Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 9321 (KAR)
SMT.MAHADEVI @ MADEVI AND ORS v. UMESH AND ANR
MFA/200177/2018 · 2025-01-16
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9321 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 9321 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#" $ %
# "&
%
# # $$'& (
)
! ! ! "
# $
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%&'()
! %&'*)
"
# +, %
$
+ + (#$ +
!))))- # . $
! + . !)(*/!)*
+
0
0
- 3 -
#
# 0
$
123 4235677896:;3 <2=3> 8??687 23 <276@ AB >16 ?6>2>2:96=3;9@6=65>2:9(#$:<>16:>:=61257635> #<:= 31:=> C>16 5>D$ 5187769E29E >16 F;@E469> 89@ 8G8=@ @8>6@ !)( ?8336@ 29 :*/!)* AB >16 -. 89@ @@7 23>=25> ;@E6 2F8B8?;=8 #<:= 31:=> 16=6298<>6= =6<6==6@ >: 83 C>16 =2A;987D$ 366H29E 6918956469>:<5:4?6938>2:9 ! 8=>263 8=6 =6<6==6@ >: 83 ?6= >162= =89H29E A6<:=6>16=2A;987
+85>3E2I29E=236>:<2729E:<>1238??6878=6>18> >16 @656836@ G83 36=I29E 29 :7256 6?8=>469> 83 ?:72565:93>8A763?6=>16:=@6=316G83@=2I29E?:7256 F66?9!)'!)*8>8A:;>(&?416G83E:29E>: 466>12312E16=:<<25287389@=2@29E>164:>:=5B576A68=29E =6E23>=8>2:9:-!/-'>:G8=@38E87H:>89@5846 968= 8E87E:4A 2778E6 8> >18> >246 @=2I6= :< >16 8= A68=29E=6E23>=8>2:9:-!/-'(*5846<=:4:??:32>6
- 4 -
@2=65>2:9G2>1E=68>3?66@298=83189@96E72E69>48996= 89@ 7:3> 5:9>=:7 :I6= >16 @=2I29E 89@ @8316@ >: >16 4:>:=5B576 :< >16 @656836@ ;6 >: >16 382@ 8552@69> @656836@3;3>8296@E=26I:;329F;=26389@@26@:9>163?:> 16 ?6>2>2:96=3 3?69> 3)))))- >:G8=@3 <;96=87 89@ >=893?:=>8>2:9 :< >16 A:@B > >16 >246 :< @68>1 >16 @656836@ G83 8E6@ 8A:;> ) B68=3 89@ 68=929E 3!')))-?6=4:9>16G83>16:97B68=929E464A6= :< >16 <8427B ;6 >: ;9>2467B @68>1 :< >16 @656836@ ?6>2>2:96=3?;>>:18=@312?16?6>2>2:96=3A629E>1676E87 =6?=6369>8>2I63 :< >16 @656836@-;=89@8??8 <276@ 57824 ?6>2>2:9 ;9@6= 65>2:9 ** :< >16 5> 366H29E 5:4?6938>2:9 <:= >16 @68>1 :< ;=89@8??8 29 >16 =:8@ >=8<<258552@69>
63?:9@69>:8??68=6@>1=:;E1>165:;9367 89@<276@G=2>>693>8>6469>@69B29E>1669>2=65:9>69>3:< >16?6>2>2:963?:9@69>:8@42>3>18>1623>16:G96= :< >16 :<<69@29E 8= A68=29E =6E23>=8>2:9 :-!/- '(*16=6239:96E72E6956:9>16?8=>:<>16@=2I6=:<
- 5 -
>1658=29>168552@69>83 16 G83@=2I29E>1658=29 37:G 89@ 58;>2:;3 48996= :G6I6= >16 @656836@ @=:I6 >16 4:>:=5B576 G2>1 12E1 3?66@ 89@ @8316@ >: >16 8= 89@ 58;36@ 8552@69> 6956 16 23 9:> 728A76 >: ?8B 5:4?6938>2:9 89@ ?=8B6@ >: @234233 >16 ?6>2>2:9 83 8E8293>=63?:9@69>: & 63?:9@69> :!93;=8956 :4?89B <276@ G=2>>69 3>8>6469> @69B29E >16 8I6=469>3 48@6 29 >16 57824 ?6>2>2:9 89@ 2> 23 5:9>69@6@ >18> >16 =2@6= :< >16 4:>:=5B576 26 @656836@ G83 @=2I29E >16 4:>:=5B576 G2>1:;>89B@=2I29E725693683:9>16@8>6:<8552@69>83 3;51 8@I6=36 29<6=6956 23 >: A6 @=8G9 8E8293> @656836@ +;=>16= >16 :G96= 89@ 93;=8956 :4?89B :< >16 4:>:=5B576 8=6 9656338=B ?8=>263 >: >16 ?=:566@29E3 =2I6=:<>1658=G839:>18I29EI872@89@6<<65>2I6 >: @=2I6=>16I61257629I:7I6@29>168552@69>695616<76@ 8G8B <=:4 >16 3?:> 8<>6= 8552@69> 8>6= ?6>2>2:96=3 89@ :G96=:<>168=295:77;32:9G2>1?:7256:<<256=4898E6@ >: ?789> >16 9846 :< 7256936@ @=2I6= >: E6> >16 57824
- 6 -
6956=63?:9@69>:!239:>728A76>:?8B5:4?6938>2:9 83578246@29>1657824?6>2>2:9 * 16 =2A;987 :9 >16 A8323 :< >16 ?768@29E3 :< >16?8=>263<=846@>16233;639:=@6=>:?=:I6>165836 ?6>2>2:96= : 6J84296@ 16=367< 83 89@ 6J84296@ :96 G2>9633 83 !
89@ E:> 48=H6@ )/ @:5;469>3 83
J3>:/63?:9@69>:389@!@2@9:>8@@;5689B 6I2@6956A;>E:>48=H6@>16@:5;469>348=H6@83 J3 >:& ( <>6= =65:=@29E >16 6I2@6956 168=29E :9 A:>1 32@63 89@ :9 >16 833633469> :< :=87 89@ @:5;469>8=B 6I2@6956 >16 =2A;987 183 877:G6@ >16 57824 ?6>2>2:9 29 ?8=> G2>1 5:3>3 > 23 :=@6=6@ >18> >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 8=6 69>2>76@ <:= 5:4?6938>2:9 :< 3())))- 87:9E G2>1 29>6=63> 8> >16 =8>6 :< /K ?6= 899;4 <=:4 >16 @8>6 :< 57824 ?6>2>2:9 >277 >16 @8>6 :< @6?:32>29E :< >16 5:4?6938>2:984:;9>29>16=2A;98789@<;=>16=167@>18> =63?:9@69> :3 89@ ! 8=6 F:29>7B 728A76 >: ?8B 5:4?6938>2:9 >: >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 89@ @2=65>6@ >16
- 7 -
=63?:9@69> :! >: @6?:32> >16 5:4?6938>2:9 84:;9> G2>1298?6=2:@:<)@8B3<=:4>16@8>6:<8G8=@ ' 16?6>2>2:96=38EE=26I6@AB>16F;@E469>89@ 8G8=@ ?8336@ AB >16 =2A;987 18I6 <276@ >123 8??687 366H29E6918956469>:<5:4?6938>2:9 / 68=@ >16 768=96@ 5:;9367 <:= >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 89@ >16 768=96@ 5:;9367 <:= =63?:9@69> :!93;=8956 :4?89B ) 16 768=96@ 5:;9367 <:= >16 8??67789>3?6>2>2:96=3 3;A42>3 >18> >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 18I6 ?=:@;56@ >16 6=I256 6=>2<258>6 89@ 878=B 6=>2<258>6 29 :=@6= >: 63>8A7231 >16 4:9>17B 295:46 :< >16 @656836@ 16 =2A;987 183 9:> 5:932@6=6@ >16 3846 89@ 8G8=@6@ 5:4?6938>2:9G125123:9>167:G6=32@66956:9>1636 E=:;9@316?=8B3>:877:G>168??687 >16 768=96@ 5:;9367 8??68=29E <:= =63?:9@69> :!93;=8956 5:4?89B 3;??:=>3 >16 24?;E96@F;@E469>89@8G8=@?8336@AB>16=2A;98789@
- 8 -
3;A42>3>18>>165:4?6938>2:98G8=@6@AB>16=2A;98723 F;3> 89@ ?=:?6= 89@ @:63 9:> 5877 <:= 29>6=<6=6956 89@ ?=8B3>:@234233>168??687 ! 6=;36@ >16 =65:=@3 89@ 5:932@6=6@ >16 3;A42332:9348@6AB>16768=96@5:;9367<:=>16?8=>263 16 ?:29> >18> 8=2363 <:= 5:932@6=8>2:9 23 G2>1 =6E8=@ >: L;89>;4:<5:4?6938>2:9 16 ?6>2>2:96=3 29 :=@6= >: 63>8A7231 >18> >16 @656836@ ;=89@8??8 @26@ 29 >16 =:8@ >=8<<25 8552@69> 18I6?=:@;56@ J>1656=>2<26@5:?B:<+89@ J( >16 56=>2<26@ 5:?B :< 518=E6 3166> ?6=;387 :< J3 89@(48H632>5768=>18>8552@69>:55;==6@@;6>:=831 89@96E72E69>@=2I29E:<>16@=2I6=:<>16:<<69@29EI612576- 8= 6E8=@29E L;89>;4 1:;E1 2> 23 >16 5836 :< >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 >18> @656836@ G83 G:=H29E 83 :7256 :93>8A76 29 8=98>8H8 :7256 6?8=>469> 89@ @=8G29E 8 4:9>17B3878=B:<3!**!*-29:=@6=>:?=:I6>18>>16
- 9 -
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
- 10 -
16=68=6>1=66 5782489>3 6956 =@183>:
A6 @6@;5>6@ >:G8=@3 ?6=3:987 6J?69363 :< >16 @656836@ 263)!)/-3)M3!*'')*-3:9>16 @8>6:<>168552@69>>16@656836@G838E6@)B68=383 ?6=>16@65232:9:<:9DA76?6J:;=>29>165836:< &' (* & $$ *
$ '+( !
>16 8??=:?=28>6 4;7>2?726= 8??7258A76 >: >16 8E6 E=:;? :< >16 @656836@23C&D16=6<:=6>16?6>2>2:96=38=669>2>76@<:= 83;4:<3)!)/)-#!*'')*J&$:9855:;9>:<7:33 :<@6?69@695B1;3G68336335:4?6938>2:9;9@6=>16 168@:<C:33:<@6?69@695BD8>3)!)/)- & 16=68=6>1=66?6>2>2:96=39I26G:<>1678G 782@ @:G9 AB >16 :9DA76 ;?=646 :;=> 29 $"& * =6?:=>6@29 #6851:<>16?6>2>2:96=38=669>2>76@<:=83;4:< 3))))-;9@6=>16168@:<C7:33:<5:93:=>2;4DG1251 5:463>:3!))))-#3)))).$98@@2>2:9>:2>
- 11 -
>16?6>2>2:96=38=669>2>76@<:=3&)))->:G8=@3<;96=87 6J?6936389@3&)))->:G8=@37:33:<63>8>6 * 1;3 >16 ?6>2>2:96=3 8=6 69>2>76@ <:= >:>87 5:4?6938>2:9:<3'!)/)-838E8293>3())))- 8G8=@6@AB>16=2A;987 ( 55:=@29E7BG6?=:566@>:?833>16<:77:G29E,
#8$ 168??68723877:G6@29?8=> #A$ 16 F;@E469> 89@ 8G8=@ ?8336@ AB >16 =2A;987234:@2<26@ #5$ 16 ?6>2>2:96=3 8=6 69>2>76@ <:= >:>87 5:4?6938>2:9 :< 3'!)/)- G2>1 29>6=63>
/K ?8 <=:4 >16 @8>6 :< ?6>2>2:9>277>16=6872N8>2:9:<84:;9> #@$ 63?:9@69> :! 23 @2=65>6@ >: @6?:32> 69>2=6 5:4?6938>2:9 84:;9> G2>129 8 ?6=2:@ :< 62E1> G66H3 <=:4 >16 @8>6 :< =6562?>:<5:?B:<>123F;@E469>
- 12 -
#6$ <<256 23 @2=65>6@ >: >=89342> >16 >=287 :;=>=65:=@3>:>16=2A;987<:=>1G2>1
,-
' "&( #
,-
'# ( #
23>:7:!&