Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9409 (KAR)

ABDUL S/O LALASAB MORUTAGI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200059/2023 · 2025-01-10

Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $ "# #!! %&'%(!)*'%) + !" # $ % & ' & &&& & & & ' & (" # $ % & ' )* $"% ' & '+ ' (,("(") & ,("(*$ ' " "(% +& '&& Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' ' & & & & - & - & # $& - &% ./011234567.289:;/872<388=02</0</>2872<3?3/:07 7.2 @=<?A2:7 9B 89:;/87/9: 3:< 9><2> 9B 02:72:82 <372< (,("(") 13002< /: 9,("(* 56 7.2 <<4 /07>/87 3:< 200/9:0 =<?2 $.2>2/:3B72> >2B2>>2< 79 30 -423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2-% /@3631=>3 C.2>2/: 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 89:;/872< 7.2 3112443:7388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:0 )(")(*( 3:< (! 9B 3:< 02:72:82<./A79=:<2>?9>/?9>9=0/A1>/09:A2:7B9>4/B23:<79 1363B/:29B0(((((D/:<2B3=479B136A2:79BB/:27.2 388=02< 0.344 B=>7.2> 52 02:72:82< 79 =:<2>?9 >/?9>9=0 /A1>/09:A2:7 B9> 3 12>/9< 9B 9:2 623> B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: )(" 9B '=>7.2> 7.2 388=02< /0 02:72:82< 79 =:<2>?9 >/?9>9=0 /A1>/09:A2:7 B9> 3 12>/9< 9B B/;2 623>0 3:< 79 136 3 B/:2 9B 0"((((D /: <2B3=47 9B 136A2:79BB/:2.20.344B=>7.2>=:<2>?90/A142/A1>/09:A2:7 - 3 - B9> 3 12>/9< 9B 9:2 623> B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: )(* 9B .2 388=02< 0.344 =:<2>?9 0/A142 /A1>/09:A2:7 B9> 3 12>/9< 9B 0/E A9:7.0 3:< 79 136 3 B/:2 9B 0"(((D /: <2B3=47 9B 136A2:7 9B B/:2 .2 0.344 =:<2>?9 0/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B9:2A9:7.B9>7.29BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: ( 9B .2 388=02< 0.344 =:<2>?90/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B0/EA9:7.03:<79 1363B/:29B0"(((D/:<2B3=479B136A2:79BB/:2.20.344 =:<2>?90/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B9:2A9:7.B9>7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: (! 9B .2 02:72:820 13002<3?3/:077.2388=02<0.344>=:89:8=>>2:746 ".235>/<?2<B38709B7.283023>230B9449C0 .2 388=02< :3A246 5<=4 343035 9>=73?/ /0 7.2 .=053:<9B<282302</63:3 C/:?79B3A/46</01=72527C22: /63:3 3:< 388=02<F /63:3 42B7 .2> .=053:< 3:< 073>72< >20/</:? C/7. .2> 13>2:70 3:< C9>G/:? 30 3 899G 37 3<3>03 0/7=372<37/./>03:?93<:23>3/4C36737/9:9B:</9C: .2 89A143/:3:7 A7 &=00/:5/ 3G3:<3> " C30 3 89DC9>G2> 9B <282302< /63:3 37 3<3>03 ?3/:07 7./0 538G<>917.2388=02<B>2H=2:746;/0/72<7.203/< 3<3>033:< .30 >9C0 C/7. .2> 3442?/:? 7.37 0.2 .3< 3: /44/8/7 >2437/9:0./1 - 4 - C/7. 7.2 9=43:30 $238.2>0 9B 7.2 3<3>03% 3:< 7.2>256 0=012872< .2> 8.307/76 3:< 8.3>3872> &2 C9=4< 98830/9:3446 1.60/834463003=47.2>.20252/:?7.2B38709:"(,"(37 359=7 (( 1A 7.2 388=02< 31123>2< /: 7.2 G/78.2: 9B 7.2 03/< 3<3>03 C/7. 3: E2 3:< 1/8G2< =1 3 >9C C/7. /63:3 3442?/:? 7.37 0.2 .3< 3: /44/8/7 >2437/9:0./1 C/7. 7.2 9=43:30 &2 ;2>53446 35=02< 3:< 3003=472< .2> C/7. E2 9: .2> .23< C/7.3:/:72:779A=><2>.2>.289A143/:3:7D"C.9C30 1>202:7 7.2>2 A3<2 2BB9>70 79 03;2 /63:3 &9C2;2> 7.2 388=02<34093003=472<"C/7.7.203A23E283=0/:?/:@=>/20 79.2>42B7.3:<B/:?2>042B7G:223:<3772A172<79A=><2>.2> .2 C/7:20020 :3A246 '3/63I =443 9.3AA3< 3B/ 3663< 3:@22>&303:3663<3<=<</: 9=433:<043A3724;/0/72< 7.2019779138/B6 77.37/:073:77.2388=02<C2:73C3656 7.>237/:? 7.2A .2 89A143/:3:7 3:< /63:3 C2>2 5>9=?.7 79 13:<3:3&901/734:</=502H=2:746/63:3C303<A/772<79 /@3631=>3 /07>/87 &901/734 C.2>2 0.2 0=88=A52< 79 7.2 /:@=>/209:"(,"(37*)(1A ) =502H=2:746 * 7.2 7.2: ;/0/72< 7.2 &901/7343:<>289><2<7.207372A2:789A143/:749<?2<56" 9:"(,"(37359=71A3012>E)3:<>2?/072>2< - 5 - 3: ' /: 8>/A2 9" "( <372< "(,"( 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:0 )"! )(* ((!9B3:<89AA2:82<7.2/:;207/?37/9: 23:C./42 7.2<237.9B7.2;/87/A/63:3C305>9=?.779./0G:9C42<?2 00=8..202:7>2H=/0/7/9:797.2 3?/07>37279/:;9G2287/9: )("9B/:>/A29" "(889></:?46287/9:)("9B C30 /:;9G2< .2>23B72> 7.2 8302 C30 /:;207/?372< 56 : !"( 7.2 388=02< ;94=:73>/46 0=>>2:<2>2< 52B9>27.29=>73:< 799G./A79194/828=079<6B9>7C9 <360J 3:< >289><2< ./0 ;94=:73>6 07372A2:7 7 7.2 52.207 9B 7.2;94=:73>607372A2:79B7.2388=02<7.2C2319:0=02<B9> 89AA/77/:?7.28>/A2/2 C30>289;2>2<=502H=2:746 9: 9573/:/:? 7.2 :282003>6 <98=A2:70 B>9A 7.2 89:82>:2< 3=7.9>/7/20 3:< >289></:? 7.2 07372A2:7 9B 7.2 C/7:20020 , B/42< 7.2 8.3>?2 0.227 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02< B9> 7.2 9BB2:820)(")(*(3:<(!52B9>27.29AA/77349=>7 B72> 89AA/7734 9B 7.2 8302 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>77.2423>:2<200/9:0=<?2B>3A2<7.28.3>?203?3/:07 7.2388=02<B9>7.23B9>2A2:7/9:2<9BB2:8203:<7.203A2C30 >23< 9;2> ;2>537/A 79 ./A &9C2;2> 7.2 388=02< <2:/2< 7.2 8.3>?2042;2442<3?3/:07./A3:<843/A2<79527>/2< - 6 - : 9><2> 79 1>9;2 7.2 8.3>?20 42;2442< 3?3/:07 7.2 388=02<7.21>9028=7/9:8944287/;2462E3A/:2<,C/7:2002030 79,A3>G2<"*<98=A2:7030E79E"*3:< /<2:7/B/2<)A372>/3495@287030 79 ) ! : 89A1427/9: 9B 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 2;/<2:82 7.2 423>:2<200/9:0=<?2>23<9;2>7.2/:8>/A/:37/:?2;/<2:829B A372>/34C/7:20020797.2388=02<3007/1=4372</:287/9:)) 9B>&9C2;2>7.2388=02<<2:/2<7.203A2.2<2B2:82 9B 7.2 388=02< /0 9B 35094=72 <2:/34 3:< 7.37 9B B3402 /A14/837/9: * '9449C/:?7.2300200A2:79B9>343:<<98=A2:73>6 2;/<2:82 14382< 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0=<?289:;/872<7.23112443:7388=02<B9>7.28.3>?20 42;242< 3?3/:07 ./A 3:< 02:72:82< ./A 30 07372< 0=1>3 .2 03/<@=<?A2:79B89:;/87/9:3:<9><2>9B02:72:82/08.3442:?2< /:7./0311234 2 .3;2 .23>< 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 >/ 3?34/ B9> 3112443:7 3:< 7.2 423>:2< <</7/9:34 7372 =54/8 >9028=79>>//<<34/:?37/4B9>7.2>2019:<2:7D73723409 C2.3;212>=02<7.2>289><0A3<23;3/4354252B9>2=0 - 7 - , .2 1>/A3>6 89:72:7/9: 9B 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 3112443:7 /0 7.37 7.2 @=<?A2:7 9B 89:;/87/9: 3:< 9><2> 9B 02:72:8213002<567.2200/9:09=>70=BB2>0B>9A12>;2>0/76 3:< /442?34/76 .2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 .30 ?>90046 2>>2< C./42 89:;/87/:? 7.2 3112443:7 C/7.9=7 <=46 311>28/37/:? 7.2 2;/<2:82 3:< <98=A2:70 14382< 52B9>2 ./A .2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 89:;/872< 7.2 3112443:7 094246 >246/:? 9: 7.2 2;/<2:829B0"3:<!C.9843/A2<7952262C/7:2002079 7.2 /:8/<2:7 &9C2;2> 7.2>2 3>2 A372>/34 89:7>3</87/9:0 3:< 9A/00/9:0 /: 7.2/> 2;/<2:82 3:< 7.2 03A2 83::97 52 >24/2< 79 1>9;27.28.3>?2042;2442<3?3/:077.2388=02<&289:72:<2< 7.37 9: 12>=034 9B 2;/<2:82 9B 0 3:< ! /7 /0 0128/B/83446 24/8/72< /: 7.2 8>900 2E3A/:37/9: 7.37 =19: .23>/:? 7.2 .=2 3:<8>67.27238./:?073BB9B 3<3>03?37.2>2<377.20197F7.2 3112443:7 B42< 9: 022/:? 7.2 8>9C< &2:82 7.2 1>202:82 9B 03:<!/:7.201978307002>/9=0<9=57&2340989:72:<2< 7.377.2>289;2>69BC2319:=02<B9>7.289AA/00/9:9B8>/A2 /0:971>9;2<3012>7.2027742<1>/:8/1429B43C567.2&9:J542 12E 9=>7 .2C2319: C30 >289;2>2< B>9A 3: 912: 14382388200/54279?2:2>341=54/8&2B=>7.2>89:72:<2<7.37 3452/77.23442?2</:8/<2:7799G143829:1=54/8>93<C./8.C30 - 8 - 7./8G46 191=4372< 3:< 7.2 03A2 C30 C/7:2002< 56 A3:6 &9C2;2> 7.2 1>9028=7/9: </< :97 ;2:7=>2 79 2E3A/:2 3:6 9B 7.90212>09:0 ( 472>:37/;246.289:72:<2<7.377.22:7/>283029B 7.21>9028=7/9:2;2:=19:89A1>2.2:0/;23:3460/09B2;/<2:82 <920 :97 A3G2 9=7 3 8302 B9> 3: 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: )(" 9B 3:< 37 7.2 A907 7.2 9BB2:82 C9=4< B344 C/7./:7.21=>;/2C9B9BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:)(3>7 9> 9B 0 7.2 2:7/>2 /:8/<2:7 988=>>2< 9=7 9B 7.2 54=2 C/7.9=7 1>2A2</737/;2 A97/;2 /:72:7/9: 3:< G:9C42<?2 7.2 2002:7/3409B287/9:)((9B3>23502:7/:7.2/:073:78302 /7. 7.202 0=5A/00/9:0 .2 1>360 79 3449C 7.2 311234 56 A9</B6/:?7.289:;/87/9:3:<02:72:82/A1902<567.2423>:2< 200/9:0=<?2 2B=7/:?7.2359;20=5A/00/9:07.2423>:2<B9> 7.2>2019:<2:7D7372;2.2A2:74689:72:<2<7.377.2@=<?A2:7 8.3442:?2<=:<2>7./0311234:2/7.2>0=BB2>0B>9A12>;2>0/76:9> /442?34/76 0/:82 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 89:;/872< 7.2 388=02< >246/:? 9: 1>219:<2>3:82 9B 2;/<2:82 3;3/43542 9: >289>< 889></:? 79 7.2 423>:2< "D89A143/:3:7 3:< - 9 - /:@=>2< 262C/7:200 8372?9>/83446 <21902< 9: 7.2 3003=47 12>127>372< 56 7.2 388=02< 597. 9: .2> 3:< 7.2 <282302< 40903:<!7.27238.2>037 3<3>037.2262C/7:20020 79 7.2 /:8/<2:7 >2/72>372< 7.37 7.2 388=02< 3003=472< 7.2 <282302<3:<"C/7. 3E2'=>7.2>7.29>347207/A9:6 9B0"3:<!89>>959>3720C/7.7.2A2</8342;/<2:82/2 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B , C.9 7>2372< " 3:< 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B ! 9879> C.9 89:<=872< 7.2 3=79106 9: 7.2 89>102 .2 423>:2<34090=5A/772<7.377./08302<920:97B344C/7./: 7.23A5/79BE8217/9:007/1=4372</:287/9:)((9B0/:82 7.2388=02<>212372<463003=472<7.2<282302<3:<"C/7. 3: /:72:7/9: 79 A=><2> 597. " 3:< 7.2 <282302< 889></:?46.21>36079</0A/007.2311234 " &3;/:? .23>< 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 13>7/20 3:< 3409 =19: 89A1>2.2:0/;2 12>=034 9B 7.2 2;/<2:82 9: >289><7.219/:707.370=>B382B9>9=>89:0/<2>37/9:3>2 - 10 - ) 0 89AA9: :3>>37/9: 3:< 89:0/<2>37/9: 3>2 /:;94;2</:7.23112349:.3:<C273G27.24/52>76793<<>200 597. 7.2 359;2 >3/02< 19/:70 B9> 89:0/<2>37/9: /: 7.2 B9>?9/:? 13>3?>31.0 : 9><2> 79 1>9;2 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2 <282302</:7./083027.21>9028=7/9:.301>2<9A/:3:746>24/2< 9: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 7.2 9879>D! C.9 89:<=872< 7.2 3=791069:7.289>1029B7.2<282302<3:</00=2<1907DA9>72A >219>73012>E"(3:<7.291/:/9:9:=029BC2319:3012> E" : 12>=034 9B E"( ! 7.2 9879> 91/:2< 7.37 K7.2<237.C30<=279- -303>20=479B.23</:@=>6K./0 91/:/9:9B7.29879>B=>7.2>89>>959>3720C/7.7.289:72:709B /:H=20713:8.3:3A3.24<9:7.289>1029B7.2<282302<567.2 :;207/?37/:? BB/82>D* 30 12> E /0 7.2 C/7:200 B9>7.203A2C.9/<2:7/B/2<7.289>1023:<7.2/:@=>/209:7.2 89>102 9B 7.2 <282302< '=>7.2> 0" ! 3:< * /2 7.2 262C/7:20020 79 7.2 /:8/<2:7 <21902< 7.37 7.2 3003=47 C30 12>127>372<567.2388=02<=0/:? 3:<7.2/:@=>/209:7.2 89>102C2>2/<2:7/B/2<.29879>91/:2<7.373447.2/:@=>/20 B9=:<9:7.289>1029B7.2<282302<3>23:7/DA9>72A/::37=>2 :0=8.8/>8=A073:820C23>29B7.289:0/<2>2<;/2C7.377.2 - 11 - 1>9028=7/9: .30 1>9;2< 7.2 .9A/8/<34 <237. 9B 7.2 <282302< 5269:<344>2309:3542<9=57 :7.2/:073:783023452/77.21>9028=7/9:2E3A/:2< C/7:20020791>9;27.28.3>?2042;2442<3?3/:077.2388=02< /7 /0 >2<=:<3:7 79 <24;2 /:79 7.2 :/776 ?>/776 9B /:</;/<=34 2;/<2:82 9B 344 C/7:20020 9 5>/:? .9A2 7.2 ?=/47 9B 7.2 388=02< 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 1>/A3>/46 >24/2< 9: 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B " 3:< ! : 12>=034 9B 7.2/> 2;/<2:82 "D7.2 89A143/:3:73:</:@=>2<C.93409.3112:079527.289DC9>G2> 9B 7.2 <282302< 37 7.2 3<3>03 <21902< 7.37 7.2 <282302< /63:3C30C9>G/:?303899G377.2 3<3>03349:?C/7..2> .2388=02<.=053:<9B7.2<282302<9:"(,"(37359=7 ( (( 1A C.2: .2>024B 3:< <282302< 1>213>/:? B99< /: 7.2 G/78.2: .2 31123>2< 52B9>2 7.2A C/7. 3: 3E2 3:< 3003=472< 7.2 .23< 9B /63:3 H=207/9:/:? .2> C.6 0.2 <202>72< ./AL .2: " 89:B>9:72< ./A .2 3003=472< .2> 42B7D.3:< B/:?2> 3:<42B742?B/:?2>03>20=477.2<282302<0=073/:2<02;2>2 /:@=>/20 3:< " 3409 0=073/:2< /:@=>/20F 597. C2>2 3<A/772< 79 7.2 .901/734 ./0 89:0/072:7 ;2>0/9: 9B " 597. /: 7.2 89A143/:7 3:< /: .2> 2;/<2:82 52B9>2 7.2 9=>7 89>>959>3720 C/7.7.2A2</8342;/<2:82/27.22;/<2:829B,7.29879> - 12 - C.9 2E3A/:2< " 3:< /00=2< C9=:< 82>7/B/8372 30 12> E"'=>7.2>7.21907A9>72A>219>7</0849020/:@=>69:7.2 .23< 9B 7.2 <282302< 49<?2< 7.2 89A143/:7 C./42 3<A/772</:7.2&901/73452B9>2*:0=8.8/>8=A073:820 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B " /0 =:542A/0.2< 524/2;3542 3:< >24/3542 0 12> 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 0 3:< ! 7.2 238.2>0 37 7.2 3<3>03 .3;2 8372?9>/83446 <21902< 7.37 9: 7.2 <372 9B /:8/<2:77.2388=02<;/0/72< 3<3>033:<1/8G2<=13>9CC/7. 7.2 <282302< 3:< 3003=472< 9: .2> .23< &2 3409 3003=472< " C/7. 7.2 03A2 3E2 452/7 7.202 C/7:20020 C2>2 8>900D 2E3A/:2< 56 7.2 <2B2:82 37 42:?7. :97./:? C9>7.C./42 C30 24/8/72<79</083><7.2/>7207/A9:6'=>7.2>3447.202C/7:20020 /<2:7/B/2< 7.2C2319:=02</:7.28>/A2.21>9028=7/9: 3409 1>9;2< 7.2 >289;2>6 9B 3E2 =:<2> E ) /0 7.2C/7:200B9>7.203A23:<.2.300=119>72<7.283029B7.2 1>9028=7/9:.2:;207/?37/:? BB/82>0/20* 3:<, <21902< 7.2 <>3C/:? 9B 7.2 >289;2>6 A3.3I3> 3:< 7.2 0197 A3.3I3>3012>E3:<E*.29879>C.989:<=872< 7.23=791069:7.289>1029B7.2<282302<.303409?/;2:7.2 91/:/9: 9: =02 9B C2319: 30 12> E '=>7.2> 7.2 1>9028=7/9:14382<7.2'>219>7E"*C.2>27.28/2:7/B/8 - 13 - BB/82> 91/:2< 7.37 7.2 1>202:82 9B 5499< 073/:0 B9=:< 9: 3E2D A378.20 C/7. .=A3: 5499< 9B ?>9=1 M J : 0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 7.2 1>9028=7/9: 14382< 0=BB/8/2:7 A372>/34 79 1>9;27.377.2388=02</07.212>127>379>9B7.28>/A2.2>2/0 :9 >2309: 79 73G2 2E8217/9: B>9A 7.2 ;/2C 9B 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 9: 311>28/37/9: 9B 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B A372>/34 C/7:20020 ! .2 3472>:37/;2 89:72:7/9: >3/02< 56 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 3112443:7 /0 7.37 7.2 387 89AA/772< 56 7.2 388=02< 0H=3>246 B3440 C/7./: 7.2 3A5/7 9B 287/9: )(( E8217/9:9BC./8./01=:/0.3542=:<2>0287/9:)(3>7 9B :83>2B=412>=0349B7.22;/<2:829B0"3:<! 7.2 A97/;2 52./:< 12>127>37/:? 7.2 387 30 89:72:<2< 56 7.2 388=02< /: ./0 <2B2:82 /0 7.37 7.2 388=02< 0=012872< 7.2 <282302< 9B .3;/:? 3: /44/8/7 >2437/9:0./1 C/7. 9:2 9B 7.2 9=43:30377.2 3<3>033:<9:52/:?2:>3?2<.2;/0/72<7.2 3<3>03 79 2:H=/>2 .2> 0=<<2: >9C 2>=172< 423</:? 79 7.2 388=02<3003=47/:?7.2<282302<3:<B=>7.2>.234093003=472< " - 14 - * .2 2;/<2:82 9B " 207354/0.20 7.37 7.2 3112443:7 :2/7.2> 799G =:<=2 3<;3:73?2 :9> 3872< /: 3 8>=24=:=0=34A3::2>A9>29;2>7.22;/<2:829B03:<! >2;23407.377.2388=02<2:H=/>2<7.2<282302<B9>7.2>2309: 0.2 <202>72< ./A 3:< C9>G/:? 37 3<3>03 : 0=8. 8/>8=A073:820 7.2 <237. 9B 7.2 <282302< C30 83=02< 9: 0=<<2:1>9;9837/9:C/7.9=71>2A2</737/;2A97/;2.2&9:-542 9=>7 .24< /: 7.2 8302 9B >219>72</:.24<7.37/:30=<<2: B/?.7 /: 3502:82 9B 1>2A2</737/;2 A97/;2 C.2: 3: 387 /0 89AA/772< /: 3 .237 9B 1300/9: 0.9=4< 7.2 9BB2:<2> :97 73G2 =:<=2 3<;3:73?2 9> 387 /: 3 8>=24=:=0=34 A3::2> 7.2 89:;/87/9: 83: 52 89:;2>72< B>9A 287/9: )(" 79 287/9: )( 3>79>3>79B:13>3?>31. 9B7.2359;2@=<?A2:7 7.2&9:J54212E9=>7.24<30=:<2> ! ! ! "# $ %&& '() * + ,-. ) / ' 01! ! ! 2 ) 1 "# $ ' - 15 - ) 3 0 ! ! ! ! 1 1 "# $ ! ! ! ! 3 # 1 "# $ %&& '() ! 3 ! 4 ! "# $ %&& '() 5 %&6 '() 1 1 4 %&6 '() %&$ ( '' '() ! & 7 8 '=>7.2> 7.2 &9:J542 12E 9=>7 /: 7.2 8302 9B ! " # >219>72</:$%.24<7.37A2>2465283=027.>22 /:@=>/20 C2>2 /:B4/872< 9: 7.2 <282302< 56 7.2 388=02< /0 /:0=BB/8/2:7 79 207354/0. 7.37 7.2 388=02< 3872< /: 3 8>=24 A3::2>.2>29:30=<<2:H=3>>24312>09:/:7.2.2379B A9A2:7 1/8G0 =1 3 .3:<6 C2319: 7.2>256 83=0/:? /:@=>/20 9:29BC./8.1>9;20B3734.2C9=4<522:7/742<797.252:2B/730 - 16 - 07/1=4372</:E8217/9:=:<2>287/9:)((9B.2:=A52> 9B C9=:<0 /:B4/872< <=>/:? 7.2 3472>837/9: /0 :97 3 <28/0/;2 B3879> , : 7.2 8302 9: .3:< 7.2 2;/<2:82 9B 7.2 A372>/34 C/7:200</08490207.379:7.2<3729B/:8/<2:73449B30=<<2: 7.2388=02<31123>2</:7.2G/78.2:9B 3<3>033:<1/8G2<=1 7.2 3E2 3:< 3003=472< 7.2 <282302< 3:< " : 12>=034 9B /0 3 .3:<6 C2319: 2;2>7.24200 7.2 <282302< 0=88=A52<797.2/:@=>/209:7.2:2E7<36/29:"(,"( /:7.22;2:/:?.9=>0&2:8289:0/<2>/:?7.29;2>3442;/<2:82 B3870 3:< 8/>8=A073:820 9B 7.2 8302 7.2 /:8/<2:7 C30 83=02< C/7.9=71>2A2</737/;2A97/;2/2/:30=<<2:08=BB42527C22: 7.23112443:73:<7.2<282302</:7.2.2379B1300/9:20/<20 7.2 3112443:7 :2/7.2> 799G =:<=2 3<;3:73?2 :9> 3872< /: 3 8>=24=:=0=34 A3::2> : 7.37 ;/2C 7.2 311234 13>7/3446 0=8822<0.2388=02</089:;/872<B9>7.29BB2:821=:/0.3542 =:<2>E8217/9:79287/9:)((9B3:<02:72:82<B9>7.2 9BB2:821=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:)(3>79B "( 2?3></:?7.2H=207/9:9B02:72:82B9>7.29BB2:82 1=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:)(3>79B/089:82>:2</7 /0 - 17 - 0=5A/772< 56 7.2 423>:2< 89=:024 B9> 7.2 3112443:7 7.37 7.2 388=02</08=>>2:746=:<2>/:83>82>37/9:B9>,623>0"A9:7.0 &2:82/:9=>89:0/<2>2<;/2C7.203/<02:72:82C9=4<0=BB/82 B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9: )( 3>7 9B 3<</7/9:3446 56 /A190/:? >2309:3542 B/:2 &9C2;2> 7.2 89:;/87/9: /A1902< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542=:<2>0287/9:0)(*(3:<(!9B<202>;2079 52 G217 /:7387 889></:?46 B9> 7.2 >2309:0 </08=002< 0=1>3 7.289:;/87/9:3?3/:077.23112443:7B9>7.29BB2:821=:/0.3542 =:<2>287/9:)("9B/04/35427952A9</B/2<5689:B/>A/:? 7.289:;/87/9:B9>7.2>2079B7.29BB2:820 " : ;/2C 9B 7.2 B9>?9/:? >2309:0 C2 3:0C2> 19/:7 9 /: 7.2 :2?37/;2 3:< 19/:7 9" /: 13>746 3BB/>A37/;2 3:< 1>9822<7913007.2B9449C/:? / .2>/A/:3411234/0& ' // .2 @=<?A2:7 9B 89:;/87/9: 3:< 9><2> 9B 02:72:82 <372< (,("(") 13002< /: 9,("(* 56 7.2 <<4 /07>/87 3:< 200/9:0 =<?2 /@3631=>3 /0 A9</B/2< 88=02< /0 89:;/872< B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542=:<2>E8217/9:79287/9:)(( - 18 - 9B /:0723< 9B 287/9: )(" 9B 889></:?46 .2 /0 02:72:82< B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:)(3>79B /// .2 388=02< /0 02:72:82< B9> 3 12>/9< C./8. .2 .30 34>23<6 =:<2>?9:2 /2 , 623>0 " A9:7.0 3:< .2 0.344 136 3 B/:2 9B 0)(((((D $=1220 .>22 3G.0 9:46% 52B9>2 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 B9> 7.2 9BB2:82 1=:/0.3542=:<2>287/9:)(3>79B3:< /:<2B3=479B136A2:79BB/:2.20.344=:<2>?9 0/A142/A1>/09:A2:7B9>312>/9<9B7C9623>0 /; B 7.2 B/:2 3A9=:7 /0 <2190/72< 56 7.2 388=02< 7.2 423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 /0 </>2872< 79 </05=>02 7.2 03A2 79 7.2 8./4<>2: 9B 7.2 <282302< 2H=3446 30 89A12:037/9: 07/1=4372< =:<2> 287/9: )*$% 9B > 9: <=2/<2:7/B/837/9: ; .2 02:72:82 /A1902< 56 7.2 200/9:0 9=>7 B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2> 287/9:0 )(*((!9B3?3/:07388=02<3>2G217 /:7387 ;/ 447.202:72:8200.344>=:89:8=>>2:746 ;// .2388=02<0.344 52>242302<9:136A2:79B B/:2 3A9=:7 30 359;2 9> =:<2>?9 7.2 <2B3=47 02:72:82 - 19 - ;/// .2 ;/87/A 89A12:037/9: ?>3:72< 56 7.2 423>:2<200/9:0=<?2=:<2>287/9:)*$% 9B>/0G217/:7387 /E =79B7.2B/:23A9=:7/A1902<567.2423>:2< 200/9:0 =<?2 B9> 7.2 9BB2:820 1=:/0.3542 =:<2>287/9:0)(*(3:<(!F0"((((D 0.3445213/<79" E 2?/07>6 /0 </>2872< 79 02:< 538G 7.2 7>/34 9=>7>289><0349:?C/7.89169B7./0@=<?A2:7 797.27>/349=>7B9>7.C/7. ,* % $) ,* % ) & /07949"