Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9503 (KAR)
M/S UMARANI POWER PRIVATE LIMITED v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
WP/200828/2024 · 2025-02-12
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9503 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9503 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$%%
&$ '
!"
#
$
%
&
'
' ''
' ' (
&&!!!&
' '
'
&&!!!&
)
' $%
' ''
'
&(
&&!!!&
*
' '
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'( (
+'(' ( !!! '( ( '
$
%&)&' ( !!!&
'
''
) ( (
(
#
$
'&),
'* ,
(
' %
'
- '
'
'
(
!&!* '$% !))&)) ) ' $% + ' '
!!!* ( '-&!)*&-!*
*
+(
'
. - 3 -
/0 1023234506 /78 849:/2 ;46 7 <632 35 2/0 572960 4; =062346763 24 >978/ 75 46?06 ?720? !&!* @07635: 4'$%!))&)) 17880? @A 2/0 608145?052 4) 75? 24 >978/ 2/0 =4BB953=72345 ?720? !!!* @07635:
4( '-&!)*&-!* 7??60880? @A 2/0 608145?052 4* 24 2/0 1023234506 /0 1023234506 /78 7C84 849:/2 ;46 7 ?360=2345 24 2/0 608145?052 48* 75? 24 164=088 328 711C3=72345 ?720? &!"!) ;46 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 ;46 0827@C38/B052 4; 7 89:76 ;7=246A 35 A 4&&"* 4; 4657C 3CC7:0 5?37C9D3E7A71967?38263=2
/0 1023234506 =45205?8 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4 /7? 89@B3220? 75 711C3=72345 ;46 75 35?982637C 052601605096 B0B4675?9B$/05=0;462/60;0660?2478. .;468/462%45C350 45 !!-! 7206 45 328 60>9082 ;46 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 2/0 96F0A 4; 5?37 =45?9=20? 75 35810=2345 4; 2/0 1641480? C4=72345 4; 608145?052 4 45 &!"! ;4CC4<35: </3=/ 2/0 2720 4F065B052 38890? 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 45 &!&!!057@C35:2/0608145?052 4 240827@C38/789:76 ;7=246A 72 A 4-) 4; 7?7<7C7:7 3CC7:0 5?3 7C9D 3E7A71967 ?38263=2 /0 608145?052 4 <78 60>9360? 24
- 4 -
89@B32 106;46B75=0 @75D :97675200 4; 8&!!!!!!! 78 1608=63@0? 95?06 C7980 $% 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" </3=/32;73C0?24?484/060;4602/0/30;360=2464; 89:76@AC02206?720?!!)7??60880?242/00=60276A24 4F065B052 4; (765727D7 01762B052 4; 5?9826308 75? 4BB06=0 35;46B0? 2/72 2/0 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 ?720? &!&!!38890?242/0608145?052 4 8244??060=4:5380? /0 608145?052 4 2/05 ;3C0? 4!& &!) =/7CC05:35:2/07;460873?C02206?720?!!)/38496235 206B8 4; 75 46?06 ?720? ! !) >978/0? 2/0 =4BB953=72345 ?720? !!) 7??60880? @A 2/0 /30; 360=2464;9:76452/0:6495?2/7232F34C720?2/01635=31C084; 572967CE9823=075?60B3220?2/0=780@7=D242/0/30;360=246 9:76;46;608/?381487C7;206388935:78/4<=79805423=0/38 46?06 <78 =/7CC05:0? @A 8 723C 9:768 C3B320? 35 4!!&!) /0 873? <632 71107C <78 ?38B3880? 35 206B84;7546?06?720?!"&&!)
) /052/35:88244?2/982/01023234506/7?711C30? ;467?38275=0=0623;3=72045&!"!)72</3=/143523523B0 2/060<060540G38235:89:76;7=246308
- 5 -
* ;206 2/0 46?068 17880? 35
4!& &!) 75? 35
4!!&!) 2/0 608145?052 4) 106B3220? 2/0 608145?052 4 24 ;96538/ 7 @75D :97675200 4;
8&!!!!!!! 35 206B8 4; 75 46?06 ?720? !&!* 75? ?0=C760?2/0608145?052 4 78750<89:76;7=246A
5F30<4;2/07@4F02/060>90824;2/01023234506 ;46:67524;?38275=0=0623;3=720<7860E0=20?@A2/0608145?052 4*F3?046?06?720?!!!*
035: 7::630F0? @A 2/0 46?06 7==01235: 2/0 @75D :976752004;2/0608145?052 4 75??0=C7635:2/0608145?052 4 78 7 50< 89:76 ;7=246A 75?
2/0 46?06 60E0=235: 2/0 711C3=72345 ;46 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 4; 2/0 1023234506 2/38 <632 1023234538;3C0? - $3% 07650? =49580C ;46 2/0 1023234506 =45205?8 2/7295?06C7980 $&%4;9:7675045264C6?06&" 2/0 =45=0650? 106845 8/7CC ;3682 4@2735 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 ;64B 2/0 750 4BB38834506 46 2/0 360=246 $9:76% 46 10=3;30? 92/4632A 2/72 2/0 ?38275=0 @02<005 8320 </060 /0 164148082480291789:76;7=246A75?7?E7=0520G38235:89:76 ;7=24630875?50<89:76;7=24630838542C0882/752/0B353B9B
- 6 -
?38275=0 1608=63@0? @A 2/0 05267C 4F065B052 46 2/0 2720 4F065B052 2 38 45CA 2/0607;206 2/72 89=/ 106845 38 792/46380? 24 ;3C0 <32/35 450 B452/ ;64B 2/0 ?720 4;
388975=0 4; ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 5?06 C7980 $% 4;9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 7;206 38 ;3C0? 2/0 =45=0650? 106845 8/7CC 89@B32 7 106;46B75=0 :97675200 4; 8&!!!!!!!242/0/30;360=2469:76<32/35)!?7A84; 2/0;3C35:4; 7889602A;463B1C0B052723454; <32/352/0 82319C720?23B0460G205?0?23B078810=3;30?35C7980 4;
9:7675045264C6?06&" ;73C35:</3=/ 8/7CC8275? ?060=4:5380?0=45205?82/72C7980 $%4;9:76750 45264C 6?06 &" B75?7208 2/72 2/0 ?014832 4; 8&!!!!!!!/7824@0B7?0<32/35)!?7A8;64B2/0?720 4;
75? ?408 542 164F3?0 ;46 388935: 7 8/4< =7980 5423=0 @0;460 38?060=4:5380?0=45205?82/722/0C720617624;
C7980 $% 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 60C7235: 24 82319C720? 23B0 46 0G205?0? 23B0 38 45CA ;46 2/0 19614808 4; 3B1C0B052723454;
78164F3?0?95?06C7980 4;9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 0 2/060;460 =45205?8 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4)=49C?542/7F00520627350?2/060>90824;2/0 608145?052 4 @A 7==01235: 7 @0C720? @75D :97675200 75? - 7 -
=49C? 542 /7F0 ?0=C760? 2/0 608145?052 4 78 7 50< 89:76 ;7=246A 0 =45205?8 2/72 2/0 1023234506 38 542 @495? @A 2/0 46?068 17880? @A 2/38 4962 35
4!& &!) 75? 35 4!!&!)78/0<7854271762A2432
$33% 0=45205?82/723; 4;2/0608145?052 4 <78 60E0=20? ;46 545=4B1C375=0 4; C7980 $% 4; 9:76 750 45264C6?06&" 2/052/0711C3=723454;2/01023234506;46 ?38275=0=0623;3=720B982/7F0@005=4583?060?78@A2/72?720 2/060 <060 54 0G38235: 89:76 ;7=246308 46 50< 89:76 ;7=246308 <32/35&DB8;64B2/01C7=0</0602/0102323450635205?0?24 0827@C38/ 89:76 ;7=246A /060;460 /0 =45205?8 2/72 2/0 3B19:50? 46?06 17880? @A 2/0 608145?052 48) 75? * 760 F34C723F04;C7980 4;2/09:7675045264C6?06&" 75?2/060;4602/03B19:50?46?068760C37@C024@0>978/0?0 7C84 =45205?8 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4) </3C0 178835: 2/0 3B19:50? 46?06 75? 7==01235: 2/0 @75D :97675200 4; 2/0 608145?052 4 /7? /0C? 72 1767:671/ 4&! 2/72 2/0 @75D :97675200 4; 608145?052 4 <78 7==0120? 35 F30< 4; 2/0 46?06 17880? @A 2/38 4962 35
4!& &!) 75?
4!!&!) 0 =45205?8 2/72 2/38 4962 5032/06 17880? 75A 46?06 35 4!& &!) 546 35
- 8 -
4!!&!) ?360=235: 2/0 7==01275=0 4; 2/0 @75D :97675200 4; 2/0 608145?052 4 5 2/0 =452676A /0 89@B3220? 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4) <78 ?360=20? 24 38890 7 8/4<=79805423=0242/0608145?052 4 @0;460164=00?35:24 =75=0C ;3C0? @A 2/0 608145?052 4 /060;460 /0 =45205?82/722/03B19:50?46?0617880?@A608145?052 4) ?0=C7635:2/0608145?052 4 78750<89:76;7=246A38C37@C0 24@035206;060?<32/
$3% /0 10232345 38 411480? @A 2/0 608145?052 4 </4;3C0?82720B0524;4@E0=23458=45205?35:2/72C7980 $% 4; 2/0 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 106B328 2/0 0G2058345 4; 23B0 78 164F3?0? 95?06 C7980 4; 2/0 9:76 75045264C6?06&" 238=45205?0?2/722/38=452052345 4;2/0608145?052 4 <787==0120?@A7446?35720@05=/4;
2/38 4962 35
4!& &!) 75? ?3F38345 @05=/ 4; 2/38 4962 35
4!!&!) 2 38 =45205?0? 2/72 </05 2/0 9:7675045264C6?06&" 164F3?0?;460G20583454;23B0 2/0 =452052345 4; 2/0 1023234506 2/72 2/060 38 75 7924B723= C71835: 4;
38 =452676A 24 2/0 67234 4; 2/0 ?0=38345 4; 2/0 45.@C09160B0496235
- 9 -
! "#$'962/063238=45205?0? 2/72 2/0 1023234506 /78 54 24 >9082345 2/0 7==01275=04;2/0@75D:9767520075??0=C7635:2/0608145?052 4 78750<89:76;7=246A835=01023234506<7835=46146720? 78 7 =4B175A 45 &!) 75? 2/060;460 2/0 1023234506 =49C? 542 /7F0 ;3C0? 75 711C3=72345 ;46 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 45 &!"!) 2 38 7C84 =45205?0? 2/72 2/0 1023234506 38 7 )6? 1762A 35206C4106 </4 /78 54 24 =/7CC05:0 2/0 7==01275=04;2/0@75D:9767520089@B3220?@A2/0608145?052 4 2 38 =45205?0? 2/72 2/0 46?06 17880? @A 2/0 ?3F38345 @05=/ 4; 2/38 4962 35
4!!&!) 38 >90823450? @0;4602/045.@C09160B0496235 4&--!*</060 2/060 38 54 46?06 4; 827A 4; 2/0 46?06 17880? @A 2/0 ?3F38345 @05=/4;2/384962
$33%
23850G2=45205?0?2/72C7980 4;9:76750 45264C 6?06 &" 82319C7208 7 23B0 C3B32 4; !* A0768 75? 0G20583454;450A0765420G=00?35:! B452/872723B0 238 =C73B0?2/72C7980 4;9:7675045264C6?06&" <78 7B05?0?352/0A076!& </3=/164F3?0?;46723B0C3B324;! A076875?0G20583454;2<4A07685420G=00?35:450A076727
- 10 -
23B0/38C79807:73595?06<0527=/75:0352/0A076!& 82319C7235:!A0768782/04920623B0C3B3275?750G20583454;
! A0768 542 0G=00?35: 450 A076 72 7 23B0 2 38 2/060;460 =45205?0? 2/060 <78 54 895802 =C7980 ;46 0G2058345 4; 23B0 95?06 C7980 4; 2/0 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 3B3C76CA C7980 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" 95?06<052 75 7B05?B052 35 2/0 A076 !! !& 75? ! </3=/ 7CC 164F3?0 ;46 0G2058345 4; 23B0 @0A45? 2/0 23B0 C3B32 1608=63@0? /060;460 32 38 =45205?0? 2/72 2/0 =C73B 4; 2/0 10232345062/722/023B082319C720?35C7980 $%4;2/09:76 75045264C6?06&" 3845CA)!?7A838;7=297CCA35=4660=2
$333% 07650?=49580C;462/0608145?052 4 603206720? 2/0 7@4F0 =4520523458 75?
=413498CA 60;0660? 24 F763498 4@806F723458B7?0@A2/045.@C09160B04962352/0=7804; 60;0660?8916775?7E9?:B0524;7?3F38345 @05=/4;2/38496235
4&!!!78<0CC787546?06 17880? @A 2/0 45.@C0 9160B0 4962 35
$% 4""!)
$3F% 07C84=45205?0?2/7245=02/0@75D:976752004;
608145?052 4 <78 7==0120? 2/05 2/0 711C3=72345 4; 2/0 608145?052 4 ;46 75 <49C? 60F062 24 2/0 ?720 4;
- 11 -
711C3=7234557B0CA-! !/060;460/0=45205?0?2/72 2/0 1023234506 ?408 542 /7F0 75A 46 :630F75=0 7:735822/07==01275=04; 4;2/0608145?052 4
$F% 083?08 2/38 /0 =45205?0? 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4 /78 @005 0G1480? 24 75 9505?35: 6495? 4; C323:72345 72 2/0 /75?8 4; 8723C 9:768 C3B320? </4 ;3C0? 4!)!&&! 0 7C84 60;0660? 24 7 =0623;3=720 ?720? & !!) 38890? @A 2/0 2720 4F065B052 </3=/ 35?3=720? 2/72 8 723C 9:768 C3B320? /7? 711C30? ;46 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 75? 32 8/4<0? 2/72 75 0G38235: 89:76 ;7=246A <78 8329720 <32/35 & DB8 ;64B 2/0 1C7=0 </060 8 723C 89:768 ;7=246A1641480?240827@C38/7;7=246A07C84@649:/2242/0 5423=0 4; 2/0 4962 80F067C =46608145?05=08 60C7235: 24 8 787F08/<767 9:768 75? 506:A C3B320? 24 =45205? 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4 <78 ;46=0? 24 ;7=0 7 @7667:0 4; 164=00?35:8 75? C323:723458 @0;460 328 <78 7==0120? 0 2/060;460 =45205?82/722/016080521023234538A027542/067220B12B7?0 24 8=922C0 2/0 164E0=2 1641480? 24 @0 3B1C0B0520? @A 2/0 608145?052 4
- 12 -
" /0C07650? 89@B3220?2/722/0711C3=723454;
2/0608145?052 4 <78=4583?060?352/0C3:/24;2/0?360=2345 38890? @A 2/0 =446?35720 @05=/ 4; 2/38 4962 78 <0CC 78 2/0 ?3F38345@05=/4;2/38496275?2/060;4602/03B19:50?46?068 76054278873C7@C0@A2/01023234506
&! /7F0 =4583?060? 2/0 89@B3883458 4; 2/0 C07650? =49580C;462/0102323450678<0CC782/0C07650?=49580C;462/0 608145?052 4 /7F07C84106980?2/060=46?805=C480?<32/ 2/0 <632 10232345 78 <0CC 78 2/0 ?4=9B0528 05=C480? <32/ 2/0 82720B0524;4@E0=2345889@B3220?@A2/0608145?05254
&& /0608145?052 4 1641480?240827@C38/789:76 ;7=246A727?<7C7:7F3CC7:0 5?37C9D3E7A71967?38263=275? @0;460 4@273535: 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 32 ;3C0? 75 45C350 /3C0 2/0 <78 95?06 =4583?0672345 2/0 608145?052 4 <78 :67520? 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 45 &!&!! /0 608145?052 4 </3=/ <78 60>9360? 24 ?014832 7 89B 4;
8&!!!!!!! 78 @75D :97675200 ;73C0? 24 ?4 84 </3=/ 6089C20?350G136A4;?38275=0=0623;3=720@AF362904;410672345 C7980 $% 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" /38 <78 =/7CC05:0?@A2/0608145?052 4 35
4!& &!)45
- 13 -
2/0 :6495? 2/72 @0;460 /4C?35: 2/72 /7? 0G1360? 2/0 71164163720 792/4632A B982 /7F0 38890? 7 8/4< =7980 5423=0 75? 2/72 2/0 608145?052 4 <78 05232C0? 24 @050;32 4; 7 5423=0 /38 ;495?
;7F496 35
4!& &!) 75? 7 =446?35720 @05=/ 4; 2/38 4962 35 206B8 4; 75 46?06 ?720? ! !)7CC4<0?2/0<6321023234575??360=20?2/0360=246 4;9:768243889078/4<=79805423=0@0;460/4C?35:2/72
38890?242/0608145?052 4 /7?0G1360?8452/0?7204;
?381487C 4;
4!& &!) 2/0 1023234506 /7? 542 89@B3220?75711C3=72345;46?38275=0=0623;3=72075?2/046?06 17880? @A 2/0 =446?35720 @05=/ 4; 2/38 =4962 35 4!& &!) <78 2/05 =/7CC05:0? 35 4!!&!)75?<78?38B3880?45!"&&!)F05 23CC2/052/01023234506/7?542;3C0?2/0711C3=72345;46?38275=0 =0623;3=720 /0 711C3=72345 4; 2/0 1023234506 ;46 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 <78 ;3C0? 45CA 45 &!"!) /0 360=246 4;
9:768 ;4CC4<35: 2/0 ?360=23F0 38890? @A 2/38 4962 35 4!& &!) 75? 4!!&!) /0C? 164=00?35:8 75? 35 206B8 4; 2/0 46?06 ?720? !&!* 7==0120?2/0@75D:97675200;96538/0?@A2/0608145?052 4 75? ?0=C760? 2/0 608145?052 4 78 7 50< 89:76 ;7=246A 72
- 14 -
7?7<7C7:7F3CC7:04580>9052CA2/060>90824;2/01023234506 ;46 388975=0 4; 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 <78 60E0=20? 45 !!!*
&
5F30<4;2/07@4F0;7=297C@7=D?6412/0>9082345 </02/062/01023234506<7805232C0?24=/7CC05:02/046?06?720? !&!*763808;46=4583?0672345352/38<63210232345
&) /0 1023234506 38 78806235: 2/72 2/0 46?06 4;
608145?052 4) 7==01235: 2/0 @75D :97675200 4; 608145?052 4 75??0=C7635:2/0608145?052 4 78750<89:76;7=246A 38 35 F34C72345 4; C7980 $% 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" /38>9082345=75542@0=4583?060?@A2/38496235F30< 4; 2/0 792/4632723F0 1645495=0B052 35
4!& &!) 75? !!&!)75?35F30<4;2/0105?05=A4;$=% 4&--!* 7:73582 2/0 46?06 17880? 35 4!!&!) ; 2/0 1023234506 <78 7::630F0? @A 2/0 46?0617880?35
4!!&!2/07116416372060B0?A ;46 2/0 1023234506 <78 24 800D 60F30< 4; 2/0 46?06 @0;460 2/0 ?3F38345@05=//384962=755428323571107C4F062/046?06 17880? @A 2/0 ?3F38345 @05=/ 4; 2/38 4962 35 4!!&!) 24 /4C? 2/72 2/0 C7980 $% 4;9:76
- 15 -
75045264C6?06&" ?4085427?B324;0G20583454;23B0 2489@B327@75D:97675200
&* /38 71762 C7980 $&% 4; 9:76 750 45264C 6?06 &" =4520B1C7208 7@492 ;3C35: 75 711C3=72345 ;46 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 @A 7 H=45=0650? 106845H .=45=0650? 106845.=49C?032/06@07535?3F3?97C467=44106723F084=302A46 7=4B175A?9CA35=46146720?95?062/04B175308=2!&)
5 2/0 =780 45 /75? 2/0 1023234506 <78 35=46146720? 78 7 =4B175A45 &!)/060;46045&!"!)</052/0 1023234506;3C0?75711C3=72345;46?38275=0=0623;3=72032<78542 35=46146720?787=4B175A/060;46032?3?542>97C3;A24@07 H7=45=0650?106845H/0=4520523454;2/0C07650?=49580C;46 2/0608145?052 4 2/722/01023234506/7?54 24 0F05 ;3C0 75 711C3=72345 ;46 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 45 &!"!) B063287==01275=0
&
5 F30< 4; 2/0 7;460873? ;35?35: 2/0 1023234506 =75542 35 2/38 <632 10232345 =/7CC05:0 2/0 3B19:50? 46?068 ?720? !&!* 75? !!!* ?0=C7635: 2/0 608145?052 4 78 7 50< 89:76 ;7=246A 75? =4580>9052CA =75542
- 16 -
=/7CC05:02/060E0=23454;2/0?38275=0=0623;3=720849:/2;46@A 2/01023234506
& 4580>9052CA 2/38 <632 10232345 ;73C8 75? 38
&- 0;460176235:;64B2/0=7802/384962/785423=0?
757220B127245091B758/31@02<0051068458;460827@C38/35:
7 89:76 ;7=246A 75? 24<76?8 2/38 2/0A 7220B12 24 492<32 2/0 42/06 @A @05?35: 2/0 C7< 24 8932 2/036 =45F05305=0 '46 0G7B1C0 2/0 608145?052 4 </3=/ <78 8911480? 24 ;3682 4@2735 7 ?38275=0 =0623;3=720 75? 2/0607;206 89@B32 75 711C3=72345 45C350 ?3? 2/0 0G7=2 60F0680 /0 4F065B052 4;
5?37B982/7F049263:/2CA60E0=20?2/0 ;3C0?7832?3?542 7==4B175A7?38275=0=0623;3=7203B3C76CA2/01023234506</3=/ <78 542 0F05 35=46146720? 78 7 =4B175A 78 45 &!"!) ;3C0?75711C3=72345;467?38275=0=0623;3=720352/057B04;2/0 =4B175A 2 2/060;460 7110768 2/72 2/0 1023234506 75? 2/0 608145?052 4 /7F02630?24@02/0076CA@36?24827D07=C73B ;46 0827@C38/35: 2/0 89:76 ;7=246A 7C2/49:/ 2/0 164=0?960 7?4120?@A@42/ 4; 2/0B <060 35F34C72345 4; 2/0 9:76 750 45264C6?06&" CC2/0827D0/4C?0688/49C?@0B35?;9C4;
- 17 -
2/0;7=22/722/09:7675045264C6?06&" 1608=63@087 545?38=63B357246A 164=0?960 ;46 46?06CA 60:9C72345 4;
0827@C38/B052 4; 89:76 ;7=246308 7=6488 5?37 /060;460 0F06A450 =45=0650? 8/49C? 8263=2CA 7?/060 75? =4B1CA 2/0 164=0?960 ;46 0827@C38/B052 4; 7 89:76 ;7=246A C082 32 8/49C? 6089C2 35 95=0627352A /0 9:76=750 45264C 6?06 &" =45273535: 2/0 164=0?960 ;46 0827@C38/B052 4; 89:76 ;7=246308 /7F35:8244?2/020824;23B08/49C?2/060;460@0=4B1C30?35 C02206 75? 813632 /38 4962 2/060;460 /4108 2/72 2/0 608145?05288/7CC0589608263=2=4B1C375=075?542:67527C45: C078/242/0711C3=7528
()
&%' %
& )