Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 9343 (KAR)

SURESH v. CHANDRAMMA AND ORS

WP/200706/2023 · 2025-01-25

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$!! %$ & ! " #$ % & '"(" ) *( ))# + , ''"() $ ' - ''"() ' ''))$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ' & ) '')(" '$ * & $ # $" ))# + , ''"() "( - ! *) - ! .''"() -/ "*(")()! -")$*#"(0 ' ! - ))* - - - % "*(")()$ & ')()( +& - 3 - - 1 & & 23 4567897:: 78 ;')()( ;8 923 :753 ;: <<797;865 387;= 7>75 &?<@3 656A?=6@7 7B A3:;=3 927B ;?=9C265538@78@68;=<3=<693<"*(")()$ADE27C268 64457C697;8 :753< AD 6 46=983=B274 :7=F 9; C;F3 ;8 =3C;=< E6B655;E3< ) 23 B?79 78 ;')()( E6B :753< :;= 46=9797;868<B346=6934;BB3BB7;8;:"92B26=3;:4567897:: 78 923 B?79 BC23<?53 4=;43=973B 23 4567897:: C;8938<3< 9269 923 <3:38<689 ;) 96G78@ ?8<?3 6<>6896@3 ;: C3=9678 B79?697;8 E6B 6BB3=978@ 9269 ;?9 ;: 923 A?B783BB 9269 E6B 655;993< 9; 27B B26=3 23 A3C6F3 6 46=983= ;: B;>3=<268 -7868C3 68< 79B B7B93= C;8C3=8 68< ;?9 ;: 923 78C;F3 36=83< :=;F 923 A?B783BB ;: B;>3=<268 -7868C3 23 E389 ;8 4?=C26B78@ 923 4=;43=973B7892386F3;:27BE7:368<B;8B 9E6B65B; C;8938<3<923<3:38<689;)E792923@?7537893897;826< - 4 - C=3693< 6 :65B3 46=9797;8 <33< ;: 923 D36= "## 68< 923 A?B783BB E6B B2;E8 9; A3 9269 ;: 6 4=;4=7396=D C;8C3=8 92;?@2923A?B783BB3B68<9234=;43=973B9269B9;;<78923 86F3 ;: 923 <3:38<689 ; ) 27B E7:3 27B B;8B 68< <6?@293=B E3=3 655 H;789 :6F75DA?B783BB3B 23 B?79 E6B C;893B93<AD923<3:38<689;)E2;<3873<9269923B?79 4=;43=973BE3=34=;43=973B;:923H;789:6F75D $ 6B3< ;8 923B3 C;893897;8B 923 B?79 E6B B39 <;E8 :;= 9=765 693= 68 64457C697;8 E6B :753< AD B;>3=<268 -7868C3 C;8938<78@ 9269 923 BC23<?53 4=;43=973B E3=3 4?=C26B3< AD 923 :7=F 78 79B 86F3 68< 923=3:;=3 923 B67< 4=;43=973B E3=3 8;9 6>6756A53 :;= 46=9797;868<92?B79<3B7=3<9;C;F3;8=3C;=<78923B?79 B;6B9;8;8B?799234567897::78B;:6=6B79=35693<9;923 BC23<?534=;43=973B 2364457C697;8 E6B C;893B93< AD 923 4567897:: E2; C567F3< 9269 923 :7=F 26< 8; =7@29 ;= 5;C?BB968<79;C567F9269923BC23<?534=;43=973BE3=3 4?=C26B3<AD923:7=F 23 9=765 ;?=9 6:93= 43=?B78@ 6 B653 <33< 38C5;B3<65;8@E79292364457C697;8:753<AD923:7=F?8<3= - 5 - =<3= ?53"()!235<9269923:7=FE6B7893=3B93<78923 BC23<?534=;43=973B68<923=3:;=368D<3C=339269F6D A3 46BB3< C;8C3=878@ 923 BC23<?53 4=;43=973B E;?5< C6B96C5;?<;892397953;:923:7=F68<923=3:;=3923:7=F E6B3897953<9;C;F3;8=3C;=<B;6B9;C;893B9923C567F ;: 923 4567897:: 38C3 79 655;E3< 923 64457C697;8 68< 43=F7993< 923 :7=F 9; C;F3 ;8 =3C;=< 78 923 B?79 378@ 6@@=73>3< AD 923 B67< ;=<3= 923 4567897:: 7B A3:;=3 927B ;?=9 ' 23536=83<C;?8B35:;=923439797;83=C;8938<B 9269923BC23<?534=;43=973BE3=34?=C26B3<;?9;:923 8?C53?B ;: 923 H;789 :6F75D 68< 923=3:;=3 923 BC23<?53 4=;43=973BE3=36>6756A53:;=46=9797;83>3892;?@279E6B 4?=C26B3<7892386F3;:923:7=F;E3>3=923536=83< C;?8B35 :;= 923 =3B4;8<389 ;"( B?AF79B 9269 79 7B 78<7B4?96A539269BC23<?534=;43=973BE3=34?=C26B3<78 923 86F3 ;: 923 :7=F E27C2 8;9 ;85D C;F4=7B3< ;: 923 <3:38<689;)A?9>6=7;?B;923=46=983=BE2;E3=38;9 F3FA3=B ;: 923 :6F75D ;: 923 4567897:: 3 923=3:;=3 C;8938<B9269923:7=FE6B3897953<9;C;F3;8=3C;=<68< - 6 - C;893B9923C567F;:9234567897::926923E6B3897953<:;=6 B26=378923BC23<?534=;43=973B 9 7B 9=793 9269 78 6 B?79 :;= 46=9797;8 79 7B 923 F3FA3=B ;: 6 :6F75D E2; C;?5< 65;83 A3 6==6D3< 6B 46=973B 8D ;923= 43=B;8 C688;9 6BB7B9 923 ;?=9 78 <3C7<78@ 923 I?3B97;8 E23923= 923 46=973B 9; 923 57B 6=3 F3FA3=B;:6H;789:6F75D68<E23923=923D6=33897953<9; 6B26=3789234=;43=973B;E3>3=7:64=;43=9D9269<;3B 8;9 A35;8@ 9; 923 H;789 :6F75D 7B B;?@29 9; A3 4=;C33<3< 6@678B9923=7@29:?5;E83=;:923B67<4=;43=9D7B3897953< 9; C;F3 ;8 =3C;=< 78 923 B67< B?79 ;85D :;= 923 57F793< 4?=4;B3;:C;893B978@923C567F92699234=;43=9DA35;8@B 9; 923 :6F75D 68< 923=3AD 8;8B?79 923 4567897:: 78B;:6= 6B 9269 4=;43=9D 7B C;8C3=83< 8 923 78B9689 C6B3 923 =3B4;8<389;"(7B646=983=B274:7=F<?5D=3@7B93=3<68< 65592346=983=B;:923:7=F6=38;9F3FA3=B;:923:6F75D :9269A3B;68<7:923BC23<?534=;43=973BB968<78923 86F3;:923:7=FE27C27B6878<3438<38938979D3897953< 9;B?368<A3B?3<7879B86F379C68C;F3;8=3C;=<68< C;893B9 923 C567F ;: 923 4567897:: 9269 923 BC23<?53 - 7 - 4=;43=973B6=38;96>6756A53:;=46=9797;86B79A35;8@B9;79 23=3 7B 8; 3==;= 78 923 9=765 ;?=9 43=F79978@ 923 =3B4;8<389;"(9;C;F3;8=3C;=<68<C;893B9923C567F ;: 923 4567897:: 78B;:6= 6B BC23<?53 4=;43=973B 6=3 C;8C3=83< * 38C3 923 439797;8 56CGB F3=79 68< 7B '( %!& ! 7B9;"5;"$