Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 935 (PNJ)
KRISHNA SHARMA AND OTHERS v. STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
CWP/28458/2025 · 2026-04-21
Harkesh Manuja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 935 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 935 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
CWP No.28458 of 202
!!"# $% # $% 789 - '!#(#(%"! (#&* )!"#(%" 0%)'+! !0#(%"8<%$#&! *(/ !*%",#&!- 79 (! !B' !!/("/!# 8<%$#&!0#,*" %$ !0#*".+! !& *2* , !&( 8E 8 *"/ 2025 (O&M)
H
% H
% H
% H
% *#!%$! *#!%$! *#!%$! *#!%$! &(1*"&*+(3,/1%0*#! % #&!'!#(#(%"! %)*+&* )*, ,* -*" *./(&*"0&*"/*, /1%0* *"0&*"/*,/1%0*#!*"/ 3*&&*4/&* -,/1%0*#! % !'%"/!"#"% GD IIII , 5 *+6 , 5 *+6 , 5 *+6 , 5 *+6 -2*-%$' !!"#'!#(#(%",#&!& #&*#%"*00%4"#%$("*/1! #!"0!,#& '+!#! /!#*(+ %$ #&!( *0;4( !/ +* #&! *"/0;4((#(%"0#,8<=>5$% !-&*1!A!!"/!' (1!/%$/4!0%) (!$+-#*#(".,("*//(#(%"#%8 !#*(+A-#&!'!#(#(%"! :+*"/%2"! ,*"%#&! 0&4"3%$+*"/)!*4 (". % 8, (++* % : (#4*#!/ ( &(+ *"/ (# (0# %&#*3 2* *+%
"/ 8> 8 F (4!/ 4"/! !0
% <>E<%$E5 G6 % <>E<%$E5 G6 % <>E<%$E5 G6 % <>E<%$E5 G6 !0((%" !0((%" !0((%" !0((%" 8 8 8 8 > > > >
!#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !#(#(%"! !'%"/!"# !'%"/!"# !'%"/!"# !'%"/!"# -*"* %0*#!2(#& *"/ &% #. %4! *(!/%"A!&*+$%$# #&!'!#(#(%"! :+*"/%2"!
0%4+/" +*"/ (" %AC!0#(%" ' !$! !/ 4"/ 5$% &% #?#&!8<=>0#@6*"/$% # )'!"*#(%"(" !'!0##&! !#% *"*+<* +*%$+*"/2&(0&2 ! ("#&!( %AC!0#(%"4"/! !0#( (".8*"*+8D* +*$% )(".' (" #&! !1!"4! !#*#! %$ 1(++* +% *0;4( !/ 1(/! "%#($(0*#(%" /*# !0#(%" > G %$ #&! 8<=> 1 $#&! +/"%# 4"/! % #&! 2* 0#(%" .'* # (++*.! /*#!/ 0# MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.24 18:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.28458 of 202
!'!0#(1!+- 2 0;4((#(%" %++ 1*+4!2**! 7D9 ! # +*"/%2"! ("0+ /()(!/ %2 '!#(#(%"! :+*"/% 8 D *"/ A!(/!*2* /%$ 7>9 !* 4A)(##!/#&!( % 4'%"#&! # '!#(#(%"! ("#! ("1(!2%$#&!# *0;4( !/ +*"/ #% '!#(#(%"! :+*"/% +!* "!/0%4"!+ D D D D#(#+!/?) ?) ?) ?) D8 8 D*"/ 4)*
"(% 4)*
"(% 4)*
"(% 4)*
"(% 7E9 !* $% *2* / %$ ! *0;4( !/+*"/'* % : * 2!++ !;4( !/#%A!( 2025 (O&M)
2* / 4"/! !0#(%" 88 %$ #&! 8 %++!0#% 5$% &% # ?#&! @6 %" !!/J +*3&'! *0 ! ! #("!"#+-, #&! !$! !"0! '!#(#(%"
"0+4/(". #&! '!#(#(%"! 4"/! ! %2!1! , !.4+* ( # ''!*+ /%2"! 2* '* #+- *++%2!/ A-
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
8<=> 0# 2* '*!/ A- #&! * %" D F = 2&! !A- #&! )* 3 #(%" $(+!/ *# #&! ("#*"0! %$ # !0#(%" 8< %$ #&! 8<=> 0# 2! !*+ % 88 %$ 8> $(+!/ A- #&( %4 # 1(/! /!0((%" /*# !!/ J >,E8,: '! *0
"#! !##&! !4'%" ! 4A)(##&*#%"0!#&!'!#(#(%" /*#!/D F =,(#2*("04)A! $#&!*0;4( !/+*"/'! #*("(".#%# >0# !* "!/0%4"!+0%"#!"/#& %"#&! #%' %1(/!/!#*(+%$# #, #&! %)((%" %" #&! '* # %$ # $*#*+ "4''% #%$&(4A)((% !/A-#&(%4 #("H
% FE H
% FE H
% FE H
% FE !%$* -*"**"/%#&! @ !%$* -*"**"/%#&! @ !%$* -*"**"/%#&! @ !%$* -*"**"/%#&! @/!0(/!/ %"@A+!'!B%4 #("0*!%$ * * * * *##&%4.&#&!'!#(#(%"! 2! !!"#(#+ *#(%" 2(#& !'!0# #% #&!( !"# * +*0%)' (!/(" !0# % 8 * - /( !0#(%" (" #&( !.* / 2! 2 *"/ * 3!# $ #&! 2! ! / A- /*#!/ *0 ! %"! A!"# %#&! #&*# $#&! $ #&! (%", E%$ E%$ E%$ E%$ !/%" *) *) *) *) #(#+!/ !"#( ! (++ 2!
! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.24 18:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.28458 of 202
79
" 0%4"!+ !' !!" !;4( !/ %$ #&! *0;4( !/ +*"/ (" 0# %2!1! , '!#(#(%"! :+*"/% !'!0#%$#&!( + (++* % : (# (# (0# %&#*3 /()(!/ 7F9 &* '*'! A%%3 7<9 !$ %$!0#(%"8=%$ !0# 586 %$#& 56 '* #( )*/ 2025 (O&M)
" #&! %#&! &*"/, +!* "!/ #*#! 0 !"#(". !'%"/!"# % *"/ D &! '!#(#(%"! :+*"/%2"! #% $4 " (" #&!( %AC!0#(%"'!#(#(%" ' !$! ! , &*1(". $*(+!/ #% /% %, /%2"! #% &*1! 0+*()!/ !"&*"0 ( +*"/)!*4 (".8*"*+8D* (#4*#!/ 2(#&(" #&! !1!"4! !#*#! *3 # ( #&4, 0%"#!"/!/ #&*# #&! &*1! &!* / +!* "!/ 0%4"!+ $% !$% !/!+1(".4'%"#&!(4!("&* %$#&!8<=>0#,#&!*)! !*/* !0#(%"8=%++!0#% #*#!)!"##%#&! 86 ")*3(".#&! !$! !"0!,#&!% $#&!%4 #,("2 (#(".4"/! &(&*"/ 5*6#&!(#4*#(%"*"/!B#!"#%$#& A4(+/(".% #*"/(".0 %'#&! ! 5A6#&!"*)!%$#&!'! %"2& ("40&+*"/, 506 #&! *)%4"# *2* /!/ $% / !0#(%"E*"/8F,% !(#&! %$#& *2* /!/4"/! !0#(%"88L*"/ 5/6($#&!%AC!0#(%"A!#%#&!*) %"2&(0&#&!*)%4"#%$0%)'!" 6 % #&! *(/ #*#!)!"# &*++ A * #(04+* %$ #&! "%#(0! ! 1!/ 4'% */!% /!+(1! !/A-#&!'* #(!("#! !
! 0%4"!+ * 2!++ * +!* "!/ !" D 1!&!)!"#+- 4A)(# #&*# (# 2 4 "(& 0%)'+!#! '* #(04+* %$ #& $! !/ 4"/! !0#(%"8< %$#&!8< %, (# 2* ()'%(A+! $% #
"0!/ 0%)'!"*#(%" *# #&( #*.!, * +*0%)' (!/(" !0#*".+!% #*#! %$ 1(++*.!
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.28458 of 202
A 0*##*#4#% -%A ("$% )*#(%"("2 *"/ !B#!"# %$ +* ' !!"#0*!,*'' ("*)40& * #& !0#*".+! % 8 !& *2* ,!&(+ #% #&! +!* "!/ %++!0#% &*1(". +*"/%2"! 2! *0;4( !/+*"/!1 #&!)("#&!( %AC 7=9 &! %4 #("#&!0*! 2&! !A-(#2*& #&!%4 # &! ! M
" ("#! *''+ #&! #&! 2* %4 %++ '* # !0# 2025 (O&M)
A* ! !*/(".%$!0#(%"8=%$#&! %A+(.*#(%"4'%"#&! *"/0;4(( 2 (#(".#%#&!+!* "!/ !$! !"0! +*"/ *0;4( !/, A!(/! ' %1(/(".
*''* !"#+-#&! $*(+!/#%!B! 0 #&! +*"/ )!*4 (". 8 *"*+ 8 8 (++* % : (#4*#!/ 2(#&( (+*"/(# (0# %&#*3,2*"%# ! / !$! !"0! %4 # " 40& 0( 0 (". $*(+!/ #% /(0&* .! (# #*#4 ! ! "%# #% 4$$! +% %$ !"&*"0 !1!"($#&!0%)'+!#!'* #(04+* (" AC!0#(%"4"/! !0#(%"8<%$#&!8 &!*$% !*(/1(!2%$/! (1!/$ %) *!%$ *)4)*
"(%"%$" &!+/#&*#(#(#&!/4#-%$#&!% !+!1*"#!B0! '##&! !%$( !' %/4 M
"/! !0#(%" 8< %$ #&! 0# #&! ("#! !#!/ 2&% &*/ "%# *00!'#!/ # *''+(0*#(%"#%#&!%++!0#% !;4( ( #&!/!#! )("*#(%"%$#&!%4 # "! #&! *2* / 2* #&! *)%4"# %$ 0%) 2*)%1!/(#2*#&!/4#-%$#&! %4 #
"/! !0#(%"8=%$#&!0 %++!0#% 2* !;4( !/#% #*#! $% '* #(04+* * )!"#(%"!/ (" 0+*4! !0#(%"8=%$#&!0# &4(#2*#&
#&!8=<>0#)*3!(#!1(/!"##&* ((#(%"%++!0#% #%' %1(/!"!0!* 0!%4 #2(#& !'!0##%#&!(#4*#( (". %#&! !+!1*"# '* #(04+* " # ! 0(!#&!*(/)*"/*#% -%A+(.*#(% + 8D * +* %$ +*"/ 0%)' (!/ (#&(" #&! !1!"4! !#*#! %$ 1(++* # !$+!0#!/("#&!#*#!)!"#4A)(## ( 04)#*"0!, #&! *"/ 0;4((#( #*#4#% - %A+(.*#(%", #&! '!#(#(%"!
"0!/ 0%)'!"*#(%" ;4* #&!( !"# ("#&( !.* /2! !"%#' %1(/!/ !8<=>0# %)#&!/!0((%"%$#&!%"@A+!' "/(* !'% #!/*?8==856> %++!0#% #%!"/$4++("$% )*#(%" %/40!/&! !4"/! #&! %"+- !;4( !)!"# $% #&! '! / #&! *2* / 2* #% )%1! * 2 (## 4( (".#&*##&!)*##! A! !$! !/$ "!%$#&!. %4"/$% #&!*00!'#( 0%)'!"*#(%" "0! 40& *''+(0*#( !%++!0#% #%)*3!* !$! !"0!#%# 0#2&(+! )*3(".#&! !$! !"0!# $% #&!("$% )*#(%"%$#&! %4 # # 4! 5*6 #% 5/6 %$ 4A!0#(%" 586 *#&!/4#-%$#&!%++!0#% #%)!"#( 4 #&*#(# * - *#(%"
" #&! *#(%", !/ (" (++*.! (##!/ (#(%"
"! !"#( ! /A- '!B >F, %"#% '! %" (##!" !/$% !'#(". (0*#(%" #%#&! 0!#&! # #&! 586 %$ !"#(%" MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.24 18:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.28458 of 202
"%# # !! +*"/ * !* #*# %$ $% /4#- #&! /!0( 789 "1 (*++%2!/ !' ("#! )%$!0# B!04#(".%4 # #&!'!#(#(%"! :+* 8D* +*0%)' 7889 &! '! (%/%$$%4 2 2&(0& !'%"/!" #&! '!#(#(%"! :+* A% "!'! %"*++- #*#!B0&!;4! 789 4 # #&!!"&*"0!/*) A-#&!'!#(#(%"! *"/("#! !#4"/ 2025 (O&M)
"%#%"+-#&!(#4*#(%"*"/!B#!"#%$ # !!, A4(+/(". % #*"/(". 0 %' +*"/(*0;4( !/)*-"%#A!$4++-0 * !**!"#! !/("#&! !1!"4! !0% #*#!*0;4( (".40&+*"/&%4+/"%# %$40&(."% *"0!%$#&!*. (04+#4 ( $% )*3(". * !$! !"0! 4"/! !0# /4#-%$#&!%++!0#% #%!"/$4++(" #&!!"#( !+*"/*0;4( !/*"/(#(#& /!0(/!#&!)*##! ("*00% /*"0!2(#&
"1(!2%$#&!/(04(%")*/!&! '%"/!"#% D(/( !0#!/#%4A) !0#(%"8=%$#&!8<=>0#A!$% ! 4 #A-("0% '% *#(".0%)'+!#!/!#* :+*"/%2"! #&! !A-("0+4/(".#&! ' (!/(" !0#*".+!% 8(++* &! *$% !*(/ !B! 0(! A! 0* (!/ 2!!3$ %)#&!/*#!%$ !0!('#%$ /!"#% DA!A4 /!"!/2(#&#&!0% :+*"/%2"! # ( )*/! 0+!* #& ++-A- !'%"/!"#% D*"/&*++ ! 4 #&! )% !,#&!+!* "!/B!04#(". *)%4"#%$0%)'!"*#(%"*.*("## ! ( !+!*!/#%#&!)*##&!!* +(
"/! #&!8<=>0#,' !$! *A+-2(#&
#%$+*"/A4#!1!"'* #(04+* %$* %' #&! !%" &! *. (04+#4 (# 2&% ++-0%"1! *"#2(#&#&!3&* *% !0% /*"/#&!
"(%"%$"/(*% # "%#A!*++%2!/#%#*3!*"-*/1*"#* +#4 (# "0!*"*''+(0*#(%"()%1 !0#(%" 8< %$ #&! 0#(# A!0%)! # ++("$% )*#(%"#%#&!%4 # !.* /( (#&! !*$#! #&!/4#-%$#&!%4 # 2(#&+*2 N &! !("*A%1!,#&!' !!"#2 (#'!#(#( A)(##&!*)!"/!/:0% !0#!/ % )8 !#&!+!* "!/ !$! !"0!%4 #04 !#*(+%$#&!*0;4( !/+*"/%2"!/ #&!+*"/'* 0!+)!*4 (".8*" *% : / %4# A- !'%"/!"# % D 2(#&(" %$0! #($(!/0%'-%$#&(% /! ,$*(+( 0%#56%$ E,:#%A!'*(/ #&*# #&! *)%4"# %$ 0%#56 &*++ *++"%#A!# !*#!/**A4 /!"%"#
".%4 #(/( !0#!/#%)*3!4 !#& ##&!0%)'+!#!*0;4( !/+*"/%2" +(!#2(#&*++%#&! #*#4#% -A!"!$ (#&("*'! (%/%$)%"#&$ %)# 5 %$*"- 2&%! % % % #&! *"#*.! )%1!/ ! #&! * /(". 4 ##% #(#(%" )8=, 04) !/A- *"*+ &(" * *(+(". *(/#% ++ A!
"#&! !#&*# 2"!/
"!$(# )#&! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.24 18:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.28458 of 202
/*#!%$$(+(".%$ #&*##&!*0;4((#( 78D9 !" ' (+ ' (+ ' (+ ' (+8 8 8 8, , , , #(3 H&! H&!
2025 (O&M)
%$#&!*)!"/!/:0% !0#!/ % ) (#(%"0%))!"0!/2*-A*03("#&! !"/(".*''+(0*#(%"56,($*"-&*++* &!#&! '!*3(".: !*%"!/ !:
&!#&! !'% #*A+! !:
% 8=,'* #(04+* +-3!!'(".("1( &!-!* ++*+%#*"//('%!/%$ 5 6 5 6 5 6 5 6 !:% !:% 6 1(!2 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.24 18:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment