Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9371 (KAR)
DR. SHIVANI SANJEEV TALPALIKAR v. THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL AND ORS
WP/200777/2022 · 2025-01-06
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9371 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9371 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!! % &
! "
#
$
%
&
$%
' &
(
"""
&
&
&' (& $
' & ' %
'
"""
)
& '
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
''
*& ' (
"""
'
! ( (
""++
& ,'
'
'
'
'
'
$ % (
""
+
'
'
' + "! #
$
'
&
)-
&
-
' & &
'
& +%
(
&
&
&
%
(
. ' ''
"+""
""
,&
+
$' % ' & ' &
&
& &
'
&'
''
&
. %
( & ' '
+
'
&
&
- 3 -
& +
&'
&'
''
&
,
&
. %
( & ' '
+
&'
''
' &
&
'
& '
/0
( '
' 1 '
23 4356567839
2:; ;7<=25 >79 : ?965 68 523 8:5<93 7> @395679:96 57 A<:;2 523 @7BB<86@:5678 C3:968= 7
"" D:53D
"+"" 6;;<3D CE 93;478D385 7+ $883F<93&% 93><;68= 57 93><8D 523 5<65678 >33 :8D 75239 >33; 23 4356567839 2:; :G;7 ;7<=25 >79 : ?965 68 523 8:5<93 7> B:8D:B<; 57 D693@5 523 93;478D385 7+ 57 935<98 523 796=68:G D7@<B385; :8D >79 68656:568= :@5678 :=:68;5 523 93;478D385 7+ >79 H67G:568= 523 93=<G:5678; >9:B3D CE 523 93;478D385 7
23 4356567839 ?:; :DB6553D 57 523 47;5=9:D<:53 @7<9;3 :5 523 93;478D385 7+ I @7GG3=3 68
- 4 -
' $3839:G '3D6@683% C:;3D 78 239 GG 8D6: :5678:G G6=6C6G65E @<B 859:8@3 3;5 $
% :8J <8D39 523 78 3;6D385 8D6:8 $ % A<75: :8D @7BB78 @7<8;3G68= @78D<@53D CE 93;478D385 7 23 4356567839 4:6D <4 523 >33; :8D ;<CB6553D :GG 239 @93D3856:G; 57 523 93;478D385 7+ C3>793 523 G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678 8:B3GE )" " 23 G:539 ;<CB6553D : 93493;385:5678 D:53D
"+" ;33J68= >79 G3:H3 >97B )"+" H38 C3>793 526; 93A<3;5 ?:; @78;6D393D 523 4356567839 :C;3853D >97B :5538D68= 523 @G:;;3;
2393:>539 523 4356567839 68>79B3D 523 93;478D385 7+ 52:5 ;23 ?7<GD A<65 239 ;3:5 :5 523 93;478D385 7+ :8D 68;6;53D >79 935<98 7> 523 796=68:G D7@<B385; :; ?3GG :; >79 93><8D 7> 523 >33 4:6D 8 93;478;3 93;478D385 7+ 93><;3D 523 93A<3;5 7> 523 4356567839 68 H63?
7> :8 <8D395:J68= ;<CB6553D CE 239 :5 523 56B3 7> K76868= 523 @7<9;3 368= :==963H3D CE 523 ;:B3 523 4356567839 6; C3>793 526; 7<95 >79 523 :>793B3856783D 93G63>;
- 5 -
) <968= 523 438D38@E 7> 526; ?965 43565678 523 93;478D385 7+ 6; ;5:53D 57 2:H3 935<983D 523 796=68:G 7> :GG 523 D7@<B385; 7> 523 4356567839 68 H63? 7> :8 685396B 79D39 =9:853D CE 526; 7<95 78
"+" 2393>793 523 78GE 6;;<3 52:5 93B:68; 57 C3 @78;6D393D 6; 523 93><8D 7> 523 >33 4:E:CG3 CE 523 93;478D385 7+ 5 :443:9; 52:5 523 93;478D385 7 I86H39;65E 9:85 7BB6;;678 2:; 6;;<3D =<6D3G683; 93=:9D68= 93><8D 7> 5<65678 >33
G:<;3 ) 7> 523 ;:6D =<6D3G683; 493;@96C3D :; >7GG7?;
' ()*(+,-.( )(/+0 ((12 3+,,34(56(++,3*( 53,60)-5-'-043113+31 )(*(37(03+,6( $%
""L
D:E; 79 B793 8()( 523 >79B:GGE8756>63D G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678
$%
"L 3;; 52:8
D:E; 8()( 523 >79B:GGE8756>63D G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678 $)% !"L
D:E; 79 G3;; -,()523 >79B:GGE 8756>63D G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678 $%
"L )" D:E; 79 G3;; C<5 B793 52:8
D:E; -,() >79B:GGE8756>63D G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678 $ %
""L '793 52:8 )" D:E; -,() >79B:GGE 8756>63D G:;5 D:53 7> :DB6;;678
- 6 -
68@3 523 4356567839 2:; :C:8D783D 239 ;3:5 :>539 83:9GE 5?7 B7852; >97B 523 G:;5 D:53 >79 :DB6;;678 ;23 6; 875 38565G3D 57 93><8D 7> 523 >33; 4:6D 57 523 93;478D385 7+ 23 4356567839 ?:; <8:CG3 57 47685 7<5 57 :8E 75239 ;5:5<579E 497H6;678 ?26@2 @7B43G; 523 93;478D385 7+ 57 93><8D 523 5<65678 >33 :8D 75239 >33; 2393>793 526; (965 43565678 D73; 875 B3965 @78;6D39:5678 68;7>:9 :; 523 93><8D 7> 523 >33 4:6D CE 523 4356567839 6; @78@3983D 7?3H39 ;68@3 523 93;478D385 7+ 2:; :G93:DE 935<983D 523 796=68:G D7@<B385; 7> 523 4356567839 26; ?965 43565678 D3;39H3; 57 C3 D6;47;3D 7>> 78 523 >7GG7?68= 539B;
6%
23 93G63> ;7<=25 >79 CE 523 4356567839 68;7>:9 :; 523 935<98 7> 523 796=68:G D7@<B385; 6; @78@3983D 6; @7B4G63D ?652 66%
23 93G63> 68;7>:9 :; 93><8D 7> 523 5<65678 >33; :8D 75239 >33; :93 @78@3983D 6; D6;B6;;3D 666%
5 6; 7438 >79 523 93;478D385 7+ 57 497@33D :=:68;5 523 4356567839 57 @7GG3@5 523 C:G:8@3 >33; 6> 65 6; 439B6553D 68 G:? 09
%!& ! 6;5 7
G 7 )