/4>904;
1023234506 <2 <:8363 70=4580: 24 /06 ;<2/0635=<B 0 @45205:9 2/<2 609145:052 4) 2/05 C39320: 2/0 /4>90 4;
1023234506 B32/35 2/0 =3?329 4; 6<?1<5@/<A<2 <5: 935@0 2/0:446B<9=4@D0:<@41A4;2/05423@0B<9<;;3F0:45
- 6 -
2/04>206:4464;2/0/4>9002/060;460@45205:92/<2 2/060 39:>0 @4?1=3<5@04; 2/0 164C393459 4;>=0 $&%4; 2/0>=09&++) ) /39 39 /4B0C06 @4>52060: 7A 2/0 =0<650:
@4>590= ;46 2/0 1023234506 B/4 9>7?3220: 2/<2 2/0 1023234506 39 542 6093:358 <2 2/0 /4>90 B/060 2/0 5423@0 B<9<;;3F0:0@45205:92/<22/01023234506396093:358<2 2/0/4>9070<63584)&!*<5:/05@02/05423@0<;;3F0: 452/04>206:4464;2/0/4>9070<63584&(:409542 <?4>52 24 164106 906C3@0 4; 5423@0 5 9>11462 4; /39 @452052345 /0 /<9 1=<@0: 45 60@46: 2/0
4206H9 3:05232A @<6: <9 B0== <9 2/0 <:/<<6 @<6: B/3@/ 35:3@<20 2/<2 2/0 1023234506396093:358<2/4>9070<63584)&!*02/>9 @45205:9 2/<2 2/0 1023234506 39 542 6093:358 <2 2/0 /4>90 B/060609145:0524)/<:1>614620:=A<;;3F0:2/05423@0 <5:/05@02/060B<954164106@4?1=3<5@0
/05 2/39 10232345 B<9 =3920: 45 !)"!!"!
2/394>621<990:2/0;4==4B35846:06
- 7 -
!! "
#
"
!$%!!%!$ &&'%%" (
)
#
* !+%!!%!$,
( 4==4B358 2/0 <74C0 46:06 609145:052 4) C39320: 2/0 /4>90 4; 1023234506 1>614620:=A ;4>5: 35 550F>60<5:/09>7?3220:<60146224:<AB/3@/60<:9 <9;4==4B9
! "# $
% &'' () *+ ,-
+.-/
' 01 550F>60 23 4 5
6/)-23 /%2378/' 999
- 8 -
% '' - - :; &< =01
> * ? :/
*8@A/8=01
>:
*-23
? @A
+B=+CD E/' F
/G)+7.H7?'
+.4/8?C - +. :
?* ? 23 4-I'
+2 "- 550F>60 23
4-
+ J- 0 D KL 4-
+ J- G)+7 .H7 ?'
+. :
+M-' : ?* -
- &N FOP?QC /'3OP?QCL R L SS
T
@
T?%L N .O?QC /' U ;(V?QCL SS T
@
T?%L N G)+ U ;(V /' -
+0-)(VL R L SS T
@
T?%L NG)+#+(V/':O/LRL SS T
@
T?% :
?* WXUY% -"Z(V/'UR(VL
L
+
-G - G)+ U(V /' G(V :
?* G(V /' :O/L [D! D
\! 4
3 W]-23 0 X
23 J1\ % %- 078+ ^ :
? -K
23 J1\ % 478+L T
@
T?%
23 J1\ % 478+ JU- ; F +>C
_`?M? +TD E/ : ?* 0 D E/' 4
*;UY _`-
- G)+ 3 /' /WOPL R&L SS T
@
T?%4*C: Z-I'&NFOP ?QC:
+M
() a /
)/8U ;(V*Ca /
)/8
" L :Ob;
:
*+- >K 4- I? /) 7?M? "c * 7?M? *
W U- :
*+?/ 8
'
? 4d- /) -K23
23
+J-7MX-' : ?*=WXUY%*C
"-A`e? K,K- ? ? @A
+B
*C78+%IJ-G)+/ _`&FOP?QC W XUY% - 7W(V [D! D
+\? +M- ? ? -K23
? :
*+K e fX
*C U78-
I
- 9 -
J- J3 W]-23 7MX-' :
?* G)+/ 3 /'/WOP:
+M
()
"-A` -.H7?'
+.: ? Ue/423
+4/ 8
J-:
+M
=+f/ 8
'
_`- e &N FOP?QC/'3OP?QCe N .O?QC/'U ;(V?QCe N U ;(V/'-
+0-)(Ve N G)+3/'/WOPe N G)+ #+(V /' :O/ -L R L
SS T
@
T?%e N /6>23<:<Ce e ( 7"[gH%h"%g L ?
)( / T
@
T?%L / SS?iD!L#SS -Kj
* /0 =0<650: @4>590= ;46 609145:052 4) 9>7?329 609145:052 4) /<: 9052 @41A 4; 5423@0 24 1023234506 45 /06 /<2911 5>?706 <5: 2/060;460 102323450639<B<604;5423@0399>0:24/06
/<C0 @4593:060: 2/0 9>7?3993459 4; =0<650:
@4>590= ;46 1023234506 <5: =0<650: ::32345<= 4C065?052 :C4@<20<5:=0<650:@4>590=;46163C<20609145:0529<5:
- 10 -
63 6>5D>?<6 ?<68>5:<11< 2/0 =0<650: @4>590= B/4 601609052909145:0524) + 5:06>=0$%4;>=09&++)1609@637092/0 164@0:>60;46906C3@04;<5423@0<5:2/09<?0390F26<@20: 70=4B -./ ## )
)( 0)( -/)
1 -/
" )
(
23 ) )
)1 -/) 1 -/
" )
" )" (
2 ),
&" /0 ;3=0 60=<2358 24 I54 @45;3:05@0 ?42345H 35323<20: <8<3592 2/0 1023234506 B<9 9>??450: <5: 2/0
- 11 -
9<?0:39@=49092/<2609145:0524)/<:906C0:2/05423@0 4; ?002358 45 <== 2/0 ?0?7069 <2 2/036 60910@23C0 6093:05@0946452/0?106945<==A/0609145:0524)39 74>5: 24 D54B 2/0 46:35<6A 1=<@0 4; 6093:05@0 4;
1023234506 B32/35 2/0 6<?1<5@/<A<2 /0 1023234506 /<9 542:39@=490:/062/01<623@>=<694;/06/4>90352/0@<>90 232=0 4; B632 10232345 7>2 /<9 54B @45C053052=A @45205:0: 2/<2 9/0 39 6093:358 35 < /4>90 70<6358 4)&!* /0 1023234506/<954290634>9=A@4520920:2/0@=<3?4;=0<650:
::32345<= 4C065?052 :C4@<20 <9 B0== <9 =0<650: @4>590=;46609145:0524)2/<2609145:0524)2630:24 906C02/01023234506<22/01=<@04;6093:05@04;1023234506 <2 <:8363 <5: 2/060<;206 <;;3F0: < @41A 4; 5423@0 45 2/0 4>206:4464;2/0/4>90932><20B32/352/06<?1<5@/<A<2 0<=94:3:542:391>202/0;<@22/<2<@41A4;5423@0B<9 9052242/010232345067A /<291145/06?473=01/450 /060;460609145:0524)/<92<D05<==9201924059>60 906C3@04;5423@04;2/0?002358/01023234506/<92630:24 :09106<20=A 9<C0 /06 14932345 <9 2/0 6093:052 4;
- 12 -
<5@/<A<2 7A @=<3?358 2/<2 9/0 B<9 542 6093:358 <2 2/0 /4>90B/0602/05423@0B<9<;;3F0: && /0 1023234506 B<9 2/0 6093:052 4; <5@/<A<2 <5: 32 B4>=: 70 C06A >5>9><= ;46 /06 24 @45205: 2/<2 609145:052 4) :3: 542 D54B /06 46:35<6A 1=<@0 4;
6093:05@0 B32/35 2/0 6<?1<5@/<A<2 <5: <60< 4>293:0 /060;460 2/0 @=<3? 4; 1023234506 2/<2 5423@0 4; 2/0 ?002358B<9542906C0:>145/0639/<6:24<@@012 &! 5 2/<2 C30B 4; 2/0 ?<2206 <5: <=94 35 C30B 4;
2/0 ;<@2 2/<2 < @41A 4; 2/0 5423@0 B<9 906C0: 45 2/0 1023234506 2/64>8/ /<2911 2/0 @4520523459 >680: 7A 1023234506 35 2/39 10232345 :409 542 ?0632 @4593:06<2345 4590G>052=A2/39B6321023234539 & 09145:052 4 39 :360@20: 24 :39@=490 2/0 609>=294;I54@45;3:05@0?42345H/0=:45& "!!"! ()
&%' %
3924&=4!*