- 1 - !!" #$ $ %%&'( ) * ! " # $% $ # &' & ()(" # $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " * ! # '' # #+""" ' ! ()("* ", *, # "! "+*"! ' """) ' "+*#"( ' $ $ - ' ' $ $- ' '! " ./0 122314 /0 5/637835 191/:08 8.3 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 /: ?"+*#"( 51835 """) @A 3:/?6 /B/4 - 3 - '<593 1:5 .1.12<6 >.363@A 8.3 4/1@/4/8A 8? 21A 7?=23:018/?: >10 C1083:35 <2?: 8.3 1223441:8:0<61:73 ?=21:A.363/: .3C178<14=186/D?C8.37103/010@34?>$ 1! .3 .<0@1:5 ?C 8.3 "08 238/8/?:36 8.3 53731035 /551::1 ?: "*"E >./43 26?7335/:9 /: ?436? '332 ?*#E+**101:3=24?A33?C6302?:53:8?*F:/835 6?2163?=21:A=38>/8.1:177/53:85<38?8.3:394/93:8 56/B/:9?C8.356/B36?C8.301/5;33210/88<6:358<6843@A8.3 0/53?C8.36?151:50<081/:35C6178<63?C8.36/9.84398./9. >1/08 387 3 >10 0./C835 8? 1=6355A ?02/814 141@<619/ ./43 <:536 86318=3:8 ./0 08183=3:8 >10 637?6535 @A 8.3 ?4/731:58.301=3>108631835100?<673?C8.3/:C?6=18/?: 1:57103>10639/083635@A8.3?4/7348/=1834A.35/35?: (*"E /: 8.3 .?02/814 .3 238/8/?:360 7?:83:5/:9 8.18 8.353731035>101935**A3160>?6G/:9/:8.301/5?=21:A 1:5 316:/:9 0# 236 =?:8. C/435 1 741/= 238/8/?: 033G/:9 7?=23:018/?: C6?= 8.3 ?>:36 1:5 /:0<636 ?C 8.3 B3./743 - 4 - @! .3238/8/?:>10?22?035@A8.3?>:366302?:53:8 ?" 7?:83:5/:9 8.18 8.3 53731035 >10 :?8 /80 3=24?A33 1:5 8.188.3177/53:8>10:?85<38?8.3:394/93:73?:8.32168?C 8.356/B36?C8.301/5B3./743.3193/:7?=31:5?77<218/?: ?C 8.3 53731035 >10 53:/35 1:5 8.3 63418/?:0./2 ?C 3=24?A36 1:5 3=24?A33 >10 140? 53:/35 8 >10 7?:83:535 8.18 8.3 6302?:53:8 ?" /0 :? >1A 7?:736:35 8? 8.3 /:7/53:8 1:5 10 0<7. 21A/:9 7?=23:018/?: @A 6302?:53:8 ?0" 1:5 5?30 :?816/03 7! 302?:53:8 ? F :0<61:73 ?=21:A /: /80 >6/883: 08183=3:8 63/8361835 8.3 7?:83:8/?:0 ?C 6302?:53:8 ?" 1:5 140? 7?:83:535 8.18 8.3 56/B36 ?C 8.3 ;332 5/5 :?8 2?00300 1 B14/5 1:5 3CC378/B3 56/B/:9 4/73:03 1:5 6302?:53:8 ?" 144?>35 8.3 01/5 56/B36 8? 56/B3 8.3 B3./743 1:5 8.363@A B/?41835836=01:57?:5/8/?:0?C8.32?4/7A /8140? 7?:83:535 8.18 1 C1403 7103 .10 @33: 639/083635 191/:08 8.3 56/B36 ?C 8.3 ;332 1:5 8.18 8.3 6/@<:14 .15 :? 8366/8?6/14 ;<6/05/78/?:8?3:83681/:8.3238/8/?: 5! :8.3@10/0?C8.31@?B37?:83:8/?:01226?26/183 /00<30>363C61=35@A8.36/@<:141:58.3"08238/8/?:36>10 - 5 - 3D1=/:35 10 " D0" 8? >363 =16G35 /: 3B/53:73 302?:53:8?"3D1=/:35/80?CC/7/1410"1:58.3?CC/7/14?C 6302?:53:8?F:0<61:73?=21:A>103D1=/:3510 D0"8?>363=16G35?:8.3/6@3.14C 3! C836.316/:98.3169<=3:808.36/@<:141>16535 7?=23:018/?: ?C 0")# 1:5 C1083:35 8.3 4/1@/4/8A ?: 6302?:53:8 ? 3/:9 1996/3B35@A 8.3 01/5 ;<59=3:8 8.3 6302?:53:8?F:0<61:73?=21:A/0@3C?638./0?<68/: 8./0122314 * .3 169<=3:80 @A 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 C?6 8.3 1223441:8:0<61:73 ?=21:A 1:5 4316:35 7?<:034 C?6 6302?:53:8?*?>:36?C8.3B3./743>363.3165?<:034C?6 6302?:53:8?0"1:5238/8/?:360!5/5:?81223168?15B1:73 8.3/6169<=3:80 E 168/30 >?<45 @3 63C36635 10 236 8.3/6 61:G @3C?63 8.36/@<:14C?68.301G3?C7?:B3:/3:73 ( .3 4316:35 7?<:034 C?6 1223441:8 F :0<61:73 ?=21:A7?:83:508.18>.3:8.3238/8/?:367?:83:508.188.3 53731035>103=24?A33?C6302?:53:8?"8.3A0.?<45.1B3 - 6 - 1226?17.35 8.3 4316:35 ?==/00/?:36 <:536 8.3 ?6G=3:H0 ?=23:018/?:788/07?:83:5358.18>.3:6302?:53:8?" /: ./0 24315/:90 10 >344 10 3B/53:73 53:/35 0<7. 63418/?:0./2 8.36/@<:140.?<45.1B37?:74<5358.188.353731035>101: <:1<8.?6/I3521003:936/:126/B183716.3B3./743.10@33: <035?8.368.1:0?7/141:55?=308/72<62?03?C8.3?>:361:5 8.363C?63 8.363 /0 B/?418/?: ?C 836=0 1:5 7?:5/8/?:0 ?C 8.3 2?4/7A630<48/:9/:1@0?4B/:98.34/1@/4/8A?C8.31223441:88/0 7?:83:535 8.18 8.3 J<1:8<= ?C 8.3 7?=23:018/?: 1>16535 <:536 8.3 .315 ?C 21/: 1:5 0<CC36/:90 /0 :?8 ;<08/C/1@43 .3 C<68.36169<308.188.?<9.8.32?4/7A/00<35/0217G1932?4/7A 8.34/1@/4/8A/04/=/8358?0"#?:4A1:58.363C?638.3 12231453036B308?@3144?>35 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 C?6 8.3 6302?:53:8 ?" F ?>:36 ?C 8.3 B3./743 >?<45 7?:83:5 8.18 8.?<9. /8 .10 7?:83:535 8.18 8.363 /0 :? 63418/?:0./2 ?C 3=24?A36 1:5 3=24?A33 8.3 4/1@/4/8A 53836=/:35 @A 8.3 6/@<:1471::?8@3/:836C3635>/8.30<@=/808.188.3?>:36 ?C8.3B3./743.1053:/358.3:394/93:73?C8.356/B361:5/C1 :?:3=24?A33?C8.3?>:36/0861B34/:9/:8.301/5B3./743.3/0 ?@B/?<04A7?B3635@A8.32?4/7A/00<35@A8.31223441:80/:73 - 7 - .3.1521/58.3155/8/?:14263=/<=8?7?B368.3/:=1830?C8.3 ;332 .363C?63 .3 7?:83:50 8.18 8.3 7?B36193 71::?8 @3 63086/78358?0"#1:5100<7.0?<9.85/0=/0014?C8.3 122314 + :8./0639165.3241735634/1:73?:8.3;<59=3:8 ?C 8./0 ?<68 /: 8.3 7103 ?C /: 51835 3 140? 634/35 ?: 8.3 ;<59=3:8 /: 8.3 7103 ?C !"#$ %& "'#$( )*/: +,,-51835. ) 8/086/8341>8.18126/B1837162?4/7A>?<457?B36 8.3<::1=3521003:9360>.?163861B34/:9/:8.3716>/8.8.3 7?:03:8?C8.3?>:36C8.3B3./743/0<035C?6./63?663>165 2<62?03 8.3: 8.3 2?4/7A 7?:5/8/?:0 938 B/?41835 : 0<7. 7/67<=081:73 8.3 4/1@/4/8A ?: 8.3 :0<61:73 ?=21:A 71: @3 1@0?4B35 ?> 8.3 J<308/?: /0 >.3: 6302?:53:8 ?" .15 53:/35 8.18 8.3 53731035 /551::1 >10 :?8 /80 3=24?A33 >.38.368.3836=01:57?:5/8/?:?C8.32?4/7A163B/?418358/0 140?86/8341>8.181:/:=183?C8.3716/0184/@368A8?7.??03 8.3 C?6<= <:536 8.3 26?B/0/?:0 ?C =24?A330H ?=23:018/?: - 8 - 78 ?6 <:536 8.3 26?B/0/?:0 ?C 8.3 ?8?6 3./743 78 ./0 102378/0:?=?63 % 236<014 ?C 8.3 18 D0" 1:5 >?<45 /:5/71838.188.353731035>./4381G/:986318=3:8181=6355A ?02/814 .15 9/B3: 1 08183=3:8 8? 8.3 ?C '3>169/ ?4/73 818/?:8.18.3>101:3=24?A33?C:/8356?2163?=21:A 1:5 8.3 B3./743 @34?:935 8? 8.3 01/5?=21:A .3 177/53:8 ?77<66355<38?8.3:394/93:73?C8.356/B36./=10.1:G161:5 .3.150<081/:358.3/:;<6/301035?:8.301/5/:C?6=18/?: 7103 >10 639/083635 1:5 <48/=1834A 7.16930.338 >10 C/435 191/:08 8.3 56/B36 1:5 /8 >10 C?<:5 8.18 56/B36 .15 1 B14/5 56/B/:94/73:03<7.56/B/:94/73:03/0140?26?5<73518 D* .363C?63 8.3 7?:83:8/?: ?C 8.3 :0<61:73 ?=21:A 8.18 8.3 56/B36 >10 :?8 .1B/:9 1 B14/5 56/B/:9 4/73:03 >10 :?8 3081@4/0.35 " .3 :3D8 7?:83:8/?: ?C 8.3 1223441:8 /0 8.18 8.3 2?4/7A /0 1 26/B183 716 217G193 2?4/7A 1:5 8.363C?63 8.3 53731035 >10 :?8 236=/8835 8? 861B34 8 /0 :?8 8.3 7103 ?C 6302?:53:8?*.363/:8.3?>:36?C8.37168.18.3.15:?8 144?>358.3537310358?861B34/:8.3716.?<9.8.3>6/883: - 9 - 08183=3:8/0:?8.122/4A>?6535/8/0:?853:/358.188.363>10 :? 0<7. 177/53:8 394/93:73 ?C /80 56/B36 >10 53:/35 /: 8.3 >6/883: 08183=3:8 .3 2?4/7A26?5<73518 D >?<45 0.?> 8.188.32?4/7A7?B360<03?C8.3B3./743C?61:A2<62?03?8.36 8.1: ./63 ?6 63>165 1:5 C3> ?8.36 4/=/818/?:0 >./7. /0 :?8 6343B1:8C?68./071038140?=3:8/?:08.188.32?4/7A7?B360 <::1=35 21003:9360 10 236 " 1:5 8.3 4/=/8 /0 0"# "" : 8.3 7103 ?: .1:5 /8 /0 8.3 :?8 8.3 7103 ?C 8.3 1223441:8:0<61:73 ?=21:A 8.18 8.3 56/B36 F ./=10.1:G16 .15144?>358.3537310358?861B34101C16321A/:921003:936 :?0<7.7?:83:8/?:/0140?02?G3:8?@A"/:./08308/=?:A .363C?63 >.3: 8.3 2?4/73 212360 743164A /:5/7183 8.18 8.3 53731035 >10 861B34/:9 /: 8.3 01/5 B3./743 8.3 :0<61:73 ?=21:A 71::?8 7?:83:5 8.18 8.3 53731035 >10 1 9618</8?<0 21003:936?61C16321A/:921003:936.363/0:?=1836/14?: 637?658?3081@4/0.8./0C178<14102378 " .3 169<=3:8 ?C 8.3 4316:35 7?<:034 C?6 8.3 1223441:88.188.3B3./743.108?@3<035?:4AC?65?=308/71:5 0?7/14 2<62?030 @<8 8.3 7?=21:A <035 /8 C?6 0?=3 ?8.36 - 10 - 2<62?03/01:1@0<65169<=3:87?=21:A>./7./0143914 3:8/8A?@B/?<04A>/44?>:1716C?68.32<62?03?C8.3@<0/:300 8.18.108?@37166/35?<8@A/803=24?A330:371::?83D2378 8.18/80.?<45@3<035C?65?=308/71:50?7/142<62?030?:4A@A 8.3 ?=21:A ?63?B36 8.363 /0 :? 0<7. 7?:5/8/?: /: 8.3 2?4/7A 5?7<=3:8 3:73 8./0 7?:83:8/?: /0 4/1@43 8? @3 63;37835 "* .3 ;<59=3:8 ?C 8./0 ?<68 /: 8.3 7103 ?C 63C36635 7?:0/5360 8.3 7?B3:1:80 <:536 " 3164/36 +"! 7?:736:/:9 8.3 7?B36193 ?C 8.3 <::1=35 21003:9360 : 161 ?C 8.3 01/5 ;<59=3:8 8.3 /B/0/?:3:7.?C8./0?<68.10.34510@34?>$ ! ""# ! $ %&' ! ( ' """"") ! ! ! ! ! *& + ,* $ !-. +/ - 11 - ** *'0$+112.3 + 345 ! 6 6 7 ! ! ! 8 "E .363C?63 8.3 :0<61:73 ?=21:A 71::?8 81G3 0.34836<:536"1:A4?:9368?7?:83:58.188.363/014/=/8 C?6 8.3 7?B36193 ?63?B36 17/67<416 /00<35 @A 8.3 /: 8.3A316%140?5/637808.3:0<61:73?=21:/308?21A8.3 7?=23:018/?: 8? 8.3 /:=1830 ?C 8.3 B3./743 >.363B36 1 217G1932?4/7A/0/00<35./0102378>10:?8/7351:5?@036B35 /:161@A1?441836143:7.?C8./0?<68/:8.3;<59=3:8?C !"#$63C36635 :5368.3037/67<=081:7308.3 169<=3:8 ?C 8.3 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 C?6 8.3 1223441:8 8.18 8.3 2?4/7A 5/5 :?8 7?B36 8.3 /:=183 ?C 8.3 716 ?: 8.3 96?<:58.18.3>10:?88.33=24?A33?C8.36302?:53:8?"F ?>:361:58.188.353731035>1019618</8?<021003:936/0:?8 - 12 - 0<081/:1@43 /: 41> .3 122314 @3/:9 @363C8 ?C 1:A =36/80 /0 4/1@438?@35/0=/00353:738.3C?44?>/:9$ /! .3122314/05/0=/0035 //! .31=?<:8/:532?0/8/C1:A@3C?638./0?<68 @3861:0=/88358?8.36/@<:14 5# '$ ) $ /08?$"4?$(