Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9556 (KAR)
SHRI. DAYANAND v. SHRI.SHIVAJI AND ANR
MFA/200339/2019 · 2025-01-15
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9556 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9556 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
! ! ##$
% & '
!"#$#
%
& '
#
(
)!*"#$
!"#$#
)
!"#$#
%
& ()+ #'
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( (
#* &#' (
' ( '
#)#))$#! #$$)$#
( ( (
,
( -.$$$$$
( /
(
0
! & 0
'
1234 561 7123814 9:;8-17 2<<123=8> ?:3 561 2<<17728528456131-<:84185 :)
$) =569:8-185:?@:56561<235=1-561A25513=- 52B18;<?:34=-<:-27
- 3 -
$* 61 2<<177285 C6: =- 561 <15=5=:813 @1?:31 561 3=@;82762-2<<3:2961456=-:;35@1=8>2>>3=1D14@E561 4=-A=--27:?6=-<15=5=:8?=714;8413195=:8#"*&':?561 :5:3 16=971- 95 =8 :#$$)$# @E 561 7123814 44=5=:827 =-53=95 ;4>1 284
, =F2E2<;32 42514#)#))$#! $ 61 2<<177285 G <15=5=:813 C2- 3=4=8> 2 A:5:39E971@123=8>1> :)!*"#$:C814@E6=A 284 61 A15 C=56 28 299=4185 2- 561 D16=971 -B=4414 284 -;-52=814 91352=8 >3=1D:;- =8F;3=1- 61 2<<177285 G <15=5=:8132<<3:296145613=@;827;8413195=:8#"*&' :?561
:5:316=971-959:85184=8>562561=-185=5714?:3 561 9:A<18-25=:8 ?3:A 6=- :C8 =8-;313 61 31-<:84185
:) =8-;32891 9:A<28E 2<<12314 @1?:31 561 3=@;827 2849:85184145625561<15=5=:8=-8:5A2=852=82@71-=891=5 =--17?A241299=4185284561:@7=>25=:8-:?56131-<:84185
:)231<;317E9:853295;27=8825;31
- 4 -
$ 61 3=@;827 2?513 6123=8> @:56 561 <235=1- 32=-14 2 H;1-5=:8 :8 A2=852=82@=7=5E 284 4=-A=--14 561 <15=5=:8 @E 317E=8> :8 561 F;4>A185 :? 561 :8/@71 ;<31A1 :;35 =8 561 92-1 :? $" 1=8> 2>>3=1D14 @E 561 -2A1 561 2<<177285 <15=5=:813=-@1?:3156=-:;35 $ 6171238149:;8-172<<123=8>?:35612<<177285 C:;74 -;@A=5 5625 561 <:7=9E C2- 2 <29B2>1 <:7=9E 284 56131 =- 2 <13-:827 299=4185 9:D13 ?:3 561 <15=5=:813 6131?:31561<15=5=:8=-A2=852=82@71 $! 61 7123814 9:;8-17 2<<123=8> ?:3 561 31-<:84185 :) G =8-;32891 9:A<28E -;@A=5- 5625 561 825;31 :? 561 :@7=>25=:8- @15C118 561 <15=5=:813 284 561 31-<:84185 :)=8-;328919:A<28E=-<;317E9:853295;27 =8825;316131?:31561<3:D=-=:8-:?561
:5:316=971- 95-:?232-=5317251-5:-525;5:3E7=2@=7=5E=-9:8913814=- 8:5 2<<7=92@71 6131?:31 8: =8513?131891 =- <13A=--=@71 ;841372C
1
- 5 -
$. 5=-1D=41855625=8561F;4>A185:?561:8/@71 ;<31A1 :;35 =8 561 92-1 :? 31?13314 -;<32=5=-9251>:3=9277E61745625561;84137E=8><3=89=<71- =82<15=5=:8;8413195=:8#"":3#"*&':? 95=- @2-14 :8561 ?2;75 7=2@=7=5E 61 <15=5=:813 6131=8C2- 561 3=413 :? 561 A:5:39E971 C6=96 C2- =8-;314 @E 561 31-<:84185 :) =8-;32891 9:A<28E -17? =8?7=9514 299=4185@E561<15=5=:813C:;748:51852=76=A5:2<<123 @1?:31 561 3=@;827 284 972=A 561 9:A<18-25=:8 ;8413 195=:8 #"* &' :? 561
95 6131 =- 8: -525;5:3E 7=2@=7=5E :8 561 <235 :? 561 =8-;32891 9:A<28E 5: 9:A<18-251561<15=5=:813C618561:@7=>25=:8-231<;317E 9:853295;27=8825;31
#$ 61 <:7=9E =--;14 @E 561 31-<:84185 :) =8-;328919:A<28EC:;74-6:C562556131=-29:A<;7-:3E 9:D13 ?:3 561 :C813- 43=D13 284 561 =8-;32891 9:A<28E 62- 2991<514 2 244=5=:827 <31A=;A :? - $ -<13561513A-2849:84=5=:8-:?561<:7=9E-;969:D13
- 6 -
=- :87E ?:3 2 -;A :? -#$$$$$ 6131?:31 561 31-<:84185 :) =8-;32891 9:A<28E 62- 5: :@7=>1 561 <15=5=:813 ;8413 561 <13-:827 299=4185 9:D13 C6=96 =- <;317E 9:853295;27 =8 825;31 ;<5: 2 A2I=A;A :?
-#$$$$$ ;96 972=A -6:;74 62D1 @118 -25=-?=14 @E 561 =8-;32891 9:A<28E A;96 1237=13 284 =5 =- 8:5 B8:C8 ?:3C625312-:8=5C2-8:5<2=4@D=:;-7E=52<<123-5625 8:-;96972=A<2<13-C131-;@A=5514@E561<15=5=:8135: 561 31-<:84185 :) G =8-;32891 9:A<28E =8D:B=8> 561 9:853295;27:@7=>25=:8- ## 61 7123814 9:;8-17 2<<123=8> ?:3 561 31-<:84185 :)G=8-;328919:A<28E?2=37E-;@A=5-5625 561 31-<:84185 :) G =8-;32891 9:A<28E =- :@7=>14 5: -25=-?E561972=A<13A=--=@71;8413561<:7=9EC6=96=-5: 561 5;81 :? -#$$$$$ 1891 =8 561 <19;7=23 9=39;A-52891-5612<<12741-13D1-5:@1277:C14=8<235 @;5 A2B=8> =5 97123 5625 561 972=A =- 8:5 1=5613 ;8413 195=:8 #"" :3 #"*&' :? 561
95 @;5 =5 =- 2 <;31 9:853295;27:@7=>25=:8:?56131-<:84185 :)5:C234-561 <15=5=:8131891561?:77:C=8>+
- 7 -
612<<127=-277:C14=8<235
61 31-<:84185 :) =- 4=319514 5: <2E 2 -;A :? -#$$$$$ 5: 561 <15=5=:813 5:C234- 561 9:853295;27:@7=>25=:8-;8413561<:7=9E
61 185=31 2A:;85 -6277 @1 <2=4 @E 561 31-<:84185
:) G =8-;328919:A<28E 4=31957E 5: 561 <15=5=:813 -;@F195 5: 9:84=5=:8 5625 561 <15=5=:813 -6277 -;@A=5 D27=4 4=-9623>1 3191=<5- 284 299:;85 4152=7- 5: 561 31-<:84185 :)G=8-;328919:A<28E
4 $
! & ! =-5 :#7 :!