- 1 - ! "" #$% "& '$ ( !" # # $%! "% & ' ( $ ) ) ) #! # #* + Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %$, , % # # %$$ " # # %$$ - % # # %$$ . !" # # %$$ & ' )-/ )/ $"( ) ,,! ,,) ) ) ) . 0 $!,,," %,),$ ) ) ) ) 0 ) ) 12 # - 3 - # 3 '# 3 ( 456789:59898;<8=>?945:@A8<98BB>5B;7594578A@;C79 64;4A=A==A8@5D945;7D57:A==5DC<D577D57,!C@5E ;< ;0 64575>? 945 A::@8FA98;< B8@5D >? 945 :@A8<98BB B;7 A::;8<9G5<9 ;B 945 ==8=9A<9 875F9;7 ;B A<D 5F;7D= B;7 D5GA7FA98;<;B>;C<DA785=4A=>55<75H5F95D , 45:A7985=A7575B5775D9;A=:57945877A<I>5B;75 94578A@;C79 " 45 BAF9= 94A9 A75 GAD5 ;C9 A75 94A9 945 =C89 4A= >55< B8@5D >? 945 :@A8<98BB =55I8<J B;7 A< ;7D57 ;B :57:59CA@ 8<HC<F98;< 75=97A8<8<J 945 D5B5<DA<9= ;7 :57=;<= F@A8G8<J 947;CJ4;7C<D57945GB7;G8<957B578<J68949455KF@C=8L5A<D :5AF5BC@ :;==5==8;< ;B 945 :@A8<98BB ;L57 945 =C89 =F45DC@5 :7;:57985= 45 BAF9= GAD5 ;C9 >? 945 :@A8<98BB A75 94A9 945 :@A8<98BB7C=98=945A>=;@C95;6<57A<D8<:;==5==8;<;B=C89 =F45DC@5 :7;:57985= 4AL8<J :C7F4A=5D 945 =AG5 947;CJ4 75J8=9575D=A@5D55D= 98=945=:5F8B8FA==5798;<94A964A94A= >55< :C7F4A=5D A75 :@;9 ;=!% !E A<D $ 9 8= BC79457 - 4 - =C>G8995D94A9:C7=CA<99;94575J8=9575D=A@5D55D=<AG5;B 945 :@A8<98BB 4A= >55< 5<9575D 8< 945 75@5LA<9 75F;7D= ;B 945 @;FA@AC94;789?A<D9AK5=A75:A8D 98=945;<@?F;<95<98;<;B 945 :@A8<98BB 94A9 D5B5<DA<9 ;=, 9; 64; A75 945 ADH;8<8<J @A<D ;6<57= A>C998<J 9; 945 @A?;C9 8< 648F4 945 :@A8<98BB 4A= :C7F4A=5DF579A8<=895=4AL5>55<8<957B578<J6894945:@A8<98BB2= :;==5==8;< 98=8<945F;<95K9;B=CF4D8=:C9594A9945:75=5<9 =C894A=>55<B8@5D - 5A7<5DF;C<=5@B;7945:@A8<98BB=C>G89=94A9A9A< 5A7@857 :;8<9 ;B 98G5 A< A::@8FA98;< 6A= B8@5D B;7 F;<DCF98<J =C7L5? ;B @A<D >5A78<J ? ;,$ $ >? B8@8<J ; A<D 945 =A8D A::@8FA98;< FAG5 9; >5 75H5F95D 648@5 ;>=57L8<J 94A9 945 A::@8FA98;<B8@5D6A=:75GA9C75A=9455L8D5<F56A==98@@9;>5 @598< 96A=BC79457;>=57L5D94A9945A::@8FA98;<6A=B8@5DA9 A :75GA9C75 =9AJ5 ; FAG5 9; >5 D8=:;=5D ;B A= :57 ;7D57DA95D,,,,$E C>=5MC5<9@? C:;< F;<F@C=8;< ;B 5L8D5<F5 645< 945 GA9957 6A= =59 ;C9 B;7 A7JCG5<9= :@A8<98BB B8@5D ;0 C<D57 7D57 ,! C@5 E B;7 A::;8<9G5<9 ;B A ;C79 ;GG8==8;<57 <AG8<J 945 ==8=9A<9 875F9;7 ;B A<D 5F;7D= - 5 - B;7 D5GA7FA98;< ;B >;C<DA785= ;B @A<D 8< ? ;,$ $ 64575>? :@;9= :C7F4A=5D >? 945 :@A8<98BB= A75 =89CA95D A<D @A<D 8< ? ;,, 645758< 945 D5B5<DA<9 ;=, A<D " 4AL5 GAD5 ;C9 945 F@A8G 45 =A8D A::@8FA98;< 4;65L57 FAG5 9; >5 75H5F95D ;>=57L8<J 94A9 A= 5L8D5<F5 8= F;<F@CD5D A<D GA9957 4A= 75AF45DA9945=9AJ5;BA7JCG5<9=89GA?<;9>5:7;:57B;7945 ;C799;A::;8<9A;GG8==8;<57A=896;C@D@5AD9;A 978A@ ;B 945 =C89 45 =A8D ;7D57 75H5F98<J 945 A::@8FA98;< 4A= >55<FA@@5D8<MC5=98;<8<948=:59898;<A78;C=J7;C<D=4AL5 >55<7A8=5D ! 5A7<5D F;C<=5@ B;7 945 :@A8<98BB 78 8D4A:C7I57 =C>G89= 94A9 =5F;<D A::@8FA98;< 6A= B8@5D AB957 5L8D5<F56A=@598<A<D8B945==8=9A<9875F9;7;BA<D75F;7D= 6A=A::;8<95DA=A;C79F;GG8==8;<57945=C8989=5@BF;C@D>5 D8=:;=5D ;B >? 9AI8<J <;95 ;B 945 =A8D 75:;79 648F4 6;C@D 5<A>@5 945 :@A8<98BB 9; =C>=9A<98A95 945 F;<95<98;<= A<D A==5798;<=GAD58<945:@A8<9 9 8= BC79457 =C>G8995D 94A9 =C89 8= ;<5 B;7 >A75 8<HC<F98;< A<D 6;C@D 75=9 ;< :@A8<98BB :7;L8<J :;==5==8;< A<D 945 =C7L5? 75:;79 89=5@B A9 945 G;=9 GA? >5 A 4A<D? 9;;@ 9; - 6 - 5<A>@5 945 ;C79 9; D5F8D5 945 FA=5 A<D GA? <;9 >5945 =;@5 D;FCG5<99;>575@85DC:;<9;D8=:;=5;BB9458<HC<F98;<=C89 9 8==C>G8995D94A9945:C7:;=5;BA::;8<98<J945;GG8==8;<57 8=;<@?9;A8D945;C799;F;G59;AF;<F@C=8;<A<DFA<<;9>5A =C>=989C959;945>C7D5<8G:;=5D;<945:@A8<98BB9;:7;L5945 :@A8<98BB2=FA=5 % 45 F;<95=98<J D5B5<DA<9=75=:;<D5<9= 8< 945 :75=5<9 GA9957 94;CJ4 =57L5D 4AL5 <;9 A::5A75D A<D 945 ;9457D5B5<DA<9==57L5DD;<;94AL5A<?=578;C=;>H5F98;<B;7 A::;8<9G5<9 ;B 945 ;GG8==8;<57 ;C<=5@ B;7 75=:;<D5<9 ;-=C>G89=94A9945:7;:579?:C7F4A=5D>?48G8=8<? ;,E A<D4A=<;948<J9;D;6894945F@A8G;B945:@A8<98BB E 9945;C9=5989GC=9>5<;98F5D94A9=C898=;<5B;7 8<HC<F98;< 45 FA=5 ;B 945 :@A8<98BB 94A9 945 :@A8<98BB 4A= D578L5D 78J49= 6894 75=:5F9 9; :@;9 ;=!% !E A<D $ =89CA95D 8< 8DDA:C7 ;@;<? A@A>C7AJ8 8< 75=8D5<98A@ @A?:C9 B;7G5D8<? ;=$-A<D,$ $ 98=945=:5F8B8FFA=594A9945 D5B5<DA<9= A75 8<957B578<J 6894 945 :@A8<98BB2= :7;:579? 9 8= BC79457 <;98F5D 94A9 945 A::@8FA98;< 6A= B8@5D A9 945 5A7@85=9 :;8<9 ;B 98G5 8< 945 <A9C75 ;B ; 8< 945 ?5A7 ,$E A<D - 7 - =A8DA::@8FA98;<FAG59;>575H5F95DA=945=AG56A=B8@5DA9A :75GA9C75=9AJ5A=:A7985=4AD<;9@598<5L8D5<F5 $ 9 8= 945 FA=5 ;B 945 :@A8<98BB 94A9 AB957 945 F;<F@C=8;<;B5L8D5<F5 ;0 4A=>55<B8@5D648F44A=>55< 75H5F95D;<@?;>=57L8<J94A9A::@8FA98;<6A=B8@5DA9945=9AJ5 ;B A7JCG5<9= A<D ;C79 FA<<;9 5<957 8<9; A 978A@ >? :57G8998<J B8@8<J ;B A::@8FA98;< A9 =CF4 =9AJ5 ;0 4A= >55< B8@5D =55I8<J B;7 A::;8<9G5<9 ;B A ;C79 ;GG8==8;<57 :75B57A>@? ==8=9A<9 875F9;7 ;B A<D 5F;7D= B;7 :C7:;=5 ;B D5GA7FA98;< ;B >;C<DA785= 8< ? ;,$ $ 64575 =C89 :@;9= A75 =9A95D 9; >5 @;FA95D A<D ? ;,, 645758< D5B5<DA<9 ;=, A<D"4AL594587F@A8G 98=945F;<95<98;<;BF;C<=5@B;7945 :@A8<98BB94A9945D5B5<DA<9=4AL594587:7;:579?8<945<A9C75;B :@;9= =89CA95D 8< ? ;,, 648F4 8= D8BB575<9 B7;G :@;9= :C7F4A=5D>?945:@A8<98BB8<? ;,$ $ $$ = 78J49@? F;<95<D5D 8B ==8=9A<9 875F9;7 ;B A<D 5F;7D=8=A::;8<95DA=A;GG8==8;<579;F;<DCF9=C7L5?A<D D5GA7FA95945:7;:579?94A96;C@D45@:945;C799;F;G59;A 78J49F;<F@C=8;<F;<=8D578<J945<A9C75;BD8=:C954575:;79 ;B945==8=9A<9875F9;7;BA<D5F;7D=6;C@D;<@?>5;<5;B - 8 - 9455L8D5<F5=9;>59AI5<<;95;B>?945;C79648@5D5F8D8<J 945 =C89 45 :;==5==8;< ;B 945 :@A8<98BB 4A= 9; >5 :7;L5D 8<D5:5<D5<9 ;B =CF4 75:;79 A<D 89 8= ;<@? ;< :7;L8<J 945 :;==5==8;< 945 MC5=98;< ;B 5<989@5G5<9 ;B 945 :7A?57 ;B :57:59CA@8<HC<F98;<8=9;>5D5F8D5D>?945;C79 $, 9 FA<<;9 >5 =9A95D 94A9 945 A@@;68<J ;B 945 A::@8FA98;< 68@@ 4AL5 945 5BB5F9 ;B F;@@5F98;< ;B 5L8D5<F5 9 GC=9 A@=; >5 =55< 94A9 ; B8@5D A9 945 5A7@85=9 :;8<9 ;B 98G5 6A= 75H5F95D 648@5 ;>=57L8<J 94A9 945 A::@8FA98;< B8@5D :78;79;@5AD8<J;B5L8D5<F5A<D6A=A9A:75GA9C75=9AJ5 < @8J49 ;B D8=G8==A@ ;B ; :@A8<98BB 4A= 78J49@? B8@5D 945 A::@8FA98;< AB957 5L8D5<F5 ;B >;94 =8D5= 8= F;<F@CD5D 648F4 FA<<;9 >5 B;C<D BAC@9 6894 < F;<97;L57=85= =CF4 A= 94;=5 94A9 A= A78=5< 8< 945 :75=5<9 GA9957 945 75:;79 ;B 945 ;C79 ;GG8==8;<576;C@D>5A9;;@B;7945;C799;D5F8D5945@5JA@ 78J49= A= A==5795D 8< 945 :@A8<9 FF;7D8<J@? B8<D 94A9 945 78A@ ;C79 4A= 5775D 8< D8=G8==8<J 945 A::@8FA98;< A<D A::@8FA98;< ;CJ49 9; 4AL5 >55< F;<=8D575D 8< @8J49 ;B 945 D8=FC==8;<GAD5A>;L5 - 9 - $" FF;7D8<J@? 945 8G:CJ<5D ;7D57 8= =59 A=8D5 ::@8FA98;< N ;0 O B8@5D C<D57 7D57 ,! C@5 E 8= A@@;65D45HC78=D8F98;<A@==8=9A<9875F9;7;BA<D5F;7D=8= A::;8<95DA=A;C79;GG8==8;<574578A@;C799;B8K945 98G5 =F45DC@5 B;7 =C>G8==8;< ;B 945 75:;79 648@5 :57G8998<J >;94=8D5=9;B8@594587G5G;;B8<=97CF98;<=FF;7D8<J@?945 :59898;<8= )* ' "&( % 8=9 ;#$@ ;#$