Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9545 (KAR)
SHIVABALAWWA @ SHIVAKKA v. CHANDSAB AND ANR
MFA/200292/2018 · 2025-01-23
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9545 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9545 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#
$""
%
&
!" #
$# %#
#$
# & '"& (
#"
#$ &#& ' #& $#
%#
#$ )*
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:03:36 - 0800
- 2 -
& &
#&
'"& )! (
#" & + '"'
& &
*,
"
&
!)
-&
& #"
#&
./#"
'&
'& - '"& **! %
&
#
"
$ $ %#
#$
# & '"&
#
"
& $ %#
#$
# & '"&
, #
"
$
%# #$
- 3 -
# & '"& (
#"
#$ &#& ' #& $#
%#
#$ )*
& &
#&
'"& )! (
#" '"' +
& &
*,
"
! &
)
-& & #"
#&
. / #"
'&
'& - '"&
*)! %
&
#.$$
"
- 4 -
," $ %#
#$
# & '"& (
#"
#$ &#& ' #& $#
%#
#$ )*
& &
#&
'"& )! (
#" & + '"'
& &
*,
"
& -&
& #"
#&
./#"
'&
'&
#
- '"&
*
!! "'&
&
0#
'& '
- 5 -
" 0#
'& '
1232 41522 6772683 652 9: 412 724;4;<=253 >86;?6=43 6@6;=34 412 ><??<= ABC@?2=4 6=C 6D65C C642C * 76332C ;= <3)! !! 6=C *! <= 412 E;82 <E 412 <B54 <E 412 CC8 ;345;>4 6=C 233;<=3 'BC@2 6=C 2?925 - ;A6:67B5 E<531<54F 5;9B=68G6336;8;=@412HB6=4B?<E><?72=364;<= 6=C 412 8;69;8;4: E6342=2C <= 412 <D=25 <E 412 <EE2=C;=@ I21;>82
#:><=32=4<E9<414127654;23412?644253652 46J2= B7 E<5 E;=68 C;37<368 41<B@1 412: 652 38642C E<5 C?;33;<=
, 265C 8265=2C ><B=328 677265;=@ E<5 412 6772886=43>86;?6=43 8265=2C ><B=328 677265;=@ E<5 5237<=C2=4 < K <D=25 <E 412 <EE2=C;=@ I21;>82 6=C 8265=2C ><B=328 677265;=@ E<5 5237<=C2=4 <=3B56=>2 <?76=:
- 6 -
#5;2EE6>43826C;=@4<41232677268365263928<D
6 = *! 412 C2>2632C 6=C 412 ;=AB52C 724;4;<=253 9<65C2C 6 I21;>82 9265;=@ 52@;34564;<= <$ *) 4< @< 4< 8;:68 ;868@2 4< 6442=C EB=2568 <E 412;5 52864;I2=265B@68<88; 6=C6412C5;I25<E41236;CI21;>82 C5<I2 412 36?2 ;= =2@8;@2=4 ?6==25 6=C >6B32C 412 6>>;C2=4 D12529: 412 C2>2632C #6??6776 3B>>B?92C 4< 412;=AB5;236=C412<41254D<724;4;<=2533B346;=2C;=AB5;23
126772886=43;=<652412>86;?6=43;= <)!4126772886=4;=<;3 412>86;?6=4;=<!!6=C4126772886=4;= <;3412>86;?6=4;=<*! 9
12724;4;<=3D252<77<32C9:412;=3B525<E412 I21;>82 ><=42=C;=@ 4164 41252 D252 I;<864;<= <E 412 425?3 6=C ><=C;4;<=3 <E 412 7<8;>:6=C4164 412I21;>82D63 92;=@ 78;2C 92:<=C 412 725?;4 6526 6=C 63 3B>1 412 =3B56=>2 <?76=: ;3 =<4 8;6982 4< 76: 412 ><?72=364;<= 4 D63 372>;E;>688: ><=42=C2C 4164 412 6>>;C2=4 4<<J 786>2 92:<=C 4128;?;43?2=4;<=2C;=412725?;4;33B2C4<412I21;>826=C
- 7 -
41252E<52412<D=2592128C8;69824<76:412><?72=364;<= 4683<56;32C412<41253><=42=4;<=352@65C;=@412HB6=4B?
6=C=2@8;@2=>2
> = 412 963;3 <E 412 5;I68 ><=42=4;<=3 56;32C 9: 9<41 412 7654;23 412 5;9B=68 E56?2C 6775<75;642 ;33B23
12724;4;<=253D2522L6?;=2C6334<,6=C
L34< ) D252 ?65J2C = <EE;>;68 <E 5237<=C2=4 < D63 2L6?;=2C63 6=C
L34<)D252?65J2C
C E425 1265;=@ 412 65@B?2=43 412
5;9B=68 6D65C2C 6 ><?72=364;<= <E 3 ;=
<)! 6 @8<968 6?<B=4 <E 3*) ;= <!! 6=C 6 @8<968 6?<B=4 <E 3) ;= <*!D;41;=42523464/7256==B?E5<?412C642 <E724;4;<=4;885268;M64;<= 12 5;9B=68E6342=2C4128;69;8;4: B7<=412<D=25<E412I21;>829:2L<=2564;=@412=3B56=>2 <?76=:#2;=@6@@5;2I2C9:41236?2412724;4;<=253652 92E<5241;3<B54
)
128265=2C><B=328677265;=@E<54126772886=43 ;=68841232?644253><=42=C2C4164412I;<864;<=<E412425?3
- 8 -
6=C><=C;4;<=3<E4127<8;>:;=>8BC2C412I21;>827<33233;=@6 I68;C 725?;4 E><B532 3B>1 I;<864;<= >6==<4 92 6 EB=C6?2=468 <=2 6=C C2>2632C 6=C ;=AB52C 724;4;<=253 652 412 76332=@253 <E 412 I21;>82 92;=@ ,5C 7654: 412: 652 =<4 ><=>25=2C D;41 412 ;=42532 C;37B42 924D22= <D=25 6=C 412 ;=3B525<E412I21;>824;37<;=42C<B44164;4;36=;=E56>4;<= <E 412 ><=C;4;<=3 <E 412 7<8;>: 6=C 41252E<52 412 8;69;8;4: 31<B8C16I2922=E6342=2CB7<=412=3B56=>2<?76=:4< 76: 412 ><?72=364;<= 2 3B9?;43 4164 412 ><?72=364;<= 6D65C2C9:412 5;9B=68;=52372>4<EC2641<E412C2>2632C ;3 683< <= 412 8<D25 3;C2 6=C 5;9B=68 E6;82C 4< 6778:
6775<75;642 =<4;<=68 ;=><?2 <E 412 C2>2632C 4 ;3 EB54125 ><=42=C2C 4164 412 ><?72=364;<= 6D65C2C ;=
<3!! 6=C *! 652 683< <= 412 8<D25 3;C2 6=C412:=22C4<922=16=>2C
! 8265=2C ><B=328 677265;=@ E<5 412 5237<=C2=4<D<B8C><=42=C4164412 5;9B=681635;@148:
E6342=2C 412 8;69;8;4: B7<= 412 <D=25 <E 412 I21;>82 3;=>2 412 I21;>82 92;=@ 78;2C <B43;C2 412 725?;442C 6526 2
- 9 -
C2E2=C3 412 HB6=4B? <E 412 ><?72=364;<= 6D65C2C 9: 412
5;9B=686=C322JE<5C;3?;3368<E4126772683
*
12 ><=42=4;<= <E 412 8265=2C ><B=328 E<5 412 6772886=4 4164 412 8;69;8;4: 31<B8C 16I2 922= E6342=2C B7<= 412 =3B56=>2 <?76=: C<23 =<4 1<8C 41;3 <B54 E<5 8<=@
12ABC@?2=4<E41272L<B54;=412>632<E ! !"" #" $% & 86:3 C<D=;=656 4164;4C<23=<452HB;52412D;3C<?<E412 F 5;7;46J6G 4164 412 2L;342=>2 <E 6 725?;4 <E 6=: =64B52 ;3 6 ?64425 <E C<>B?2=465: 2I;C2=>2 6=C C;52>42C 4164 412 ;=3B525D6352HB;52C4<76:412><?72=364;<=6?<B=44<412 >86;?6=436=C;32=4;482CE<552><I25:<E41236?2E5<?412 <D=25 <5 C5;I25 <E 412 <EE2=C;=@ I21;>82 1252E<52 412 6372>4<EI;<864;<=<E412425?36=C><=C;4;<=3<E412725?;4 16I;=@922=C2>;C2C9:41272L<B54E;=688:412 5;9B=68 ><B8C =<4 16I2 E6342=2C 412 8;69;8;4: B7<= 412 <D=25 <=8:
12724;4;<=25392;=@B=><==2>42C4<412;=42532425?36=C ><=C;4;<=3<E4127<8;>:924D22=412<D=256=C412;=3B525 412:D2522=4;482CE<5><?72=364;<= 1252E<52412=3B525
1 *
))
- 10 -
1634<92C;52>42C4<76:412><?72=364;<=4<412724;4;<=253 D;418;9254:4<52><I2541236?2E5<?412<D=25
<?;=@ 4< 412 HB6=4B? <E 412 ><?72=364;<= 41252;36=22CE<552633233?2=4<E412><?72=364;<=3;=>2 412=<4;<=68;=><?2;=52372>4<EC2>2632C6>>2742C9:412
5;9B=68;3<=4128<D253;C2
12 @B;C28;=23 ;33B2C 9: 412 $65=646J6 4642 2@68 25I;>23 B41<5;4: $ E<5 324482?2=4 <E 412 C;37B423 92E<52 412 <J C6864 7523>5;92 412 =<4;<=68 ;=><?2 <E 3*) E<5 412 :265 !
= B?7422= =B?925 <E C2>;3;<=3 41;3 <B54 163 128C 4164 412 @B;C28;=23 ;33B2C9: $ 652 128C 4< 92 6>>2746982 <= 412 @5<B=C 4164 412: 652 ;= @2=2568 ><=E<5?;4: D;41 412 ?;=;?B? D6@23 E;L2C B=C25 412 ;=;?B? 6@23 >4
1252E<52 412 =<4;<=68 ;=><?2 <E 412 724;4;<=25 ;3 6>>2742C 63 3*) 725 ?<=41 1252E<52 412 8<33 <E C272=C2=>: ;= < ;3 >68>B8642C 63 3*) N *) L L L , L O 3 * 9:
- 11 -
6C<74;=@ 6 ?B84;78;25 <E 6=C 6CC;=@ / 4<D65C3 412 EB4B5275<372>43
= 6CC;4;<= 4<412 69<I2 6?<B=4 412 724;4;<=253 652 683< 2=4;482C E<5 6 3B? <E 3 N 3) N 3) D;41 6= 23>6864;<= <E ,/ D1;>1 ><?23 4< 6 4<468 <E 3 1252E<52 9: 6CC;=@ 412 ?2C;>68 2L72=323 D1;>1 D252 372=4 9: 412 6772886=43
3) 412 4<468 ><?72=364;<= ;3 C2425?;=2C 63 3 )
1252 D;88 92 6= 2=16=>2?2=4 <E 3,)
634126772886=4;=<!!;3 ><=>25=2C 312 16C 3BEE252C ><=4B3;<= 6=C 3D288;=@ <E 412 5;@14 M:@<?64;> 6=C 5;@14 659;4565: D688 12 16C 683< 3BEE252CE56>4B52<E412C;346856C;B3<E4125;@14D5;34A<;=4
12 5;9B=68 ><=3;C25;=@ 412 ?2C;>68 9;883 <E 3,**! 6D65C2C 6 @8<968 ><?72=364;<= <E 3*) D1;>1 67726534<92<=8<D253;C2 12724;4;<=2592;=@6<?6= <<8;2 6@2C , :2653 16I;=@ 3BEE252C E56>4B52 <E 412 5;@14 56C;B3 ;3 2=4;482C E<5 6 4<468 @8<968 ><?72=364;<= <E
- 12 -
3) ;=3426C <E 3*) 63 6D65C2C 9: 412
5;9B=68 1252D;88922=16=>2?2=4<E 3)
12 724;4;<=25 ;=
<*! 16C 3B346;=2C86>25642CD<B=C<I254125;@14E<<4?263B5;=@ L>?9B4312D63;=764;2=4E<56E2DC6:341252E<526 @8<968 ><?72=364;<= <E 3) ;3 6D65C2C 4< 125 63 6@6;=34 3) 6D65C2C 9: 412 5;9B=68 1252 D;88 92 2=16=>2?2=4<E 3
, 2=>2412E<88<D;=@
; 884126772683652688<D2C;=7654 ;;
12 ;?7B@=2C ><??<= ABC@?2=4 6=C 6D65C 76332C9:412 5;9B=68;312529:?<C;E;2C ;;;
12 6772886=4 ;=
< 724;4;<=25 ;= <*! ;3 2=4;482C E<563B?<E 34126772886=43;= < 24;4;<=253 ;=
<)! 652 2=4;482C E<5 6 3B? <E
- 13 -
3,) 6=C 412 6772886=4 ;=
< 724;4;<=25 ;=
<!! ;3 2=4;482C E<5 ><?72=364;<= <E 3) D;41 ;=425234 64 !/ 725 6==B? E5<? 412 C642 <E 724;4;<=3 4;88 5268;M64;<= ;= 6CC;4;<= 4< D164 163 922= 6D65C2C 9: 412
5;9B=68 ;I 237<=C2=4 < =3B56=>2 <?76=: ;3 C;52>42C 4< 76: 412 ><?72=364;<= 6?<B=4 4< 412724;4;<=25364412E;534;=346=>2D;418;9254:
4< 52><I25 412 36?2 E5<? 5237<=C2=4 < K <D=25<E412I21;>82412526E425 I
12 5234 <E 412 <5C25 76332C 9: 412 5;9B=68 52@65C;=@C27<3;424>52?6;=3B=684252C
C '" (
"
# ;34<8< ,
$