- 1 - ! ! "# $% &$ ! # '(')*+('** & !"# $ % & ! ' ( ( ' !" ( ) ' %& * !" $ % ' ! ' & Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' ( *'' )+ " ( ' '' "# ( !) ' !#" ( ' ' ' )+ " ' ' ( , ( ORAL ORDER (PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.VISHWAJITH SHETTY) --./01 2 34 5360 2)+ " 5073/80501 9: ;2<= 2>3-0 8?8324 ?>?9.57?3 38: @25 2@@04-0/ A.43/;?9>0.41050-8324/"#!)2@<;3-;3/42< A041347 90@250 8;0 2.58 2@ 1138324?> 3B3> .170 C '?>?9.5?733/90@2508;3/2.58.41050-83242@ 5 <38; ? A5?:05 82 D.?/; 8;0 048350 A52-001347/ ?/ ?7?34/8;36 0?518;0>0?54012.4/0>@258;0A?5830/ - 3 - ' 34 5360 2)+ " <?/ 5073/80501 9: ;2<= 2>3-0 8?8324 ?>?9.5?73 @25 8;0 ?@250/?31 2@@04/0/ ?7?34/8 .44?A.50 ?41 /0B04 28;05/ 24 8;0 9?/3/ 2@ 8;0 @35/8 34@256?8324 1?801 "" 50-03B01 @52650/A24104823/;<?5?E 2.41?AA?2/?6?43 <;2 3/ 8;0 /24 2@ 10-0?/01 34 8;0 A50/048 -?/0 0347 ?77530B019:8;0/?31A52-001347/A0838324053/90@2508;3/ 2.58 0?54012.4/0>@258;0A083832405/.9638/8;?8 8;0 ?>>07?8324/ @2.41 34 8;0 @35/8 34@256?8324 ?50 428 /.@@3-3048 82 A52/0-.80 8;0 A083832405 @25 8;0 ?>>0701 2@@04-0/0/.9638/8;?834/363>?5-35-.6/8?4-0/8;02 25134?80 04-; 2@ 8;3/ 2.58 ;?/ ?>50?1: D.?/;01 8;0 36A.7401 -53634?> A52-001347/ ?/ ?7?34/8 ?--./01 2! 0838324053/?A5?-83-347?1B2-?80?41;0;?/9004@?>/0>: 36A>3-?801348;0A50/048-?/0 05 -2485? >0?5401 37; 2.58 2B0546048 >0?105 ?41 >0?5401 2.4/0> @25 50/A241048 2 ;?B0 2AA2/018;0A5?:056?10348;0A0838324 - 4 - # 0?5401 2.4/0> @25 50/A241048 2 /.9638/ 8;?8A083832405;?1A.5-;?/01-058?343662B?9>0A52A058: @526 8;0 10-0?/01 .4105 ? 5073/80501 /?>0 1001 1?801 "#""! ?41 8;0 /?>0 -24/3105?8324 ?62.48 <?/ 428 A?31 .4105 8;0 /?31 /?>0 1001 ;0 10-0?/01 <;2 <?/ @?-347 /0532./ @34?4-3?> -24/85?348/ ;?1 50A0?801>: ?AA52?-;018;0A083832405/00=347A?:60482@8;0?62.48 2@ /""""" <;3-; ;0 <?/ 1.0 82 A?: .4105 8;0 5073/80501 /?>0 1?801 "#""! 34-0 ;0 ;?1 @?3>01 82 A?: 8;0 /?31 ?62.48 10-0?/01 ;?1 -26638801 /.3-310 ?@805 >0?B347 ? 10?8; 4280 --251347>: ;0 A5?:/ 82 13/63//8;0A0838324 + 05./?>2@8;0@35/834@256?8324/.96388019:8;0 /242@8;010-0?/01<2.>17282/;2<8;?810-0?/01;?1 92552<01 6.>83A>0 >2?4/ @526 A53B?80 @34?4-305/ ?41 ?>/2 @526 ?--./01 2/ ?41 8 3/ /8?801 34 8;0 @35/8 34@256?8324 8;?8 10-0?/01 ;?1 /2>1 -058?34 3662B?9>0 A52A058:828;0A083832405.4105?5073/80501/?>01001@25 ?/?>0-24/3105?83242@/""""" 9.88;0048350/?>0 - 5 - -24/3105?8324 2@ /""""" <?/ 428 A?31 ?41 8;050@250 10-0?/01 <;2 34804101 82 50A?: 8;0 >2?4 92552<01 9: ;36 .83>3F347 8;0 /?>0 -24/3105?8324 <?/ @?-347 /0532./ @34?4-3?> -24/85?348/ ?41 38 3/ .4105 8;0/0 -35-.6/8?4-0/;0;?1-26638801/.3-31034?>2170248;0 34805B04347 437;8 2@ """ ?41 !"" 9: ;?47347?@805>0?B347?10?8;4280 ;0/?>085?4/?-8324908<0048;010-0?/01?41 8;0 A083832405 <?/ 5073/80501 24 "#""! ?41 .413/A.801>: 1.5347 8;0 >3@08360 2@ 10-0?/01 ;0 ;?1 428 34383?801?4:A52-001347/038;0582-?4-0>8;0/?>0100125 82 50-2B05 8;0 ?>>0701 ?62.48 <;3-; <?/ 1.0 @526 8;0 A083832405 ) 05./?> 2@ 8;0 @35/8 34@256?8324 <2.>1 72 82 /;2< 8;?8 10-0?/01 ;?1 92552<01 ;.70 ?62.48 2@ >2?4 @52613@@05048/2.5-0/?41;0<?/@?-347/0532./@34?4-3?> A529>06/ G-0A8 /8?8347 8;?8 8;0 A083832405 <?/ 1.0 82 A?: -058?34 ?62.48 82 8;0 10-0?/01 .4105 8;0 /?>0 85?4/?-83242@8;0:0?5"!8;0503/4228;05?>>07?8324 - 6 - 038;05 34 8;0 @35/834@256?832425348;010?8;4280 2@ 8;0 10-0?/01 <;3-; <2.>1 72 82 /;2< 8;?8 A083832405 ;?1 -26638801 ?4: /.-; ?-8 366013?80>: A5325 82 10-0?/01 -266388347/.3-310<;3-;;?1038;0534/837?80125?908801 8;010-0?/01 82 -26638 /.3-310 48;0?9/04-02@/.-; ?4?>>07?832438-?442890/?318;?840-0//?5:3475013048/ /2 ?/ 82 34B2=0 8;0 ?>>0701 2@@04-0 A.43/;?9>0 .4105 0-8324"#2@3/@2.41348;0A50/048-?/0 !" ;3/ 2.58 <;3>0 D.?/;347 8;0 36A.7401 A52-001347/ ?/ ?7?34/8 ?--./01 2! 34 5> 2"!++ " A?5?75?A; 2/+ ?41 ;?/ 29/05B01?/@2>>2</ H ! " #! $ % & " ' ! ! # ! # (((' )!( ! ! # $ - 7 - ((# # # ((( ' * + , '!( '!((# ( " "# ! - . '' &/ '(( ! '!( (( ' 0 ( ( ! !( ( ((" , 1( !0 !" #$% &' ( !! ;0/?3150?/24347?//374019:8;3/2.58<2.>1 90?AA>3-?9>0828;0-?/02@8;0A08383240590-?./08;024>: ?>>07?8324?7?34/88;0A0838324053/8;?8;0<?/1.082A?: -058?34 ?62.48 82 8;0 10-0?/01 34 50/A0-8 2@ 8;0 /?>0 85?4/?-8324<;3-;;?18?=04A>?-0348;06248;2@?5-; "! 4 /.-; ?4 ?>>07?8324 38 -?4428 90 /?31 8;?8 8;0 A083832405;?1038;0534/837?80125?9088018;010-0?/0182 -26638 /.3-310 413/A.801>: 42 A52-001347/ ;?B0 9004 34383?801?7?34/88;0A083832405@2550-2B05:2@8;0?>>0701 - 8 - ?62.48<;3-;;0<?/1.082A?:828;010-0?/014105 8;0 -35-.6/8?4-0/ ?6 2@ 2A34324 8;?8 8;0 36A.7401 -53634?> A52-001347/ 34383?801 ?7?34/8 8;0 A083832405 ?62.48/ 82 ?9./0 2@ A52-0// 2@ >?< --251347>: 8;0 @2>>2<347 ;0 A0838324 3/ ?>>2<01 ;0 048350 A52-001347/ 34 5360 2)+ " 5073/80501 9: ;2<= 2>3-0 8?8324 ?>?9.57?3 38: @25 2@@04-0/ A.43/;?9>0 .4105 0-8324/ "#!)2@42<A04134790@2508;02.582@8;0 1138324?> 3B3> .170 C ' ?>?9.5?73 3/ ;0509: D.?/;01?/?7?34/88;0A083832405 ,+ '% &$ !* $ TMP List No.: 1 Sl No.: 31