Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9326 (KAR)
HALEEMA BEGUM AND ORS v. JALEEL MIYAN AND ANR
MFA/201072/2019 · 2025-01-29
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9326 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9326 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#
! ! $
! " #
$
%
&
'
(
)$"
"
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.03 10:58:29 - 0800
- 2 -
)
*
' '
%
&& + ' (
)$"
,
, )"! *
' - '
! . %
! $
' %
!$$) /
") /
)
% ' 0
- 3 -
0 1
% %
! 01
% %
2345 6234725 89:7;26 <94 =>2 3??26637=; 375 623472589:7;26<94=>242;?97527=;
>2 ;:@;=37=A36 B:2;=A97 9< 63C =>3= 34A;2 <94 897;A5243=A97 A; C>2=>24 =>2 6234725 9DDA;;A9724 :7524 =>2
D?69E22;.9D?27;3=A978=C3;F:;=A<A25A73@;96GA7H =>2 6A3@A6A=E 9< 42;?97527= 9 2G27 =>9:H> =>2 ?42;27= ?2=A=A97 A; <A625 :7524 =>2 ?49GA;A97; 9< =>2
D?69E22; 9D?27;3=A978=37597=>2H49:75=>3==>2C94ID37>35 GA963=25 =>2 =24D; 375 8975A=A97; 9< =>2 ?96A8E @E 3669CA7H D942=>37?24DA==257:D@249<?3;;27H24;J
! >2 3??26637=; >242A7 342 =>2 863AD37=; @2<942 =>29DDA;;A9724:7524=>2
D?69E22;9D?27;3=A978=A7 9$EF:5HD27=3753C34553=25! =>2 6234725 9DDA;;A9724 52=24DA725 =>2 89D?27;3=A97 9< ;!$$)375<3;=2725=>26A3@A6A=E9742;?97527=9 K 9C724 @E 3@;96GA7H =>2 6A3@A6A=E 9< 42;?97527= 9)
- 4 -
7;:43782 9D?37E C>A8> >35 A;;:25 3 D9=94 G2>A862 7;:4378296A8E
"
>2<38=:36D3=4AL9<=>283;23423;@269C0
3 7 $ =>2 52823;25 ) @43>AD C3;
54AGA7H =>2 G2>A862 9,)!&$!
3=3 3HA8 G2>A862 375 72343I224 2I53):D73@35=>29<<275A7HG2>A862@234A7H 9)$)& 83D2 <49D 9??9;A=2 5A428=A97 375 53;>25 =9 =>2 G2>A862 9< =>2 52823;25 = C3; 897=27525 =>3==>252823;25C3;C94IA7H:752442;?97527=93;3 54AG24375>25A25A7=>2;3A5388A527= @ 2;?97527= 9 3??23425 @2<942 =>2 9DDA;;A972437535DA==25=>3==>252823;25@43>ADC3; 94ID37:7524>AD236;935DA==25=>3==>2G2>A862C3; A7;:425CA=>42;?97527=9 8 2;?97527= 9 ) 7;:43782 9D?37E 897=27525 =>3= =>2 52823;25 >35 3669C25 D942 =>37 ?24DA==25 7:D@24 9< ?3;;27H24; A7 =>2 ;3A5 3=3 3HA8 - 5 - '2>A862 375 =>242<942 =>242 A; GA963=A97 9< =>2 =24D; 375 8975A=A97;9<=>2?96A8E3753;;:8>A=;6A3@A6A=E@23@;96G25 5 =A;79=2C94=>E=>3=;2G24369=>24863AD?2=A=A97; C242 36;9 <A625 @E =>2 A7F:425 A7D3=2; 9< =>2 3=3 3HA8 '2>A862 3H3A7;= =>2 9C724 375 A7;:424 9< =>2 G2>A862 C>242A7 =>2 9=94 88A527= 63AD; 4A@:736 >265 =>3= =>242 C3; 897=4A@:=94E 72H6AH2782 97 =>2 ?34= 9< =>2 52823;2536;97=>9;2?2=A=A97;@2<942=>2 A7A=A366E 3882?=A7H =>2 897=27=A97 =>3= =>2 52823;25 @43>AD >35 3669C25D942=>37=>2?24DA==257:D@249<?3;;27H24;=>2 6A3@A6A=EC3;<3;=2725:?97=>29C7249<=>2G2>A8623=24 =>2 <A75A7H; 9< =>2 C242 8>36627H25 A7 9;&$ 375&&@2<942=>29)45A73=2 278> 9< =>A; 9:4= C>242@E =>2 ;3A5 3??236; >3G2 @227 3669C25 97 =>2 H49:75 =>3= =>2 =9=36 7:D@24 9< 863AD ?2=A=A97;C24262;;=>37=>2?24DA==257:D@249<?3;;27H24; 375 =>242<942 3@;96GA7H =>2 7;:43782 9D?37E <49D ?3EA7H=>289D?27;3=A9783779=@2;:;=3A725 - 6 - 2 7 GA2C 9< =>2 F:5HD27= 42752425 @E =>2 =>262347259DDA;;A9724:7524=>2 8=36;989786:525 =>3= =>2 7;:43782 9D?37E A; 79= 6A3@62 375 <3;=2725 =>2 6A3@A6A=E:?9742;?97527=9 " >2623472589:7;263??234A7H<94=>23??26637=; C>9 342 =>2 863AD37=; @2<942 =>2 9DDA;;A9724 C9:65 897=275=>3==>28368:63=A979<=>289D?27;3=A973D9:7=@E =>2 9DDA;;A9724 A; A7894428= = A; 897=27525 =>3= =>2 C3H2; 3; 79=A<A25 3= 28=A97 ") 9< =>2 D?69E22; 9D?27;3=A978=C24279=897;A52425@E=>29DDA;;A9724 375 =>242<942 =>242 A; 24494 A7 8368:63=A97 9< =>2 89D?27;3=A973D9:7= $ >2 ;28975 ?497H 9< =>2 34H:D27= A; =>3= =>2 6A3@A6A=E 9< 42;?97527= 9 ) 7;:43782 9D?37E 89:65 79= >3G2 @227 3@;96G25 @E =>2 9DDA;;A9724 ;A782 =>2 ?96A8E 89G2425 =>2 4A;I 9< =>2 54AG24 36;9 >2 4A;I 9< =>2 54AG24 89G2425@E=>27;:437829D?37E83779=@286:@@25CA=> =>24A;I9<=>2?24DA==257:D@249<A7D3=2;9<=>2G2>A862 >242<942>2;22I;<94A75:6H27829<=>A;9:4= - 7 - & >2 6234725 89:7;26 3??234A7H <94 42;?97527= 9C9:65;:@DA==>3=A7GA2C9<=>2F:5HD27=9<=>29) 45A73=2278>9<=>A;9:4=A7=>23??236;34A;A7H9:=9<=>2 ;3D2388A527=A=>3;@227>265=>3==>27;:437829D?37E A;6A3@62375=>242<942=>2B:2;=A979<3@;96GA7H=>26A3@A6A=E 9< =>2 A7;:43782 89D?37E C9:65 79= 34A;2 2 ?9A7=; 9:= =>3==>2897=4A@:=94E72H6AH27829<=>252823;25@43>ADA; 36;9 79= ?24DA;;A@62 =9 @2 43A;25 A7 =>A; ?2=A=A97 C>A8> A; <A625 :7524 =>2 ?49GA;A97; 9< =>2 8= >242<942 >2 897=275; =>3= C>27 =>2 4A;I 9< =>2 54AG24 A; 89G2425 :7524 =>2?96A8EA;;:25@E42;?97527=9=99C7249<=>2G2>A862 42;?97527= 9 =>2 7;:43782 9D?37E A; @9:75 =9 ;3=A;<E;:8>863AD; >2 6234725 89:7;26 3??234A7H <94 42;?97527= 9 C9:65 ;:@DA= =>3= =>2 GA963=A97 9< =>2 =24D; 375 8975A=A97; 9< =>2 ?96A8E @E 3669CA7H D942 7:D@24 9< ?3;;27H24; =>37 ?24DA==25 A7 =>2 G2>A862 A; 3 <:753D27=36 @4238>=>242<942=>2F:5HD27=9<=>262347259DDA;;A9724 A;?49?24375894428= - 8 - =A;C94=>=979=2=>3==>2?498225A7H;:7524=>2 ?49GA;A97;9<=>2 D?69E22;9D?27;3=A978=A;=9=366E973 5A<<2427= <99=A7H = A; 3AD25 =9 89D?27;3=2 =>2 C94ID27 C>93422D?69E25375;:<<2437A7F:4E94523=>5:4A7H=>2 89:4;29<3759:=9<=>22D?69ED27==>3;79=>A7H=959 CA=> =>2 72H6AH2782 94 =>2 =94= =>242<942 =>2 B:2;=A97 9< 897=4A@:=94E72H6AH2782A;:7I79C7=9=>2?498225A7H;:7524 =>2?49GA;A97;9<=>2 8= =
A; =9 @2 79=25 =>3= =>2 ?96A8E A;;:25 @E 42;?97527= 9 A7 <3G9:4 9< 42;?97527= 9 A7G34A3@6E 89G24;=>24A;I9<=>254AG2436;97355A=A97=9=>254AG24A= 89G24; =>2 4A;I 9< ?3;;27H24; >242<942 =>2 ?96A8E A;A;;:2597=>2?42DA;2=>3==>254AG24C>9C3; 54AGA7H =>2 G2>A862 A; 89G2425 375 C>27 >2 A; 54AGA7H A7D3=2; 9< =>2 G2>A862 342 36;9 89G2425 < =>2 4A;I 9< =>2 54AG24 A; 79= 89G2425 =>2 B:2;=A97 9< 89G24A7H =>2 4A;I 9< A7D3=2; 976E >3; 79 D237A7H >242<942 79= 89G24A7H =>2 4A;I9<=>254AG24@:=89G24A7H=>24A;I9<=>2A7D3=2;A;37 3@;:45?49?9;A=A972782=>27;:437829D?37EA;6A3@62 =989D?27;3=2=>2A7F:4A2;=>3=89:65@2;:<<2425@E354AG24 - 9 - 37536;9=>2A7D3=2;:?=93D3LAD:D7:D@249<7 =>A; ?42DA;2 =>2 9)45A73=2 278> 9< =>A; 9:4= >3; 3669C25 =>2 3??236; A7 9;&$ 375 =>2 897728=25 D3==24 >242<942 =>2 5A;DA;;36 9< =>2 863AD ?2=A=A973;3H3A7;=42;?97527=9)7;:437829D?37EA; A7894428=>27=>242A;79;:8>GA963=A979<=>2 =24D; 375 8975A=A97; 9< =>2 ?96A8E 2L82?= 8344EA7H D942 7:D@249<?3;;27H24;A=A;=>27;:437829D?37EC>A8>A; 6A3@62 =9 ?3E =>2 89D?27;3=A97 =9 =>2 863AD37=; C>9 >3G2 3??4938>25 =>2 9DDA;;A9724 :7524 =>2 ?49GA;A97; 9< =>2 8= >262347259DDA;;A9724>3;<3A625=979=2=>3= =>2 89D?27;3=A97 =9 @2 8368:63=25 :7524 =>2 ?49GA;A97; 9< =>2 8=342H9G24725@E=>2?49GA;A97;9<28=A97"9< =>2 8= >2F:5A8A36?4979:782D27=;9<=>A;9:4=375 =>3=9<=>2?2L9:4=>3G2>265=>3==>279=A<A83=A97A;;:25 :7524 28=A97 ") 9< =>2 8= 342 @A75A7H 375 D3753=94E A7 73=:42 >242 A; 79 499D <94 52GA3=A7H <49D ;:8> 79=A<A83=A97; A;;:25 >242<942 =>2 8368:63=A97 9< =>2 89D?27;3=A97@E=>262347259DDA;;A972436;93??234;=9 - 10 - @2A7894428=783;29<523=>=>242;>366@23525:8=A979< $/=>242<942=>289D?27;3=A97A;8368:63=253; ;L $/L!M ;$")7355A=A97=9A=3;:D9< ;$) A; =9 @2 35525 =9C345; =>2 <:72436 2L?27;2; >:;=>23??26637=;34227=A=625<943;:D9< ;") 88945A7H6E =>2 ;:@;=37=A36 B:2;=A97 9< 63C 43A;25 A; 37;C2425A7=>272H3=AG22782=>2<9669CA7H0 A >23??236A;3669C25A7?34= AA >2 ?2=A=A9724 A; 27=A=625 <94 3 ;:D 9< ;")3697HCA=>A7=242;=3==>243=2 9</?24377:D<49D=>253=29<2L?A4E9< ! 53E; <49D =>2 53=2 9< =>2 388A527= =A66 53=2 9< 52?9;A= 3; 3H3A7;= ;!$$) 3C34525@E=>2 4A@:736 AAA
>242;?97527=9)7;:437829D?37EA; 5A428=25=952?9;A==>289D?27;3=A973D9:7= CA=>A73?24A959<&C22I;<49D=>253=29<
- 11 -
4282A?=9<389?E9<=>A;F:5HD27=@2<942=>2 62347259DDA;;A9724 AG
>2 42;= 9< =>2 94524?3;;25 @E =>2 6234725 9DDA;;A972442D3A7;:736=2425
5) %
! & ! A;=90690$$
0,