Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9399 (KAR)
THE RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE v. SHAIKH AHMED ALI AND ANR
MFA/200203/2018 · 2025-02-06
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9399 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9399 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#
$
$ %%&
' ( )
!"
#$%$&
' ( (
#!'#'&)
*+
#$%$&
, '#
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.11 11:13:26 - 0800
- 2 -
)! ( '%&-'&)
").'&"
(
(
/(
(
$ /(
(
0123 433510607 89 :;0 <=73>02: 427 4?457 74:07 '%&-'&) @4AA07 12 B").'&- 89 :;0 771:1B24C 021B5 161C (=730 427 4C48=5431 50A@B2702: B'#2A=542D0 B>@429 1A 80EB50 :;1A B=5: 124@@04C ' ;0 @0:1:1B205 4@@5B4D;07 :;0 518=24C DB2:027123:;4:B2&"&''&"4:48B=:)!&@>?;1C0 ;0 ?4A @5BD007123 B2 4 >B:B5D9DC0 8045123 B#!' #$"$ :;0 751605 BE :;0 4=:B 51DFA;4? 8045123 B#!'#'&) D4>0 E5B> B@@BA1:0 A170 12 4 54A; 427 203C1302:>42205427DBCC1707?1:;:;0>B:B5D9DC07=0:B
- 3 -
?;1D;:;0@0:1:1B205E0CC7B?2427A=A:4120712<=510A427 ;0 ?4A A;1E:07 :B B6052>02: BA@1:4C =C84534 ?;050 ;0:BBF:504:>02:EB548B=::;500749A:?4ADB2:02707 :;4: ;0 ;4A A=EE0507 4854A1B2A 427 B:;05 12<=510A 12 :;0 4DD1702:
! ;0 @0:1:1B2 ?4A 50A1A:07 89 50A@B2702: B'# 2A=542D0 B>@429 DB2:027123 :;4: :;0 DB>@02A4:1B2 DC41>071A;13;C90GB581:42:1>4312459427=2:0248C0427 1: ;4A 702107 :;0 430 12DB>0 427 BDD=@4:1B2 BE :;0 @0:1:1B205 1: ;4A DB2:02707 :;4: :;0 751605 BE :;04=:B51DFA;4??4A2B:;46123464C177516123C1D02D04:
:;0 :1>0 BE 4DD1702: 427 :;4: :;050 1A DB2:518=:B59 203C1302D0B2:;0@45:BE:;0@0:1:1B205A12D0:;04DD1702: BDD=55074::;0>177C0BE:;05B47
" 2 :;0 84A1A BE :;0 5164C DB2:02:1B2A :;0 518=24C E54>07 4@@5B@514:0 1AA=0A 427 @0:1:1B205 ?4A 0G4>1207 4A 427 GA :B & ?050 >45F07 2 BEE1D14CBE50A@B2702: B'?4A0G4>1207427GA :B!?050>45F07
- 4 -
$ E:05 ;045123 8B:; :;0 A170A :;0 518=24C 4CCB?07:;0@0:1:1B2 12 @45: 427 4?45707 4 DB>@02A4:1B2 BE A'$&&&# :B :;0 @0:1:1B205 89 E4A:02123 :;0 C1481C1:9 B250A@B2702: B'#2A=542D0 B>@429 . 0123 433510607 89 :;0 A417 B5705 :;0 2A=542D0 B>@429 1A 80EB50 :;1A B=5: 4AA41C123 :;0 C1481C1:9E4A:0207=@B21: ) 0457 :;0 C045207 DB=2A0C 4@@045123 EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42:#2A=542D0 B>@429 427 :;0 C045207 DB=2A0C 4@@045123EB550A@B2702: B#@0:1:1B205 % 045207 DB=2A0C 4@@045123 EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42:# 2A=542D0 B>@429 DB2:027A :;4: :;0 518=24C E41C07 :B 4@@50D14:0:;0E4D::;4::;050?4ADB2:518=:B59203C1302D0 B2 :;0 @45: BE :;0 @0:1:1B205 ;0 A0DB27 @5B23 BE :;0 453=>02:1A:;4::;07516123C1D02D0?4A2B:EB5:542A@B5:
60;1DC0A 427 :;050EB50 :;0 518=24C DB=C7 2B: ;460 E4A:0207:;0C1481C1:9=@B2:;02A=542D0 B>@429
- 5 -
- 05 DB2:54 C045207 DB=2A0C 4@@045123 EB5 50A@B2702: B@0:1:1B205 ?B=C7 A=8>1: :;4: :;0 4@@0CC42:#2A=542D0
B>@429 ;4A 2B: 508=::07 :;0 203C1302D0 4::518=:07 :B :;0 751605 BE :;0 4=:B 51DFA;4?
;0 D;4530 A;00: 427 :;0504E:05 @C047123 3=1C:9 89 :;0 751605BE:;04=:B51DFA;4??B=C73B43412A::;0453=>02:
D4264AA07 89 :;0 C045207 DB=2A0C EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42: : 1A @B12:07B=::;4:12610?BE:;0<=73>02:BE:;0@0G B=5:
12 :;0 D4A0 BE
:;0 2A=542D0 B>@429 D422B: 0AD4@0 E5B> :;0 C1481C1:9 :B @49 :;0 DB>@02A4:1B2 B2:;035B=27:;4::;0751605BE:;04=:B51DFA;4??4A2B: ;46123464C177516123C1D02D0 & A513;:C9@B12:07B=:89:;0C045207DB=2A0CEB5 50A@B2702: B :;0 <=73>02: BE :;0 @0G B=5: 12 :;0 D4A0BE
;4AC4177B?2:;4::;0 A@0D14C :9@0 BE :;0 7516123 C1D02D0 12 50A@0D: BE :;0 :542A@B5:60;1DC01A2B:50H=15071E:;0=2C4702?013;:BE
1 '&) !..%
- 6 -
:;0 60;1DC0 1A 80CB? )$&& 3A 861B=AC9 :;0 60;1DC0 126BC6071A:;04=:B#51DFA;4?427:;050EB50:;0<=73>02:
BE :;0 @0G B=5: AH=450C9 4@@C10A :B :;0 DB2:02:1B2A 541A0712:;1A4@@04C;02A=542D0 B>@429D422B:A00F 48ABC60>02: BE 1:A C1481C1:9 B2 :;0 35B=27 :;4: :;0 751605 ?4A2B:;461234C1D02A0:B751604:542A@B5:60;1DC0:1A @05:1202::B2B:0:;4:G!:;07516123C1D02D0A;B?:;4:
:;0751605;4764C17C1D02D0:B751604210 =:B 51DFA;4? ;0 A0DB27 DB2:02:1B2 1A 503457123 :;0 DB2:518=:B59 203C1302D0 : 1A 061702: E5B> :;0 518=24C 50DB57A :;4: :;0 @BC1D0 4E:05 1260A:134:1B2 ;460 DB>0 :B :;0DB2DC=A1B2:;4::;050?4A203C1302D0B2:;0@45:BE:;0 751605 BE :;0 4=:B#51DFA;4? 2 :;0 D5BAA#0G4>124:1B2 BE :;0 B5 89 :;0 1270@02702: 061702D0 BE :;0 :;050 1A 2B:;123 B2 50DB57 ?;1D; ?B=C7 A;B? :;4: :;050 ?4A 429 DB2:518=:B59 203C1302D0 B2 :;0 @45: BE :;0 @0:1:1B205
- 7 -
' : 1A @05:1202: :B 2B:0 :;4: 50A@B2702: B' # 2A=542D0 B>@429 12 B5705 :B 508=: :;0 D;4530#A;00:
DB=C7 ;460 4: C04A: 50C107 =@B2 :;0 A@B: AF0:D; B A=D; A@B:AF0:D;?4A4CAB@5B7=D0789:;02A=542D0 B>@429 :B A;B? :;4: :;0 4DD1702: BDD=5507 4: :;0 D02:50 BE :;0 5B47 ;050EB50 :;0 DB2:02:1B2 BE :;0 C045207 DB=2A0C 4@@045123 EB5 :;0 4@@0CC42: :;4: :;050 ?4A DB2:518=:B59 203C1302D0 B2 :;0 @45: BE :;0 @0:1:1B205 D422B: 80 4DD0@:0702D0:;04@@04CE41CAB28B:;:;0A0DB=2:A ! DDB57123C9:;0EBCCB?123
1 ;04@@04C1A 11 ;0 4>B=2: 12 70@BA1: 1A B570507 :B 80 :542A>1::07:B:;0518=24C
7# &
$ ( $
(( 1A: B C B ".