- 1 - ! ! "# $% &$ ! # '()'*+,()'++ & ! " # $ % % " # $ % &'%# $ & % #($( !) !! % %% % %% Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )% !!& %% * *% ' !! % ( +* (* #+* (* $ ,,-./0 12 314/ 5!) !! 3/61.7/3/0 89 21:/3.179 5;1,/ 7<7152 <;<8-3<61 =53 7>/ 5==/2,/ ?-21.><8;/ -20/3 /,7152 ) 5= !!& 1. 8/=53/ 7>1. 5-37 -20/3 /,7152 & 5= !!& .//@126 3/6-;<3 8<1; ! /<307>/;/<32/05-2./;=537>/?<371/. & % 12 314/ 5!) !! A<. 3/61.7/3/0 89 21:/3.1795;1,/ 7<7152<;<8-3<61<6<12.77>/?/717152/3 >/3/12 52 7>/ 8<.1. 5= =13.7 12=534<7152 .-84177/0 89 7>/ :1,714 ;<09 <6/0 <85-7 ! 9/<3. -3126 7>/ ,5-3./ 5= 12:/.716<7152 ?/717152/3 A<. <33/.7/0 52 !) !! 2:/.716<7152 12 7>/ ,<./ 1. ,54?;/7/0 <20 ,><36/ .>//7 ><. 8//2 =1;/0 =53 7>/ <=53/.<10 5==/2,/ <1; <??;1,<7152 - 3 - =1;/0 89 7>/ ?/717152/3 8/=53/ 7>/ B-31.01,7152<; /..152. 5-37 12 31412<; 1.,5! !! A<. 3/B/,7/0 52 ! !!!>/3/=53/>/1.8/=53/7>1.5-37 /<32/05-2./;=537>/?/717152/3.-8417.7><7 =53/C73<2/5-.3/<.52.7>/<;;/6/0:1,714><.4<0/=<;./ <;;/6<7152. <6<12.7 7>/ ?/717152/3 >/ <;;/6/0 :1,714 1. < 4<331/0;<09<20<=7/3.>/><0=5-6>7A17>>/3457>/312 ;<A.>/<20>/3>-.8<20A/3/61:/2.>/;7/312?/717152/3D. >5-./>/A1=/5=7>/?/717152/31.7>//;0/3.1.7/35=7>/ :1,714 ;<09D. >-.8<20 2:/.716<7152 5= 7>/ ,<./ 1. ,54?;/7/0 /717152/3 1. < 4<331/0 4<2 ><:126 < 41253 0<-6>7/3,,530126;9>/?3<9.75<;;5A7>/?/717152 /3 ,5273< ;/<32/0 16> 5-37 5:/324/27 ;/<0/3A>5><.5??5./07>/?/717152.-8417.7><7127>/ /:/27?/717152/31./2;<36/0528<1;>/1.;1@/;9757<4?/3 A17>7>/?35./,-7152A172/.. ) /3-.<; 5= 7>/ 4<7/31<; 52 3/,530 A5-;0 65 75 .>5A 7><7 4<331<6/ 5= 7>/ :1,714 ;<09 A<. ?/3=534/0 <85-7 ! 9/<3. ?3153 75 7>/ 3/61.73<7152 5= % A17> 52/ <../2.<8 -;;<:<;/ 7 <??/<3. 7><7 :1,714 ;<09 ><0 - 4 - E-<33/;/0A17>>/3457>/312;<A<207>/3/<=7/3.>/A<. 61:/2.>/;7/3897>//;0/3.1.7/35=>/3>-.8<20<7>-?<; /62553:1;;<6/2!& !!7>/>-.8<205=7>/:1,714 ;<09><0<;;/6/0;9652/5-7=53A53@<20>/3.1.7/312;<A ><412</6-4A<.<;.5257127>/>5-./>/0<-6>7/3 5= ><412</6-4A<.?;<91265-7.10/7>/>5-./A17>7>/ 4581;/ ?>52/ <20 <7 7><7 714/ 7>/ ?/717152/3 A>5 1. 7>/ >-.8<205= ><412</6-4<;;/6/0;9755@7>/:1,714613; 12757>/@17,>/2127>/>5-./<20.7<7/075>/37><71=.>/ ><. ./C A17> >14 .>/ A1;; ,52,/1:/ <20 61:/ 8137> 75 < ,>1;0 -7 A>/2 .>/ 3/=-./0 75 ,55?/3<7/ A17> >14 =53 ><:126127/3,5-3./>/<;;/6/0;9=53,/0>14./;=52>/3<20 ><0 =53,18;/ ./C-<; 127/3,5-3./ A17> >/3 <20 7>/3/<=7/3 ;/=7 7>/ >5-./ <=7/3 ,31412<;;9 1271410<7126 >/3 2 7>/ .<4/0<9.>/<;;/6/0;912=534/0<85-77>/12,10/2775>/3 >-.8<20<20<;.575>1..1.7/3 ><412</6-4A>51.7>/ A1=/ 5= 7>/ ?/717152/3 >/3/12 >/3/<=7/3 <=7/3 01.,-..126 A17>>/3?<3/27.52!) !!.>/><.<??35<,>/07>/ 5;1,/<20.-84177/07>/=13.712=534<7152 - 5 - F /717152/3<20:1,714A>51.<4<331/0;<09<3/ ,;5./ 3/;<71:/. <20 :1,714 <20 >/3 >-.8<20 A/3/ 61:/2 .>/;7/3127>/>5-./5=7>/?/717152/3<=7/37>/:1,714><0 E-<33/;/0 A17> >/3 457>/312;<A ;;/6<7152 <6<12.7 7>/ ?/717152/3 1. 7><7 A>/2 7>/ >-.8<20 <20 .1.7/312;<A 5= 7>/ :1,714 A/3/ 257 12 7>/ >5-./ ?/717152/3 ><0 =53,18;/ ./C-<;127/3,5-3./A17>>/32:/.716<71525=7>/,<./1. ,54?;/7/0<20,><36/.>//7><.8//2=1;/0201.?-7/0;9 7>/?/717152/3><.2557>/3,31412<;<27/,/0/27. <7/31<; 52 3/,530 A5-;0 65 75 .>5A 7><7 ?/717152/3 ><. < 41253 0<-6>7/3 A>5 A<. ?3/./27 12 7>/ >5-./527>/<;;/6/00<7/5=12,10/27>/<;;/6<71524<0/ <6<12.77>/?/717152/31.3/E-13/075?35:/012<=-;;=;/06/0 731<;52.10/31267>/=<,7.<20,13,-4.7<2,/.5=7>/,<./ <207>/2<7-3/5=<;;/6<71524<0/<.<6<12.77>/?/717152/3 <20 <;.5 ><:126 3/6<30 75 7>/ 0/;<9 5= 7>3// 0<9. 12 <??35<,>126 7>/ ?5;1,/ <4 5= 7>/ :1/A 7><7 A17>5-7 /C?3/..126<295?12152527>/4/317.<200/4/317.5=7>/ ,<./ 7>/ ?3<9/3 4<0/ 89 7>/ ?/717152/3 =53 63<27 5= - 6 - 3/6-;<3 8<1; 2//0. 75 8/ <2.A/3/0 <==134<71:/;9 ,,530126;97>/=5;;5A126 1 >/?/7171521.<;;5A/0 11 >/?/717152/31.013/,7/0758//2;<36/0528<1; 12 314/ 5!) !! 5= 21:/3.179 5;1,/ 7<7152 <;<8-36<1 3/61.7/3/0 =53 7>/ 5==/2,/ ?-21.><8;/ -20/3 /,7152 ) 5= !!& .-8B/,7757>/=5;;5A126,52017152. <$ >/ ?/717152/3 .><;; /C/,-7/ ?/3.52<; 8520 =53 < .-4 5= . A17> 7A5 .-3/71/.=537>/;1@/.-4757>/.<71.=<,7152 5=7>/B-31.01,7152<;5-37G 8$ >/ ?/717152/3 .><;; <??/<33/6-;<3;9 52 <;; 7>/0<7/.5=>/<31268/=53/7>/31<;5-37 -2;/.. 7>/ 31<; 5-37 /C/4?7. >1. <??/<3<2,/=53:<;103/<.52.G ,$ >/ ?/717152/3 .><;; 257 013/,7;9 53 12013/,7;9 7>3/<7/2 53 7<4?/3 A17> 7>/ ?35./,-7152A172/../.G 0$ >/ ?/717152/3 .><;; 257 12:5;:/ 12 .141;<3 5==/2,/.12=-7-3/G - 7 - /$ >/ ?/717152/3 .><;; 257 ;/<:/ 7>/ B-31.01,7152 5= 7>/ 31<; 5-37 A17>5-7 ?/341..1525=7>/.<105-37-271;7>/,<./ 3/61.7/3/0<6<12.7>141.01.?5./05== -, '% &$ !+ $ 1.75 ;5