- 1 - ! ! "# $% &$ ! # '(')*+,'** & !!" #$ % & ! ' $ $ $$ ' ((( # $ % $$' ! ' & $') ' $%&)*' %& $ $ $ $ !+) ' Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ' '' $ , ",%&%-& )) ' $),!'$+! $ ' . '%$& $%$&+) $ ' / %$ / & 0012345267%$&8+)63-45-9:3;8<3=>3 81<= 8; 447 52=<50= ? 32258-2 1493 @-4 ' @7@:1<@95 @<525-9 81= 8; <5A3 8!+) <3952=3<34 3B@<95 $87503 =@=58- @7@:1<@95 ;8< =>3 8;;3-032 61-52>@:73 1-43< 30=58-2 , ",%&%-& )) 8; $ @-4 30=58-2 ) , @-4 ! 8; $ 52 :3;8<3 =>52 81<= 1-43< 30=58- )* 8; +233C5-9<3917@<:@57 3@<4=>373@<-3481-237;8<=>36@<=532 ' 5- <5A3 8!+) B@2 <3952=3<34 :D 3B@<95 $87503 =@=58- @7@:1<@95 5-5=5@77D ;8< =>3 8;;3-03 61-52>@:731-43<30=58-,8;$@9@5-2=1-C-8B-63<28- - 3 - 8-=>3:@2528;=>3;5<2=5-;8<A@=58-<3035E34;<8A<3268-43-= 8>3<35-8-!++)1<5-9=>3081<238;5-E32=59@=58- 63=5=58-3< @-4 =>3 E50=5A 95<7 B3<3 =<@034 63=5=58-3< B@2 @<<32=348-+ +,+)@-421:23F13-=7D<3A@-434=8G14505@7 012=84D -E32=59@=58- 8; =>3 0@23 52 08A673=34 @-4 0>@<93 2>33=>@2:33-;5734@9@5-2=>5A;8<=>3@;8<32@548;;3-03252 :@57 @66750@=58- ;5734 :3;8<3 =>3 <5@7 81<= B@2 <3G30=34 8- + +!+>3<3;8<3>352:3;8<3=>5281<= ) 3@<-34 81-237 ;8< =>3 63=5=58-3< 21:A5=2 =>@= 63=5=58-3<@-4=>3E50=5A95<7B3<35-78E3@-45->3<2=@=3A3-= <308<434 1-43< 30=58- !,) 8; <$ 2>3 >@2 @4A5==34 =>3 2@A32>3>@2@728-8=A@43@-D@7739@=58-8;23H1@7@22@17= 8- >3< :D =>3 63=5=58-3< 8B3E3< :3;8<3 =>3 <5@7 81<= 2>3 >@2 A@43 03<=@5- @7739@=58-2 @9@5-2= =>3 63=5=58-3< B>573 >3< 6@<3-=2 >@E3 =1<-34 >82=573 =8 =>3 0@23 8; =>3 6<82301=58- $3=5=58-3<B>8>@2-88=>3<0<5A5-@7@-=30343-=2525-012=84D ;<8A+ +,+)>52012=84D52-8=<3F15<3425-03=>3A@=3<5@7 0>@<93 2>33= B5=-32232 >@E3 :33- @7<3@4D 3H@A5-34 008<45-97D6<@D2=8@778B=>363=5=58- - 4 - $3<08-=<@73@<-34$>@28668234=>363=5=58- >321:A5=2=>@=E50=5AB@2@A5-8<@28-=>34@=38;5-0543-= @-42>3>@2A@43@7739@=58-@9@5-2==>363=5=58-3<:3;8<3=>3 <5@7 81<= 3@<-34 81-237 ;8< <3268-43-= 8 >8B3E3< 21:A5=2=>@=>3>@2-88:G30=58-=8@778B=>3:@57@66750@=58- , '5<2=5-;8<A@=58-B@221:A5==34:D<3268-43-=8 @;=3< >52 4@19>=3< B>8 B@2 @934 @:81= !" D3@<2 !! A8-=>2 B@2;81-4A5225-9;<8A=>3>81238-++);;8<=2A@43 =8 =<@03 >3< >@4 ;@5734 @-4 =>3<3;8<3 8- !++) <3268-43-=8>@4@66<8@0>34=>36875031<5-9=>3081<23 8; 5-E32=59@=58- 63=5=58-3< @-4 =>3 E50=5A 95<7 B3<3 =<@034 $3=5=58-3< B@2 @<<32=34 8- + +,+) @-4 21:23F13-=7D 43A@-434=8G14505@7012=84D " >32=@=3A3-=8;=>3E50=5A95<71-43<30=58-!,) 8; <$ B@2 <308<434 8- !*+,+) @2 8- =>3 2@54 4@=3 E50=5A>@408A673=34!*D3@<28;@93>3>@22=@=34=>@=2>3 B@25-78E3B5=>=>363=5=58-3<@-4>3<6@<3-=2>@44305434=8 63<;8<A >3< A@<<5@93 B5=> @-8=>3< :8D =>3<3;8<3 8- ++) 2>3 >@4 98-3 =8 =>3 E577@93 8; =>3 63=5=58-3< 8B3E3< =>3 6@<3-=2 8; =>3 63=5=58-3< 454 -8= 3-081<@93 >3< - 5 - ;8<=>3<3@28-=>@=2>3>@4-8=@==@5-34@938;A@G8<5=D>3 >@2 2=@=34 =>@= 2>3 2=@D34 5- =>3 >8123 8; 63=5=58-3< @= >5CC845;8<@63<5848;8-3B33C@-4=>3<3@;=3<6@<3-=28;=>3 63=5=58-3< >@4:<819>= >3< =8 @5:>@: $87503 =@=58- >3 >@2 @7282=@=34=>@=63=5=58-3<>@2-8=08AA5==34@-DB<8-9>3 E50=5A 95<7 >@2 :33- -8B 3H@A5-34 :3;8<3 =>3 <5@7 81<= @2 $!@-4>3<6@<3-=2@<33H@A5-34@2$? * 3@<-34 $ >@2 :<819>= =8 =>3 -8=503 8; =>52 81<= =>819> E50=5A 95<7 >@4 -8= A@43 @-D @7739@=58- @9@5-2= =>363=5=58-3<5->3<2=@=3A3-=<308<4341-43<30=58-!,)8; <$ 2>3 >@2 -8B A@43 03<=@5- @7739@=58-2 @2 @9@5-2= =>3 63=5=58-3< 41<5-9 =>3 081<23 8; >3< 436825=58- :3;8<3 =>3 <5@7 81<= 3=>@=@25=A@D=>3;@0=<3A@5-2=>@=63=5=58-3< B>8 >@2 -8 8=>3< 0<5A5-@7 @-=30343-=2 52 5- 012=84D ;<8A + +, +) 5-03 =>3 E50=5A 95<7 @-4 >3< 6@<3-=2 >@E3 :33- @7<3@4D 3H@A5-34 :3;8<3 =>3 <5@7 81<= =>3<3 0@--8= :3 @-D @66<3>3-258- =>@= =>3 63=5=58-3< 52 75C37D =8 =@A63< B5=> =>3 A@=3<5@7 6<82301=58- B5=-32232 1= 8; 0>@<93 2>33= B5=-32232 =577 4@=3 8-7D !! 0>@<93 2>33= B5=-32232 >@E3 :33- - 6 - 3H@A5-34 -43< =>3 05<01A2=@-032 @A 8; 865-58- =>@= =>3 6<@D3<A@43:D=>363=5=58-3<;8<9<@-=8;<3917@<:@57-3342=8 :3@-2B3<34@;;5<A@=5E37D008<45-97D=>3;8778B5-9 5 >363=5=58-52@778B34 55 >363=5=58-3<5245<30=34=8:33-7@<9348-:@57 5- <5A3 8!+) <3952=3<34 3B@<95 $87503 =@=58- ;8< =>3 8;;3-032 61-52>@:73 1-43< 30=58-2 , ",%&%-& )) 8; $ @-4 30=58-2 ) , @-4 !8;$21:G30==8=>3;8778B5-908-45=58-2 @& >3 63=5=58-3< 2>@77 3H301=3 63<28-@7 :8-4 ;8< @ 21A 8; 2!+++++ B5=> =B8 21<3=532;8<=>375C321A=8=>32@=52;@0=58- 8;=>3G1<52450=58-@781<=I :& >3 63=5=58-3< 2>@77 @663@<<3917@<7D 8- @77 =>34@=328;>3@<5-9:3;8<3=>3<5@781<= 1-7322 =>3 <5@7 81<= 3H3A6=2 >52 @663@<@-03;8<E@754<3@28-2I 0& >3 63=5=58-3< 2>@77 -8= 45<30=7D 8< 5-45<30=7D =><3@=3- 8< =@A63< B5=> =>3 6<82301=58-B5=-32232I - 7 - 4& >3 63=5=58-3< 2>@77 -8= 5-E87E3 5- 25A57@< 8;;3-0325-;1=1<3I 3& >3 63=5=58-3< 2>@77 -8= 73@E3 =>3 G1<52450=58- 8; =>3 <5@7 81<= B5=>81= 63<A52258-8;=>32@5481<=1-=57=>30@23 <3952=3<34@9@5-2=>5A52452682348;; -+ '% &$ !* $ $52=8!78! $