Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9396 (KAR)
ALLAUDDIN S/O SYED SAB CHINCHOLI v. GUNDAYYA AND ANR
MFA/200681/2019 · 2025-01-09
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9396 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9396 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#!! $
! "#
"
$! %
! %
$ !&& '
! ! ! "( " ) ! " $ *
$ !&&#
! ! +
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$ !&& '
$ ,
-#
! ,
(! %
&-
) (! $ ! $ ! % ! )
! (! %
"
" . ( (
! ".
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
56/ 8:C?1B ;0@@7 8: 3/5D//: 56/ 78=<@/ 0:2 56/ A18/E4?74:/ 3?556/1/3/8:A:40=<?50584:85D074<8:/254 3/78=<@/4D/E/1 94:782/18:A56/7/07</957 85D4?@23/ C?750:2<14</1540D01207?=4; 7& 8:0228584:54 D6056073//:0D012/23B56/ 183?:0@ : E8/D 4; 56/ ;095 5605 1/7<4:2/:5 4 602 0<</01/23/;41/56/ 183?:0@0:260294:5/75/256/=055/1 56/287<?5/3/5D//:1/7<4:2/:5470:20754D6/56/1 - 7 - 56/218E/14;56/E/689@/6020E0@82218E8:A@89/:7/41:45870 =055/1 54 3/ 2/982/2 0=4:A75 56/=7/@E/7 D6896 87 8: 56/ 1/0@= 4; 5/1=7 0:2 94:28584:7 ?5 D6/: 1/7<4:2/:5 4 607 0<</01/2 3/;41/ 56/ 183?:0@ 0:2 ;8@/2 687 D1855/: 7505/=/:5 85 D4?@2 3/ <14</1 54 281/95 1/7<4:2/:5 4 :7?10:9/ 4=<0:B 54 <0B 56/ 94=</:70584: 0:2 56/: 1/94E/156/70=/;14=56/4D:/14;56/E/689@//:9/56/ ;4@@4D8:A" 8 6/0<</0@870@@4D/28:<015 88 6/0<</@@0:587/:585@/2;410:0228584:0@7?=4; 7& 8: 0228584: 54 D605 607 3//: 0D012/23B56/ 183?:0@ D8568:5/1/7505J</1 0::?=;14=56/205/4;</58584:58@@1/0@8K0584: 888 6/ :2 1/7<4:2/:5 :7?10:9/ 4=<0:B 87 281/95/2 54 <0B 56/ 94=</:70584: 0=4?:5 D8568: D//>7;14=56/205/4;1/9/8<54;094<B4;5687 412/1 D856 @83/15B 54 1/94E/1 56/ 70=/ ;14= 56/ 751/7<4:2/:54D:/14;56/E/689@/ - 8 - 8E :581/0=4?:5412/1/26/1/8:87543/1/@/07/254 56/</58584:/1 2 %! & ! 8754"@4"#
"$