Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9517 (KAR)
SMT LALITHA v. THE COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/200885/2022 · 2025-01-13
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9517 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9517 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%"" &% '
! "
# $ %"
&
$$ '
%()*""
#
#(
(# )&
%(+"
$",&- #
! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
$
&&* && $
$ ! $
$ . "&&"*
$
&"(%"*")*) $ &
'
%
$
! $ $
. "+#&&" $
! !" # $
"
'
%
$
! $ $
" & $
"(""&&" '
%$
$ $
$
%
%"
$
$
/0
1
23 4356567839 2:; <2:==38>3? :8 79?39 @3:968> 7
&"(%"*")*) ?:53? "&&"*A6?3883BC93D<:8<3=68>523:==75E3857F:
27C;3 F79 878%4:GE385 7F 523 :==75E385 496<3 H65268 523
- 3 -
56E3 ;564C=:53? 23G 2:A3 :=;7 <2:==38>3? 523 :==75E385 7F 523 27C;3 57 93;478?385 7# 68 539E; 7F 523 79?39 @3:968> 7
$ )*&&"%&& ?:53? #"&&&
& 23 4356567839 H:; :==7553? H652 : 27C;3 78
"**&"" :8? H:;
93IC693? 57 4:G : ;CE 7F ;"&&&%68F7C93IC:=68;5:==E385;523=:;57FH26<2 H:; 78 &*"&"" 23 4356567839 4:6? 523 =:;5 68;5:==E385 78 "(""&"" 23 93;478?385 7;" :8? & 52393F793 4:;;3? 523 6E4C>83? 79?39 <:8<3=68> 523 :==75E3857F52327C;357523435656783978523>97C8?52:5 5234356567839H:;93IC693?57?347;65523385693:E7C8568 783%;275 23 93;478?385;:C52796563; 6;;C3? : =35539 7F :==75E385 :==75568> 523 27C;3 57 93;478?385 7# 239368 368>:>>963A3?@G523;:6?79?3952343565678396;@3F793 526;7C95
# 3:983?<7C8;3=F795234356567839<78538?;52:5 523 4356567839 H:; 93IC693? 57 ?347;65 523 A:=C3 7F 523
- 4 -
27C;3 68 F7C9 68;5:==E385; :5 ;#(*% 3:<2 3 <78538?;52:5523=:;568;5:==E385H:;?C378&*"&"" 3 <78538?; 52:5 523 4356567839 2:? 4:6? 523 :E7C85 78 &*&"" &*)&"" "(""&"" :8? "(""&"" 93;43<56A3=G 3 ;C@E65; 52:5 :; 439 523 =35539 7F :==75E385 68 523 3A385 7F :8G ?3=:G 68 4:G68> 523 :==75E385 496<3 523 4356567839 H:; @7C8? 57 4:G 523 685393;5 352393F793<78538?;52:552343565678396;=6:@=3 57 4:G 523 685393;5 :8? 238<3 49:G; 52:5 523 6E4C>83? 79?39 4:;;3? @G 93;478?385 7;" :8? & <:8<3=68> 523 :==75E3857F5234=75:8?93%:==75568>655793;478?3857# @3;35:58:C>25
3:983? <7C8;3= F79 93;478?385 7;" :8? & ;C@E6553? 52:5 523 4356567839 2:; F:6=3? 57 4:G 523 :==75E385 496<3 :; 439 523 =35539 7F :==75E385 :8? 52393F793 93;478?385 7;" :8? & H393 H3== H65268 52369 47H39; 57 <:8<3= 523 :==75E385 :8? :==75 65 57 : 5269? 439;78 <<79?68>=G 23 <78538?; 52:5 93;478?385 7;"
- 5 -
:8?&2:A3<:8<3==3?523:==75E385:8?2:A3:==7553?6557 93;478?3857#
( 23 93;478?385 7# 2:; 875 :443:93? 527C>2 ;23H:;;39A3?H6525238756<37F523H96543565678
* 5:443:9;F97E523=355397F:==75E38552:5523 4356567839 H:; 93IC3;53? 57 4:G ;CE 7F ;"&&&% @368> 523 :==75E385 496<3 68 F7C9 3IC:= 68;5:==E385; 7F ;#(*% 23 68;5:==E385; F3== ?C3 78 &*&"" &*)&"" &*+&"" :8? &*"&"" 7H3A39 523 4356567839F:6=3?57?347;65523:==75E385496<378523?:53;
E3856783? :@7A3 @C5 @3=:53?=G ?347;653? 523 :E7C85 78 &*&""&*)&"":8?"(""&""93;43<56A3=G23 :=;7 4:6?
: ;CE 7F ;*(&"% @368> 523 F683 :E7C85 78
"(""&""2393F793527C>252343565678392:?4:6?523 :==75E385496<3523;:E3H:;875?783H6526856E3:8?65 :443:9; 52:5 78 523 :?A6<3 7F 523 93;478?385; 685393;5 H:;4:6?785237C5;5:8?68>2C;65H:;875JC;56F63?@G 52393;478?3857;":8?&57<:8<3=523:==75E3857F523 27C;3 F6A3 G3:9; :F539 93<36A68> 523 385693 <78;6?39:5678
- 6 -
; 96>25=G <78538?3? @G 523 =3:983? <7C8;3= F79 523 435656783952:5523=355397F:==75E385H:;;C@J3<557E:8G <78?65678;7837FH26<2H:;:;F7==7H; %
! " # $ %!&'()&* +,-./ 0 1$,0 '(23& " 45 67 '(
89: / 0; +' $< =
" # $>: 1# ? @3ABC +')
27C;37A39783;23:?6;:8:<263A3E3857F:
=6F356E3 :8? 57 :<263A3 526; :8 68?6A6?C:= H7C=? 2:A3 ;4385 : H27=3 =6F356E3 H:6568> F79 26; 5C98 8 52:5 <69<CE;5:8<3?38G68>523@383F657F:==75E385F79:596A6:= 93:;78 6; 875 JC;56F63? 52:5 577 :F539 F6A3 G3:9; 7F 523 43565678394:G68>C4523385693:==75E385496<38?39523 <69<CE;5:8<3; 523 6E4C>83? 79?39 7F <:8<3==:5678 7F :==75E3857F52327C;3575234356567839?3;39A3;57@3;35 :;6?3 :8? <78;3IC385=G 523 79?39 7F :==75E385 7F 523
- 7 -
27C;3 57 93;478?385 7# :=;7 ?3;39A3; 57 @3 ;35 :;6?3 38<3523F7==7H68>
6! 23H965435656786;
66! 236E4C>83?79?39<:8<3=68>523:==75E385 7F 523 27C;3 57 523 4356567839 6; ;35 :;6?3 :8?<78;3IC385=G523:==75E3857F27C;357 93;478?385 7# @G 93;478?385 7;" :8? &6;:=;7;35:;6?3
666! 2343565678396;?693<53?574:G523685393;5 F97E 523 ?:53 523 93;43<56A3 :E7C85 F3== ?C3 56== 523 ?:53 523 4356567839 E:?3 523 4:GE3855793;478?3857;":8?&H65268 : 43967? 7F 52933E7852; F97E 523 ?:53 7F 93<36457F:<74G7F526;79?39
()
&"'
"
6;57"=7*