Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9547 (PNJ)
M/S YEE KAY TECHNOCRAT PRIVATE LIMITED v. COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL EXCISE, FARIDABAD
CEA/60/2011 · 2025-01-28
Arun Palli, Sudeepti Sharma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9547 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9547 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"# $"%$& '( ) !"!%"* !"# $"%$& '( )
+++++,, -%
+++++. # /,
+ . ,, /,
.+ . . . !"# !$%&'! (&)! **! )#+! )& !!$,- &#*
.,) )!""!$%&'! (&) &$ . . ( + / ) ! !*, ($#$',&01&() !* 2','/3445(&)&6'/34478(&9#!),-,+ #-$&$$!$ :1;/:;//52#<08.)=>)*!$ ,=#!*$,+,$)! !* &()! **!)&*$,-)!)! **!,&,*$&=(,&(
$, : )=,((!'&()'!! $<,<
,-,!*!)!) ! **!,)+!#(!'#&(-,,-*!,' &+ &!$.! !%!,*,-(!',*,>&(
$,#$
$,#*?:;;::;;4 0 #,-)'&#&(!#$,&()(,!',!*!$2','&$&() !,.!&,'$=>)#$, !>)!)!)!$!%!,*$&(
$,!+&#,-&:@A;/:<&($#> !,$& ! ,!*&&$!$! PRERNA JOSHI 2025.01.29 13:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)!+,+'*!,+$$ ',!,&&(), !&(%!*#&('! ,!*-&&$.),') )!+&#&($#>&#')'! ,!*-&&$#$',&0:&() '&+ !2'/3B/.),')! !$&=!%,&*!,&&() &%,,&&(#* 4548&()
$,#*:;;45.),*
:;;:8#*,-, 2',%!%!,*+&(
$,=>)! **! 4 )! **!=>),*$!$:4;@:;;B!$+,$)(!'&( )!%,-!"$&#=*=(,=>!%!,*,-&(
$,!.**!'*!,+,-&( $ ',!,&#$)'&+ !2'&()!!+&#&($#>.),')(&+$! !&()%!*#&(#') ! ,!*&&$.),')=(,!''&$,-&)+.&"$ &#&=:AA@@3<!$&:@A;/:<! &,$&#=>)#$, !>.! !*&,(&+$)!%,$'&+ !2#.,))'&+ !2$ !+ )!$=(,*$=>)+ 1 ,',! !$)!)
$,!+&#,-&:AA@@3< 5# .&!',-)>,-) )&#!$%#$$!$%>,
*>8 !", '&()'! ,!*-&&$.!!%!,*$&(.&-*>,%,&*!,&&( ) &%,,&&(#*4548&()
$,#*:;;4:;;:!$)!) !,$.&-!%!,*+'&#*$&=+!$-&&$=>(,*,-!%,$'&+ !2 #.,))'&+ !2 !+=>%,-)!,$$ ',!,&=(, !*!$>!%!,*$&(!'*!,+$=>)! **!!$)!)!,$.&- !%!,*+&('$,.!$&.,*(#**>!$,,&!**>.,)!%,.&%!$,- !>+&($#>!$# $)!,$(!'(&+)$ !+!$)!) $ !+ -& "&.*$- &( , &*> & '&$#',- !#$, &( ) ! **! !''&#!)&.'!# &,'.!,#$&)! **!.)&(,*$ && )!+!$ !( -,%,- ),+ &!* )!,- ) '$, !+&#,- & :AA@@3<5# .&!',-)>,-) )&#!$% #$$!$%>,
*>8!%!,*$=>)!.!$,!**&.$#$ PRERNA JOSHI 2025.01.29 13:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0 #*/4&()
$,#*:;;4!$.,)',&//&()' /344#) !*>&)#&(:AA@@3<#$',&// &()' /344!$.,)#*/15:8&()
$,#*:;;4.!,+ &$, $<,<
,-,!*=>),! &++,,&&:B0//::;;@ B )! **! ($! !*!-!,&$$!$:B0//::;;@ =(& ) &++,,& &( !* 2', 5 !*8 .)=> *!$
&++,,&5 !*8+&$,(,$),+ #-$
$<,<
,-,!*%,$&$ $!$;/;1:;;3.),').!!-!,')!**-$=>)! **!=(&*!$
#&+2',!$%,' !2 **! ,=#!*=>.!>&((,*,-! !* !$ ,=#!*%,$&$$!$:1;/:;//$,+,$)! !*(,*$=>) ! **!') ! !* @ !$'&#*(&)! **!'&$)!)*!$ ,=#!* $,+,$)! !*&()! **!)&*$,-)!)! **!,&,*$& )=(,&(
$,%)&#-)=(,&($ ',!,&.!%$ =>)! **! A '&! *!$ '&#* (& ) &$ '&$ )! !$+,$*>)! **!!%!,*$.&=(,&(
$,!.**! $ ',!,& )(& ) ! !* (,*$ => ) ! **! )! ,-)*> = $,+,$=>*!$ ,=#!* 3 C)!%)!$*!$'&#*(&) !,!$ #$).)&* '&$&()'! /; )#$, #$(!'.),'),!*&!$+,$=>)! **!,)! )! **!!%!,*$
$,!+&#,-&:@A;/:<&($#> !,$& '! ,!*-&&$!$!)!+,+'*!,+$$ ',!,&&(), !&(%!*#&( '! ,!*-&&$.),') )!+&#&($#>&#')'! ,!*-&&$#$ ',&0:&()'&+ !2'/3B/.),'),,%,&*!,&&(#*4548&() PRERNA JOSHI 2025.01.29 13:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
1
$,#*:;;4#*4548&(
$,#*:;;4:;;:, &$#'$)#$ D, 1+ . ,,2 - + 548 ) '$,, '&('! ,!*-&&$)!**&= !**&.$, '&()! !&()%!*#&('! ,!*-&&$.),') )!+&#&($#> & #')'! ,!*-&&$ .),')) +!#(!'#'*!,+!$ ',!,&#$',&0:&()'&+< !2'/3B/540&(/3B/8E // )!$+,$(!'&'&$,)!)! **!!%!,*$
$,&'! ,!*-&&$&)#&( B0B0A/,)>!:;;/<;:!$ ::1/4/<$#,-)>!:;;:<;0#,-)'&#&(!#$,&()(,!',!* !$2','&$&()! **!'&$#'$=> !*2',!#$,!+,.! &=%$=>)!#$, !>)!)!)!$,+#*!&#*>'*!,+$) =(,&($ ',!,&&)'! ,!*-&&$,),(,!',!*!''&#!.**! '&+ !2#(&)*%!>!$!$+,$*>,.!&*>.),.! &,$&#&)! **!)!)>)!$!%!,*$.&=(,)! **! %,$),'&+ !2#(&)>!:;;0<;4&0/;1:;;1.)!) ,&$,$, #.!:;;/<;:!$:;;:<;0 ) #* , )! $#,- ) (,!',!*>!:;;/<;:!$:;;:<;0)! **!)!$!%!,*$!$#,*,F$
$,&)'! ,!*-&&$!$,+#*!&#*>'*!,+$=(,&( $ ',!,&&)'!
,!*-&&$#$',&0:&()'&+ !2'/3B/ ,),'&+ !2#(&)!+>!:;;:<;0!$:;;0<;4!$) =(,&(!,$$ ',!,&.!%#$$=>)+!)>)!$,) (,*$)%,$'&+ !2#(&)!+>!:;;:<;0!$:;;0< ;4&)>)!$$,')!-$)*,!=,*,>&(!$$,,&!*,'&+!2.),').&#*$ )!%!''#$&!''&#&(#$&(=(,&($ ',!,&&'*!,+$ PRERNA JOSHI 2025.01.29 13:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
) $#,-)!=&%!+>! )(&! )*-!* &%,,&)
$,.!&!**&.!=*&)! **!&)'! ,!*-&&$,' )>'*!,+$$ ',!,&&)-&&$,), =&&" &( !''&#!$ '&+ !2#(&)>!:;;/<;:!$:;;:<;0!$! #*4548&(
$,#*:;;::;;4) ! **! $,$ & (#*(,* )
'&$,,& (& !**&.,- )
$, )(& ='!+ *,!=* (& '&%>&(
$,.&-*>!"&&&#*>(#$$#$#* /4&()
$,#*:;;4 /: %,.&()!=&%.$&&(,$!>,(,+,>,),+ #-$ &$$!$:1;/:;// !$=>)*!$ #&+2',!$%,' !2 **! ,=#!*)(&)!+,!((,+$!$) ! !*, $,+,$ /0 **) $,-! *,'!,&,(!>!*&!$$, &$&(
,,
. . $"%$& '( )
G
PRERNA JOSHI 2025.01.29 13:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document