- 1 - ! "# $" ! %&'%()*+&%)) $ ! "# $ % & # % # # &' ((( ! "# % ) %$ % *%#&* # *& Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % % % %% # *'"$+"$",$* "$%#&*+% & *" $"-$ *"$"./0$ *"$".$ % "$ 11 % 2 3# 2 "3# 2 $ 445678 9: ;9,7 <*& ;7=96>7;78 ?@ A<;0B5;<C947>0>9<:08=9;D<;>A7<DD7:476B5:96A0?C7 5:87; 74>9<:6 *'"$ +"$",$ * "$ <D # &* 74>9<:+<D>A74>& 0:874>9<:6*" $"2$ *"$"./0$0:8*"$".$<D "$4> 1196?7D<;7 >A96 <5;> 5:87; 74>9<: * <D # &* 677E9:= ;7=5C0;?09C 70;8C70;:784<5:67CD<;>A7B0;>976 * % 9: ;9,7 <*& -06 ;7=96>7;78 ?@ A<;0B5; <C947 >0>9<: 08=9; 0=09:6> >A7 B7>9>9<:7; - 3 - A7;79: D<;>A70D<;76098<DD7:476 <: >A7 ?0696 <D >A7 D9;6> 9:D<;,0>9<: 80>78 * && ;7479.78 D;<, >A7 .94>9, =9;C 5;9:= >A7 4<5;67 <D 9:.76>9=0>9<: <D >A7 4067 >A7 B7>9>9<:7; A7;79: -06 0;;76>78 <: && :.76>9=0>9<: <D >A7 4067 96 4<,BC7>78 0:8 4A0;=7 6A77> A06?77:D9C78 A7?09C0BBC940>9<:D9C78?@>A7B7>9>9<:7; ?7D<;7 >A7 F5;96894>9<:0C 7669<:6 <5;> 9: ;9,7 <*&-06;7F74>78<:&& & A7;7D<;7A7 96?7D<;7>A96<5;> 70;:784<5:67CD<;>A7B7>9>9<:7;65?,9>6>A0> >A7B7>9>9<:7;0:8>A7.94>9,=9;C-7;79:C<.7 A7.94>9, =9;CA08.<C5:>0;9C@044<,B0:978>A7B7>9>9<:7;0:86>0@78 ><=7>A7;9:0C<8=7 A7.94>9,=9;CA060C;708@4<,BC7>78 @70;6<D0=70:8>A7B;<6745>9<:A06:<>B;<85478A7; ,0;E6 40;8 <; 7G59.0C7:> 47;>9D940>7 >< B;<.7 A7; 0=7 A7 B7>9>9<:7; A06 :< <>A7; 4;9,9:0C 0:>74787:>6 A7;796087C0@9:D9C9:=>A7% 44<;89:=C@A7B;0@6>< 0CC<->A7B7>9>9<: - 4 - 7; 4<:>;0 C70;:78 9=A <5;> <.7;:,7:> C7087; D<; ;76B<:87:> < 0:8 C70;:78 4<5:67C D<; ;76B<:87:> < A0.7 <BB<678 >A7 B7>9>9<: A7@ 65?,9> >A0>>A7.94>9,=9;C960=780?<5> '@70;6,<:>A60:8 6A7 A06 ,087 0CC7=0>9<:6 0=09:6> >A7 B7>9>9<:7; 9: A7; 6>0>7,7:> ;74<;878 5:87; 74>9<: + <D ; A7 87C0@9:C<8=9:=>A7% A06?77:B;<B7;C@7HBC09:780:89> 96<:C@0D>7;>A7.94>9,=9;CA088964566780?<5>>A7,0>>7; -9>AA7;B0;7:>66A7A080BB;<04A78>A7B<C947 :>A7 7.7:> >A7 B7>9>9<:7; 96 7:C0;=78 <: ?09C A7 ,0@ >0,B7; -9>A>A7B;<6745>9<:-9>:7667644<;89:=C@>A7@B;0@>< 896,966>A7B7>9>9<: + A7 .94>9, =9;C A06 0BB;<04A78 >A7 B<C947 <: * && 0:8 ?0678 <: A7; 6>0>7,7:> % 9: ;9,7 <*& -06 ;7=96>7;78 ?@ A<;0B5; <C947 >0>9<: 08=9; 0=09:6> >A7 B7>9>9<:7; D<; >A7 0D<;76098 <DD7:476 7;560C <D >A7 D9;6> 9:D<;,0>9<: =9.7: ?@ >A7 .94>9, =9;C -<5C8=<><6A<->A0>6A7966>58@9:=9:674<:8@70; 0:86>0@9:=9:0A<6>7CA7A066>0>78>A0>>A7B7>9>9<:7; - 5 - 5678><4<:>04>A7;<.7;BA<:70:86A70C6<5678><>0CE -9>A A9, -A94A -<5C8 B;9,0 D0497 =< >< 6A<- >A0> >A7@ -7;704G509:>78-9>A704A<>A7;A7A060.7;;78>A0><: 1 &&>A7B7>9>9<:7;A08D<;49?C@>0E7:A7;9:040; 0:8>A7;70D>7;A7A08>0E7:A7;><0C<8=70>08=9;0:8 A08 D<;49?C7 67H50C 9:>7;4<5;67 -9>A A7; A7 A066>0>78 >A0> <: & && -A7: >A7 B7>9>9<:7; A08 B0;E78 A96 40;0:8A08=<:7><B5;4A067?;70ED06>6A7A087640B78 D;<, >A7 6098 40; 0:8 >A7;70D>7; 6A7 ;704A78 A7; A<,7 0:8 9:D<;,78 0?<5> >A7 6098 9:4987:> >< A7; B0;7:>6 0:8 ;7C0>9.76 A<5=A>A7.94>9,=9;CA08;7>5;:78><A7;A<,7 <:& &&0:8A089:D<;,780?<5>>A79:4987:>><A7; B0;7:>60:8<>A7;;7C0>9.766A7A060BB;<04A78>A7B<C947 ?7C0>78C@<:* && ' 6;9=A>C@B<9:>78<5>?@C70;:784<5:67CD<;>A7 B7>9>9<:7; >A0> >A<5=A >A7 .94>9, =9;C A06 4<,BC7>78 A7; >A7B<C947A0.7B;<85478<:C@>A747;>9D940>7966578 ?@ >A7 9:6>9>5>9<: 9: -A94A >A7 .94>9, =9;C 96 6>58@9:= >< B;<.7A7;0=7 A7B7>9>9<:7;-A<A06:<<>A7;4;9,9:0C - 6 - 0:>74787:>6969:456><8@D;<, && :.76>9=0>9<: <D>A74067964<,BC7>780:84A0;=76A77>A06?77:D9C78 %<; >A7 B5;B<67 <D 0>>;04>9:= >A7 0CC7=78 <DD7:476 >A7 B;<6745>9<:96B;9:49B0CC@;7G59;78><B;<.7>A0>>A7.94>9, =9;C -06 0 ,9:<; 06 <: >A7 80>7 <D >A7 0CC7=78 9:4987:> A7 ,0>7;90C <: ;74<;8 -<5C8 =< >< 6A<- >A0> >A7 .94>9, =9;C06-7CC06>A7B7>9>9<:7;A08B;<85478>A79;;76B74>9.7 08A0;0;89:>A7C<8=79:-A94A>A7@A084A74E789:<: 1 && 0:8 >A7;70D>7; >A7@ A08 6>0@78 ><=7>A7; 9: >A76098C<8=7 A7B;<6745>9<:9:0CCA0649>78*4A0;=7 6A77>-9>:766769:>A7B;767:>4067 A7 ;90C9:>A74067 96@7>><4<,,7:47 <:6987;9:=>A70D<;7609806B74>6<D>A7,0>>7; 0, <D >A7 .97- >A0> -9>A<5> 7HB;7669:= 0:@ <B9:9<: <: ,7;9>60:887,7;9>6<D>A74067>A7B;0@7;,087?@>A7 B7>9>9<:7; D<; =;0:> <D ;7=5C0; ?09C :7786 >< ?7 0:6-7;78 0DD9;,0>9.7C@44<;89:=C@D<CC<-9:= A74;9,9:0CB7>9>9<:960CC<-78 - 7 - A7B7>9>9<:7;04456789689;74>78><?77:C0;=78<: ?09C 9: ;9,7 <*& <D A<;0B5; <C947 >0>9<: 08=9; ;7=96>7;78 D<; >A7 <DD7:476 B5:96A0?C7 5:87; 74>9<:6 *'"$+"$",$* "$<D#&*74>9<: +<D>A74>& 0:874>9<:6*" $"2$*"$"./0$ 0:8*"$".$<D "$4> 11B7:89:=<:>A7D9C7 <DC70;:7896>;94>0:87669<:658=708=9;65?F74>>< >A7D<CC<-9:=4<:89>9<:6 0$ 7>9>9<:7;6A0CC7H745>7B7;6<:0C?<:8D<;0 65, <D 6 &&&&&/ -9>A >-< 65;7>976 D<; >A7 C9E765, >< >A7 60>96D04>9<: <D >A7 F5;96894>9<:0C <5;>) ?$ 7>9>9<:7; 6A0CC 0BB70; ;7=5C0;C@ <: 0CC >A7 80>76<DA70;9:=?7D<;7>A7 ;90C<5;>5:C766>A7 ;90C <5;> 7H7,B>6 A96 0BB70;0:47 D<; .0C98 ;706<:6) 4$ 7>9>9<:7; 6A0CC :<> 89;74>C@ <; 9:89;74>C@ >A;70>7: <; >0,B7; -9>A >A7 B;<6745>9<: -9>:76676) 8$ 7>9>9<:7; 6A0CC :<> 9:.<C.7 9: 69,9C0; <DD7:4769:D5>5;7) - 8 - 7$ 7>9>9<:7;6A0CC:<>C70.7>A7F5;96894>9<:<D >A7 ;90C <5;> -9>A<5> B7;,9669<: <D >A7 6098 <5;> 5:>9C >A7 4067 ;7=96>7;78 0=09:6> A9, 96 896B<678<DD ,* %# $" ) " 96>< C< 1